Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
  • entries
    3
  • comments
    16
  • views
    8,888

Welcome and First Mistake


Welcome to my blog. I've decided to do something a little bit different from a normal golf blog by focusing a bit more on the Rules of Golf.

The impetus behind this blog is that I volunteered to be the Rules Chairman for my men's club this fall. Now, I am of fairly sound mind, but volunteering to do that is probably a bit crazy. It is fair to ask why I volunteered. Well, I've been interested in the Rules of Golf since I started playing golf seriously. I never really had them introduced to me, so I've been mostly self-taught. They aren't some arbitrary gobbledygook to me - I intuitively understand the reasoning behind most of the rules. Instead of learning as an 8 year old that you can't step on the line of your putt without understanding why, I get why that is a rule. I'm also a lawyer, so the rules do not intimidate me. They are very straightforward compared to what I deal with. I have a book of regulations that is 1003 pages long and contains 10 regulations. This tiny book that is what, 150 pages long, is no big deal in comparison to that. I have, on multiple occasions, been able to read the Rules on the course and figure out what to do quickly enough to not delay play. One time, I found a dead fish on grass within the margin of a water hazard, and wasn't sure what I could do, but I figured it out after quickly reading the rules (bonus points if you can tell me the answer below).

That said, our club is lucky enough to have an experienced and knowledgeable professional rules official in it. He was the former Rules Chairman, and I can lean on him for any help. Which I will likely need, as you'll see in a second.

To prepare for this redoubtable position, I have started to follow the Rules of Golf section here more closely. I have been learning a ton by the rules questions asked in there and finding the answers on my own. I also took a 2 day rules seminar put on by the Colorado Golf Association. That was ... fun. A bit dry, to be honest, but I learned a lot of nuances in the rules. I also affirmed that I had a decent, although not spectacular, handle on the rules already. So, I should be pretty good at this, right?

Well... our club has a biennial (every other year - I had to look that up originally, too) rules requirement. You can fulfill it by taking an online rules quiz (I'll have a post about that later), or be attending 1 of 2 seminars we host during the year. Last weekend was our first seminar. Fortunately, the experienced rules official ran it, so I didn't have to do much besides introduce him and help his explanations when needed. But, as I held myself out as an expert, I had a couple of people ask me questions after the formal presentation was over. One asked me about whether the nearest point of relief from an immovable obstruction could be in a hazard. I said, without consulting the Rules, that it could be in a hazard. Taking relief from an immovable obstruction doesn't guarantee you a good lie or line. Well, I was right about the second sentence, but not about the first. Turns out the nearest point of relief when you're taking relief from an immovable obstruction can't be in a hazard. D'oh. Sent an e-mail, with my figurative tail between my legs, later that day to apologize and correct myself. In my defense, that situation rarely, if ever, occurs at my home course.

So, lesson learned. Read the rules before opining on a nuance like that. Probably better that I learned that lesson when it didn't matter as opposed to when it could affect someone's score.

That's probably enough for me. I'm going to try to update this periodically with tales from rules questions at my club. Please comment away. I welcome all criticism, although I strongly prefer positive.

  • Upvote 2

11 Comments


Recommended Comments

Phil McGleno

Posted

Loose impediment-Do not touch it or move it.

  • Upvote 2
DeadMan

Posted

12 hours ago, Phil McGleno said:

Loose impediment-Do not touch it or move it.

Yep. I'll give you 1000 bonus points for that answer.

Mop Bucket

Posted

If the fish was living would it be different?

  • Upvote 1
DeadMan

Posted

7 hours ago, Mop Bucket said:

If the fish was living would it be different?

Pretty sure it would then be just an outside agency. So you could wait for it to move out of the hazard, or move it yourself.

Getting this from Decision 23/6.5:

Quote

Q. What is the status of a snake?

A. A live snake is an outside agency. A dead snake is both an outside agency and a loose impediment. It is possible for an item or person to fall under more than one Definition.

But since it's a loose impediment when it's dead, you cannot move it out of a hazard (that's in Rule 13-4).

RandallT

Posted

18 minutes ago, DeadMan said:

But since it's a loose impediment when it's dead, you cannot move it out of a hazard (that's in Rule 13-4).

Aha, so you can resuscitate it first, then move it!

  • Upvote 1
bkuehn1952

Posted

8 hours ago, Mop Bucket said:

If the fish was living would it be different?

A live fish would be considered an outside agency.  My thought is that as such, one would be allowed to move an outside agency interfering with one's stroke or stance.  Before you do that, you may want to get a better educated decision!  ;)

  • Upvote 1
DeadMan

Posted

So in the fish situation, the fish didn't really interfere with the ball at all. It was close, but you could make a swing pretty easily without the fish making a difference. Personally, if I don't absolutely need to, I'm not going to move anything in a hazard (this is assuming my ball is in the hazard). It's just safer that way, and you don't invite the question of doing something wrong. While you are technically allowed to move a beer can out of hazard, why even bother until your ball is out of the hazard. That way nobody will question you.

  • Upvote 2
bkuehn1952

Posted

2 minutes ago, DeadMan said:

... While you are technically allowed to move a beer can out of hazard, why even bother until your ball is out of the hazard. That way nobody will question you.

Precisely! I have played enough tournament golf to have arrived at the same opinion.

  • Upvote 1
  • Administrator
iacas

Posted

1 hour ago, RandallT said:

Aha, so you can resuscitate it first, then move it!

Can you resuscitate a fish without touching it?

  • Upvote 1
Mop Bucket

Posted (edited)

Hahaha! golf is weird smetimes. "Time of death of the fish is 11:23 am, the exact moment it became of loose impediment."

Edited by Mop Bucket
  • Upvote 2
Hardspoon

Posted

This fish is no more. It has ceased to be. It's expired and gone to meet its maker. This is a late fish. It's a stiff. Bereft of life, it rests in peace. If you hadn't nailed it to the hazard, it would be pushing up the daisies. It's rung down the choir and joined the choir invisible. This is an ex-fish.

  • Upvote 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • Blog Entries

  • Posts

    • Day 10 (18 Mar 26) - two-fold session today, 1st - walked the back nine with 8 club setup plus a few extra holes on the front.  With the fewer clubs, had great opportunity to work on the approach process.  2nd - worked with the Jr Golf team at the local Christian school, helping them focus on course strategy - it’s a blast to see a kid get excited making the shot they envisioned.  
    • Wordle 1,733 4/6* 🟩🟨⬜⬜⬜ 🟩⬜⬜⬜🟨 🟩🟨⬜🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    • A bit of an update Set up - Less knee bed, more hip flex, weight feels more on the balls of my feet, and heels feel off the ground or lightly touching the ground. I have to check this from time to time. I like to squat too much and get my weight back. If I look at where my right pocket meets my shirt, that is over my ankles. It feels like I am on my toes.  Backswing - Feel like my left kneecap stays facing towards the ball, doesn't move. This controls my knees in the backswing. Which controls my hips. Lots of resistance feeling in the left leg, lots of stability here. The hands feel like they go in a bit, keeping them closer to my right hip, then hinge straight up. In reality the hands go straight towards the camera than in. I am trying to keep the hands from going out and rolling the club inside from A2 to A4. Mostly hinge from wrist and still feel like I keep my right elbow straighter. So, its hinge wrist, then left upper arm off chest. Elbow feels like it doesn't do much. The hinge and the club finish nearly the same time as my right arm retracts. So, it's not continuing on a ton here. I don't think I could overexaggerate enough how fast and the quantity of hinge I can do here.  Downswing - This is the drill I set up. I wanted to create a spatial target for my swing path. So, I added a 2nd foam ball. This one off my right foot, about 1-ft away from the shoe. I chose this position because if I stop the swing at the top then bring my right hands down to my pocket and turn from there, that ball would be in its path. I am trying to swing the club down and behind me to make that 2nd ball in the swing path to the actual ball. It won't, but it is a good visual. It really has helped me. I did it slow a few times, then I did one swing at like 70% and it looked pretty good.  Checkpoints A1 to A2 - Club travels inward a bit and hands travel inward and straight back. Club is outside the hands at A2.  A2 to A4 - Club hinges here and still stay on plane pretty well. At A3, the club is pointing inside the ball. Previously it was like 10+ FT outside the ball. Right elbow and right hands are in front of the chest more. A small nitpick here is, maybe the hip turn is a tad over what I want. Very very small nitpick here. Probably could have hinged a bit sooner and gotten the club up a bit quicker to finish the backswing. This was a slower swing, so timing is a bit off.  A4 to A6 - the club keeps tracking down such that the club pass just under my hands. The path misses the 2nd ball by a lot. I am trying to get the club down to hit it.  When the knees are square to the target line in the downswing. My hands are down at waist height and the clubhead is at shoulder height. while in recent swings with no shallowing, my hands are like up near my chest, the club head is like above my head. People talk about being stuck behind them, I was stuck in steepness.  At impact, I could be more open with the hips if I used my left leg better, more work to do on that.  My right elbow and hands are on my trail side. I don't have to stop turning to get my hands and clubs through to hit the ball.  Overall, pretty good. I just need to rep this and continue to work on getting that left leg straighter.  Warning Label - The LED lights have a strobe effect due to the slow-motion camera. If you have photosensitive epilepsy (PSE) or certain visual sensitivities, you have been warned.      
    • Awesome. We were originally going to play Quail Ridge but ended up moving some things around and are going to do the following when we go in May Day 1 Tobacco Road Day 2 Southern Pines and Pine Needles Day 3 Tot Hill Farm There are a couple good course vlog/matches on YouTube at Southern Pines, it looks awesome.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.