Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
jl923

Maintaining butt's position throughout downswing

22 posts in this topic

I took a down the line video of myself where my butt moves towards the ball a few inches during the downswing. is this common? is this the cause for my pushes? any drills to work on this problem? i see how tiger squats down during his downswing and i wondered how i could add this to my swing.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

need to post the vid so we can see

but it sounds like your squated down to far when at address and then standing up before you hit the ball
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a similar problem. Can cause the pushes and big over draws. Few drills you can do

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

what does the second drill do?

Same thing, just different feel, different visual. Second one works best for me. If the right knee stays straighter and the hips slide forward, then the butt won't come off the "wall". Just having the chair there, doesn't guarantee the forward part, for me. My impact positions are different in both clips, the hips are working differently, linear versus rotational.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I took a down the line video of myself where my butt moves towards the ball a few inches during the downswing. is this common? is this the cause for my pushes? any drills to work on this problem? i see how tiger squats down during his downswing and i wondered how i could add this to my swing.

It is common. For me, it can cause a lot of shanks and fats. Also the occasional big pull if I turn my swing to the left in order to ge the club to come back to the ball.

I don't think I'd intentionally emulate Tiger's squat. Putting it in would build more compensations into your swing, which is not the direction an amateur (particularly high-handicap) should try to go. For me, it seems to have everything to do with how I have my weight distributed between my heels and toes. If my weight is on my toes at address, my hips move in toward the ball during the swing. If I feel like my weight is maybe 60-70% on my heels at address, then it doesn't happen. -Andrew
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think I'd intentionally emulate Tiger's squat. Putting it in would build more compensations into your swing, which is not the direction an amateur (particularly high-handicap) should try to go.

Only if you overdo it. For some they may need to feel like they stick their butt through the wall on the downswing just to keep it on the wall.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Same thing, just different feel, different visual. Second one works best for me. If the right knee stays straighter and the hips slide forward, then the butt won't come off the "wall". Just having the chair there, doesn't guarantee the forward part, for me. My impact positions are different in both clips, the hips are working differently, linear versus rotational.

found this old thread my searching the forum. I have this exact problem with maintaining my butt.

MVMAC-the 2nd vdo post was missing from youtube but it might be what can help me.

I tried the chair drilled but I don't feel like my weight shifted forward correctly.

I want to try your (missing) 2nd drill but afraid of doing it wrong. " If the right knee stays straighter and the hips slide forward, then the butt won't come off the "wall"".

Anyone please help on this?

Thanks much everyone.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

found this old thread my searching the forum. I have this exact problem with maintaining my butt.

MVMAC-the 2nd vdo post was missing from youtube but it might be what can help me.

I tried the chair drilled but I don't feel like my weight shifted forward correctly.

I want to try your (missing) 2nd drill but afraid of doing it wrong. " If the right knee stays straighter and the hips slide forward, then the butt won't come off the "wall"".

Anyone please help on this?

Thanks much everyone.

Yeah I took that video down for some reason. Here's an updated version of it

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Just FYI - it is common.  Depending on the certification body, roughly 64-90% of amateurs tested (well over 10,000 cases) early extend which is essentially what you're talking about.

Mvmac's drills are great but you may want to also go back and re-capture some hip mobility (toe-touch, squat, etc.).  In very broad terms this pattern is often the body unable to hold posture...most of the control happens at the spinal cord level meaning it's a reflex.  Consciously changing it can be a chore that some folks just aren't in a good place to do physically.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just FYI - it is common.  Depending on the certification body, roughly 64-90% of amateurs tested (well over 10,000 cases) early extend which is essentially what you're talking about.

Mvmac's drills are great but you may want to also go back and re-capture some hip mobility (toe-touch, squat, etc.).  In very broad terms this pattern is often the body unable to hold posture...most of the control happens at the spinal cord level meaning it's a reflex.  Consciously changing it can be a chore that some folks just aren't in a good place to do physically.

Yes and just to clarify, I strongly believe some early extension is a good thing. It's very rare to see a good player, including tour players, keep their heads on the "wall" for the entire downswing. Can actually take away from the dynamics. That video of me with the chair against my tailbone is almost 3 1/2 years old so I've "evolved" a little since then.

I think the knee/stick drill can be very useful for those players that excessively over flex that trail leg.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Yes and just to clarify, I strongly believe some early extension is a good thing. It's very rare to see a good player, including tour players, keep their heads on the "wall" for the entire downswing. Can actually take away from the dynamics. That video of me with the chair against my tailbone is almost 3 1/2 years old so I've "evolved" a little since then.

I think the knee/stick drill can be very useful for those players that excessively over flex that trail leg.

I suffer from this. Sometimes I have to really force my left hip to go back and up. So the extension is there, I am just not getting the weight forward and allowing that left hip to go back as much as it should.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I suffer from this. Sometimes I have to really force my left hip to go back and up. So the extension is there, I am just not getting the weight forward and allowing that left hip to go back as much as it should.

When I really force myself to keep my butt, I did the same thing to force my left hip to go back in downswing. This lead to my weight got shifted to the heel on the downswing. Is this the right thing to do though?

Yes and just to clarify, I strongly believe some early extension is a good thing. It's very rare to see a good player, including tour players, keep their heads on the "wall" for the entire downswing. Can actually take away from the dynamics. That video of me with the chair against my tailbone is almost 3 1/2 years old so I've "evolved" a little since then.

I think the knee/stick drill can be very useful for those players that excessively over flex that trail leg.

When looking at my VDO, some how, my butt is off the wall BUT my head is down and forward!!!!!.

I hope this drill can solve both problems?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just FYI - it is common.  Depending on the certification body, roughly 64-90% of amateurs tested (well over 10,000 cases) early extend which is essentially what you're talking about.

Mvmac's drills are great but you may want to also go back and re-capture some hip mobility (toe-touch, squat, etc.).  In very broad terms this pattern is often the body unable to hold posture...most of the control happens at the spinal cord level meaning it's a reflex.  Consciously changing it can be a chore that some folks just aren't in a good place to do physically.

festivus...could you please briefly clarify more on hip mobility ...what is toe-touch...squat?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Sometimes" people "hump the giraffe" to shallow things out.  So you "might" need to lay the club down on the down swing as you work on maintaining your inclination to the ground.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mike, I would like to learn more about why some early extension is a good thing.  Will that change the angle of inclination, but increase the speed (what is good on some early inclination)?

Thanks.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mike, I would like to learn more about why some early extension is a good thing.  Will that change the angle of inclination, but increase the speed (what is good on some early inclination)?

Thanks.


Typically the parameters  I am looking for are, no "early extension" prior to A5.  That will change the your inclination to the ground, but in "moderation".  Some early extension can show that the player is using the ground properly and a bit more dynamic motion.

@mvmac

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • When is the weather "too bad" to play?
      Its the same at Stoneleigh, recovered from aerification, and the rough just loved all the rain.  Member-Guest is next weekend, fairways will be important.
    • Jr Tournament play?
      For the junior tournaments where I worked as a rules official, the parents were not allowed near the players or their balls.  They had the status of being observers or fans, nothing more.  No coaching was allowed, and certainly they did not race ahead to the area where the balls lay after a stroke.  In fact the only carts allowed for family were for those who were disabled - all others walked.  Such potential interaction as you describe would not have been allowed.
    • The Dan Plan - 10,000 Hours to Become a Pro Golfer (Dan McLaughlin)
      Dan is the first to my knowledge to formally challenge the Talent Code, a non gifted individual who would commit to 10,000 hours of practice with the established goal of being a PGA Tour player.   Many members here that claim they want to be a pro golfer are younger kids who show some potential in the sport and are deluded or convinced into believing they have the raw talent required to become a professional.  I don't think we've had someone actually document their journey with the level of transparency Dan provided in the beginning of his "plan".   I started following him later in his plan and while I was initially rooting for him I eventually started to question his approach and commitment, as well as his transparency in his progress.  
    • Using the tee box markers?
      The player is not using equipment in an unusual manner since the  tee marker is not equipment - it is nothing more than an obstruction which is deemed to be fixed (i.e. immovable) when playing his first stroke from the teeing ground of the hole being played.  After that they are movable obstructions.   There is no prohibition about standing on an obstruction, immovable or movable, with one or both feet, when making a stroke as long as nothing is done that would constitute building a stance. As far as being a device, the all encompassing dictionary definition goes well beyond the meaning of the term as it is applied in the Rules of Golf.  A device is an obstruction, and it may be equipment if it meets that definition, but not all obstructions are equipment or devices. This is simply a case of trying to read into the rules something that isn't there.  If it isn't prohibited, then it is permitted.  I see nothing that would lead me to rule against putting one foot on or against a tee marker, provided that the tee marker doesn't move during the process.
    • Chipping from tight lies?
      I agree. Bounce is your friend. I had a pretty straight forward punch shot yesterday.  For short punch shots I like to use more of a pitch motion. An 8 iron has about 4 degrees of bounce. #NoGlide  In terms of difficult lies. I'd say a soggy fairway is the worst. I rather hit of concrete than soggy fairway. It's just tough to let the club glide when the ground has that much give to it. 
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Adunifon
      Adunifon
      (35 years old)
  • Blog Entries