Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
IGNORED

Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?


Greatest Golfer (GOAT)  

222 members have voted

  1. 1. Tiger or Jack: Who's the greatest golfer?

    • Tiger Woods is the man
      1628
    • Jack Nicklaus is my favorite
      820


Recommended Posts

Posted
I am an old soul. I love to watch highlights of Jack's game. But it is hard to beat TW when his is on.

What I Play
905T 9.5 NV65
AP1 3-W
56deg
Studio Select - Newport 2 34" e6+ Studio Design 2 - in the barn for now


Posted
Indeed. Another piece of reading:

Reading this only makes me think, once more, of the competition Jack had to face. Maybe it's the passing of the years has me putting Jack's competition on a pedestal, but Trevino, Player, Palmer, Watson.. those guys were fierce competitors. They were mature, they were mentally tough in ways Tiger's competitors don't seem to be.

Correct me if I am wrong- would Palmer or Player have taken a nine in such an infantile, idiotic fashon at the US Open? It almost seems Phil may as well have had a pacifier hanging out of his mouth while he hit those wedges- all because he thought the course setup was unfair. boo hoo. And he's the main challenger? And don't even start me on Sergio...or Adam Scott. Trevino would slice your heart out over a two dollar bet- and he was the most consistant ball striker since Hogan. He went toe to toe with Nicklaus Sunday after Sunday, and he was never intimdated. What about Gary Player, who in this country was regarded as the little brother among the "Big Three?" Guess who is one of only five guys ever to win the modern career Grand Slam? Palmer was never bashful about wanting to beat Nicklaus either- that's a given. Maybe it's just me getting old, but I have a tendency to regard these modern computer perfected wonderkids as soft in the middle. The older guys grew up more in the school of hard knocks. If they didn't win tournaments, they were going to back to the farm to dig ditches. Many of these kids on the tour now are from the school of computer generated David Ledbetter perfect positions at the top. The swings may be better, but the GOLF, the human drama, is sorely lacking. They just seem to be a bunch of cookie cutter copies of each other today. They don't have any fire. Tiger seems to be the only one who could travel back to that era and be right at home. But that's just me. I am sure lot's of people see it differently.

  • Administrator
Posted
Correct me if I am wrong- would Palmer or Player have taken a nine in such an infantile, idiotic fashon at the US Open?

It's undoubtedly happened - particularly when they're not in contention (as Phil wasn't).

Palmer took double bogey from the middle of the 18th fairway at Augusta in 1961 when par would have won the tournament for him. So yeah. Tiger's so dominant he simply MAKES his competition look that much worse than Jack's. And a lot of those guys won many of their majors when Jack was out of his prime. Arnie won most of his before Jack came along, and Tom Watson started winning his towards the end. Tiger's winning percentage is far and away better than Jack's. That alone tells you he's winning more - thus giving less chances to the second tier players (Phil, Ernie, Vijay, etc.).

Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
Maybe it's just me getting old, but I have a tendency to regard these modern computer perfected wonderkids as soft in the middle. The older guys grew up more in the school of hard knocks. If they didn't win tournaments, they were going to back to the farm to dig ditches. Many of these kids on the tour now are from the school of computer generated David Ledbetter perfect positions at the top. The swings may be better, but the GOLF, the human drama, is sorely lacking. They just seem to be a bunch of cookie cutter copies of each other today. They don't have any fire. Tiger seems to be the only one who could travel back to that era and be right at home.

Wow, that was well put. Bravo.

Totally agree, although I think Phil Mickelson still embodies the game quite nicely (takes chances, plays the game for what it is, etc). You hardly see some of these new kids even getting excited when they make a great shot anymore. It's like the game doesn't bring them anything but a high class paycheck. Smug golf prepschool kids... at least that's how they come across in my view.
Favorite Practice Course:
Z Boaz Municipal, Fort Worth <<< Ben Hogan grew up playing here!
--------------------------------------------------

In the bag: 983E 9.5*, Fuji Speeder S RPM LP, 4W, Neutral Bias STAFF Ci6 irons, S (going up for sale soon) Tom Watson PVD 08 Wedges (G.S,L)... and a 4...

Posted
I am brand spanking new and crushed that now that I found golf ,Tiger will be out for some time .Watching him makes me realize that golf is a special sport. He just make it all look so easy that it is encouraging to a newbie!

Wait until you play for a couple years, feel like you're getting better, then worse again, then worse more, then better, then worse....and see if you think Tiger's poetry in motion swing of perfection looks so good then

He's so good it makes me frustrated sometimes to try and compare your own swing to his. Something to strive for though.
TM R7 SuperQuad - 9.5* Stiff || TM V-Steel 15/18* Stiff || Mizuno MP-52 3-PW PX5.5 || Titleist Vokey OC 52/58* || Odyssey White Hot #1

Posted
Right now there's only one way to answer the question. You have to say Jack is the greatest golfer of all time simply because his accomplishments dwarf those of everybody else (yes, even Tiger for the time being).

Tiger, on the other hand, is the best in terms of ability. Hands down. Even Jack would agree with that. Once his accomplishments equal those of Nicklaus, (and they will) we'll look back and wonder why we even bothered to ask the question.

-k

Posted
The thing is, you can argue many of these points in both directions. i.e:

On the topic of Tiger's competition compared to Jack, you culd say that Jack had better competition, but you could also say that the lack of cumulative majors in Tiger's competition can be attributed to the fact that Tiger is that much better.

Monster Tour 10.5* w/ Redboard 63
FP400f 14.5* w/ GD YSQ
Idea Pro 18* w/ VS Proto 80s
MP FLi-Hi 21 w/ S300
CG1 BP w/ PX 6.0 SM 54.11 SM 60.08 Sophia 33"


Posted
I have to say Tiger also because I was not around to see Jack. I see the field of competition that Tiger just dominates and I know that I could not even attempt to compete with that group.

Like his father said that he would be more mentally prepared than anyone else that he would ever meet.

Joey R

In the Bag:

905T w/Aldila NV 75x 904F w/Dynamic Gold x100 MP-32 w/Project X 6.5 Vokey 52.08 BeCu 56 MP-R 60 Studio Stainless Newport 2 ProV1, ProV1x, or NXT Tour


Posted
After last weekend at the US Open, Woods has to be the best. Just would like to watch tournaments on the other players as well, I guess we can now.

In my Bag:

Driver- Launcher Driver 9.5 Loft, Stiff Shaft
Woods- G2 3- Wood
Hybrid- Halo 2 Iron G10 3 Iron HybridIrons- 4- Pitching i10Wedges- 52, 56 and 60 Degree RACPutter- 2 Ball


Posted
I wasn't alive to see Jack do his thing, but in my lifetime Tiger Woods has been one of the most incredible and awe-inspiring athletes that I've had the privilege to witness.

Posted
Ive always thought that Jack in his prime was more graceful than Tiger is now. This may sound like a strange question, but does anyone know who he (Tiger) 'hangs out' with when he's not on the golf course ? (he is a very private person).

Posted
Tiger is the best clutch putter ever! That is why he is the best ever. Jack was awesome, but Tiger is still better.

Driver: MP-600 9.5 w/ Fujikura E360 Stiff Shaft
4 Wood: F-60 16.5 w/ Exsar FS3 Stiff Shaft
Irons:MP-57 3-PW w/ Dynamic Gold S300 Shafts
Wedges: MP-R Black-Ni 52, 56, & 60
Putter: Studio Select Newport 2Ball: ProV1/ProV1xGrips: Winn Xi7


Posted
The majority of people who have voted on this have either only lived through Tiger's era, or, because they have been immersed in everything Tiger for the last 10+ years, their view of what jack did is diminished, so most people lean toward Tiger whether they mean to or not.

Posted
I would say that it's way too early to be making this comparison. Certainly if Tiger's career ended now he'd be behind Jack and probably a couple others as well. That's the golf comparison. If you wanted to compare some other things, maybe overall game or overall impact, then Tiger would be ahead. But I think it's silly to say Tiger's the greatest ever at this stage.
In my Hoofer2 bag:

Driver: 905S 9.5° (Grafalloy Blue XS Shaft) or 975F 7.5° (Grafalloy Shaft)
Fairway Metal: 906F2 13° (UST Proforce V2 75 gram XS Shaft)
Irons: Apex Forged 2-PW (Dynamic Gold X100 Shafts)Wedges: Vokey 54° and 60° (Dynamic Gold Wedge Shafts)Putter: Newport Studio...

Posted

tiger woods is the man.... hes a millie

In My Weekender Bag
Driver: Nike Sumo 5000 9.5
Irons: Big Bertha 96's 2-pw-sw
Wedge: Forged X-Tour 58*
Putter: White Hot Tour Putter #1Ball: e6+14 Years old


Posted
Tiger all the way
In My SasQuatch tour Golf Bag:
Driver: Tour Burner with UST Proforce V2 stiff shaft
3 wood: SasQuatch 15*
3 Hybrid: X Tour
Irons: X-20 tourSand Wedge: Srixon WG-504 56*Lob Wedge X Tour 60*Putter: Studio Select Putter

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • It sucks to carry around a lot of water, but ideally it should be way more than we think.  I buy those gallon jugs of water and hang them from my pushcart when I walk. I agree with the electrolytes as well. You don't just sweat out water, but you lose electrolytes as well. 
    • A 2010 study from the Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research compares the effects of different pre-round stretch routines for competitive golfers. Active Dynamic Warm-up: Swing Medicus driver, hit 3 shots each with selected clubs. Passive Static Stretches: Various athletic stretches such as hamstrings, chest stretch and reverse trunk twist. The subjects were collegiate golfers with a HDCP index of 5 or less who engaged regularly in strength and fitness routines. All golfers had two test days: one with active dynamic (AD) warmup, a second with AD followed by static stretches (SS). The results were then compared, within golfers and across golfers. For performance testing after the warmups, golfers hit three driver shots at time 0, 15, 30 and 45 minutes after the warmup. The study shows that static stretch formats produced poorer performance outcomes in the four measures shown in Table 5, which shows Time Zero results. The performance deficits under the PSS protocol decreased over time. Some suggestions on why the passive protocol was tied to lower performance than the active protocol: The passive stretches routine induced excessive range of motion,  basically producing wobbles in the golf swing. Other research indicates that the stretching produced slack in the tendons, lessening the amount of muscle force that could be transferred into the shot. One caveat: The study had good scientific controls and balancing of treatments (test routines). This was, however, an exploratory study and raises as many questions as it answers. Also, although the study was done back in 2010, it is still cited as a primary work in recent reviews. A quick online search did not reveal any follow-ups on the study. For those interested, the study PDF is below. PassiveStretchGOLF.pdf  
    • I have trouble with vertigo on occasion, but have gotten nutritional and biofeedback tips to keep it at bay. Dehydration can help trigger v-like symptoms so one recommendation, along with maintaining overall hydration, is to start with 8 oz. of water early in the morning. A meta-analysis on Golf As Physical Activity indicated that golf is rated as a moderately intensive physical activity. This scientific literature review came from the University of Edinburgh. The physical activity level ties into hydration. A former university colleague was a marathon runner who had published a couple of articles on endurance training. He likewise said that golf was a moderate physical activity especially when the round stretched past  the two-hour mark. For hydration he recommended switching from water to electrolyte drink on the back nine (past two hour point of exercise) to prevent cramping. At the two-hour point of moderate activity, water starts flushing electrolytes out of the body, which can lead to fatigue and cramping. (I have had trouble with leg cramps in the past during exertion.) During a round, I start out with water on the front nine and switch to sports drink on the back nine. If the day is unusually hot, I may drink 8 oz. of Pedialite concentrate before going to the course. Maintaining overall hydration plus on-course boosters keeps me going.
    • Personally I’d try booking direct first - either via the Vidanta golf reservations number/email or through the resort concierge - especially for Christmas/New Year. Vidanta’s main courses (Greg Norman and Nicklaus designs) are popular and can book out fast this time of year, so direct often gives you the best shot at your preferred tee times.
    • Wordle 1,677 5/6* ⬜⬜🟨⬜⬜ ⬜🟨⬜⬜⬜ ⬜⬜⬜🟩🟩 🟩⬜⬜🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.