Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
k-daugh

What are the best ben hogan irons for the beginner?

11 posts in this topic

Hi all, Im new at the game and have absolutly  fallen in love with golf. I currently have a set of hogan radial blades which I here aren't the ideal club for the beginner. My uncle ray has been playing the game for 40 or so years and loves hogans . A few guys at the local country club hit hogans too and they all love them ...heck i love mine and i cant really hit them that well...anyways my question is which hogans would be the best for the beginner golfer....there are many nice sets on ebay just so many too choose from...i've shot just under 10 rounds and have shot between 99 and 110 just to give you an idea of my skill level

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

I think you want the Apex irons.  They were more of a game-improvement club with a nice cavity back and a wider sole.  No sense limiting yourself to Hogans though, theres lots of other great brands on the market that you might like better.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

any suggestions??? also im 5'6" tall i've been told i have a very smooth swing for a beginner and my uncle says i have a "good swing speed" now i know this isnt a considered a custom fitting but please.....humor me and give me any suggestions especially hogan suggestions because i like the look of them ... also i hit my uncle s hogan apex edge i think and it felt a world of difference over my blades ....no pain in the hands and high and much more consistent ....but im up for any other suggestions and or advice..thanks

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hogan's SGI clubs are the C.F.T.  They have a wide cavity back and are perimeter weighted.  Most Hogan loyalists didn't like these clubs because they weren't forged or look like the older Hogan irons.

Be careful, Hogan irons can be pretty confusing because they re-used names quite often.  The previous poster mentioned Apex irons, there are irons that have the Apex name from 1972, 1973, 1988, 1992, 1994, 1998.  Then there are variations of the Apex name such as Apex II, Apex PC, Apex BH Grind, Apex Plus and Apex Pro.  These are all different models, and look very different from one another so it's important to know which ones you are looking at and buying.  The Apex name comes from the shaft which are typically labeled (2), (3), (4) - I think 2 is senior flex, 3 is regular flex, and 4 is stiff flex.  I've never seen a (1) or (5) but I've heard they were produced.  I'm guessing (1) was ladies flex and (5) was x-stiff.

The Apex Plus and Pro's have  forged heads and are pretty forgiving.  They were produced more recently so you're more likely to find these models in better condition than some of the older Hogan blades, like the 1 Plus / Plus 1 or Apex / Apex II which are also much less forgiving.  I own the One Plus, Apex (1973), Apex II (1979), Apex Pro and C.F.T.

Here's a link of the Hogan irons timeline so you have an idea of when they were produced.

http://web.archive.org/web/20011206100727/www.benhogan.com/53-99_Clubs.html

While I have come to greatly admire Mr. Hogan as a golfer, and started a collection of his clubs I'm not sure you should limit your choices, especially since todays clubs are more forgiving, and given you'd likely be limited to purchasing them on ebay or second hand stores getting custom fitted could be difficult and expensive.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I believe that the Apex Edge would be a good place to start... they also made another GI set that wasn't forged that they called the BH-5...  might be worth a look.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

thanks for the advice guys..... well giving the description of my game and swing can anyone give me a general idea of which clubs i should be considering ....

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by k-daugh

thanks for the advice guys..... well giving the description of my game and swing can anyone give me a general idea of which clubs i should be considering ....



Just generally speaking I'd look at some GI clubs (game improvement)... but as to a specific make or model, no.  Your best bet is to go to a shop and hit as many as you can... See what you hit best as well as what suits your eye and your wallet.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I second the Hogan CFT Edge irons. Great beginner clubs and can be had on ebay for around $100.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My first set of clubs were the Apex Edge set...

They are GI irons, perimeter weighted, and have a big sole with an undercut cavity making them quite forgiving.  They were much more forgiving than the Tommy Armour set I borrowed for a few months before buying my own clubs.  And, because they are forged, I was getting good feedback on my mishits.

Mike

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I began with Apex Edge irons from 2001 and still like them. The regular graphite shaft gets to be a little soft on my (balloning shots), distance is still OK.

I am currently messing around with different Apex blades for fun. If you mishit them, you loose much distance - bet you already figured that out, I guess. The Apex Edge from 2001 or 2006 are a good choice.

You could look at buying cheap single irons and try them (or look at the guys Hogan clubs at your place). I own a BH-5 6i and do not like it. It is a cast club and does not has the feel/sound of a forged club. The FTX form 2006 is nice to play, too. I read a lot of not so favorable remarks about the CFT irons, but have never played one. I am eager to try the Apex Pro sometime, too.

Oh, btw, the Hogan Bettinardi putters are really nice, too.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd second the Apex Edge set. My son just started playing and they're a great quality set at at a reasonable price. We picked them up from Amazon.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00CPS0PS2/ref=as_li_tf_tl?ie=UTF8&camp;=1789&creative;=9325&creativeASIN;=B00CPS0PS2&linkCode;=as2&tag;=wefuhwe-20

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • I hurt my shoulder a while back. After a doctor's visit, and a  very minor surgical proceedure, I was told 4-6 weeks for return to golf. That was about 3 weeks ago. My shoulder feels great, and normal everyday use is not a problem. However, a full swing of a golf club is not considered "normal everyday use" by my doctor. I am most likely not going  press my luck for at least another 2 weeks.  As posted above, you should go see your doctor. What you might think is tendonitis, might be something worse. Plus after a week's rest, and your elbow feeling great, it might not actually be ready for the rigors of a golf swing. 
    • For any hobby/pasttime the constant pursuit of "progress" can produce a diminishing return.  I'm fighting it right now.  I've been practicing a lot and watching my scores get worse and getting fed up.  But why should I be working so hard and getting frustrated at a game that I'm supposed to be playing for fun?  This past weekend at a member meetup I shot a "stellar" 122 and had a blast doing it.  And that's the real point, isn't it?  Having fun?  If you're playing golf "for fun" (i.e., not to put food on the table and roof over your head) but need to somehow reward yourself when you don't swear at bad shots, maybe your focus in the wrong place.  That's all I'm saying... I may be wrong.
    • I guess considering I got coached in the mid 80's and have never altered (though I have tampered with minor things) the swing since then, most likely my reverse C is a position I will play for a long time unless I really put in the time for new coaching or my back tells me I cannot do that anymore.  Hopefully I will be able to strengthen my core muscles so that this swing does not affect me
    • One thing that helped me improve my game was to take an honest look at my round. I would write out every hole and what happened. Something like this: Hole 1 [] - bogey - driver to right rough. 50deg from 120 to front bunker. 58 to 15ft. 2 putts (15,1) I did this for about 4 rounds and immediately started to see some common themes. Here is a direct example out of my file from 2014 for the first hole that paved the way to me dropping at least 5 shots per round. Hole 1 [] - bogey - driver to right rough. 50deg from 120 to front bunker. 58 to 15ft. 2 putts (15,1) Hole 1 [gir] - par - driver to right rough. 58deg from 92 to 20ftt. 2 putts (20,3) Hole 1 [gir] - bogey - driver to left bunker. PW from 128 to 60ft long. 3 putts (60,7, 1) Hole 1 [fw,gir] - par - crap driver in fairway. 9 iron from 140 to 22ft. 2 putts (22,1) I remember when I wrote that last one out kind of laughing. That hole felt easy to make a par on once I was on the fairway. I would stand on the tee and be scared of the water right, or the OB left, or the bunkers left, or the cart path (can't count how many times I hit it). Here is the hole I then decided that trying to hit a driver over the bunker on the left was stupid. I started hitting a hybrid to just short of that bunker. ie: the fattest part of the fairway. I was around 70% pars on that hole. The previous year I was probably something like 40%. It went from my most hated hole to one I enjoyed as it was low stress. A hybrid would never go in the water. Longest I would have in to the pin would be a 7 iron. If the pin was back right I would aim for middle back of the green and call it good. I did this for the remainder of the year. I ended up hitting driver less. About 5 times less. Which, surprise surprise, saved me 5 shots per round :) As the season progressed I dropped my handicap from about 8ish to 4. I have stuck around the 4 since then. I still shot the odd 92, almost always on a course I have never played before. If I have played the course I generally expect to be in the 70s. Now with the advent of things like GameGolf, Sky Golf, and Arccos, you can pretty easily get this information and figure out where you are throwing shots away.   
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

  • Blog Entries