Hank Haney quality?

[iacas]

  x129 said:

Originally Posted by x129

I think judging anyone off a TV show is a pretty poor idea. They are edited for entertainment not education.

I don't. I think there were enough segments showing him teaching that people could form an opinion.

  x129 said:

Originally Posted by x129

Tiger needs a lot different advice than a 28 handicap. And if your learning method doesn't match the teaching method, you are going to struggle.

I think you'd be surprised at how similar the advice is. It may be finer details, but the advice is basically the same. Physics and geometry don't change because the student plays golf for millions of dollars.

[jamo]

  x129 said:

I think judging anyone off a TV show is a pretty poor idea. They are edited for entertainment not education.

While it's sometimes bad to judge people off T.V. (the producers of Big Break edit the footage to cast the competitors as a certain character), in this case it's fine. Hank's producers have edited hi shows to make his look as good as he can. And he still came off looking bad.