How do you know when it's time for new clubs?

[double_j]

I'm currently debating getting some new irons but am not really sure I need them. I'm fairly happy with my overall iron play and don't feel that I'm giving up any strokes due to equipment. That said, it's really hard to know what I'm missing since I haven't played anything else for quite a while now. One thing I know for sure is that my irons are relatively old (for someone who tends to enjoy having the latest and greatest, at least) and that technology has definitely moved forward since 2005/2006.

So the question - how do you know that you need new equipment if there's really nothing wrong with your current set up? I'm a bit worried that switching clubs might mess with my game more than anything else but new technology is always so darned tempting.

FYI, my current irons are the 2005 (or 2006?) TaylorMade TP RAC forged cavity back irons. I think they were part of the first wave of forged CBs for the 'serious player' and they do have an awesome feel to them. I don't notice any serious weaknesses other than the fact that they're stock out of the box and I haven't been fitted to know if they're my ideal. In all honesty, I'd probably benefit from a 1/2" to 1" longer shaft and a slightly upright bend although I've already adapted to my current set so it's not really an issue).

My choices for a new set at this point are the AP2s or TaylorMade R9 TPs (or a leftover set of the TM "Tour Preferred" irons). Impressions of either would be much appreciated. I'd also appreciate feedback on the Project X shafts vs. the normal DG S300s - I've never played the former and have used the latter in my irons as long as I can remember. I know I really just have to road test them, but initial thoughts about what I might find would be great!

[HotSauce]

If there's not a problem, don't change anything. Either do nothing, or fit the clubs you have now. Fitting is probably the best "equipment" money you can spend IMO.

As for the Project X shafts, it's hard for me to give a truly fair comparison as I switched clubs as well as shaft, but I have LOVED my X6.0s on my Bridgestone J36s.

As for tech change.....Maybe I'm alone in this but irons haven't changed THAT much. Find something you like and are comfortable with, which you already have.

[shades9323]

For most people, it is time to change when they get bored and have money burning a hole in their pocket.

[Clubchucker]

Here's how I know it's time to buy irons: when I either mention, show or talk about new irons and the wife's immediate response isn't "you just bought new irons".

[sean_miller]

. . . FYI, my current irons are the 2005 (or 2006?) TaylorMade TP RAC forged cavity back irons. I think they were part of the first wave of forged CBs for the 'serious player' . . .

I'm not a shaft junkie, but here's what I think about the DGS300s. They're absolute perfection if they're right for you. I have them in 3 different sets and I know I can put the same strike on the ball and make good contact. I also like the older Hogan shafts (Apex 3, 4, and 5 - all good). I'm not sure I'd consider anything out in the past decade the first wave of players forged cavity backs. They're a dozen or more years too late. Great irons though.

[enis750]

For most people, it is time to change when they get bored and have money burning a hole in their pocket.

couldnt have said it better myself

Here's how I know it's time to buy irons: when I either mention, show or talk about new irons and the wife's immediate response isn't "you just bought new irons".

exactly

I actually got chewed out this am just for that I have my reasons though In all honesty dude (to the OP) don't fix it if it aint broke now IF you have some cash you wanna spend, or just want something shiney and new in your bag - than all the power to you bro

[moparman426]

Clubchucker, I think our wives must be related.

[kevin.chan]

I just bought a set of used irons - the same set that i m current using but the 3 to 5 are cavity back. Crazy , huh ?

[zeg]

When your 5 iron head snaps off at the hosel during a round, that's a hint you should start looking into new irons. When your 3 iron head snaps off and flies 30 yards into the driving range 2 weeks later, it's time to pull the trigger. At least, that's how I knew...