Blades vs Cavity Back

ace2894 · November 19, 2008

Hey I'm 14 and want a new set of irons. I'm a 10 handicap so do I want a blade or should I try a better players cavity back and what are some good sets of each?

Driver:Cleveland Hibore 10.5
FW:Cleveland Launcher 15 and 19
Hybrid:Cleveland Halo 22
IRONS: TAYLORMADE SUPERSTEEL 4-pw
Wedge:Vokey Oil Can 56
Putter:Never Compromise GM2 HM

**Stacey_E** · November 20, 2008

JMHO...a player's cavity might be the way to go with your handicap. You obviously are able to strike the ball with some consistancy. Maybe you could look for a workable set of irons that could help you shave some strokes without overly punishing your bad hits. Some I would consider are Mizuno MP 52/57/60s, Titleist AP2, Callaway X20 tours, Ping S58 & 57s and I10s, TaylorMade R7 tps or Cobra Pro Cbs. That's just a short list of some of your newer options. Another set I would highly recommend, but am partial to since they are in my bag, is the Cleveland CG2s. I just think they are Cleveland's best player's cavities (more like a cavity muscle). But some love the CG golds as well.

Of course if you want to consider a blade you have lots of options as well. You will hear arguements both for and against them, none of which I can personally refute. My only advice in deciding is that you get as much range time as possible with what ever irons you are interested in before buying. And as always get your irons fitted.

Good Luck!

roundieryan · November 20, 2008

I am in the same situation. I have demo'd a ton of irons recently and I really really like the cleveland CG reds. Awesome iron.

**Never3putt** · November 20, 2008

There's a reason that a LOT of pros use cavity back irons rather than muscle back blades .... do yourself a favor and take advantage of technology .... find irons that you like and can play well and don't concern yourself with the name brand or if they're blades or not.

**tim31x** · November 20, 2008

No one here can really tell you what you want, only your yourself can do that. However, we can make suggestions. I myself favor blades for their workability over cavity backs. Both have their pros and cons, most notably being that cavities are generally more forgiving while blades more workable and better control. Here are a few of my suggestions:

Blades:

Wilson Staff Fi5
Wilson Staff Fg59 Irons
Any Mizuno blade really
Titliest 755, 775
The new Nike TW Victory Red series

Cavity Backs:
Ping G5, G10, I10
Taylormade r7
Tayloremade RAC
Mizuno MX-25
Wilson Staff Di7
Wilson Staff Ci7
A Nice Set of Hogans
Callaway X-whatever they are all pretty good

On Cavities, you really can't go wrong with a set of pings or callaways.

**Baraethon** · November 20, 2008

I like the X-20's, they are fairly responsive, but have a bit of forgiveness, if that's what you want.

Not that I'm an expert judge ;)

**ks8829** · November 20, 2008

I will give you 3 answers below...........

1) Buy the Mizuno mp33 blades
2) Buy the Mizuno combo set with mp33 up to 7 irons and get a set of cavity back, mp30
3) Buy the mp33 iron and get hybrids to fill in the gap

darthfader · November 20, 2008

Here's what the top 25 pros are playing, in case someone is counting...

1. Tiger Woods - blades
2. Sergio Garcia - MB TP "blades", until very recently
3. Phil Mickelson - blades
4. Padraig Harrington - cavity
5. Vijay Singh - blades
6. Robert Karlsson - blades
7. Camilo Villegas - cavity
8. Ernie Els - blades
9. Anthony Kim - blades
10. Lee Westwood - cavity
11. Henrik Stenson - cavity
12. Jim Furyk - cavity
13. Steve Stricker - cavity
14. Geoff Ogilvy - blades
15. Stewart Cink - ehh… CCI Forged… lets be honest, it’s a blade
16. K.J. Choi - blades
17. Adam Scott - blades, until very recently
18. Justin Rose - MB TP "blades"
19. Kenny Perry - cavity
20. Miguel A. Jimenez - S59… big muscle pad in the back… it’s a blade
21. Mike Weir - cavity
22. Trevor Immelman - cavity
23. Justin Leonard - blades
24. Ben Curtis - cavity
25. Ian Poulter - blades

So my rough count says 15/25 are playing blades (or something pretty close). What does that mean for you?

Well... it should mean absolutely nothing. You aren't gonna get any "macho" points just because you're hitting a blade 2-iron instead of a hybrid. And if the face is a couple degrees open at impact, it won't matter if you're swinging a Tiger blade or a big Callaway shovel. The ball will go right.

I play blades and I love them. I've hit cavity irons that felt awful, and I've hit some that felt great. I've also hit blades that felt very harsh. It's simply a matter of confidence. You need to hit a bunch of different kinds of irons, and find something that works well. Period.

[NOTE: Just in case there are some blade-haters out there who don't like my assessment of the top 25 players.. lighten up guys. Even if my math/equipment is a little off, the point remains.. plenty of those guys still play blades. That was the point I was trying to make.]

**bogeyhitter25** · November 21, 2008

Mizuno MP-30s. Nice clubs, good price. And they are pretty much right in between cavity-backs, and blades which would probably be perfect for you. Also check out some Titleists'.

**golf_junkie27** · November 21, 2008

Why not try a combo set like the Bridgestone J36? Full Cavity in the lower, split cavity in the middle and blades in the scoring irons.

Nike makes a combo set, too as does Titleist, if I am not mistaken.

I can tell you, from experience, that you will like the Bridgestones. They're simple a really nice, soft iron offering forgiveness, playability and feedback.

**wkdspd** · November 22, 2008

first thing you need to figure out is which end of your clubs you hit better - long irons or short irons? Im a tad squirrely with my long irons, but like to play darts with my short irons, so I agree with the comments so far about a combo set. Im playing TM Rac OS 3-6 irons, and TM TP MB 7-p. this gives me the forgiveness I need when cruising a longer shot and am trying to swing more fully, but allows the finesse I need to drop shots close with a tighter swing. the combinations that have been mentioned so far are all good options, go swing several and find a set that you like, then look for the combo version of it. buying used also helps you create that matched set you're looking for. hope that helps.

golfaddict714 · November 22, 2008

Mizuno mx 23. Trust me..........

golfaddict714 · November 22, 2008

if you want a blade, go with the Mizuno Mp 30. Its half blade half cavity, a hybrid. Butter.....

**mako224** · November 22, 2008

I play titleist 690mb blades but also own a set of 755 cavity backs. I don't notice much difference between them shotwize. A good shot is a good shot. Its the archer not the arrows so to speak. I will say this though whatever you get make sure they are forged soft steel not cast or forged stainless. 1025 carbon steele just feels so much better at impact. The 1025 is more of a woosh feeling while stainless is like a sharp click at impact. You can feel so much more of what's going on at impact with the soft carbon steel irons. It will make you a better player.

golfaddict714 · November 23, 2008

i also played the mp 30s. Perfect clubs, i learned the game using those clubs and my handicap dropped while using those.

**ks8829** · November 23, 2008

Look at the deals out there for Mizuno mp33 irons sets.........

sold for $145 including shipping
http://cgi.ebay.com/MIZUNO-MP-33-MP3...1%7C240%3A1318

sold for $131 including shipping
http://cgi.ebay.com/Mizuno-MP-33-iro...1%7C240%3A1318

**loopy** · November 23, 2008

I just switched from Cobra 3100 i's to more of a players cavity back (Precept tour premium forged). Got 'em used even up swap. I was looking for a smaller head profile with more workabilty. They also have some pretty stiff shafts (rifle 6.5). Lost about one club length, but now I can work the ball a little better and my shots are a lot straighter. I made the swap so I could work on better mechanics and ball contact becasue I felt my old irons let me get away with mediocre swings. Just my $.02.

**Prodigy** · November 24, 2008

i switch off between players cavity and blades. But ive been hitting blades since i was 13. Im just gonna go out and say it if you want to learn how to hit a golf ball the right way just get blades. Only reason i went to players cavity was becuase my dad would not stop nagging about the blades "lack of forgiviness" . If you want percision and the ball to obey your evey command then get blades. If you want a mix with a tad of forgiviness get the players cavities. I would reccomend some mizunoor titleist for blades. And as for players cavitie only way to go is callaway x forged belive me

hope this helps
..Chris

Sign In

Blades vs Cavity Back

Recommended Posts

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

Create an account

Sign in

Topics Being Discussed Right Now on The Sand Trap

TST Partners

Posts

Important Information