Switch to a Heavier Shaft?

[Nedzer1]

Hi all, 

I'm new to the forum and have a question about iron shaft weight. I game mizuno 919 forged with a 105g dg shaft. I started golfing 2 and a half years ago and got fitted for the irons after about 6 months (not sure if this was too early to get fitted). I'm wondering if  a heavier iron  shaft would be a good idea (for consistency and distance) as my swing speed is a lot faster than it was originally.  Thanks for any help and I'm looking forward to being more active on the forum.

Cheers. 

Playing off 7.6

[arturo28mx]

In my experience the major effect of shaft weight is in your consistency hitting the center of the clubface In my opinion this should be your first priority. If you consistently hit the center of the clubface you'll get all the distance you need. Some people do better with heavier shafts some people do better with lighter shafts.

[Nedzer1]

Thanks for the reply. I thould the lighter shaft was for people with a slower swing(to swing faster). I am a fairly consistent striker of the ball but could always be better. 

[arturo28mx]

I just saw an instructional video that showed a guy hitting 10 shots with a lighter shaft and displaying more clubhead speed (naturally) but LESS ball speed. Why? Because he was not hitting the center of the clubface consistently. Clubhead speed is of no use if it does not translate into ball speed. My personal view.

[Nedzer1]

Thats what I was wondering. Could a heavier shaft help with consistency of strike giving a higher smash factor which would result in more distance? 

[boogielicious]

23 minutes ago, Nedzer1 said:

Thats what I was wondering. Could a heavier shaft help with consistency of strike giving a higher smash factor which would result in more distance? 

It depends on what causes the inconsistency. I was fit years ago with Nippon 950GH, which are 95g. I was a newer player. But as I got better, I felt I had control issues with the lighter shafts. I currently play Project X LZ 5.5 which are 115g. My swing speed is the same, but I feel I have more control.

What you need figure out is what is causing the inconsistency. Are they fat or are they direction control issues, etc. We have a Member Swing area where you can post videos of your swing. You can get help there.

[Nedzer1]

Thanks @boogielicious for the info and advice. I definitely will post a swing video to see what everyone thinks