Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Wisco-Kid

Swing Plane with Driver Different?

16 posts in this topic

I know there are alot of threads about swing planes, inside-out, steep or flat etc. What I have been very confused about ever since I started playing golf is that my swing just doesn't translate when I use my driver.

I hit my irons great, good compression, high ball flight, with a slight fade. I have a fairly steep swing. When I go to hit my driver if I use the same swing plane I slice it. It is not a crazy slice but a slice.

My questions: Is the swing plane with the driver supposed to be alot flatter?
What would be a good tip on how to start the swing with a driver. Is it supposed to feel like I am swinging a baseball bat?

I am trying to match my swing plane up with the angle of the shaft on my
driver but I just cant seem to get the right feel.
It feels like I am missing something..Any suggestions are welcome.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

I think the driver is flatter simply because of the length of the shaft..I feel that you should release the club a little earlier with the longer clubs...best of luck
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the driver is flatter simply because of the length of the shaft..I feel that you should release the club a little earlier with the longer clubs...best of luck

Wow, the first thing you've said that I can agree with.

The plane is flatter, indeed, because the shaft is longer. The modern 460cc driver is also, for some, a bit tougher to close. Check your grip and make sure your closing the clubface in time. The only other option would be that you are playing a pull-cut with your irons, which can often translate into a plain old slide with the driver because of the differences in how you hit them (irons: off the ground, hit down and through, etc.).
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Check your grip and make sure your closing the clubface in time.

What is the best way for me to check my grip. I use a neutral grip right now.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is how I try to explain this to my students. Get in front of a mirror and address the ground. You will see that the shaft will lie at a particular angle for any given club. This is what I refer to as the shaft plane. (Others definition may vary and I don't wish to be corrected.) Imagine that the shaft were to continue through your torso behind you.

If you were to only rotate your torso and NOT lift your arms or change your original spine angle the shaft will remain along this plane throughout the entire backswing.

Your swing may be more conventional but the original "shaft plane" thing should give you a good idea of how whatever swing plane you wish to refer to alters by club.

Tom
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is how I try to explain this to my students. Get in front of a mirror and address the ground. You will see that the shaft will lie at a particular angle for any given club. This is what I refer to as the shaft plane. (Others definition may vary and I don't wish to be corrected.) Imagine that the shaft were to continue through your torso behind you.

Right that makes sense and I think I understand that. I just cant seem to get the feeling of keeping that "shaft angle" with my driver.

I like your bit about rotating your torso and not lifting your arms. Is that the whole idea?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(Others definition may vary and I don't wish to be corrected.)

That comes off as having quite a bit of attitude. The "corrections" offered previously regarding your "one-plane" and "two-plane" thing were warranted, in my opinion, so please choose your words carefully. If, as an instructor, you've not learned that lesson yet I hope you do soon.

If you were to only rotate your torso and NOT lift your arms or change your original spine angle the shaft will remain along this plane throughout the entire backswing.

While true, I'm not certain I see the point. The golf swing does involve "lifting" the arms. It's not a purely rotational movement.

If all you're saying is that the shaft plane is flatter, so the swing plane changes - that's already been said in this thread, hasn't it?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Yep, pretty much. I try to teach the most relaxed and efficient swing possible. No arm or hand action whatsoever. If you concentrate on only rotating your torso and do absolutely nothing with your arms or hands you will find that you will stay on what I defined as the shaft plane throughout the backswing.

Then all you have to do to swing forward is to get your belly button to face the target before impact. If you can keep your hands and arms passive your plane will flatten a little more coming forward while your body stays well ahead of the clubhead creating great lag.

I often use the belly button analogy as it tends to make people forget about their arms as well as whether their weight shift, hip turn, or shoulder turn dominate the downswing.
In simplest terms turn your belly directly away from the target in the backswing, then point your belly directly at the target before you make contact with the ball. It will feel strange but get you great lag with very little effort.

You will find that rotating your torso (actually rather at a leisurely pace) in the correct sequence will produce prodigious distance and accuracey. Remember the more you have to do during the swing the more you will mess up. Keep it simple and let science do the work for you.

Tom
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My thousands of hours video taping students does indeed tell me that while their shouldn't be any lifting of the arms during the swing, most people actually do lift the club off plane. I did not state that the swing was purely rotational. When I offer advice it is given in a way that I believe people should think, not necessarily what they should do. What people feel versus what they do are usually totally different things.

As for my clarification of MY definition of shaft plane. I think it was warrented given the reproaches offered here. I did not want any confusion with what I was saying and what may have been pulished somewhere else by anyone who managed to get a book deal. In no way was it directed towards any member of this forum. So I am sorry if that is what you inferred.

I humbly disagree with you sir, you may lift your arms if you wish, that is your choice. I however find absolutely no benefit whatsoever in doing so. Experience has taught me that it simply necessitates a more aggressive transition move to return to the flatter plane necessary during the downswing as well as additional timing issues and stress in the arms and hands. Just my opinion and experience. We will have to agree to disagree.

Tom
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Golf requires two swings, irons and woods.

I disagree with that. I think that you have the same swing, however a different set up with each club. The different setup is what makes you hit the ball either on the upswing with the driver or downswing with the irons. Your striking the ball at different times during the swing, but the swing itself is the same. At least it is for me.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To keep it simple, there are some visual images in golf magazine of the varied swing planes according to each club.

I guess I'm more of a visual learner, but these swing-plane images helped me. Of course, reproducing these swing planes, particularly with the driver, is another matter. (smile)

- k
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My best driver shots have been when I smoothly pivot with arms carried along by momentum instead of manipulation. The trick is in maintaining a relatively motionless spine.

If it's good enough for 'Iron Byron', who am I to improve on it ?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Golf requires two swings, irons and woods.

I disagree with the belief that two swings are required (one for irons and one of woods), and I disagree that there is a significant difference between the swing plane of an iron and the swing plane of a wood. While its true that clubs have different lie angles at address that doesn't mean they have to be swung differently. In relation to the body, ball, and ground the club still swings into the same positions. You'll often hear tour pros say they want to keep the swing simple. If you're trying to swing differently with each club you'll making things complicated, not simple.

Look at the image I have linked below: http://img524.imageshack.us/img524/6...nplanesbp4.jpg With both the iron and wood we see: The shaft points at the belt buckle at address. The hands and club head are both on the same level and on the orginal shaft angle plane. The shaft points just inside the ball at the left arm parallel backswing position. The shoulders are perpendicular to the spine at the top of the swing, and the left arm is parallel to the to the line that the shaft was on at left arm parallel back. The shaft at hip high on the downswing is parallel to the original shaft angle plane and points just above the ball with both clubs. At shoulder high in the through swing the shaft again points in the same place it did on the left arm parallel back location. Now after seeing all that who still thinks the irons and driver require a different swing?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sheeeet..Three quarters of the way back you could rest your beer on the clubface of my driver..thats how flat I swing dat thang..
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My thousands of hours video taping students does indeed tell me that while their shouldn't be any lifting of the arms during the swing, most people actually do lift the club off plane. I did not state that the swing was purely rotational. When I offer advice it is given in a way that I believe people should think, not necessarily what they should do. What people feel versus what they do are usually totally different things.

Tom - would you say you teach a one plane swing then? The idea of swinging left, right? Look up a guy named SliceFixer on youtube and GolfWrx. My problem with swinging this way, other than I can't find an instructor here in Kansas, is that the arms can get out of synch easier than the two plane swing - my main problem.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Popular Now

  • Posts

    • Fair warning, this is a bit of a rant... I used to belong to a private club where I had regular group I played with, but due to various factors I gave up the membership this year, and I find myself playing as a single a lot more often on the local public courses. In the past week or two, I've been cut in front of multiple times, hit into a few times despite trying to leave my push cart somewhere visible, even the cart girl passed me by on a really hot day when I could've used a Gatorade OK, the last one was not the end of the world, but after everything else I was beginning to feel invisible. I get that as a single sometimes you have to take what you can get and just roll with the punches, but this in particular was ridiculous: It was late-afternoon and the starter told me to go tee off. I was about 20 steps from the first tee box when a kid (probably older teen) and his dad roll up from behind, drive past me up to the next set of tees and proceed to get ready to tee off.  They looked back and saw me, where I was now on the tee box behind them, at which point I was sure they'd apologize for not noticing me and either ask to join (which would've been fine) or wait.  Instead, they just played their tee shots and drove off. If that was the last time I saw them it would've been one thing, but I ended up waiting on them for nearly every shot through the first five holes.  Finally they skipped ahead to somewhere else on the course and I didn't get held up the rest of the time. Another time, I was already at the tee box (again, at the direction of the course), when a foursome rolled up ahead of me. This time, a lady in the group yelled back and said they were in a league and that I shouldn't be there. I explained that the course had told me to tee off.  She said, "Well, they shouldn't have" and they proceeded to play in front of me.  They were about 40 yards up so a polite discussion to sort things out wasn't going to happen. I waited for them all to play their second shots and got ready to tee off myself, except the lady turned her cart around and just waited in the middle of the fairway. I really wasn't in the mood to put up a fight so I went back in the pro shop and they sent me off the other side. It's not like I'm trying to play during prime time, these were both late-afternoon tee times.  I probably could've stuck up for myself more, but I didn't want to start a confrontation in either case at the risk of ruining my round.  Does anyone else run into this regularly? Not to get all "woe is me," but it starts to feel like the rest of the course wishes you weren't there, and in some cases people behave as though you aren't. Is this just the norm?      
    • Ok, I get that, but why can any Joe Blow guy can still sell "New" product on eBay for less than MAP? I've seen it happen hundreds of thousands of time. Brick and Mortars resellers it's a lot more strict. @newtogolf I have a question for you... I'll use Mizuno as an example... Let's say I go to a Golf retailer and want a set of 2014 JPX- EZ irons... and they have them in their possession.... and have paid the wholesaler and Mizuno already has their money.... The retailer trying to get rid of stock, can't they sell them for whatever they can to break even... (we're not talking custom)... I know you can dump off demo clubs for whatever you can get for them. But I understand the whole eBay thing... Just list it as used... sell them at slightly more than wholesale...  As the OP said, longer product cycles are needed. The Trade- in value of certain clubs even clubs only 2 years old is going down the loo. Like I know a guy who dumped off a shitload of clubs at Dick's (like 90 or so) and only got a little over $500 and most were made within the last five years. Trade in a set of 1982 Ping Eye 2 irons you still get $80... (Still want a set of green dot eye2s +1" Stiff flex please)... With the fact that companies like Taylormade and Callaway were putting out product 4 times a year, it really effects the trade in values of their clubs. They want you to buy their newest product, but they are negatively effecting the ability of golfers to trade in one set of clubs and only have to pay maybe about half of full price for a new set. I will say, TaylorMade to my knowledge hasn't really released any new clubs since the M2 Tour irons.... I think with Mizuno, Titleist and Ping the product cycles are longer so they can control the prices a little longer and the value of gently used clubs doesn't depreciate quite so fast...   
    • The PGA never does that in a major. 2005 and 2014 come to mind as two times where they could have done that and didn't. One time they got lucky, the other time they got burned. It's all about TV.
    • Especially since they preemptively suspended play before the rain actually started, it is weird (or, rather, an oversight) that they didn't start the round earlier in the day. 
    • Nice round of golf after my lesson. Some stuff stuck well ? https://bnc.lt/yzOb/01H1A3wsrv
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. amgolfer
      amgolfer
      (32 years old)
    2. help4coaches
      help4coaches
      (30 years old)
    3. signal12
      signal12
      (45 years old)
    4. Steelergolfer311
      Steelergolfer311
      (21 years old)
    5. WolFpackJD
      WolFpackJD
      (27 years old)
  • Blog Entries