Jump to content
IGNORED

When Pros look like Amateurs

FLOG4

By FLOG4,
in Golf Talk

 Share
Note: This thread is 4555 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

FLOG4 Dedicated Member

FLOG4

  • Author


Originally Posted by Spyder

I'm confused. Doesn't hitting the ball well go hand-in-hand with getting the ball to the hole, as well as getting it close enough to put it in? lol I would venture to believe that they are all a part of golf, and they all matter. All 3 things that you said above do go together.

"Doesn't matter how well he hits it" "He looked solid in all aspects".

You can't be solid in all aspects of the game if you're not hitting it well. Or if your putts are off, you're not solid in all aspects, etc.

Sorry you are confused Spyder... I guess I need to elaborate.  I've had many rounds where my tee to green game was not too good....Yet my short game was phenominal.  I've had days where my play tee to green was spot on yet I couldn't get it in the hole.  Funny thing is sometimes my scores on bad hitting days are better than good hitting days.

My point about Tiger was he made putts yesterday.  He didn't the prior days for the most part.  He lips out a couple early and who knows?  Yesterday he was solid in all aspects of game. The other days he just had parts of his game solid.  The standard quote I use is " your game will be judged not by how good your good shots are but by how good your bad shots are" JMHO

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Spyder Great Member

Spyder

No I understood just fine. At the professional level though, one aspect of your game cannot be off when it comes to a championship. If you happen to pull off a win with part of your game lacking, that would be quite a lucky day and it doesn't happen often.

We, as amateurs, can obviously have a day where Drives are great, irons suck and putting is great and shoot well. We can also do the same when Driving sucks, irons are great and putting is average. Professionals do not have so many chances to drop a stroke due to a poor shot. One missed opportunity can cost these guys millions. There's many different ways to shoot 90 with the above examples. Even a lower 80 or high 70 is still feasible with one part of the game lacking. When you're shooting under par and carry a +2 or +5 hc though, there is no exception to your game. You cannot be off in any aspect at all.


That is what I mean by amateurs making the misconception that professionals play the same game as them. Professionals need every aspect of their game to be in sync to pull off a victory 99% of the time in my opinion. The competition and difficulty is miles ahead of where any of us on this board are at.

Just reminds me of finishing up a round on Sunday and having a beer in the clubhouse afterwords and hearing people make comments on the golfers on TV. I remember one time when they were commenting on Ricky Fowler's every shot and critiquing. Really? lol We're sitting at a course that is barely 6500 and you played from the whites at that, and you're comparing your game to a pro...

I'm not saying you're doing that. I'm just reinforcing the fact that way too many of us amateurs forget just how difficult these guys have it. They make it seem easy like its a routine because we're used to viewing it - not because it is that easy.

When these guys are in front of a camera and say "well, my irons could have been better" and they shot -2, they're telling the truth. But, those irons still were not that bad to post under par. Tiger has just been an easy target in the media for years now and people make commentary on him like they know his game better than he does.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FLOG4 Dedicated Member

FLOG4

  • Author

Spyder, Way back when I went to ETSU to create a path to the PGA.  Didn't take me long to realize that wasn't gonna happen. Mike Hulbert was our 5th man on our team.  So I understand the dynamics of differential of bad shot for an Am vs a pro vs Tiger.  On the very best of analysis a pro only hits 70% gir yet has an average score of 69......That's getting it in the hole.  I use to play day in day out with 3 guys who played on PGA tour. One was Alan Strange, Curtis's identical twin brother.  Oh I'd love to have that game back. I busted a wrist and lost 12mph on my swing a decade ago.  But I can still putt like a scratch....HaHa

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kobey Well Established Member

Kobey

What it looks like to me is that by making harder courses they are making it harder for the professionals to show their stuff.  If you have a flat green and a shot from 20 feet the pros are gonna make that putt a lot more than an amateur and be a lot more impressive on the ones they don't make.  But if you put the hole in a place where if it doesn't go in it will roll for 30 more feet, everyone looks pretty much the same except for the lucky few that make it.  I really don't like the idea of a luck factor when it comes to the pros.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FLOG4 Dedicated Member

FLOG4

  • Author


Originally Posted by Kobey

What it looks like to me is that by making harder courses they are making it harder for the professionals to show their stuff.  If you have a flat green and a shot from 20 feet the pros are gonna make that putt a lot more than an amateur and be a lot more impressive on the ones they don't make.  But if you put the hole in a place where if it doesn't go in it will roll for 30 more feet, everyone looks pretty much the same except for the lucky few that make it.  I really don't like the idea of a luck factor when it comes to the pros.

If you know that if your ball is positioned pin high or behind the pin that your putt will be exceptionally fast and maybe even roll off the green.....Guess you better keep it below the hole. When a pro attacks a pin knowing the previous they know the consequences.....On a flatish surface just take dead aim and let's make it a putting contest.  Personally I like to see the pros get bitch slapped for an errant shot vs having a slightly more difficult putt. Extreme conditions like Royal Melbourne had or any US Open require proper execution of every shot. Placement in fairway and maybe even need to be left or right. below the hole, which actually could be to the right or left if the green slopes more sideways.  Precise touch of putts.  Perfect execution of a chip, pitch, lob or sand shot.

When its a play week where- bomb the drive, find it take dead aim, now make a putt.....That's just mundane and advantage gorilla boy's....I prefer the thinking mans game of extreme conditions.  It seperates the pretenders. But that's just me. Birdie fests can be fun too at times.  Yesterday Phil put his ball in his pocket the first three holes....He is too good for that to happen.  He played like crap and got bitch slapped....Very rude awakening for the guy noted as one of the best short game practictioners in the world!!!!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Note: This thread is 4555 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up

  • TST Partners

    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-15%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope.

  • Posts

    • TxGolfDude
      Not Sure Who Will Care, but it Took Me 13 Years to Combine Three Different Things to Get a Consistent, Repeatable Golf Swing That Is Accurate. Here's What I Did.

      By TxGolfDude ·

      Feel free to read or not, this is more of a benchmark post for me but I wouldn't mind questions and feedback either. In the words of Arnold Palmer, "Swing your swing". So much easier said than done. Videos to come soon (to the probable horror of most of you here lol), but man: this took along time. Hogan wasn't kidding when he said the secret was in the dirt. Can't say I'm not happy about it though. So here was my situation: My first (and only) post here was back in 2019 about trying to game a new 3-wood to replace my old 2008 Taylormade Burner (which I loved but only carried 208 yards with a stupid-high spin rate).  At that time I had been golfing for about 8 years., I was hitting four 80-ball buckets per day (320 total, I'm a psycho) and playing two rounds per week. I was using a "Width Swing" (probably my 15th try at a 'better' swing) from a book and videos called "The L.A.W.S of Golf" by Jim Suttie, TJ Tomasi and Mike Adams. Since I had hardly any flexibility back then at 49 (still don't lol), I had to get my clubhead depth from the width dimension, meaning dropping back my right foot, flaring my feet, and swinging around my body. This took a ton of work, but I got down from a 15 handicap to an 8 by using it, so I was pretty ecstatic. The problem? My lower back hated it, and I mean bad. Really bad. Like pull-out-in-the-middle-of-a-Houston-Amateur-Golf-Tour-tournament bad. Soooo...while playing some of my best golf, I just figured my golf days were over, especially after the Rona hit the next year in 2020 and shut everything down. I figured I would simply be a golf fan for the rest of my life, and that my days of playing (painfully) were done Fast forward three years. I *really* missed playing golf. I started watching (hold your nose) videos of Moe Norman's swing on YouTube and then that led down the rabbit hole of watching videos of Matt Kuchar and Craig Stadler and Bryson DeChambeau and videos by Kirk Junge and Todd Graves...you get the idea. This went on for weeks...and this is how we always get sucked back in, right? Single plane was supposedly the cure for lower back pain because the extension and torque could be mitigated to a degree that might make a golf swing tolerable for someone with lower back issues. I really missed playing the game, so last fall I thought to myself: "Self, you have nothing to lose. Get your clubs out of the trunk (they'd been sitting in there for three years).  Hold your arms straight and look like an idiot at the PGA Superstore in one of the swing bays trying this single plane swing and at least you'll be the only one who has to witness it." I tried it...and it went horribly wrong. I couldn't even get the ball in the air, I was topping everything at first. Then when I tried Moe Norman's famous 'vertical drop' as he called it, I fatted the mat every time. This went on for the hour I was in there. I left there tired, frustrated and about to say 'screw it'. But when I got to my car and went to get in the seat, I noticed something: Even after about a hundred swings, my back was totally fine. I thought maybe it was because I had injured it all those years ago with a rotary swing and now it had healed. Hmmmm...maybe that was it. After a couple days at home, and more video-watching of Moe and Moe alone, I went back to the hitting bay to see if I could find some sort of workable single plane swing based on what I had watched and taken notes on. This session went much better. Pretty straight ball flight (my miss was a slight cut), and no pulls or hooks (my old misses were the dreaded two-way misses, block or pull-hook). I had kinda-sorta figured out the 'vertical drop' deal, but it was too hard to time it consistently. When I did get the timing right, the ball went dead straight. HOWEVER...I was hitting with a 7-iron the whole time and my normal 148-yard shot now only traveled 134. 14 yards is a lot to give up...but I chalked it up to my swinging slower to get the timing down. Plus, I had no idea how the longer clubs would do or if I could even hit, say, a 3-wood with this swing. After another hundred shots or so, I called it a session and went home. So far, all I hit was a 7-iron with this 'swing' of mine. I had completely forgot about my back and didn't think about it until that evening and realized it felt fine. I thought to myself: "Even if you never get your normal distance back...wouldn't it be fun to just play golf again?" Then I thought to myself: "Self, it would be fun to be back on the golf course again." BUT...I was determined not to make a fool of myself out there, so I kept going back to the hitting bay. This third time I went back, I brought in only my Taylormade Burner 7 wood, thinking the shaft length is short enough that I can make contact with the ball, but it's a fairway wood, so I'll see if this swing can handle that. I hit it great...and straight...but the distance was, alas, like the 7-iron...just not there. "You're hitting it *really* straight though", I sad to myself, as if saying that would console a Recon Marine veteran who's ethos is that manly men do manly things...and a 165 yard 7-wood for me is about the furthest thing from 'manly' there can be on a golf course. Ego... I was torn between my love of playing the game on one hand, and on the other hand going out to the course with a swing that would be mocked, ridiculed and laughed at...but would look passable and understandable if I was 75 years old (I'm 54). Decisions decisions... I went back to the drawing board at home and thought "There's got to be some sort of compromise to this swing...some kind of combination of swings...something I can build that would get my old distance back but not destroy the lower lumbar of my spine." In the past 13 years, I had tried it *all*. Conventional swing, modern swing, stack and tilt (my back still hurts when I think of that one), rotary swing (hello shanks), the peak performance golf swing (don't ever fat one while trying that swing, you might break your wrists), 3/4 hold-off swing (great for wedges, not so much a driver), hand-and-arm swing...and on and on. Soooo...I went back to thinking about the width swing I had learned in the L.A.W.S of golf book and videos I had studied, and how I could implement the width element of that swing without destroying my back. It was the only swing technique I ever tried that got me comfortable distance and consistent impact and ball flight while swinging around say 85% or thereabouts. Hmmmm... What if I could combine it with a single plane swing? I know, I know...it sounds loony tunes. But I had already plunked down the $149 for a year's worth of unlimited hitting bay time at the PGA Superstore (commitment, right?), so I figured I had nothing to lose by attempting what would appear to be  moronic and ridiculous-looking setups and stances and swings in a hitting bay all by myself. The results have been nothing less than astounding to me. Setup (after four months of this on an actual driving range and getting *really* strange looks) is as follows (I'll have pics and video soon for whoever can bear to watch it): Grip: Left hand *slightly* strong, right hand neutral (this is to keep the ball from hooking off the planet). Alignment: All irons straight off the nose (I'll explain why in a bit), fairway woods of my left cheek, driver off my left nipple. Posture: *Slightly* hunched over with rounded shoulders (this is to give me room for my arms to come under my chest in the back swing). Foot Position: Left foot flared, right foot flared and dropped back about 12 inches (this gives me room to rotate my thoracic spine and gives the club depth in the width dimension, since I don't have Bubbas Watson's flexibility). Shoulders stay square with the target line. Hands stay high and in line with the lead forearm a la Moe Norman. Slight spine tilt away from the target. Backswing is in and up at a 45 degree angle if looking from behind. I only swing back until my lead forearm is parallel to the ground. I tuck the left elbow on the downswing and let it rip. The reason I play all my irons off my nose? Wait for it... All my irons... 7 iron to Sand Wedge... are single length irons. So I'm using a rotational swing...on a single plane...with single length irons (based off my 7 iron). Never hit my irons better in my life - and hitting just as far now as I was when I started golfing 13 years ago. Also - driver and fairway woods are stupid-easy for me to hit now. My misses are mostly a high cut now, and that only happens when I slide my left hip because I get fast at the top. As long as I keep my lower body quiet until my hands drop (they don't have far to drop, either), then I get a pretty dang straight ball flight. Pull hooks and block are now a thing of the past. Anyhoo, here's the setup of my clubs. I have about a 94 mph driver swing speed. Driver: Ping G410 9 degree cranked up to 10.5 degrees, Alta CB R flex carry is 235-ish  3-wood: Ping G 410 13.5 degrees Alta CB R flex 65 grams, flat setting, stated loft, carry is around 215 5-wood: Ping G-410 17.5 degrees Alta CB R flex 65 grams, flat setting, stated loft, carry is 202 7-wood 2008 Taylormade Burner, 21 degrees, stock REAX S flex 49 grams, carry is 192 9-wood Ping G410 23.5 degrees Alta CB R flex 65 grams, flat setting, stated loft, carry is 182 6 hybrid Ping G425 31 degrees Alta CB R flex 70 grams, stated loft, flat setting, carry is 158  Irons: are all custom fit Sterling single-length irons by Wishon Golf. 7 146 yds 8 135 yds 9 125 yds PW 110 GW 98 SW 83 Putter: Custom Edel blade I had made in 2012 after golfing for a year and I can't hit the broad side of a barn with it. REALLY interested in getting fitted for a L.A.B DF 3 with a forearm grip...stroked a L.A.B. DF 2.1 at the PGA Superstore they had on the 'pre-owned' rack and it was $519 wuuuuut!!! So that's only 13 clubs...but I am looking on eBay to fill that gap where the 5 hybrid should be, would be a perfect 170 yd club right there I think. Before doing to the single length clubs, I had Ping irons 7-PW and four Vokeys in 48, 52, 56 and 60 in the bag and the single length clubs were gathering dust in the closet for the last 5 years. However, after actually playing a few rounds and seeing where the numbers were adding up, it was missed greens from 150 and in. So, I wanted to take the variable length mid and short irons out the the equation to keep my setup simpler. Gotta say, it worked like a charm.  Same setup as a 7-iron for all my scoring clubs and it keeps everything repeatable. Yes, it feels weird looking down at a wedge with 7-iron length, but I got used to it. The ball goes the same distances as my Ping irons and Vokey wedges used to but flies *way* higher and lands super soft. Also, if I want to chip or pitch with them I just choke down a little, as the swing weight difference won't matter much for those shots. I haven't actually kept score yet, as I haven't even gotten around to really working on my short game or putting at all. Right now, I'm just scoring fairways and greens hit or missed, approaches hit or missed and how many pars per round I can make. So far my best since this 'comeback' started is 8 pars, 1 birdie (almost had a hole-in-one lol), two bogies and seven 'others' (fats, thins, skulled chips across the green and tears may have been involved). I hit 3 of the Par 4 greens in regulation and hit 10 of 14 fairways. The ones I missed were not off the fairway by much and I finished the round with the same Pro V1X I started with - albeit a little scuffed up. Anyway, that's the story and after years of struggle I finally found something that works *for me*. I'll try to get some pics of setup and possibly video if anyone's interested and has a strong stomach haha. I'm gonna start reading the Dave Pelz short game and putting bibles this week, I'm sure that will be an adventure haha! Thanks for the space to write this.
    • DaHolla
      "5 Minutes Daily" Practice Challenge

      By DaHolla ·

      Day 125 - Played 18. Ball striking is still off. Way off. 
    • Darkfrog
      "5 Minutes Daily" Practice Challenge

      By Darkfrog ·

      Day 28: Wind really aggravated my allergies today, so attempted some full swing work outdoors but was kind of miserable. Moved indoors for some putting and mirror work. 
    • iacas
      The Pro Tours Random Thoughts and Musings Thread

      By iacas ·

      Also, the drop was legit: PGA Tour Fargo Championship 2024: Xander Schauffele controversial drop video, ruling, leaderboard, Jason Day, highlights ‘Most ridiculous thing I’ve seen’: Golf fans fume at US star‘s unbelievably lucky break The rules don't exist only to punish golfers.
    • DeadMan
      "5 Minutes Daily" Practice Challenge

      By DeadMan ·

      Day 304: did a stack session. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

  I accept
The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...