• Announcements

    • iacas

      Introducing TST "Clubs!"   08/28/2017

      No, we're not getting into the equipment business, but we do have "clubs" here on TST now. Groups. Check them out here:
Sign in to follow this  
inthecup

Looking at Irons, Tried Adams CB2, Nike VR, Ping I15, Mizuno JPX 800 , JPX 800 Pro, Titilest AP2

Recommended Posts

I only went out once so far and it was interesting.

My handicap is trending down at this point and my ball striking is improving quite a bit.

I currently play Callaway X-18's, they were not fitted.  I am replacing them for no good reason other then I have some mad money and I want fitted irons.

I liked the Adams CB2's the best on the one day I demo'd clubs.

I kind of liked the I15's but they were very dead, every shot felt great even if you miss hit it.  Very odd.

I did not like the sound of the Mizuno's.  They were both very "clicky" like I was hitting rocks.  I went in expecting to like them and was surprised that I did not.

I did not like the AP2's much either.  Coming from clubs with offset I think little or no offset was a big change.

I found it interesting that ping has no club between the I15 and a blade, S56.  I also was not fond of the look of the I15 Ping.

I am going to go back again and revisit all the clubs and try some Taylormade's also.

I hate the looks of the Callaway Razors, I am not sure what they were thinking.

Any suggestions on something else to try?

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!



Originally Posted by inthecup

I only went out once so far and it was interesting.

My handicap is trending down at this point and my ball striking is improving quite a bit.

I currently play Callaway X-18's, they were not fitted.  I am replacing them for no good reason other then I have some mad money and I want fitted irons.

I liked the Adams CB2's the best on the one day I demo'd clubs.

I kind of liked the I15's but they were very dead, every shot felt great even if you miss hit it.  Very odd.

I did not like the sound of the Mizuno's.  They were both very "clicky" like I was hitting rocks.  I went in expecting to like them and was surprised that I did not.

I did not like the AP2's much either.  Coming from clubs with offset I think little or no offset was a big change.

I found it interesting that ping has no club between the I15 and a blade, S56.  I also was not fond of the look of the I15 Ping.

I am going to go back again and revisit all the clubs and try some Taylormade's also.

I hate the looks of the Callaway Razors, I am not sure what they were thinking.

Any suggestions on something else to try?

Thanks

Actually, they do....the Ping Anser.

They have a super-game improvement set in the K15's, a game improvement set in the G15's, a competition set in the i15's, a competition set in the Anser's and a tour set in the S56's.

I'm not sure why you think they need any additional models?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by schlebrock

Actually, they do....the Ping Anser.

They have a super-game improvement set in the K15's, a game improvement set in the G15's, a competition set in the i15's, a competition set in the Anser's and a tour set in the S56's.

I'm not sure why you think they need any additional models?


I did not try the Anser, I was told they are a blade and I was quoted $1350!!!

I guess my observation is that the I15 lacks a little to much feel for my taste.  I like their engineering but I prefer a bit more feel.  I want the ball to fly as well as it can with a miss hit but I want to know it was a toe shot or whatever the case was.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

When I went to dicks the other day I swung some Cleveland Irons and I really liked them. I think Cleveland has done a great Job making some Irons that have a lot of the things people like about blades without giving up the feel of a cavity back completely.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by LankyLefty

When I went to dicks the other day I swung some Cleveland Irons and I really liked them. I think Cleveland has done a great Job making some Irons that have a lot of the things people like about blades without giving up the feel of a cavity back completely.



Thanks I'll take a look.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

during my demoing, the AP2's and Burner 2.0's were immediately at the top of my list. two great sets of irons.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by dhanson

during my demoing, the AP2's and Burner 2.0's were immediately at the top of my list. two great sets of irons.



The AP2 was my buddies fitted club.  Maybe that was the problem I will revisit them also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I have the Adams CB2's. They are by far the best club I have EVER owned!!! I absolutely love them! The feeling off the face of those forged irons is incredible. It might just be in my head, but it really feels like you can feel the ball compress on & off the face. Spin is great. Distance is great! You wont be disappointed. These irons give you a lot of rom to grow in to them as well. I was like you when I started playing with these irons. Somewhere around a 19 handicap. Im now at a 15 and dropping, and ive only owned them for a few months.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

inthecup,

I recently went to a large demo day that featured every major company. I had been wanting a new set of irons since I knew my swing had changed as had my iron specs, since I had been taking lessons for the past few months and practicing daily. I tried the Cleveland CG-16 black pearl irons, Cobra S-3, Callaway Razr and Razr X-tour, and Diablo Forged, Taylormade Burner 2.0, Titleist AP-1, Ping G-15 and i-15, Adams CB-2, and the Mizuno MX-1000, JPX-800, and JPX-800 pro. My requirement that I had set for myself on what I wanted in my new iron set were: great feel on impact and great sound, good looks that inspire confidance, forgiving and have several shaft options to chose from to match "me". I'll give ya a little break down of what "I" thought of the following irons. Disclaimer: the opinions are mine alone and I realize that some of the irons that I did not like are some of the best selling irons.

Adams: CB-2 black pearl irons,..... great looks and good feel,.... but just didnt make me say wow.

Callaway: Razr just didnt suit my eye and the Razr X-tour just didnt have the feel that I wanted even though it looked a lil better than the Razr

Diablo Forged - wow,... felt wonderful, they looked good and sounded good and were forgiving as well. unfortunately the Callaway rep was less than helpful about shaft options.

I wasnt crazy about the uniflex shafts. I figured if I was spending over $1,000 on a set of irons I could have gotten a little more attention from the rep about different shaft options.

Cleveland : CG-16 black pearl irons they looked great and felt and sounded just OK to me.

Ping : G-15 and i-15,.... as much as I tried to keep and open mind neither of the Pings got me excited.

Taylormade : Burner 2.0 they look pretty good but they are definately built for distance, but then again if you jack up the length and loft of a six iron to the usual specs of a five iron is it really

a six iron anymore just because it has a six stamped on it?

Mizuno :  MX-1000 they were very very easy to hit but man they sure didnt appeal to my eye.

JPX-800 they were easy to hit, looked good and were forgiving but just didnt quite have the sound and feel that I was looking for.

JPX-800pro They looked great, had that wonderful soft feel and sweet sound when struck well, and were pretty forgiving. They were forgiving just enough that you would be barked

at instead of bitten on a less than perfect swing.

Titleist:    AP-1 they were nice but just werent the total package for me.

In the end the Mizuno guys tried many shaft options and fit the clubs just for me and my swing so I wound up with the JPX-800pro, and I love them more and more each day. The Callaway Diablo Forged irons were a great looking iron that also felt wonderful but the rep was less than helpful, so in all fairness to the club it was a very close second place to the JPX-800pro. Matter of fact if the Callaway rep had been as helpful as the Mizuno guys were I "might" have chosen them instead. But overall, I couldnt be any happier.

Here is my suggestion: There are several different manufacturers that are making a game improvement forged iron now. You ought to take a look at some of the different ones out there.

Good luck and hope you find a set that makes you fall in love with them

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not to be biased, but try the Wilson Staff Ci9s

Forgiving enough. but still a thin top line and a great over all look and feel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by Kieran123

Not to be biased, but try the Wilson Staff Ci9s

Forgiving enough. but still a thin top line and a great over all look and feel



I looked locally for these and they are not available.  They also have a 44 degree PW.  That is strong.  I'd like to hit them if I can find them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by Shaggy

inthecup,

I recently went to a large demo day that featured every major company. I had been wanting a new set of irons since I knew my swing had changed as had my iron specs, since I had been taking lessons for the past few months and practicing daily. I tried the Cleveland CG-16 black pearl irons, Cobra S-3, Callaway Razr and Razr X-tour, and Diablo Forged, Taylormade Burner 2.0, Titleist AP-1, Ping G-15 and i-15, Adams CB-2, and the Mizuno MX-1000, JPX-800, and JPX-800 pro. My requirement that I had set for myself on what I wanted in my new iron set were: great feel on impact and great sound, good looks that inspire confidance, forgiving and have several shaft options to chose from to match "me". I'll give ya a little break down of what "I" thought of the following irons. Disclaimer: the opinions are mine alone and I realize that some of the irons that I did not like are some of the best selling irons.

Adams: CB-2 black pearl irons,..... great looks and good feel,.... but just didnt make me say wow.

Callaway: Razr just didnt suit my eye and the Razr X-tour just didnt have the feel that I wanted even though it looked a lil better than the Razr

Diablo Forged - wow,... felt wonderful, they looked good and sounded good and were forgiving as well. unfortunately the Callaway rep was less than helpful about shaft options.

I wasnt crazy about the uniflex shafts. I figured if I was spending over $1,000 on a set of irons I could have gotten a little more attention from the rep about different shaft options.

Cleveland : CG-16 black pearl irons they looked great and felt and sounded just OK to me.

Ping : G-15 and i-15,.... as much as I tried to keep and open mind neither of the Pings got me excited.

Taylormade : Burner 2.0 they look pretty good but they are definately built for distance, but then again if you jack up the length and loft of a six iron to the usual specs of a five iron is it really

a six iron anymore just because it has a six stamped on it?

Mizuno :  MX-1000 they were very very easy to hit but man they sure didnt appeal to my eye.

JPX-800 they were easy to hit, looked good and were forgiving but just didnt quite have the sound and feel that I was looking for.

JPX-800pro They looked great, had that wonderful soft feel and sweet sound when struck well, and were pretty forgiving. They were forgiving just enough that you would be barked

at instead of bitten on a less than perfect swing.

Titleist:    AP-1 they were nice but just werent the total package for me.

In the end the Mizuno guys tried many shaft options and fit the clubs just for me and my swing so I wound up with the JPX-800pro, and I love them more and more each day. The Callaway Diablo Forged irons were a great looking iron that also felt wonderful but the rep was less than helpful, so in all fairness to the club it was a very close second place to the JPX-800pro. Matter of fact if the Callaway rep had been as helpful as the Mizuno guys were I "might" have chosen them instead. But overall, I couldnt be any happier.

Here is my suggestion: There are several different manufacturers that are making a game improvement forged iron now. You ought to take a look at some of the different ones out there.

Good luck and hope you find a set that makes you fall in love with them


I'll revisit the Mizuno's

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I love my Yonex VMS - http://www.yonex.co.uk/golf/Product.aspx?ProdID=895. I'd definitely suggest giving them a go if you can find somewhere that does them.

For me they look awesome, they're light and balanced and they feel really smooth at impact.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by MiniBlueDragon

I love my Yonex VMS - http://www.yonex.co.uk/golf/Product.aspx?ProdID=895. I'd definitely suggest giving them a go if you can find somewhere that does them.

For me they look awesome, they're light and balanced and they feel really smooth at impact.


Not available here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by inthecup

Not available here.


Weird. They're listed on the Yonex US website but with no details:

http://www.yonexusa.com/displaysubcat.cfm?subcatid=20

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by MiniBlueDragon

Weird. They're listed on the Yonex US website but with no details:

http://www.yonexusa.com/displaysubcat.cfm?subcatid=20

I checked the two largest retailers in my area.  They do not carry Yonex clubs.  I would want to be at a place where I could demo many clubs at the same time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades



Originally Posted by inthecup

I checked the two largest retailers in my area.  They do not carry Yonex clubs.  I would want to be at a place where I could demo many clubs at the same time.

Yeah absolutely. May just be that the Yonex US website's wrong anyway. :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    Talamore Golf Resort
    PING Golf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Mission Belt
    Snell Golf
    Frogger Golf
    PitchFix USA
  • Posts

    • Venturing out to the Marine Base today. Have not played there in some time. Hope to get a tee time around 10:30 as a walk on. Short notice, but anybody that can make it.... (also have to stop by the exchange...it seems that S.W.M.B.O.  has run out of Chanel Nr 5...this constitutes an emergency).
    • @Vinsk The only thing I can really do is describe what I have felt/done. I played my best lead arm dominant golf with the intent of the lead arm being soft and swinging like a pendulum very vertically.  So,  what I mean is what worked for me was to let's say just stand normally no club in hand and then swing the lead arm at about a 45 degree angle to the chest.  Left shoulder swing center. Relative to golf posture I would imagine a straight line on the ground maybe 35-40 degrees from the inside and swing my lead arm on that line feeling like the hands never got outside that line.  The feel I used was left arm feeling like it was swinging vertically like a pendulum but right on the imagined line of approach.  So the line of approach let's say ball is 12 o'clock target is at 9 the line would be around 4 o'clock. The trail arm in this method just added support but never dictated the clubhead motion.  This method worked well for me but I moved on to other things and can't really even make it workable anymore.  The crucial aspect was that the location of that vertical left arm pendulum created the body motion.  It was similar to the Malaska type deal a bit. So,  now it's very different.  Now the basis of my swing is like if you stood there with a piece of wood horizontal at waist height with a nail in it and a hammer in the trail hand and hammered the nail. So,  kinda like a bicep curl.  The lead arm is basically inert or soft.  The motion is controlled by the trail hand arc.  Feels like the swings center is more the right elbow to me.  My feel is that I try to hammer back through address.  I just try to remain still and make that motion. My body moves only a bit.  I never felt with either method when playing well that I was aggressively pivoting but that my body moves turns in accommodation of the master intention.   The downward hammer arc basically kicks the clubhead out at the bottom.  For me I stay in pretty decent shape with steady head doing this and the clubhead carries me into the finish.  If you have watched Malaska it's kinda like a right arm Malaska deal.  It's not complicated.   I don't shift weight bump hips squat or post up or try to spin the shoulders.  The swing gets me to my lead side every time without thinking about it.    For me this style is very very easy on my body.   Thats my ramblings on that for now,  @Vinsk.  You have a unique situation.  I do know that I can't play well without having one side or the other be the master.  Trail or lead.      
    • Yes, it's surprising that you can get a ball to stop or slow down with a partial swing or even a putting stroke. The ball you use likely makes a big difference in these cases.
    • The challenges should be fascinating. Our hunch is that there will be many challenges on the difficult par three 17th, but each team will make decisions independently (and could vary based on conditions as they go).  6 points up for grabs with the challenges in today's matches. Reminder, the yellow ball will be played alternate shot and team that shoots par or better (net) gets the point.
  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. billymo2
      billymo2
      (25 years old)
    2. bostonboy9416
      bostonboy9416
      (17 years old)
    3. kpaulhus
      kpaulhus
      (30 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon