Do i neeeeeed a 4 iron?

[dagolfer]

For the longest time i played a set up consisting of a 23 degree 4 hybrid and a 4 iron and i sorta liked it. First day out on the course this spring my 4 iron broke. I have been playing some practice rounds without it and seem to be doing just fine. I just had to accomodate to punching out from trees with 5 iron instead. However, i am going to purchase new irons i believe and i was wondering if you see the need for me to purchase a 4 iron. So my iron set would either be 4-p or 5 -p. Thanks.

[DaSportsGuy]

I read in a golf magazine that if you're using anything less than a 5 iron, you'd better be at least a 5.0 handicap.

I'm well above a 5.0 handicap but I prefer to carry a 4 iron myself because I have much more confidence in hitting my irons. Plus, it's much easier to hit out of the rough than a hybrid because it doesn't get caught up and open up as easily.

Some people think hybrids are the way to go, others side with irons. IMO, it just depends on what you feel comfortable with.

[ash]

Agree with DaSportsGuy... I use (and love) my 3-iron, no hybrids, no 5-wood, no problems with distance gapping.... Definitley depends on your game, and whether you find you need it or not.

[jamo]

You guys, I think he is saying not having a 4 iron at all, hybrid or otherwise. If it workd for you, I don't see why not, it is all about maintaining consistent yardage gaps, and if a Pw-5 set does that, go for it.

[Shindig]

Jim Furyk has neither a 4-iron nor a 4-hybrid. He's done OK for himself. Punching out is slightly more difficult with a 5 than a 4, but that's about it. The only problem is if this introduces a distance gap that affects your game, but if you're fine without it in practice rounds, you might be for competitive rounds too. Given that you've got a 23° hybrid in the bag, I doubt it will be a problem.

I took out my 4-iron not too long ago, after a long time of carrying it and a hybrid. I haven't added a 14th club. I might put it back for a few tournaments later this month, but if I had to go out and purchase it, I wouldn't do so.