Stewart Cink Shouldn't have be DQ'd

Just saw this on the USGA.com site.......Interesting interpertation.

The R&A;, USGA Announce Position On Raking A Similar Hazard


April 8, 2008
E-mail address: mediarelations@usga.org

The Joint Rules Committee (JRC), consisting of representatives of the Rules of Golf Committees of The R&A; and the United States Golf Association, have issued an interpretation of Rule 13-4a with respect to testing the condition of a similar hazard (whether a bunker or a water hazard). At its customary April meeting, the JRC reviewed several issues relating to Rule 13-4 (Ball in Hazard; Prohibited Actions), including some that were carried over for resolution from the previous quadrennial Rules revision cycle. One such question was whether a player whose ball lies in a bunker may smooth sand to tidy up another bunker, even though he had not made a stroke from that other bunker.

After discussion, the JRC agreed on the following position, effective immediately:



Rule 13-4a prohibits a player from testing the condition of the hazard in which his ball lies or a similar hazard. Yet Exception 3 to the Rule, which was introduced in 2008, allows a player to test the condition of one hazard after playing from that hazard into a similar hazard. Although Decision 13-4/0.5 lists smoothing a bunker with a rake, club or otherwise as an example of testing the condition of the hazard, the Etiquette Section of the Rules of Golf provides that "Before leaving a bunker, players should carefully fill up and smooth over all holes and footprints made by them and any nearby made by others."

It is not the intent of Rule 13-4a to prohibit players from practicing the proper etiquette of the game when more than one bunker is involved. Therefore, when the player’s ball lies in a bunker, it would not be a breach of the Rules if the player were to smooth the sand in another bunker, provided (a) the smoothing is for the purpose of tidying up the bunker, (b) the smoothing does not breach Rule 13-2 (Improving Lie, Area of Intended Stance or Swing, or Line of Play) with respect to his next stroke and (c) there is not a reasonable possibility that the smoothing could affect a subsequent stroke by the player.

If the player were to smooth sand in the bunker in which his ball lies prior to making his first stroke in that bunker, he would be in breach of Rule 13-4a.


While the JRC does not normally make public the results of its deliberations outside the updates of the Decisions on the Rules of Golf every two years and the Rules of Golf every four years, The R&A; and the USGA do informally answer questions about the Rules of Golf as those questions arise. Questions have arisen in connection with a recent ruling involving Stewart Cink at the Zurich Classic of New Orleans. In that situation, the player incurred a penalty for smoothing sand in a bunker from which he had not made a stroke, when his ball lay in another bunker -- a ruling that followed the USGA’s Rules of Golf Committee’s position at that time. To avoid such an act being a breach of the Rules in the future, the JRC has decided to make public its agreed position on smoothing a similar hazard.

Technically, he should have been at the time. Now the R&A; and USGA have apparently made a decision that clarifies the interpretation of the rule. This will no doubtedly be in the next revision on Decisions on the Rules of Golf book. The rules of golf are always being adjusted, because of incidents like this aren't thought of when the rules are made.

The way my dad explained it to me (he is a rules official), they basically nullified the vast majority of situations in which this rule would take effect. They basically did all they can to take it out since the rule book won't be changed for another two years.

Those decisions came a couple of days after Cink's incident and DQ. Under the rules of the time, he was legitimately DQ'd.

Agreed. You play by the rules of the day. Like them or not.

You guys are all right. However, do you think this will come up on any other circumstances? The players can fall back on "etiquette" if they are able to.