• Announcements

    • iacas

      Create a Signature!   02/05/2016

      Everyone, go here and edit your signature this week: http://thesandtrap.com/settings/signature/.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Tronik

Soooooo many clubs to chose from

7 posts in this topic

Hello. Im pretty new to this forum to bare with me If I do something out of line. Iv been playing golf seriously for around 12 months and have had the same irons since I started. Ping G15. I have come down in handicap and now play off 15. I have recently upgraded driver to a SLDR and absolutely love it. The irons however seem to be a little chunky and heavy in the end for me now. I have had some lessons and seem to be striking the ball a lot better than when I started and I feel now is the right time to invest in some different irons. The choices out there are vast so I was looking for some guidance from fellow golfers. Brand new or decent second hand clubs will do me but there are so many options. Obviously being fitted is the best policy but I want to get the general consensus on what irons are doing the business for a mid handicap golfer. Look forward to the replies and advice received will be greatly appreciated.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

Depends, if you don't like chunky irons then play something more thin. Maybe try out Mizuno irons. I know guys who play more bladish irons, and some who play game improvement irons.

Find what looks best to you, and what you are comfortable with.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

Hello. Im pretty new to this forum to bare with me If I do something out of line.

Iv been playing golf seriously for around 12 months and have had the same irons since I started. Ping G15. I have come down in handicap and now play off 15.

I have recently upgraded driver to a SLDR and absolutely love it. The irons however seem to be a little chunky and heavy in the end for me now. I have had some lessons and seem to be striking the ball a lot better than when I started and I feel now is the right time to invest in some different irons.

The choices out there are vast so I was looking for some guidance from fellow golfers. Brand new or decent second hand clubs will do me but there are so many options. Obviously being fitted is the best policy but I want to get the general consensus on what irons are doing the business for a mid handicap golfer.

Look forward to the replies and advice received will be greatly appreciated.

Welcome to TST! :beer:

Well, 99% of us will obviously always start off responding to these types of questions with "Go get fitted and try as many clubs as you possibly can".

However, if you're literally asking for a biased opinion based on what some of us are currently using, I would vouch for the Titleist AP1 712 or Titleist AP1 714 irons. If you can find the 712s, buy them as you'll most likely save several hundred dollars. If you want shiny and brand new, the 714s are probably going to last you "forever" in terms of ability. To me, personally, I find them to be extremely easy to hit, very forgiving and sweeter than any other club I have ever played.

But, I do have to reiterate the importance of being properly fit for your clubs. Not only loft and lie, but the club and brand itself. Try as many clubs as you honestly can, on a launch monitor with a respectable and educated individual at the helm to help you find what works for you. Don't make the mistake of buying something and trying to make it work for you. When you find the right clubs, you're only making this game easier. That's something that everybody wants to do in the end, right?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Greetings, and welcome.

Spyder said it well so +1 to most of his comments, particularly with regard to the Titleist AP1s.  I replaced my Ping G20s (yes, I also understand your comment about the G15s feeling clunky) with 714 AP1s a couple of months ago and couldn't be happier.

You said you were open to new or used clubs, but I've no idea of your financial position of course.  The thing with fittings is that a good one includes trying various shaft combinations as well as determining whether you need R-flex or S-flex shafts and measuring for lie angle.  I was amazed at how much variation in feel and ball flight you get with different shafts.  So if you can see your way clear from a money perspective I think a properly fitted new set would likely be the way to go.

If you are thinking of used, I'd at least go for a big-box store fitting of the brand and model you're looking at.  They may not have anything but the standard shafts to try, but at least you can determine flex and see how they feel before heading off to shop Ebay or whatever.

Finally, I personally think that mid handicappers are much better off sticking to game improvement clubs rather than diving into "players" models, even if they are pretty and feel good on the occasions you hit one cleanly.  There are a range of GI clubs, the Ping G15/G20/Karstan being out on the end toward Super GI, and the AP1s some Callaway Apex, and others being closer to the "Players" side of the spectrum.  But golf is hard enough without saddling yourself with clubs that are harder to hit than need be.

How to decide?  One valid way, IMHO, is to talk to your local pro and other good golfers you may know and ask who the good fitters are in your area.  The biggest reason my bag is stuffed with Titleist clubs is because there is a Titleist Advanced Fitting Center with an excellent fitter in the area.  Find a fitter you feel good about and then select brand/model based on that person's recommendation.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys, thanks heaps for your replies. I am located in the UK so I have made a call to American Golf who offer a fitting service for free. I can choose which brands I want to try and the relevant options so naturally I am going to test them all. The service is free so why the hell not. They test club head speed, grip thickness, shaft flex and loft/lie options. Sounds pretty good to me. Booked in. I will let you know which irons I get attached to.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For anyone who reads this thread here is my update.

I was playing ping g15 purple dot irons which were completely no good for me. My actual ping dot is a blue dot. ANYWAY! Went to get fitted for some clubs tonight. Standard length and standard lie were perfect for me as im 6ft on the dot.

I hit ping g25, titleist ap1 714 and callaway x2 hot irons. Didn't agree with the titleist from the off so i scrapped that. With the two that were left i found the g25 got more height but than in turn sacrificed distance. With the callaway x2 hot iron i found to gain a more penetrating ball flight with added distance. Most shots that didn't quite come out of the meat also went quite a way. These were the clubs for me.

I definitely feel better after going to get fitted. Thanks for the advice again guys.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Congratz on your new clubs, hopefully you'll see some lower scores with them..

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards and Achievements

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • Jack or Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?
      Look at Ben Hogan. He played in exactly one Open Championship. Before Arnold Palmer brought it back into the fold as something you should be playing every year it was just too expensive for such a little purse to win. There wasn't much prestige in winning it during that time.  Look at the US open. Since 1993, only 52% of the time a non-US golfer won the US Open. From 1950 till 1993 only 92% of was won by US golfers.   Same with the PGA Championship. Since 1993 the US has only won 56% of them. From the time they went to stroke play (1958) till 1992 the US won 86% of them.  Same with The Masters. Since 1993 the US has won 56% of them. From 1950 till 1992 the US won 77% of them.  It just goes to show you that the influx of non-US golfers to the PGA Tour field of players has made it that much more difficult for US golfers to win a major.  Could I say that it was 30% easier for Jack to win those majors because of the non-US golfers who stayed away from traveling to the US to play?  US Open: 40% less likely US player wins after 1993
      PGA Championship: 30% less likely a US Player wins after 1993
      The Masters: 20% less likely a US Player wins after 1993
       
    • Great golfing quotes
      You're Never a 14 handicap! Hitting balls like that!!! End of round Nice playing with you, you scored net 80, you know you should really stay out of bunkers! Attributed to my fellow members, all of them did any one see that? No I hate golf Probably happens to everyone
    • Nike hyperflight golf balls
      Thanks for the hidden gem!!! Thats encouraging stuff. I really like the ball Ive been playing, but after reading that, Im looking forward to giving them a shot.
    • How Do You Decide Where to Play Golf
      Decision matrix: Course quality, then time available, then cost. dave
    • Longer or More Accurate?
      That doesn't make it a trick question. People aren't so lousy with accuracy that they're off 200 yards, but their tee shots travel 200 yards toward the target fairly often. The 10% thing helps to adjust them to the proper scale. I hit my driver 270, but I don't miss by 1/4 of that distance (67.5 yards). The wildest 100-shooting golfers are about +/- 10°. Their average is about 7°. 80-golfers are around 6°. 70 golfers probably about 5°. PGA Tour pros are around 3.5°. So 10% of those numbers are 0.7, 0.6, and 0.5°, with 0.35° for PGA Tour players. And yet, give each of them a full 1° (or  14% more accuracy for 100-golfers, 17% more accuracy for 80-golfers, 20% more accuracy for 70-golfers, and nearly 30% more accuracy for PGA Tour players… and they still come up short (or, at the PGA Tour level, only begin to break even). This means that the poll is biased, indeed, but in the opposite direction you think, @Marty2019. The poll could have said "would you choose 25% more accuracy or 10% more distance" and everyone (generalized to groups, not individuals) would STILL be better off choosing the distance. The only "trick" is that people value accuracy way, way too much, to the point where many are happy to take only a 10% improvement in accuracy while even a 25% improvement still can't account for the added value of driving the ball an extra 10% farther.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. TessaEdin
      TessaEdin
      (24 years old)
  • Blog Entries