Jump to content
IGNORED

Pinnacle Gold vs. Srixon QStar vs. Titleist DTS Solo

bjwestner
 Share
Note: This thread is 3729 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

bjwestner Dedicated Member

bjwestner

Having a hard time settling on one ball.  I started out playing with Pinnacle Gold because they were cheap, fairly durable, and had okay distance.  Then I tried the DTS Solo from Titleist.  I like them a lot but not the price.  I noticed a difference putting the DTS Solo vs. the Pinnacle Gold.  I putted better with the DTS Solo as it seemed to have a better feel versus the hard Pinnacle Gold.

Based on reviews I purchased QStar from Srixon because it is supposed to have better feel versus Pinnacle and is cheaper than the DTS Solo.  Can anyone comment on their experience with these balls?  I do like the DTS Solo but cannot see spending $40 or more for a dozen golf balls.  The Pinnacles were working fine but now that I am getting a better feel for the ball especially with putting, I find that I can putt much better with the DTS Solo.  Hoping that the QStars will give me the feel of the DTS Solo but at closer to the Pinnacle price.....

https://youtu.be/L5DdpWMiHmg

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades
1

tomwalshco Newbie

tomwalshco

Want a ball that feels good, goes deep and won't break the bank - Wilson Staff DUO - $19.95. Actually bites pretty good around the green, too. I'd play it all day, but they don't make 'em in yellow, which is a must for my old eyes.

Noodle+ ain't bad, either (no yellow). Q Star - too hard, skids. NXT - too expensive. Pinnacle Gold - no grab.


JoeShark Newbie

JoeShark

Originally Posted by bjwestner

I do like the DTS Solo but cannot see spending $40 or more for a dozen golf balls.

Not sure where you are buying your DTS Solo's, but they are $19.99 at Golfsmith (cheaper then the Q Stars which go for $24.99).


School Yard Pro Member

School Yard Pro

+2 on the Wilson Staff Duo. Very underrated ball.

Driver:Adams 9064LS 9.5 *stiff

3 Wood: Nike VRs

Hybrid: Adams A7 19*

Irons: Nike VRs Pro Cavity 4-AW

Wedges: Nike VR Pro 56'

Putter: Nike Method mc3i1

Ball: Wilson Staff Duo

Bag: Ogio Assassin


bjwestner Dedicated Member

bjwestner

  • Author

Thank you JoeShark, I thought they were more than that.  Do you know if they make the DTS Solo in Yellow?

I like playing the yellow ball, easier to find.

BTW - I played Friday, Saturday, and Sunday all with the QStar and liked it a lot.  I shot the best round ever on Friday (88), shot okay on Saturday (91), and then shot another best round ever on Sunday (87).  I liked the feel especially putting the QStar, much better than the Pinnacle.

The only other issue that I have with the DTS Solo is that everyone plays Titleist and when I've played them in white color anyway, you think you found your ball until you realize that it's someone elses that is also playing a Titleist.  Even marking the ball sometimes is hard if it's facing the ground......

https://youtu.be/L5DdpWMiHmg

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades
1

bjwestner Dedicated Member

bjwestner

  • Author

After playing with the DTS Solo and the QStar, I have decided to go with the QStar for now.  While it is more expensive (an extra $5 per dozen), I just like the feel with the QStar a bit better than the DTS Solo which is not bad at all.  The reason I went with the QStar is a little better feel with putting and the fact that it seems to control better in the air.  If I hit a ball that is slightly drawing too much, the damage seems to be limited with the QStar better than any ball I've seen so far.  Don't get me wrong, if I hit a massive slice or hook, the ball is still going to slice or hook, it's just with the ones that are slightly going bad where the QStar seems to limit the damage and control this better than the DTS Solo.  Thanks to everyone for their feedback!

https://youtu.be/L5DdpWMiHmg

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades
1

lisevolution Established Member

lisevolution

Just to add a slightly more expensive ball to your list for the future, I was playing the Bridgestone E6 which is very similar to the Q-Star and also comes in yellow.  While I loved the ball off the tee, whenever I'd hit an approach or a pitch that actually landed in good position on the green it would fly off in the rough.  I was talking to the Golftec coach I'm working with and he suggested I try the Callaway Hex Chrome rather than the Q-Star because the Q-Star has the same issues as the E6 around the green.  The Hex Chrome is definitely more expensive, I think I paid $35/dozen but it does come in yellow and It's definitely longer off the tea and sits down way better on the green than the E6.  It also has a nice soft feel off the putter face.


Not trying to have you spend more $ but just wanted to chime in because I just went through this same type of decision.


ClayHbg Established Member

ClayHbg

don't mean to be "that guy" by offering a 4th option, but the Gamer V2s are the best ball under $20 on the market.  Hands down! (imo)

nike.gif  VR-S Covert 10.5*

nike.gif  SQ2 15*

  Idea Black Hybrid, 19*

mizuno.gif  MP54, 4-PW

vokey.gif SM 50*, 54*, 58*

nike.gif  Method 001

nike.gif  RZN One


DigDeep Newbie

DigDeep

Plus one on the Top Flite Gamer V2s.(+1).

I like the Pinnacle Gold off the Tee but that's where it ends.

I like playing the Noodle.  Good all around ball.  Feels good off the club face and does a good job around the green.  Plus I get usually get everyone saying "The Noodle!" when I tee off.


NuclearMike Dedicated Member

NuclearMike

Agreed on the Top Flite Gamer V2.  It's a three piece ball with better-than-average distance and really good spin with a soft feel on the green.  Can't ask for more from a ball under $20 than that.


KrazyTrain18 Well Established Member

KrazyTrain18

My home course is sponsored by Srixon/Cleveland, so Q-Stars are everywhere, the range balls are Q-Stars, I like them good feel and inexpensive at the store too.

Titleist 913D2 9.5 (UST VTS 65)

Titleist 913F 15 (Diamana S+)

Titleist 913H 19 (Diamana S+)

Titleist 714 AP2 (4-PW) (DG XP-95)

Titleist Vokey SM5 (52,56,58) (DG XP-95)

Ping Anser 2 Classic


Spyder Great Member

Spyder

If I can add my own recommendation, not to be the one who comes in throwing an off-topic brand or "titleist" choir boy... but the new 2012 Titleist DT SOLO is an extremely nice ball in my opinion. I typically play the NXT Tour/NXT Tour S, but the DT SOLO has become very soft. I honestly believe it is the most well designed 2 piece ball and feels very nice off of the putter as well. Retails around $19.99/dozen or $19.99-$24.99 if you purchase them at a reasonable course.


slodsm Well Established Member

slodsm

I agree with the DT SoLo, it's an excellent ball. I've played the SoLo most of the summer and it's a great ball off the tee and not bad at all around the greens. I like the Tour S a little better as I get a little better (maybe mental) because I think I do better with it on short approach shots and with the putter but if I had no choice but to play a SoLo for the rest of my life, I wouldn't gripe much at all.

  • Upvote 1

 910 D2 10.5  910F 3w  910H 19*

 712 AP1 4-GW  Vokey SM4 54* and 58*

  Select Golo  E5


Spyder Great Member

Spyder

Originally Posted by slodsm

I agree with the DT SoLo, it's an excellent ball. I've played the SoLo most of the summer and it's a great ball off the tee and not bad at all around the greens. I like the Tour S a little better as I get a little better (maybe mental) because I think I do better with it on short approach shots and with the putter but if I had no choice but to play a SoLo for the rest of my life, I wouldn't gripe much at all.

I absolutely agree with you. The past DT SoLo was not a bad ball at all, but I could easily tell the difference between the DT SoLo and my NXT Tour. Now, the new 2012 DT SOLO offers a softer core and you can definitely feel this off of your irons. Still not as easy to check on the greens as the NXT Tour and definitely not as nice off of the putter, but it is my go-to ball when I play a new course, or a course with many risk/reward decisions and hazards. (i.e.: It's my secondary ball when I'm having a bad day or am at risk of losing a ball). From now (mid-August) through early November, I will play nothing but the DT SOLO. The NXT Tour and NXT Tour S I reserve for May through mid-August.


bjwestner Dedicated Member

bjwestner

  • Author

Sounds like a lot of people end up liking the DT SoLo - it's not bad.  The last few weeks I have only been playing the Tour Yellow Srixon Q-Star.  I find the flight just a bit better than the DT SoLo and prefer the Q-Star just by a bit when putting.  The downside (if you could call it that) is that the Q-Star does not make the same great sound when I putt (I use an Odyssey White Ice/White Hot putter).

Has anyone purchased used golf balls?  I saw refurbished golf balls for sale online at rockbottomgolf.com.  I have no issue playing a ball that has been played before as long as there is no damage to it.  How do they "fix" the balls that have scrapes or scuffs on them?  I read that they re-paint the balls which also seems kind of odd (for example I do not believe that the Q-Stars are actually painted but are that color because of the color of the plastic).  Also, what is stopping someone from painting a ball white and stamping "Titleist Pro V1" on a lower quality ball?  I'm not saying that this happens, I'm just saying that it could happen.  Has anyone purchased used/refurbished balls from rockbottomgolf?  Were you happy/satisfied?  Thanks for all of your input!

--BJ

https://youtu.be/L5DdpWMiHmg

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades
1

Note: This thread is 3729 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up

  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).

  • Posts

    • ChetlovesMer
      Garmin R50 Launch Monitor

      By ChetlovesMer ·

      One thing I've wondered about with set to the side camera models in addition to toe shanks; Is does the plexiglass covering the cameras get all dirty? Especially when hitting from grass. I've used skytrak with a mat before and it ends up getting what I'll call "mat dust" on it. But that easily wipes right off. I've never used one of these in the grass. But I would think they'd get "grass splatter" on them. ... maybe? is that an issue? 
    • ChetlovesMer
      Can Somebody Explain to Me Why Lie Angle Balanced Putters Are Important?

      By ChetlovesMer ·

      I see what you are saying. I work with companies that make everything from hearing aids, to assembly cells, to fire trucks, to combines. Pretty much everything in between. I know of very few who cannot handle one-piece flow. (I'm actually struggling to think of any other than Rolls Royce. Incidentally, Rolls Royce is without a doubt the worst manufacturer I've ever worked with.) Either LAB's factory is really behind the times. (Pre-1992) or they are sticking you for ordering a custom.  Again, if they are making their customs from special order parts that's one thing. But since they are just building from standard parts, then either their factory sucks, in which case I could help them. Or they are just charging what the market will bear. And in that case, shame on us, the consumer, for allowing it.  A couple of good reads on the subject are "The Toyota Production System" (originally published in 1992, updated several times.) And the even better "The Toyota Way" (originally published in 2003). Any manufacturer of any product should be able to achieve one-piece flow.       Don't get me wrong. Even though I personally didn't really like their putter, I'm rooting for them. I've been involved with American Manufacturing since the late-80's. I got to see first hand as Toyota Principles migrated to the US. Pretty much every major American Manufacturer has adopted these principles in some form or another.... or they've gone out of business.  LAB is an American Manufacturer and therefore I'm on their side. Which is why if they really do need an extra 110 to 150 bucks to produce a custom from standard parts, I (and others like me) can help them.  I decided to write them an email and simply ask them if the additional cost was due to market value or cost-plus pricing. I'll let you know if they respond.   
    • WillieT
      "5 Minutes Daily" Practice Challenge

      By WillieT ·

      Day 229 (18 Dec 24) - Wonderful Wedge Wednesday - pulled out the 58* to hit some easy 58* wedges in the backyard-key focus again was on the foot position (getting that slightly open foot stance, opened hips and making a smooth swing thru the ball.  
    • iacas
      Garmin R50 Launch Monitor

      By iacas ·

      Some quick notes. Mine arrived yesterday, and on Monday I used a student's in his lesson with him. The touch interface is very responsive. Almost iPad-like. Not at all like crappy touch screens that lag or where you're not sure you hit the button. A lot of the smaller (negative) issues are software based, so I think they can iterate on them and improve them: I named myself "Erik J. Barzeski" and so my little user "circle" shows up as "EJ." First, stop assuming someone's initials. Second, when I choose "Edit Users" the only option to edit is… to remove the user. I can't edit my name or whether I'm a righty or a lefty. That's not "editing" a user. I created "Student Lefty" and "Student Righty" as guest profiles, and think they should add colors to the little circles. It could let you more quickly find the person you're looking for. Not much of an issue with three, but if you play with a group of ten friends here and there, it would help. There are four different ways to dismiss a screen, which I found funny. You can tap away from a panel, click an "X," click "save/cancel," or click "Done." They could have done Not all clickable areas appear to be tappable. "Power Save" and "Battery Save" are tappable (you can change the settings), but they just say "Power Save : ON" or something. I definitely don't love the shot tracer. In the overhead view, a dot appears where your ball would have landed. But… if you're hitting the same club, every dot is the same color (orange for a 7I). I think the last dot, the last shot, should be a different color. After you've hit five or ten shots, you don't even really know which dot is the new one. The impact camera is more than what's offered by a lot of things (like even the QuadMAX), but at the same time, not all that useful. It's only about six (eight? ten?) frames and it's snot from a not great angle because you hit from so side-on. The hitting area with club data is pretty small. This won't work very well off of grass. And you'll want to move it around lest you wear out your Alignment is super easy. Lay a club down, rest two balls against it… aligned. I do wish it prompted you to align it when you turn it on, even if one of the options was "keep current alignment" if you haven't moved it since last using it (or it never moves in your sim or something). I don't have a subscription yet and may never get one. I don't plan to use Home Tee Hero for much. I may plug it in to GSPro at some point. I think you can connect to it via your WiFi network. As in… it joins your network, and so you can be online and connected to it wirelessly. I'm not sure what the USB-C port is for. The fiducials (club stickers) I have for the GCQuadMAX also work on the Garmin. You don't need to use their larger stickers. Heck, I used the tab from a GC fiducial on Monday and it worked fine. The storage/travel case is well done. It's solid, sturdy. But, oddly, there's no real good place to put the charger and cable. Maybe I can set it in against the back side beneath the handle? I could have used a little pocket for that. The weight is not anywhere near as substantial as it looks. Because the GCQuadMAX is denser, I think it may almost be just as heavy (I think officially it's 7.x pounds for the Quad and 9.x for the R50). Because the unit sits almost directly beside the golf ball, I don't think people are going to be as worried about shanks as they are with the GC units (GC3, GC4/MAX) or other "side-on" units. I do wonder about someone accidentally hitting it off the toe and into what seems to be plexiglass covering the cameras, though. The range UI is nice — you can split screen to show the impact video, the shot data, the range overview of ball flight… etc. If you hook it up to an external display I'm pretty sure you can get three things. Maybe four, with split screens on both? That's all I can think of for now, but I'll be updating this as I go.
    • saevel25
      Can Somebody Explain to Me Why Lie Angle Balanced Putters Are Important?

      By saevel25 ·

      I am sure they do have software that does that. Manufacturing and design software's are pretty sophisticated now.  If they were to make it all custom, that would not be mass manufacturing that gets them the profits they need. Building a putter one exact way is way cheaper than having to input 300 different combinations. Also, they are selling through big box stores, so they need that one putter. That is why you do not see Edel in golf stores, it is all custom built.  Yea, but PXG is not selling their clubs in big box stores, trying to do bulk sales. They are doing everything custom. So, having multiple options available at no cost adder is a very good business decision that makes it look like they are giving you a deal.  I am not sure Mizuno does that anymore, at least online purchases. When I go to their website, there is no option to customize loft and lie angle. They do that if you get fitted. Also, I am not sure what the price is compared to just buying a set off the shelf at the store.  To me, it could be a perception of no adder, but is it really? Also, if Srixon is selling you clubs at the same price as a big-box store, they are not giving you a deal. So, maybe that customization is built into the price of the club there? The big box store is going to mark up on the irons in addition to what Srixon makes selling to a big box store.   
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

  I accept
The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...