or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Pro Shop › Clubs, Grips, Shafts, Fitting › New Driver = help needed
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

New Driver = help needed

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 

I had a Caddyshack moment yesterday playing in an Open Competition at my club.  Playing off 10 I had just parred the 10th, after birdyin 8 and 9,to get to level par for my round when I took my driver out of my bag going to the 11th tee, only for the head to fall off.  When I looked I discovered the shaft had snapped about a foot up from the head.  I don't have an idea how it happened because I'd put it in the bag after hitting a great drive up 10 and I didn't notice any problem with it.  Anyway, my dilemna is what to replace my beloved G15 driver with.  My handicap has come down in the last couple of years, largely because of my improved driving with the G15, but I need to find a few extra yards off the tee, and of course I want to take the lazy option through club technology rather than working harder on the range.  I'm 52, fairly fit, but with a medium clubhead speed, being more a Luke Donald than a Bubba Watson.  I've considered the RBZ, although I hate the white head, and the Callaway Razr Fit, but I'm interested in hearing some suggestions.  I liked the G15 initially because of its forgivenes, but my game has improved considerably over the last year.

post #2 of 10

Try the 910D2, you will be happy you did trust me.

post #3 of 10
Is the G15 for sale as is? If so, PM me a price please.
post #4 of 10
Why don't you just get a new shaft and move on, I have heard multiple times that proper shaft matching can be the most beneficial thing when building a driver.
post #5 of 10
I moved from a g15 to a i20 and I love it even more.
post #6 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by FarWest View Post

I had a Caddyshack moment yesterday playing in an Open Competition at my club.  Playing off 10 I had just parred the 10th, after birdyin 8 and 9,to get to level par for my round when I took my driver out of my bag going to the 11th tee, only for the head to fall off.  When I looked I discovered the shaft had snapped about a foot up from the head.  I don't have an idea how it happened because I'd put it in the bag after hitting a great drive up 10 and I didn't notice any problem with it.  Anyway, my dilemna is what to replace my beloved G15 driver with.  My handicap has come down in the last couple of years, largely because of my improved driving with the G15, but I need to find a few extra yards off the tee, and of course I want to take the lazy option through club technology rather than working harder on the range.  I'm 52, fairly fit, but with a medium clubhead speed, being more a Luke Donald than a Bubba Watson.  I've considered the RBZ, although I hate the white head, and the Callaway Razr Fit, but I'm interested in hearing some suggestions.  I liked the G15 initially because of its forgivenes, but my game has improved considerably over the last year.

Before throwing away your G15 driver, send it back to PING via golfsmith. I did it twice for really obnoxiously stupid reasons, and they replaced it twice without any questions.

So, if they replace it you will still have a backup driver, and don't have to tell your boss that they replaced it. Your plans for getting a new driver will have not been foiled.

Also, I tried out the i20 driver 9.5 degrees stock stiff shaft, it's really sweet. I can't justify getting it, though. The ANSER seems pretty good too, but the i20 had a really snappy sound when hitting.

I guess you can hear a PING in my comments. a1_smile.gif
post #7 of 10

If you like Ping, call Ping Customer Service and see if they will replace the shaft - might be a warranty issue since there was no reason for the club to fail.

 

If you want a new driver, I'd still call Ping CS, and if you like Ping, and want another driver, try another Ping (Anser) at a demo day this Fall where they have the launch monitor. You might ask about digitally lofting to make sure you get the loft you want.

 

Or wait and try the new Titleist 913, and Adams Drivers are typically very good, and generally on sale. Razr Fit gets good reviews. Lots of choices. Demo. Get Fit. 

post #8 of 10
Thread Starter 

Thanks for all the comments.  I have thought about replacing the shaft with a mid kick shaft to get lower launch, but its a draw bias head that I got to correct a very destructive slice.  My golf has improved considerably over the past couple of years after I made a conscious decision to play more, and I think I can look at a different driver.  I played this morning with a G5 that a mate lent me, and if anything I'm hitting the ball with a slight fade, and also getting 10 yards or so extra distance without a draw bias, so it confirmed that I can move away from it.  I like the look of the i20, and being a bit of a Ping disciple I think I'll go and get fitted properly.  I've discovered that as part of our club fees that we actually have insurance against club breakage so it looks like I'll get half the price of  anew toy from them.  All in all not a bad result.  Thanks again. 

post #9 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by FarWest View Post

Thanks for all the comments.  I have thought about replacing the shaft with a mid kick shaft to get lower launch, but its a draw bias head that I got to correct a very destructive slice.  My golf has improved considerably over the past couple of years after I made a conscious decision to play more, and I think I can look at a different driver.  I played this morning with a G5 that a mate lent me, and if anything I'm hitting the ball with a slight fade, and also getting 10 yards or so extra distance without a draw bias, so it confirmed that I can move away from it.  I like the look of the i20, and being a bit of a Ping disciple I think I'll go and get fitted properly.  I've discovered that as part of our club fees that we actually have insurance against club breakage so it looks like I'll get half the price of  anew toy from them.  All in all not a bad result.  Thanks again. 

i20 - reviews are that it's not forgiving and only for better players - the Anser is between the G and i Series.

 

Take a look.

 

Good rule of thumb - get as forgiving as you can while still liking the look and performance characteristics.

post #10 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Desmond View Post

i20 - reviews are that it's not forgiving and only for better players - the Anser is between the G and i Series.

 

Take a look.

 

Good rule of thumb - get as forgiving as you can while still liking the look and performance characteristics.


Hit the Anser the other night with the Razr Fit. Both are solid sticks. 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Clubs, Grips, Shafts, Fitting
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Pro Shop › Clubs, Grips, Shafts, Fitting › New Driver = help needed