Jump to content
IGNORED

Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?


Greatest Golfer (GOAT)  

222 members have voted

  1. 1. Tiger or Jack: Who's the greatest golfer?

    • Tiger Woods is the man
      1628
    • Jack Nicklaus is my favorite
      820


Recommended Posts

Lee Trevino basically said....The players as a whole are better than they were back in Jack's era, but there were better top notch players in Jack's era than there is today.

I agree, with you and Lee...


Have to go with Tiger. Mainly because he is the golfer of my generation, and besides hearing about Jack, I don't have the same connection with his accomplishments as I do with Tigers.

Tiger...total freak...in more ways than one

What's in my TaylorMade stand bag:
taylormade.gifSuperfast TP 10.5° Matrix HD6 graphite stiff shaft
nike.gifSasQuatch 2 Steel #3 Wood: 15° Diamana SasQuatch Graphite
cobra.gifBaffler DWS Hybrid Utility Woods: 3/R 20°
cobra.gifS2 Forged irons 4-PW stiff flex steel shaftcleveland.gifCG15 satin chrome 48° gap wedge 8 bouncemizuno.gifMP T Series chrome 53° sand...cleveland.gifnike.gifbridgestone.giftaylormade.gif


I think tiger is better because

Tiger has a slight advantage in athletic ability,but Jack has made some of the most incredible shots in golf with equipment technology from the 1960's.We may never know who is the best unless they go head to head with hickory shafts and gum balls.


Tiger...total freak...in more ways than one

Tiger may be more athletic than Jack in his prime,but we must not forget that Jack made some of the most amazing golf shots history with club and ball technology from the 1960,s. We may never know this answer unless they go head to head with hickory shafts and gum balls.


Tiger may be more athletic than Jack in his prime,but we must not forget that Jack made some of the most amazing golf shots history with club and ball technology from the 1960,s. We may never know this answer unless they go head to head with hickory shafts and gum balls.

They can do that right after someone invents a time machine to send Tiger back to 1972. Jack is almost 70 years old.

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.


I figured out a way to shed light on this debate. Take Tiger and a few of his contemporaries out on a course that hasn't changed much since the late 60's, especially in distance. Find some clubs and balls from that era, and see what they do. I remember one time Jack hit a 600 yd par 5 with a driver, and then another driver off the fairway. Wonder if the "stars" of today could do the same with that old equipment.

PrairieParson
From Lubbock, Texas: the Heart of Flyover Country.
Ping G-15 Driver 12 deg.
Mizuno MP-33 Irons
Ball: White, mostly round and lots of dimplesScores this year: 78


I have seen both and in their prime(which Tiger is now) I voted for Jack because Tiger hasn't broken the record book YET
Tiger Woods is the perfect storm (if, and my guess is he will overcome his current problem) of African American athleticism, Discipline (from a military father), Buddhism (the ability to project an end result), Commitment to excellence (Golf I'm talking about), Work Ethic, and Ego.
No one in my mind will ever be better equipped to compete in this sport, his ability to see the shot, hit the shot is unparrelled.
I would think though that in a head to head, both players in their prime, there would not be a big gap. Also I beg to differ the oldtimer view, Jack's competition was mentally stronger than todays players, which made them harder to beat. Young men nowadays are better athletes but I question their heart across the board.

Alpha V5 9.0 XStiff
Cleveland Hi-Bore 13* Stiff
Cleveland Hi-Bore 19* Hybrid Stiff
Cleveland CG Red Irons 4-PW Stiff
Merit Golf 52* StiffCleveland 900 series 56* & 60* RegScotty Cameron Laguna Mid-Slant"I hit 2 good balls today, I stepped on a rake."


Jack had tougher compettion and won 18 majors but even more unbeliveable he finished second something like 15 times!!

That's exactly why I voted Jack.

Tiger's excellent but Jack (along with those he played with in his day) didn't have the technology advantages of today. Everyone had to be creative in shot making.

Jack has the record, and the record is the only thing that is measurable. Tiger has to beat it. Any other discussion about ability, equipment, strenghth of competition, isn't worth a hill of golf balls. But then again, if you throw medications/enhancements into the equation, where does that leave the records?

Shortgamewiz
c5_banana.gif


In my opinion Tiger would be the greatest golfer in the next years but Jack is the best but my vote goes for Tiger.


PD:Angel Cabrera rule's.

Jack is the greatest .....Period ......Case Closed.......and here is why...

Jack has 18 majors

Tiger has 14.....

here is the MAJOR difference !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jack has 19 runner up finishes in majors.... Tiger is not even in the same city as Jack on this one......

Tiger has 5 runner ups.........


That means Jack finished in the top two 37 times in majors almost double Tigers 19.


Case Closed..................

In my FT Performance bag

Driver: FT-9 I-mix 9.5 Fubuki 63s
3 Wood: X Hot Fubuki 73s
Hybrid: 3H Aldila VS Proto 80-SIrons: X-20 Tour 5-PW Project X 5.5 Wedges: X-Forged 50*, 54*, 58*, 62* Project X 6.0Putter: Japan IX #9Ball: HX Tour


You made one point. How does this close the case. Have a look at Tiger's overall winning percentage (including non-majors) and his margin of victory in majors. I preferred to watch Jack and Tom Watson's duels. Better doesn't mean more exciting.

Mizuno MP600 driver, Cleveland '09 Launcher 3-wood, Callaway FTiz 18 degree hybrid, Cleveland TA1 3-9, Scratch SS8620 47, 53, 58, Cleveland Classic 2 mid-mallet, Bridgestone B330S, Sun Mountain four5.


Depends what you want to include in the characterization. Since both were great golfers, I have to vote for the one that's not a putz.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Yeah, that's right. I remember now. Pia Nilsson. I've read a couple of her books. "Be A Player" and "Every Shot Must Have A Purpose".  I read them back maybe 10 years ago. ... maybe 5? ... pre-pandemic anyway.  Good memory. 
    • Having had the opportunity to live and work in a few different countries, I've encountered some golf traditions, whether they are well-established customs or unique experiences at local courses. While not all of these are widely practiced, they highlight the diversity and creativity in the golfing world. 1. Japan - The O-Bon Golf Festival In Japan, during the O-Bon (lantern) Festival, I've seen golf courses hosting night golf events with glowing balls and lantern-lit fairways. It's a serene and beautiful way to combine golf with culture.  2. Scotland - The Guising Golfers In Scotland, around Halloween, I've come across golfers participating in "guising," where they dress up in costumes and play a round of golf. It adds a festive twist and a lot of fun to the game. 3. South Korea - The New Year's Honbae In South Korea, golfers play a round of golf on New Year's Day, followed by a celebratory meal and drinks (9th hole and after the game). It's a time for camaraderie and positive intentions for the year ahead. Besides new year's, on higher end courses, they often break on the 9th hole for some light food and drinks like fancy ramen and makgeolli rice wine (ordered in advance). 4. Australia - The Outback Golf Challenge (I have not experienced this one myself) In Australia, there is apparently an Outback Golf Challenge, where golfers navigate rough terrain and face unconventional obstacles. It's considered a true test of skill and adaptability (but hasn't produced many PGA golfers 😉 ). 5. Finland - The Midnight Sun Golf Tournament (I have not experienced this one myself) In Finland, the Midnight Sun Golf Tournament is where golfers play late into the evening under the perpetual twilight of the summer months. The endless daylight makes it a truly unique event. While these traditions may not be universally established, they represent the variety of golfing experiences around the world. I'm curious if any of you have encountered or participated in unique or local golf traditions, whether internationally or closer to home.
    • It's from "Every Shot Has a Purpose" which was co-written by one of Annika's coaches. Decent read about reducing uncertainty and committing to the golf shot.
    • Ah, I didn't realize this was about standing over the ball versus time to play the shot. Definitely two different things there. Yea I would imagine being static over the ball/taking a long time over the ball does make things worse in the long run, hence all the waggles guys will do before pulling the trigger.
    • I'm not sure who said it first but I've seen it a lot. There's this "think box" vs "play box" theory. I've also seen it with a planning vs doing line on the ground. The idea is basically you stand away from the ball (a couple feet) and do your "think box". This is where you do your planning, your swing cues, your practice swings (if you believe in practice swings.) All of that is done in the "Think Box". Then you step into your "play box" address the ball and hit it. Sometimes it's done with a imaginary line on the ground. You do all of the think box stuff behind the line. Then once you cross the line you step up and hit it.  Here's Annika Sorenstam demonstrating the "Think box" and "Play box": So, Annika's time over the ball is really short. Because she did all of that other stuff not over the ball, but in her "Think box".  There are lots of variations on this theme. But I think you get the idea. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...