Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Philip9210

Why am I hitting my irons so short?

15 posts in this topic

So I am having trouble,ever since I changed from my starter Dunlop irons to my current SuperSteel Burner's (the model from the early 2000's), I haven't been able to hit my irons anywhere near good distances. I am currently hitting the following:

PW,9,8 Usually about the same...between 100-125 depending on how I hit it.

7...around 130

6...around 140

5...around 150

This is really confusing me because I hit my driver a solid 240-250 when I hit it well and I can hit my 3 wood around 210 when I hit it well. Was just wondering if possibly the shafts were the problem, or if I'm just not compressing the ball properly. Thanks for any and all advice.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

Shafts may not match your swing.  It isn't as simple as stiff or regular.  There's also kickpoint (low, medium, and high).  Swing dynamics and shaft characteristics are better determined by a club fitter.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Originally Posted by Philip9210

So I am having trouble,ever since I changed from my starter Dunlop irons to my current SuperSteel Burner's

So were the distances with the Dunlops good before you changed?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regardless of club and flex you should still be able to hit the ball a reasonable distance with a good hit. I'm putting my bet on your ballstriking not being good enough. Which we can't really say anything about without seeing a swing video.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I'm going to play 18 tomorrow with some friends and I will get one of them to record my swing and I will post it under the member swing forum on here. Maybe somebody can help me figure out what I got going on here haha.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Actually, i just went out in the yard and hit some wiffle balls and recorded it, I'll post up the vids once they get done uploading to youtube.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is the explanation, though it is a bit hard to see from the still shot. Your hands are not leading the clubhead into the ball. This adds loft, contributes to a lower smash factor, less spin and generally makes the ball fly shorter. [URL=http://thesandtrap.com/image/id/235556/width/293/height/280][IMG]http://thesandtrap.com/image/id/235556/width/293/height/280[/IMG][/URL] The factors for distance boils down to: [LIST] [*]Clubhead speed [*]Amount of forward shaft lean at impact [*]Smash factor (where you hit the ball on the clubface) [/LIST] You also got the ball flight, trajectory, ball, club etc., but they don't matter as much as long as they are within normal limits. The speed of the swing itself is probably not an issue, it's more about hitting the ball with the maximum amount of speed. Getting the shaft to lean forward at impact contributes to hitting the ball clean with a downward strike. Hitting the ball on the toe won't make it fly very far. You want to hit the ball as close to center as you can. The amount of forgiveness depends on the clubs you hit. I used to hit my PW maximum 110 yards, today I hit it 130 yards on a stock shot. My long irons usually flew the same distance, rarely farther than 175 yards. Today I carry my 4 iron 200 yards. I probably swing my arms a bit faster, but the change in distance is primarily a result of hitting the ball clean with a forward leaning shaft. I'm still a bit off center, mostly towards the toe, but my distance is OK because of my impact position. You got some stuff to work on in your swing, but it's probably best to cover that in your swing thread. I just wanted to give an answer to the specific question in this thread.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I am having the same problem with not much distance.

For me its a combination of not using quite enough wrist in my backswing and forward shaft lean.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am having a huge problem with hitting certain clubs so short.  I don't know what is causing it.

sw 85 wtf?

gw 95 wtf?

pw 125-130

9iron 135-140

8iron 150

7iron 160

6iron 168 wtf?

5iron 175 wtf?

4iron 185 wtf?

3iron 195 wtf?

3wd   240-250 wtf?

driver 280-300

Anyone know what could be causing this?  How the hell is tiger hitting sw's 130 and 8 irons 180?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by jestein16

I am having a huge problem with hitting certain clubs so short.  I don't know what is causing it.

sw 85 wtf?

gw 95 wtf?

pw 125-130

9iron 135-140

8iron 150

7iron 160

6iron 168 wtf?

5iron 175 wtf?

4iron 185 wtf?

3iron 195 wtf?

3wd   240-250 wtf?

driver 280-300

Anyone know what could be causing this?  How the hell is tiger hitting sw's 130 and 8 irons 180?

Those are pretty good distances... tiger doesn't always hit his SW 130. I like to think of it like when I hit a full LW. It's going to stop and come back some, so if he can take a SW instead of a 9I, he might be able to be a bit more aggressive and not land it short of the pin in a tight spot.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OP, you said you might not be compressing the ball, and you were right. You have a decent reverse pivot going on, and a nice flip action, both of which lead to loss of energy transfer.

Stop swaying forward on you backswing and back on your downswing. Keep you head exactly where it is throughout the whole swing, and try to drive the ball into the ground with your irons. This will trap and compress the ball.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used to do thesame thing, I figured it was casting at the bottom because driving the ball didn't really suffer for distance but irons did.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Philip,

Joined just to reply to this :-), couldn't let it go without comment.

1) Not sure on your grip, cant see it well enough but it looks like a very weak right hand position?. Get it checked (go for neutral/slightly strong if theres any choice)

2) The reason I joined :-

Others above have commented on your sway, you need to fix this before even thinking of doing anything else.

The problem is not that you sway (thats just a symptom) you need to fix the cause. The reason you sway is that your hips are not being used correctly!

You need to learn how to disassociate your hips, (do the twist from the 60's lol).

I promise, if you learn how your hips are supposed to move and do it, your golf swing will change massively for the better. Dont even bother working on anything else untill its fixed, because you will just be working on stuff that may not even be a problem afterwards.

Check the link below :- it's a Titleist Performance Institute presentation, they talk about the issue you have with the hips.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bk06DErc3rc&feature;=plcp

Good luck.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by jestein16

I am having a huge problem with hitting certain clubs so short.  I don't know what is causing it.

sw 85 wtf?

gw 95 wtf?

pw 125-130

9iron 135-140

8iron 150

7iron 160

6iron 168 wtf?

5iron 175 wtf?

4iron 185 wtf?

3iron 195 wtf?

3wd   240-250 wtf?

driver 280-300

Anyone know what could be causing this?  How the hell is tiger hitting sw's 130 and 8 irons 180?

That's pretty typical if you aren't lagging the club and hitting with a nice, downward strike.  Check your divots and see if they are 2-4 inches in front of the ball.  If you're actually hitting your driver that far (have you checked with gps?) then your swing speed should be fine... and only 8 yards between clubs tells me you're not making correct contact.  I have ~120mph swing speed and my irons are almost 15 yards apart.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • This is the difference between my pitch and my chip; a pitch in my game is a smaller, gentler iron swing (takeback is only to between 9 and 12 o' clock instead of to 2-3 o' clock), and it's something I've only recently been able to hit cleanly, to say nothing of dropping it where I want it especially at very short range. If I'm inside 10 yards from the edge of the green, I'll just take a club that will roll out the distance I want afterward (somewhere between a 7 and a gap) and give it a stiff-armed, stiff-wristed bump to set it on the green and let it run out from there. As far as rollout distance, it depends on the club and you really just have to try em out. Bring your bag to the chipping green and start with your highest-lofted club. Start about 3-5 yards off the green and aim for the edge, then see how much further past the edge the ball rolls. Take notes (mentally or on paper); this carry-to-rollout ratio will be similar for just about any strength of swing with this style of chipping. So, when you get to the course, estimate how many clublengths it is from your lie to the green, and then how many clublengths more to the hole, choose your club accordingly, and then aim for the edge of the green. This works until you have to carry a longer distance than you can roll out, at which point you switch to the pitch shot to drop it where you want it.
    • Great set of clubs but elbow issues have forced me to go with some graphite in my irons. Sad to let them go but I don't foresee myself playing steel again for at least a year. Clubs are standard L/L/L and the grips are practically new. 6-3 iron have very little use since I used them as a combo set with some MP-H4s (also for sale). Some bag chatter and small dings here and there as you'd expect from a soft forged iron. Asking $500 shipped.      
    • I will always believe, if fitted properly,  it is the golfer's swing that makes any club work well for them. Cheap, or expensive, it does not matter. Some clubs might be of better quality than others, but that's about it.  Many years ago, I took a group lesson from a pga instructor. Someone in the group ask the instructor if he was any good. He proceeded to hit balls with clubs from our different individual bags like they were custom fitted to him. He told us, that all he did was make a grip adjustment to offset any difference in our clubs's different lie angles. It did not matter what the brand name on the club was. All the balls he hit, went towards his intended target, at the correct distances. His own swing sent the ball flying. This was the only thing I took away from this lesson. The next night there was a different pga instructor, which is another story. 
    • And fast greens can be near impossible to get the ball close on down hill putts, the margin of distance error is really thin.  On my most recent round I had a 60 foot downhill putt that I hit 90 feet and right off the green, I went fringe to fringe.  Ended up with 4 putts and the greens were not that fast.
    • I think it also depends on green conditions too. Firmer greens with significant contour can tend to knock even a steeply descending ball with lower spin far from the landing spot due to the extra energy from the height being deflected laterally by the slope angle at the landing spot (unless the slope acts as a backstop). A lower trajectory 2-hop & stop shot with lots of spin may tend to hold more contoured, firmer greens better as they meet the slope at a shallower angle with less vertical speed reducing chances for lateral deflection due to the slope angle. The surface friction from spin opposing the horizontal speed of the ball is what holds the ball near the landing spot. If the green is relatively flat then height usually helps even if the greens are firm.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. OR Cat
      OR Cat
      (55 years old)
    2. RandallT
      RandallT
      (50 years old)
  • Blog Entries