Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Eric Lindgren

Question about iron sets?

3 posts in this topic

Last year, after having played for 20+ years, I finally decided to get more serious about getting better. I got lessons for the first time in my life (3 day golf school), part of which was a professional fitting. I currently have Cleveland TA-5 irons (4-PW) that I had 3/4" added to when I got them. The professional that measured me recommended a steel shaft (I have about 100-105 mph swing speed), a 39.5" shaft for my 5 iron with standard loft and lie and oversized grips. I'm 6'5" and have always felt I needed longer shafts, but never got measured. He also recommended either Ping or Taylormade irons because he said, they're among the lightest weight irons made. He watched me swing my clubs and asked if my back bothered me, and while I don't have back problems, I do find it my back getting more sore after playing than it used to (part of that is getting me getting old). I tend tend to slice my mishits and have had a lot of trouble hitting my irons for about the last year and a half (after I tried to totally rebuild my swing on my own).  I'm currently about a 25 handicap, and at one point, was down to about a 17 (pre-swing rebuild).

I'm ready to get my irons and have been shopping around looking at the different Ping and Taylormade sets. I've always been a Nike guy, and was looking at the Nike VR irons, but after my experience at the golf school (I highly recommend it, by the way) I'm focusing more on what was recommended to me. I'm having a hard time narrowing my choices between the Ping G15, G20, i20, Anser, and the TaylorMade RocketBallz, RocketBladez, and the Burner 2.0. Does it really come down to personal preference, or is there any real difference between these clubs? Thanks again to every one!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

I may be in the minority here, but when it comes to iron play, I recommend sticking to what you are familiar with.  As I've posted in other replies, if you are used to a specific look, feel, and sound from one manufacturer, it's very difficult to change to another - unless these specific attributes are less important to you.

Not sure that I agree with the pro that told you to go with a specific OEM because of their weight characteristics as each manufacturer provides customization options that can get you what you really need.

One final note, and I think this is most important, don't compare today's iron lengths to older irons.  Your TA5's have much softer lofts than today's irons, so comparing the distance between the TA5 7-iron and the TM Rocketblades 7-iron, is an unfair one.  You may have to compare the TA5 6-iron, to the Rocketblades 7-iron (lots of opinion around this, so be ready for some contradictions).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • It seems from the ratings that I have seen that, like me, there were a lot of people watching the final round of golf for both the women and the men at the Rio Olympics. The ratings for the men were in fact, second only to the Masters. That is truly fantastic to hear. Going into this Olympics, at least on the men's side, you might think that we were set for a complete disaster. All but a few of the high profile names dropped out for multiple reasons. Pika, safety, or the real reason - just plain tired. I suspect all that didn't play sort of wished they did. They will come out and say that they didn't miss it, because they don't want to look stupid, but the reality is they probably have a pit in their stomach for missing the first Olympics in over 100 years. I am talking about Jason Day, Jordan Spieth, and yes I suspect even Rory McIlroy.
      (...)
      Read the rest of Reliving the Olympic Success (702 words) by mchepp for The Sand Trap, © 2016. | Permalink View and Comment on the Full Article
    • It seems from the ratings that I have seen that, like me, there were a lot of people watching the final round of golf for both the women and the men at the Rio Olympics. The ratings for the men were in fact, second only to the Masters. That is truly fantastic to hear. Going into this Olympics, at least on the men's side, you might think that we were set for a complete disaster. All but a few of the high profile names dropped out for multiple reasons. Pika, safety, or the real reason - just plain tired. I suspect all that didn't play sort of wished they did. They will come out and say that they didn't miss it, because they don't want to look stupid, but the reality is they probably have a pit in their stomach for missing the first Olympics in over 100 years. I am talking about Jason Day, Jordan Spieth, and yes I suspect even Rory McIlroy.
      (...)
      Read the rest of Reliving the Olympic Success (702 words) by mchepp for The Sand Trap, © 2016. | Permalink View and Comment on the Full Article
    • Let us know how it goes when you get them.
    • According to GAME GOLF, I have 68% GIR and 13% birdies. 13%/68% (I almost never chip in for birdie) = 19.12%.
    • Damn dude, 4.1?  Wow.  I think you and I were about even when I joined here a couple years ago, 6-something.  You're going in the right direction, I'm headed the other way.  I'm actually at 9.4 at the minute but haven't updated here cuz it's painful and I consider it temporary .  Hand pain gone, actually went to the range this week, 1st time in a year.  So, I plan to throw down a 78 or so and be back under 9 by end of day, fingers crossed.  Keep rolling. No idea what my birdie conversion rate is, I'd guess pretty respectable cuz my putting never left me.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    No users celebrating today
  • Blog Entries