Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
Note: This thread is 5915 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

Posted
So when i started golf, i brought a second hand iron set to start with, now i have progressed very quickly from when i started golf. 6months ago when i started, i was playing off a 26 handicap, now im down to 8.3 and shoting a avg round of 72-73.

I now what to get a iron set fitted for me since i am now going in to start playing some Junior golf tornys.

So ive narrowed it down to 3 Iron sets, Nike Forged Blades vs TW Blades Vs Taylormade R9 TP. I still think i prefer blades for feel and for the slight amount of extra workability you get with blades so I can knock it in close on those tight pin positions.

The main question is has anybody hit the old forged blades and compard them to the new ones?
I quite like the sound of the new blades because i herd they have a little bit more forgivness on those miss hits.
I have not been able to hit the new blades yet, but im going to a demo night very soon to test them out.

Anyways, let me know what you think.
Thanks.

By the way, please don't post, your a 8 HC you should not be using blades.

Driver: 909D3 8.5* Diamana White Board X
3 Wood: MP 630 15* GRAFALLOY PROLAUNCH RED X
Hybrid: 909H 19* "Real" VooDoo X
3 - P: MP-68 KBS Tour Black Nickel X
56* 10 Wedge Vr60* 06 Wedge: VrPutter: Custom Made.Golf Ball: TOUR B330SI am the greatest, I said that even before I knew I was....


Posted
Out of those options I would go with the older nike blades because the R9's are cast and you wont get the feel you are looking for. As for the TW blades I thought they just seemed really small. (I know there supposed to be small they just seemed especially small.)

However my top picks for blades would be Mizuno MP 68's and Titleist 710 MB.

Posted
Oh I never herd they seem'd small, im rlly looking forward to trying them now!

As for the MB and the 68's, 68's not a fan oh the look. And the MB were comming out a little low for my liking, but they also did not feel that soft when hitting them.

Driver: 909D3 8.5* Diamana White Board X
3 Wood: MP 630 15* GRAFALLOY PROLAUNCH RED X
Hybrid: 909H 19* "Real" VooDoo X
3 - P: MP-68 KBS Tour Black Nickel X
56* 10 Wedge Vr60* 06 Wedge: VrPutter: Custom Made.Golf Ball: TOUR B330SI am the greatest, I said that even before I knew I was....


Posted
I'm assuming the Nike forged blades are the VR's (?) if so, very good clubs. IMO the TW blades were okay and I haven't been a fan of TM irons since around 05, but know many ppl who have them and like them. So my vote goes to the VR's.

Posted
I'm assuming the Nike forged blades are the VR's (?) if so, very good clubs. IMO the TW blades were okay and I haven't been a fan of TM irons since around 05, but know many ppl who have them and like them. So my vote goes to the VR's.

What you described are the same club. The Nike Forged Blade is very clean looking and just has the swoosh on the back. The Victory Red TW Blades are the ones with the Victory Red logo and TW logo on the back.


Posted
I really like all the irons you have narrowed it down to. Be aware the forged blades have very weak lofts, I think the PW is 49 or 50*. If you found the Titleist MB's were coming out a little low you may find the same problem with most blades due to the nature of them. I would probably go for the R9 tp's, we all need forgiveness in our game (including the worlds best players), and quality cast clubs are not very far off a forged club in terms of feel.
adams.gif Speedline fast 10 9.5˚
adams.gif Speedline fast 10 15˚
adams.gif A7 17˚
adams.gif Idea Pro 3-PW
mizuno.gif MP T-11 52˚, MP T-10 58˚  cameron.gif Red X  titleist.gif NXT

Posted
As for the TW blades I thought they just seemed really small. (I know there supposed to be small they just seemed especially small.)

They are so small, it makes me laugh when I look at the 3i at setup. Can hardly see it down there.

In my Tour Combo Bag:

Driver: Superquad 9.5°
5W: 2008 Burner 18°
3H: Idea Pro Gold 20°4H: 2008 Burner Rescue 22°Irons: MP52 R300 5-PWedges: Vokey SM 50.08, 54.11, 58.04, 60.11Putter: Itsy Bitsy SpiderBall: TP Red


Posted
So when i started golf, i brought a second hand iron set to start with, now i have progressed very quickly from when i started golf. 6months ago when i started, i was playing off a 26 handicap, now im down to 8.3 and shoting a avg round of 72-73.

I personally play the Forged Combo irons. The PW-8 iron are the same as the forged blades, the 7-5 irons are split cavities, and the 2, 3, and 4 irons are full cavities. I really like them, they have some forgivness in the longer irons, while maintaining the feel and workability of the blades in the short irons.

I wouldn't reccomend a full set of blades, and even the tour pros are rarely using full sets of blades anymore (they usually have cavities in their long irons, or hybrids). The trajectory and forgiveness are not there in blade long irons. Blades are certainly better, but every now and then you get that one random errant shot that just tears off to the right or left. I like to keep that shot off the scorecard.

Posted
I wouldn't reccomend a full set of blades, and even the tour pros are rarely using full sets of blades anymore (they usually have cavities in their long irons, or hybrids). The trajectory and forgiveness are not there in blade long irons. Blades are certainly better, but every now and then you get that one random errant shot that just tears off to the right or left. I like to keep that shot off the scorecard.

+1

A full set of true blades is not generally recommended for anyone without a PGA Tour card. That being said, I've hit the r9 TP set and the sweet spot is about .01 square inches. It's TINY! Never hit the other 2, but I'm not sure how even the pros hit the r9 TPs with any success. If you hit it off center, those things will streak hard off to the right or left.

What's in my Sun Mountain C-130 bag:

Driver - Taylormade Superfast 2.0 TP 10.5
3 Wood - Taylormade Burner 15* REAX
Hybrid - Adams Idea Pro 18* GD YSQ-HL

Irons - Callaway X-18 4-PW

GW - Cleveland 588 51*

SW - Cleveland CG 12 56*

LW - Cleveland CG15 60*

Putter - Cameron Studio Style Newport 2

Bushnell Medalist rangefinder


Posted
+1

I would say that not even someone with a PGA tour card need play a full set of blades. Only a small number of tour pros play them anymore, Tiger being one example, but even Tiger has given up his 2 iron in favor of a 5 wood. Phil plays a blade with a little bit of forgiveness and a hybrid. Furyk plays blades, but has a hybrid. Harrington plays CBs and uses a hybrid. Stricker plays CBs. Every major winner in 2009 used cavity back irons.

That's why I suggest a mixed bag. I think blades are great up to about the 6 iron, maybe the 7, then you start to look at cavities. A few companies make wonderful combo sets like that, Bridgestone, Titleist, and Nike being some of them. The combo irons will give you the blade feel and control you want, but the longer irons will give you a higher launch and better stopping power. That's why my vote goes to the Nike mixed sets.

Posted
That being said, I've hit the r9 TP set and the sweet spot is about .01 square inches. It's TINY! Never hit the other 2, but I'm not sure how even the pros hit the r9 TPs with any success. If you hit it off center, those things will streak hard off to the right or left.

I personally didn't think the sweet spot was that small. I thought these were relatively forgiving also.

Driver- SuperTri 9.5*
Wood- 906 F2 13*
Hybrids- Rescue TP 17*
Irons(4-PW)- R9 TP w/ KBS Tour
Wedge-ZTP 52* w/ KBS Tour Wedge-58* VokeyPutter- Studio Select New Port 2 Mid-SlantBall-TP Black/Red

Posted
Nikes are better than the r9's i feel. Two golf buddies have them and the Nikes feel a lot better than the r9's. Vote for the Vr's.

07 Burner regular flex. (my dads-doing wonders with it) :D
supersteel burner steel shaft strong 3 wood
R7 draw 5 wood
Rapture 4-pw uw. Red dot. <3
56 deg sw60 deg Cg14 white steel two ball putter penta golf shoes. =D


Posted
The taylormade R9 weighted bit behind club face get smaller as you get closer to the long irons which is strange

Posted
As others have said, i wouldnt go with a full set of forged blade irons either. If you are a mega high spin player who has problems keeping the ball down ( ala tiger woods or Davis Love III) then that would be the only reason i could see going with a blade iron at your level. Ive never hit any taylormade iron, so i cant give advice there but the Nike TW split cavities seem to be well liked.
THE WEAPONS CACHE..

Titleist 909 D2 9.5 Degree Driver| Titleist 906f4 13.5 degree 3-Wood | Titleist 909 17 & 21 degree hybrid | Titleist AP2 irons
Titleist Vokey Wedges - 52 & 58 | Scotty Cameron Studio Select Newport 2 Putter | ProV1 Ball

Posted
I dont see the big deal with someone who is not a tour pro playing all blades its all about confidence. I know one of the reasons I want to switch to blades is because I have a tendency to swing to hard and with blades I dont have that problem because I know an out of control swing will end poorly. Furthermore they help my concentration which is somthing I have to work on.

The OP is asking for sugestions on which iron set and doesnt want to hear about why he or others should not play blades, and I doubt he will be swayed by all of these negative comments.

Posted
I dont see the big deal with someone who is not a tour pro playing all blades its all about confidence. I know one of the reasons I want to switch to blades is because I have a tendency to swing to hard and with blades I dont have that problem because I know an out of control swing will end poorly. Furthermore they help my concentration which is somthing I have to work on.

I agree. As someone who grew up at time when there were only blades (forged or IC), I can tell you most of what people are calling blades these days are infinitely more forgiving and can be played easily by most single digit handicappers. I am sorry I ever fell for the GI iron. I plan on switching this season to the TM Tour Preferred blade. I think the original poster should consider those instead of the R9 TPs as they will give him more of the feedback and feel he is looking for through the set.

My Tools of Ignorance:

Driver: Ping I20 9.5*
Woods/Hybrids: Cobra AMP 3W and 3 HY

Irons: Cobra AMP 4-GW

Wedges: Callaway Forged Copper 56* and 60*

Putters: Scotty Cameron  35" (Several of the flow neck blade variety)

Ball: Bridgestone B330-RX and Srixon Z-Star

Bag: Nike Performance Carry


Posted
I would say that not even someone with a PGA tour card need play a full set of blades. Only a small number of tour pros play them anymore, Tiger being one example, but even Tiger has given up his 2 iron in favor of a 5 wood. Phil plays a blade with a little bit of forgiveness and a hybrid. Furyk plays blades, but has a hybrid. Harrington plays CBs and uses a hybrid. Stricker plays CBs. Every major winner in 2009 used cavity back irons.

I agree, I'm just saying that non-PGA Tour players shouldn't even consider it. You're right, most tour players don't play a full set of blades. A good chunk play combo sets and there are still plenty that play muscleback and cavity backs. If someone like needs a little forgiveness, I'm certain that I need it.

I know I just switched to some GI irons, but I've played some of each: blades, mb's, cavities, and I think the best scores for almost any golfer will not come from full blade sets. My vote also goes for any combo set over full blades. And as much of a TM guy as I am, I wouldn't suggest anyone playing the r9 TPs. I've hit those only on the launch monitor, so take that for what it's worth. But my experience with those on the launch monitor didn't go well.

What's in my Sun Mountain C-130 bag:

Driver - Taylormade Superfast 2.0 TP 10.5
3 Wood - Taylormade Burner 15* REAX
Hybrid - Adams Idea Pro 18* GD YSQ-HL

Irons - Callaway X-18 4-PW

GW - Cleveland 588 51*

SW - Cleveland CG 12 56*

LW - Cleveland CG15 60*

Putter - Cameron Studio Style Newport 2

Bushnell Medalist rangefinder


Posted
I agree, I'm just saying that non-PGA Tour players shouldn't even consider it. You're right, most tour players don't play a full set of blades. A good chunk play combo sets and there are still plenty that play muscleback and cavity backs. If someone like needs a little forgiveness, I'm certain that I need it.

I gotta agree with you on the R9 TP's, not one of their better irons.


Note: This thread is 5915 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    Carl's Place
    PlayBetter
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • I would think of it in terms of time. The time it takes to get the arm angle into a good position to deliver the club with proper shaft lean. Another component is rotation, but that is also a matter of timing. It relates to how the body stalls to give the golfer time to hit the ball. If you have to get 80+ degrees out of that right elbow in one third of a second versus 50 degrees in the same time then you have to steal time from somewhere. It is usually body rotation. That does not help with shaft lean.  I agree in that amateurs tend to make the swing more complicated than pro golfers. 
    • I haven't been able to practice like I wanted and won't for the next week.  1. The weather sucks in Ohio this year. I have been mostly inside hitting foam balls. Just kind of my basic stuff.  2. I woke up last Saturday with a left side rib muscle on fire. If I turned or leaned a certain way it would spasm that almost buckled my knees. I have been taking a break to let that settle. I don't want to get a long term injury. I think I pinched a nerve or just aggravated a muscles.   3. I am going on a mini-vacation to Florida (screw you Ohio weather) with a friend, and rolling that into a work conference I have next week. I will be with out my clubs for a week.  I will be back next in two Fridays to hit the ground running with some warmer temps and better weather in Ohio, hopefully. I would really like to get more out on the course and the range.     
    • Day 580 - 2026-05-04 Played eight holes. Sometimes golf kicks you in the nuts. 😉 
    • I work with a lot of golfers who want more shaft lean at impact, who currently have AoAs that range from +2° to -2°, and who love to see the handle lower and more "in front of their trail thigh" from face-on at P6. And a lot of these golfers try to solve the issue by working on the downswing. They do something to drag the handle forward. Or they just leave their right thigh farther back so the same handle location "looks" farther forward. Or they move the ball back in their stance. Or they push themselves down into the ground to get the handle lower and increase (decrease?) their AoA (to be more negative). The real fix is often to get wider in the backswing. To do LESS in the backswing. To hinge less, fold the trail arm less, abduct the trail arm less. I had a case of this over the weekend. Before, the player had 110° of trail elbow bend, "lifted" his trail humerus only a few degrees, etc. The club traveled quite a bit around him, and he tended to "pick" the ball from the fairways. In the "after" swings below (which are mild exaggerations — this golfer does not need to end up at < 70° of elbow bend. These were slower backswings with "hit it as hard as you normally would" intent downswings), you can see that he bent his elbow about 70° instead of 110° and lifted his right arm an extra ~15° or more. You can't see how much less this moved his hands across his chest (right arm abduction), but it was also decreased. His hands stayed more "in front of" his right shoulder rather than traveling "beside" them so much. The two swings look like this: The change at P6, without talking about the downswing one little bit (outside of him telling me that he tends to pick the ball), is remarkable: Without 110° of elbow bend to get out (which he gets to 80°, a loss of 30°), the golfer actually loses slightly less elbow bend (70 - 50 = 20), but delivers 30° less elbow bend, lowering the handle and letting the elbow get "in front of" the rib cage… because it never got "behind" or "beside" the rib cage. If you look at this video showing the before/afters of P6, you'll note the handle location (both vertically and horizontally) and the shoulders (the ball is in the same place in these frames). This golfer's path was largely unaffected (still pretty straight into the ball, < 3° path and often < 1.5°), but his AoA jumped to -5° ± 2°. I've always said, and in talking with other instructors they agree and feel similarly, that we spend a lot of time working on the backswing. This is another example of why.
    • We had a member of our senior club who developed a mental block on pulling the trigger. I played with him to see what the membership was talking about. I timed him a few times when he would get over the ball. 45 seconds. He knew he had a mental block and would chide himself, “Just hit it!” Once on the green he was okay and chipping was a bit better. It was painful to watch him struggle. Our “bandaid” was to put him in the last tournament  tee time with two understanding players. We should have suggested to him to take a break from our tournaments. I agree with the idea that when a player realizes they have a problem, the answer is to go fix it and not return until they are able to play at an acceptable pace.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.