Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
danL

Need guidance in club choice (fairway wood, irons, wedges)

7 posts in this topic

I started golfing when I was around 6 and played very well for several years but ended up losing interest for whatever reason. 20 years later I'm getting back into it and I'm beginning the process of buying some nice clubs. I already bought a Callaway Razr Fit Xtreme driver (10.5*) and an Odyssey White Hot Pro V-Line putter.

My handicap now is around 20 but I've been improving with every game as I get my groove back so I'm looking to get some clubs that I can "grow into" so to speak. I definitely do not want a pure GI iron that will hold me back once I get my swing adjusted again.

I have been looking at Mizuno MP64's and when I hit them the other day they felt amazing and not a single mis-hit with them. I've also been looking at Callaway Apex and X-Forged but I haven't had the chance to hit them yet. I've read some people say that the X-Forged and MP64 are almost identical clubs with only negligible differences, but then I see some say that the X-Forged have quite a bit more forgiveness but still allow you to work the ball a decent amount.

Are the MP64's really not very forgiving irons? This seems odd to me because I usually mishit about 1 out of every 10 balls at the driving range but when I was hitting the MP64 the worst shot I had was 180yds with a 5 iron, but it still got nice loft, so I figured that they were pretty forgiving irons because it doesn't seem likely that I'm out-performing myself with a completely new and foreign set of clubs.

In the mean time I wouldn't mind acquiring a 3 wood and some wedges, though. I know I will have to get them separately anyway, and I don't really know where to start. I'm looking for minimal spin in my wedges, I'd definitely like a higher loft to drop the ball right on target with as little movement after impact as possible. I tried a few Cleveland wedges and really liked them (don't remember the models), but are there some tips you could provide in picking out a fairway wood and wedges?

Sorry to ask so many questions at once, I hope it's not overwhelming.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

GI irons don't hold back the numerous tour players who use them, including multiple major winners. You can get the MPs if you want, they're really nice clubs, but they will not perform as well as GI irons.

I'd recommend a hybrid you like somewhere in the 18-22 degree range, and if you really want to then add a fairway wood.

As far as wedges, I'd try to get fitted if possible, but just try to pick good loft gaps and get the distances you need. They are 99% technique, so the shot shape and spin you want are all on you. Mizuno wedges are hard to beat though.

Always look for older models for better deals compared to the latest stuff; I got a pair of R12s new for 60$ each. Never paid over 150 for a club.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I didn't mean to sound arrogant if that's how I came off. What I meant is, I would like to have forgiveness but I also want to be able to work the ball in the future and I don't want to have to buy new clubs to do that.

I've tried hitting a 4 hybrid but I just cannot ever get a good hit with it, that's why I was leaning more towards a fairway wood because I can hit 3 woods pretty consistently. I'm not sure why I can hit a wood but not a hybrid, but that seems to be the case. My first experience with a hybrid was this season, though.

I was looking at the MP60's because they are significantly cheaper than the MP64's, but from what I read the 64's have more forgiveness which is what made me lean towards those despite the higher price.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like to have forgiveness but I also want to be able to work the ball in the future and I don't want to have to buy new clubs to do that.

I've tried hitting a 4 hybrid but I just cannot ever get a good hit with it, that's why I was leaning more towards a fairway wood because I can hit 3 woods pretty consistently. I'm not sure why I can hit a wood but not a hybrid, but that seems to be the case. My first experience with a hybrid was this season, though.

Don't take my statements as calling you arrogant, it's just that the idea that most tour players use blades is a complete myth. None of them have trouble working the ball; if anything, Bubba Watson uses a cavity back set and GI driver and he's probably the most famous for working the ball. Almost all use some form of hybrid as well.

Regarding the hybrid, go to a shop and demo as many different ones as you can. One hybrid at one loft will not represent the available choices; many are more wood-like in their shape than iron-like, and a 5 wood can accomplish the same things if you really want. Just find one you like and it's a very versatile weapon.

I have hit the MP64s and the MP4. Neither of them are forgiving. The MP54s are the closest thing to what you seem to want, though something like the JPX800 pro would be a better option.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

No clubs of decent quality are going to hold you back. There are major winners using what some call "game improvement" clubs. The brand has nothing to do with it and the ones that are harder to hit will not make you a better player, nor will they allow "workability" . The only problem GI clubs is that they may not suit a player who naturally hits it high.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan, a few questions:

  • How old are you?
  • What is your overall fitness situation - strength and flexibility?
  • What is your driver swingspeed? (would influence overall shaft selection)

Also, I've heard from a lot of golfers personally on the Players/blades, GI and SGI irons. One scramble partner from  a few years ago had been a scratch golfer for his small college team, when he played blade irons. I met him in his late 20s, when he had a job and a wife and two sons. He had swapped out the blades for GI irons. The gladly traded the blades " trick shot" potential for the reliability of the GI irons - he just didn't have the practice time to keep a "blade swing' in tune.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Don't take my statements as calling you arrogant, it's just that the idea that most tour players use blades is a complete myth. None of them have trouble working the ball; if anything, Bubba Watson uses a cavity back set and GI driver and he's probably the most famous for working the ball. Almost all use some form of hybrid as well.

Regarding the hybrid, go to a shop and demo as many different ones as you can. One hybrid at one loft will not represent the available choices; many are more wood-like in their shape than iron-like, and a 5 wood can accomplish the same things if you really want. Just find one you like and it's a very versatile weapon.

I have hit the MP64s and the MP4. Neither of them are forgiving. The MP54s are the closest thing to what you seem to want, though something like the JPX800 pro would be a better option.


I agree with Lucius here.  It seems like every tour player hits Titleist MB blades but I would bet more play the AP2's.  There are a lot of forged clubs out there that can give you workability while not punishing you very harshly for an off shot.  I would rather lose 10 yards of distance than shoot 20 yards left or right.

I just pulled the trigger on JPX 850 pro's and was really up in the air between them and the MP54's.  It came down to shots that I missed slightly.  When I hit them perfect, the MP54 was the best feeling club I have ever hit.  The JPX 850's were one of the best feeling.  When I missed though, the JPX 850 still provided me with a GI lie where the MP54's didn't leave much to work with.

I would not go for the MP's but these are just my opinions

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • My Swing (Hardspoon)
      Good practice session today.  I reviewed the grip thread one more time before I went out, and made that a point of emphasis before every shot. My focus was to continue to groove the in-to-out path I've been working on, but to start to really work on proper clubface angle.  My tendency right now (when I take the "correct" grip) is to leave the face open at impact, leading to straight pushes and push-fades. It's not easy, but I did have some success, starting with slow-motion swings and working up to (what felt like) 80-90%.  I focused on using the move that @iacas explained in Erie (hand rotation, not a "wrist-flip") to get the face squared up.  I was able to hit some nice push-draws and straight draws with both the irons and driver...not consistently, but it was encouraging. I also bought a tripod adapter for my iPhone so I can try some 240fps recordings of my swing this weekend.    
    • Signing an Incorrect Scorecard
      It matters. Please read the last paragraph of my original post (the one that explains why I'm tracking a bogus HI). I'm using an online Handicap tracker. My HI is not legitimate on a couple levels. I don't belong to a club and I play the vast majority of my rounds by myself. That's why I don't show a HI in my profile. It's only important that I play by the rules because I want an honest assessment of my progress. I may never play in a tournament, but if I do, I'd like to be bit more familiar with how these things are done. Just because I suck at golf doesn't mean I can try to learn the rules.
    • Hitting behind the ball and making deep divots...
      I took a look at your my swing thread - looks like you've gotten some good advice there and made some solid improvements.  FWIW - I posted this thread here called "What is the Secret of the Golf Swing" . .and I said that, for me, it was realizing how not to aim at the ball.  This "realization" helped me fix a lot of the things I see in your swing.  I'd been told lots and lots of times - don't hit at the ball, swing through to the target . but it didn't make sense to me . .until one day it suddenly did.  Anyway - while I suffered from this misconception - I had a variety of bad shots.  On my good days I could hit it pretty good.  On my bad days anything could happen . .I could slice it, hit it fat, pull hook it, top it, skull it, etc.  Anyway - it's not as easy as just "don't hit at the ball" . .or, as I think of it.  .don't aim "the energy of your swing at the back of the ball".   Speaking just for myself, it took a lot of practice and lessons to get to where I could "suddenly have this realization".  But . .in the meantime - you are hitting it fat (or whatever) because you're making a lot of corrections for some fundamentals that are off.  And, for sure, fatigue would have a lot to do with it.  The more fatigued you are, the less likely you'll be to make this corrections successfully .  If you get lessons or sign up for evolvr or just keep posting in the myswing thread - you can get the (slow) way forward - it's by focusing on one thing and then the next and then the next and yada yada.  I couldn't say what your "next thing" to work on is, though.     
    • "5 Minutes Daily" Practice Challenge May 2016
      Practicing different speeds of backswing almost making a drill of it.  Super slow checking positions, then slow, then kind of slow and swing  . I think I had one day of my reply to topic not posting bc sometimes my phone is crappy but was able to do the next morning and had two entries that day.  Its up to the powers that be if I completed the challenge. 
    • My Swing (Masher41)
      Better video. Full swing.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. obwan
      obwan
      (70 years old)
    2. rkim291968
      rkim291968
      (54 years old)
  • Blog Entries