forearm rotation A2-A3

Quote:

Originally Posted by dean007 

I'm confused and this maybe a stupid question.  Some say you're not supposed to rotate your forearms at all on the backswing.  Others say some rotation is OK, a slight fanning after A2.  Is one way correct or is it specific to ones swing.  Thanks 

Everyone rotates their forearm on the backswing. Some will wait until later than others (A2 to A4), others start it right away. Generally about 90°.

Quote:

Originally Posted by iacas 

 

Everyone rotates their forearm on the backswing. Some will wait until later than others (A2 to A4), others start it right away. Generally about 90°.

Yep. I hold off rotating as long as possible. Most pro instructors would say it's technically wrong but it is my swing now and forever. On my backswing at parallel, the toe of my club is not pointed up...at least not straight up as most instructors would say....then I just let it do what it does. 

Quote:

Originally Posted by iacas 

 

Everyone rotates their forearm on the backswing. Some will wait until later than others (A2 to A4), others start it right away. Generally about 90°.

In relation to what? 

Quote:

Originally Posted by cbrian 

If setup is 0 or what you are measuring against, I would think you could see a good amount less than 90*. Even more so with the players that do a bunch of shallowing in transition.

I think we might be talking about things differently. 90° would be fairly standard. Third accumulator...

Instructor fight!  jk

But i do have a question,

How does forearm rotation (and the timing of the forarm rotation) in the takeaway/backswing relate to when your back arm folds and then with then verticle angle of the backswing.

That might sound kind random, and the answer might be obvious but it relates to something i am working on and any better understanding is a good thing.

Mike (@mvmac) post that Dana video.

Errr, wait. This one should work.

Originally Posted by dean007 

thanks for the replies.  My confusion comes from a few mvmac vids.  In one he cocks the club straight up and makes a turn.  In the other he holds the club out in front of him shoulder high and rotates 90 degrees and drops ths shoulder the get in the perfect backswing position.  Are these 2 different elements blended together on the backswing.
 

The videos serve different purposes.  This one is for players that get the club head too far inside the hands on the takeaway (I'm assuming you meant this one). It's to exaggerate the hinging feel.  Good swings will have a combo of some hinging, (up and down) and wrist bend (side to side).

The video where I have the club in front of me, what iacas posted, provides a good feel for players that over bend the right arm or get the right elbow past the shirt seam.  Might feel like the right hand is pushing into the left hand.  It also gives you an idea of how a centered pivot would look at the top of the back swing, other video below.  Want to be clear that these aren't feels that everyone should or needs to put into play, depends on the player and their needs.

http://thesandtrap.com/t/62804/steady-head-drill-and-how-painting-mental-pictures-can-help-your-swing

Quote:

Originally Posted by iacas 

Mike (@mvmac) post that Dana video.

 

Errr, wait. This one should work.

 

 

Mike,

Love the videos.  But I can't help wonder what onlookers would be thinking when you film them!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by boogielicious 

Mike,

 

Love the videos.  But I can't help wonder what onlookers would be thinking when you film them!!!

Oh they know I'm crazy