Proper tip weights

[Hacker James]

I want to tip trim a graphite shaft to increase stiffness. I will be taking off 1 inch from the tip. This would effectively result in a -6 point change in swing weight. Would I then be correct in using a 10-12 gram tip weight to bring the swing weight back to about where it was?   or  I could cut as proposed and give it a try, but a six point change seems like a lot.

[WUTiger]

Adding 2 grams of weight to the head area will increase the swingweight by one point. So yes, 12 ounces of tip weight would recapture the six lost swingweight points.

[boogielicious]

32 minutes ago, WUTiger said:

Adding 2 grams of weight to the head area will increase the swingweight by one point. So yes, 12 ounces of tip weight would recapture the six lost swingweight points.

Do you mean 12 grams?  12 ounces is a whole lot more!

[dkolo]

23 minutes ago, boogielicious said:

Do you mean 12 grams?  12 ounces is a whole lot more!

Oh good, I was just about to duct tape a soda can to my driver to get the weights right. That was close!

[boogielicious]

27 minutes ago, dkolo said:

Oh good, I was just about to duct tape a soda can to my driver to get the weights right. That was close!

Lol! Soda is in fluid ounces though, not weight ounces. 12 ounces is 3/4 of a pound!

[dkolo]

Just now, boogielicious said:

Lol! Soda is in fluid ounces though, not weight ounces. 12 ounces is 3/4 of a pound!

Yeah, that's the part of that story that didn't make sense.

[Hacker James]

haha...well I did want a swingweight of  Z23

 

[WUTiger]

4 hours ago, boogielicious said:

Do you mean 12 grams?  12 ounces is a whole lot more!

Good catch, B... you are correct, 12 grams.

12 ounces would be a weird TourLock counter-counterweight which hasn't been invented yet.

------

As per Z23 swingwt, years ago I had a Wilson Triple Duty Wedge  (supposed pitch,sand and chip). I couldn't count on it for much except short sand shots or half swings around the green, as it seemed heavy.

One day I put it on a swingweight machine, and it registered G1. So, I took it to a machine shop and had the guy drilled out four holes in the sole to lessen the weight. It came out D8 which made it much more versatile. A WUT History Moment!

[Lagavulin62]

I thought I read somewhere that adding more than 5 grams to the head area was inadvisable? That some would not do this? Not trying to talk you out of it but you could experiment with several different weights before committing with the epoxy. I think just handling the club at address and waddling it should give you a good idea of the feel. Maybe you don't need all that weight and if it feels right but ends up D0, does it really matter? 

[Hacker James]

2 minutes ago, Lagavulin62 said:

I thought I read somewhere that adding more than 5 grams to the head area was inadvisable? That some would not do this? Not trying to talk you out of it but you could experiment with several different weights before committing with the epoxy. I think just handling the club at address and waddling it should give you a good idea of the feel. Maybe you don't need all that weight and if it feels right but ends up D0, does it really matter? 

I think it depends. Mathematically it is correct, but as for results, it could be that you really could get by with 6 points less, lets say from a D2 down to C8 or so. But to me, it would mess up your timing. Another approach would be to go with a lighter grip, that combined with a "little" extra weight at the tip might achieve the same purpose.  If you found a big box store with a swing monitor, swing weight scale e.t.c. they might let you experiment a little. I remember a short while back when Dick's and Golf Galaxy got rid of all their PGA Pro's, that some of the replacements, were more than willing to give you their time. I even worked "with" a guy, hands on when I was making some adjustments to a TM R-7 Limited. We cut the shaft, put on new grip, tried various combos of movable weights (this was before the SLDR).  My best option of course, would be to take the driver to an independent fitter, try out various "new" shafts and come up with something that works. In all likelihood however, he would end up selling me a whole new driver.

[Lagavulin62]

1 hour ago, Hacker James said:

In all likelihood however, he would end up selling me a whole new driver.

Ha.  Oh ain't that the truth! Yes whatever you decide do it yourself.  

[WUTiger]

17 hours ago, Hacker James said:

I remember a short while back when Dick's and Golf Galaxy got rid of all their PGA Pro's,

Dick's got rid of in-store pros, Galaxy kept them.

[Lihu]

23 minutes ago, WUTiger said:

Dick's got rid of in-store pros, Galaxy kept them.

Speaking of which, I was told by a Golfsmith employee that Dicks purchased them and are planning on changing the name to Galaxy. I think GolfTec is also part of the deal? I wonder how much it will affect their service and prices?

On 1/25/2017 at 0:14 PM, Hacker James said:

I want to tip trim a graphite shaft to increase stiffness. I will be taking off 1 inch from the tip. This would effectively result in a -6 point change in swing weight. Would I then be correct in using a 10-12 gram tip weight to bring the swing weight back to about where it was?   or  I could cut as proposed and give it a try, but a six point change seems like a lot.

This will probably affect the kick point a bit as well?

Are you also using a launch monitor to evaluate the results?

[Hacker James]

not a big fan of GolfTec. but Dick's store is a lot closer than Galaxy. GolfSmith is not too far away, but would have about 30 mile drive to Mission Valley, San Diego. Another store close by is Golf Mart, but again, not my favorite place.

5 minutes ago, Lihu said:

Speaking of which, I was told by a Golfsmith employee that Dicks purchased them and are planning on changing the name to Galaxy. I think GolfTec is also part of the deal? I wonder how much it will affect their service and prices?

This will probably affect the kick point a bit as well?

Are you also using a launch monitor to evaluate the results?

Kick point will be affected a little. Launch monitor is good idea, but not critical as long as I get a decent "feel" from swing scale results. Mostly, this is just tinkering.

[WUTiger]

2 hours ago, Lihu said:

Speaking of which, I was told by a Golfsmith employee that Dicks purchased them and are planning on changing the name to Galaxy. I think GolfTec is also part of the deal? ...

It appears GolfTec was a partner or a tenant at some Golfsmith site. In the St. L area, the Manchester Road site was inside a Golfsmith (now GG). The Clayton and Des Peres operations, however, are free-standing GolfTec shops.

I'm wondering how the franchise custom clubfitting operations will fit into all this.