Should Hips & Spine Be Rotated as One?

[KevinBlake]

When I say "as one" I mean should you rotate them both at the same speed, so that they both will match up in their rotation on the backswing? 

 

Reason I ask is because since the spine can rotate more than the hips, should the spine be rotated more quickly - or should you rotate them at the same pace, then when the hips reaches it's limit, keep rotating the spine until it turns 90* while the hips stay in the fixed position

 

Here's a pic of what I mean, you can see his spine is rotated far more than his hips, because the hips have reached their limit 

[saevel25]

28 minutes ago, KevinBlake said:

Reason I ask is because since the spine can rotate more than the hips, should the spine be rotated more quickly - or should you rotate them at the same pace, then when the hips reaches it's limit, keep rotating the spine until it turns 90* while the hips stay in the fixed position

Go look up kinematic sequence for the golf swing.

also, even after you find an answer. What you feel happens might not match up. 

like, I feel a slight torso turn and a small bit of hand stuff. The video shows full hip turn, full shoulder turn, and the club ends up near parallel for the driver and short of parallel for the irons. 

the downswing, I feel much more the finish position. Stretch in the left side from hip to shoulder. Belt buckle facing the horizon more. I don’t feel the kinematic sequence of hip slide, rotation starting from the ground up.

so, these questions of what happens, don’t translate to actually feeling that motion. Yet, the video can show it.

[iacas]

@KevinBlake, buddy, come on man.

You are going about this all wrong.