Fantasy Start or Sit thread

[webb1522]

A place where you can ask for advice if you're in a pickle over who to start over who. Didn't find another thread like this, if so I'll delete this one.

[webb1522]

Charles Clay TE vs KC Or Larry Donnell TE vs HOU Clay hasn't had a great game but KCs D is pretty banged up, and Donell has proved to be Elis security blanket over these past 2 games

[RJH999]

Charles Clay TE vs KC Or Larry Donnell TE vs HOU Clay hasn't had a great game but KCs D is pretty banged up, and Donell has proved to be Elis security blanket over these past 2 games

Charles Clay.

[webb1522]

Charles Clay.

Thanks for the input. Still up in the air. Clay is questionable with a hindering knee problem. He is due for a big game though

[RJH999]

Thanks for the input. Still up in the air. Clay is questionable with a hindering knee problem. He is due for a big game though

Clay has a bunch of raw natural talent. I feel like he could have a game with 10 catches, 150 yards, and two TD's or go bust and put up a 2 for 15. We shall see.

[Jakester23]

Larry Donnell he will get a lot of looks. Houston will be up early forcing the Giants pass and a te is a good safety valve when he JJ Watt is flying around.

[jackieMoon]

Ok couple here. Ertz or Rudolph Hopkins or Steve smith sr 3 of, Asiata, gerhart, pierce or Terrance west

[Jakester23]

Rudolph Hopkins West asiata and pierce.

[RJH999]

Ok couple here. Ertz or Rudolph Hopkins or Steve smith sr 3 of, Asiata, gerhart, pierce or Terrance west

Zach Ertz. DeAndre Hopkins. Bernard Pierce, Terrence West, Toby Gerhart.

[webb1522]

Ok couple here. Ertz or Rudolph Hopkins or Steve smith sr 3 of, Asiata, gerhart, pierce or Terrance west

Ertz has been great so far Sr. West pierce asiata

[jackieMoon]

Looks like it will be Ertz getting lots of targets Sr hopeing that Haden covers Torrey And not pierce cause he's not active

[JP golf]

Blockbuster Trade????  Accept or Decline??? What team benefits more and would you make the trade?  I'm not saying which team I am.

Aaron Rodgers and TY Hilton for Phillip Rivers, Keenan Allen, and Roddy White    -PPR and points for kick/punt returns...

Potential line ups after trade:

Team 1:

QB: Phillip Rivers
WR: Roddy White
WR: Keenan Allen (SD, Double up every time Rivers connects for a TD!!!)
RB: Marshawn Lynch
TE: Owen Daniels
Flex: Frank Gore

Bench Pierre Garcon

Team 2:
QB:    Aaron Rodgers
WR:   Damaryius Thomas
WR:   DeAndre Hopkins
RB:    Demarco Murray
TE:     Jimmy Graham
Flex:  CJ Spiller (PPR & Return Points makes him a consistent play regardless of running yards)

Bench TY Hilton

[webb1522]

[U] Blockbuster Trade????  Accept or Decline??? [/U] What team benefits more and would you make the trade?  I'm not saying which team I am.  Aaron Rodgers and TY Hilton for Phillip Rivers, Keenan Allen, and Roddy White    -PPR and points for kick/punt returns...  Potential line ups after trade: [U] Team 1: [/U] QB: Phillip Rivers WR: Roddy White WR: Keenan Allen (SD, Double up every time Rivers connects for a TD!!!) RB: Marshawn Lynch TE: Owen Daniels Flex: Frank Gore   Bench Pierre Garcon [U] Team 2: [/U] QB:    Aaron Rodgers WR:   Damaryius Thomas WR:   DeAndre Hopkins RB:    Demarco Murray TE:     Jimmy Graham Flex:  CJ Spiller (PPR & Return Points makes him a consistent play regardless of running yards) Bench TY Hilton

I like team 1. I myself have the Rivers Allen connection. With Woodhead and Matthews being out the passing game opens up. Rivers almost had 400 last game and Allen had his 1st big game.

[JP golf]

I like team 1. I myself have the Rivers Allen connection. With Woodhead and Matthews being out the passing game opens up. Rivers almost had 400 last game and Allen had his 1st big game.

Yea, I don't know what to do....

Right now...

Phillip Rivers----------------> Insert Aaron Rodgers

Keenan Allen---------------> Insert DeAndre Hopkins or TY Hilton depending on match up.

Damaryius Thomas

Demarco Murray

Jimmy Graham

CJ Spiller  <-------------- Sneaky in PPR and points for return leagues-  Hasn't had breakout game but really steady points

BENCH

Roddy White  <-------- Open for bye week flexibility

DeAndre Hopkins  <--------- Hopkins or Hilton depending on match up.

Thing is we only have two bench spots .... and we have DEF, K, DL, LB, LB, DB, DB, D......  So going into the Bye weeks, I'll have to end up dropping Roddy or DeAndre Hopkins or Keenan Allen at some point to allow for some FA moves during bye weeks...

I have been offered Aaron Rodgers and TY Hilton for Rivers, White, Allen....  I think I might do it as I get Rodgers (Rivers is sneaky close but Rodgers is a little better).  It frees up some flexibility going into bye weeks......      Would you do the trade?

PS... It's a 12 team league, so I'm in good shape either way...

[Jakester23]

Yea, I don't know what to do.... Right now... Phillip Rivers----------------> Insert Aaron Rodgers Keenan Allen---------------> Insert DeAndre Hopkins or TY Hilton depending on match up. Damaryius Thomas Demarco Murray Jimmy Graham CJ Spiller  <-------------- Sneaky in PPR and points for return leagues-  Hasn't had breakout game but really steady points BENCH Roddy White  <-------- Open for bye week flexibility DeAndre Hopkins  <--------- Hopkins or Hilton depending on match up. Thing is we only have two bench spots .... and we have DEF, K, DL, LB, LB, DB, DB, D......  So going into the Bye weeks, I'll have to end up dropping Roddy or DeAndre Hopkins or Keenan Allen at some point to allow for some FA moves during bye weeks...  I have been offered Aaron Rodgers and TY Hilton for Rivers, White, Allen....  I think I might do it as I get Rodgers (Rivers is sneaky close but Rodgers is a little better).  It frees up some flexibility going into bye weeks......      Would you do the trade? PS... It's a 12 team league, so I'm in good shape either way...

Take rodgers and hilton. The packers don't play another good pass defense really all season (unless you think Carolina will turn it around ).Also Hilton gets a ton of targets. White hasn't been healthy in a few years and San Diego still has Denver twice KC twice and the Jets.

[webb1522]

Yea, I don't know what to do.... Right now... Phillip Rivers----------------> Insert Aaron Rodgers Keenan Allen---------------> Insert DeAndre Hopkins or TY Hilton depending on match up. Damaryius Thomas Demarco Murray Jimmy Graham CJ Spiller  <-------------- Sneaky in PPR and points for return leagues-  Hasn't had breakout game but really steady points BENCH Roddy White  <-------- Open for bye week flexibility DeAndre Hopkins  <--------- Hopkins or Hilton depending on match up. Thing is we only have two bench spots .... and we have DEF, K, DL, LB, LB, DB, DB, D......  So going into the Bye weeks, I'll have to end up dropping Roddy or DeAndre Hopkins or Keenan Allen at some point to allow for some FA moves during bye weeks...  I have been offered Aaron Rodgers and TY Hilton for Rivers, White, Allen....  I think I might do it as I get Rodgers (Rivers is sneaky close but Rodgers is a little better).  It frees up some flexibility going into bye weeks......      Would you do the trade? PS... It's a 12 team league, so I'm in good shape either way...

If you feel like bye weeks are going to lead to losses preventing playoffs I'd do the trade, I've never played individual defense before so I'm not too sure the pain you're going through lol. Rodgers is an elite QB and has great WRs but his line scares me. Rivers has been playing well though. Go with your gut on this one man. Value on either end there.

[JP golf]

I accepted the Trade - Aaron Rodgers and TY Hilton for Phillip Rivers, Keenan Allen, and Roddy White...

Really it's a toss up... and comes down to what I'm trying to do with my team...   I couldn't make up my mind!!!! lol

Ultimately, considering we only have two bench spots, I free up one spot going into the bye weeks to make roster moves - in this league there is high volume drop adding of decent players during the bye weeks even with 12 teams in the league.  You are usually forced to make decisions to drop someone or start someone on a bye if you don't plan properly.

I really feel like I would have had to drop Roddy White either way...   Aaron Rodger and Phillip Rivers are closer than people think in Fantasy, but I definitely give the edge to Rodgers.

I end up with:  - in a 12 team league....

QB:    Aaron Rodgers

WR:   Damaryius Thomas

WR:   DeAndre Hopkins

RB:    Demarco Murray

TE:     Jimmy Graham

Flex:  CJ Spiller (PPR & Return Points makes him a consistent play regardless of running yards)

Bench: TY Hilton

Bench:  T. Kelcey (Graham on a bye next week)

Def:  Sea

LB, LB, DB, DB, DL, D (flex defensive person) - I don't feel like listing my player out here but I'm okay...

[webb1522]

QB:    Aaron Rodgers WR:   Damaryius Thomas WR:   DeAndre Hopkins RB:    Demarco Murray TE:     Jimmy Graham Flex:  CJ Spiller (PPR & Return Points makes him a consistent play regardless of running yards) Bench: TY Hilton Bench:  T. Kelcey (Graham on a bye next week)

That's a solid lineup for a 12 team league, where are you at in standings?