Jump to content
IGNORED

Oosthuizen loses drive left into the "water"?????


reedf
Note: This thread is 4294 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

Under "local rules" at my home course players are allowed to drop at point of entry with a one stroke penalty if the ball gets lost in them. This is of course to speed the pace of play and I thought maybe this may become something the USGA may want to change in the rules regarding "native/grass areas".
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by zeg

Quote:

Originally Posted by onesome

So native grasses are only recomended to courses to be declared lateral hazards,my course declares these grasses under local rules to be treated as lateral however our weekly mens club round doesn't and we get hit with stroke and distance. I wonder if the USGA will take a firmer stance on native grasses being considered lateral hazards.

Fourputt's comment only applies to native grasses / woods that are adjacent to and can reasonably be treated as part of a water hazard. There has to be water inside the hazard, you can't just declare a dry native area to be a lateral hazard.

Thank you Zeg.  That is exactly what I was referring to.

Originally Posted by onesome

Quote:

Originally Posted by zeg

Fourputt's comment only applies to native grasses / woods that are adjacent to and can reasonably be treated as part of a water hazard. There has to be water inside the hazard, you can't just declare a dry native area to be a lateral hazard.

Under "local rules" at my home course players are allowed to drop at point of entry with a one stroke penalty if the ball gets lost in them. This is of course to speed the pace of play and I thought maybe this may become something the USGA may want to change in the rules regarding "native/grass areas".

That's what a provisional ball is for.  My home course in Colorado has native rough that can grow 4 feet tall  after a wet spring.  We know that when the ball heads that direction, you play a provisional ball.  We don't just bypass the rules.  By the way, that so-called "local rule" would never be officially approved because it improperly modifies a rule.

Rick

"He who has the fastest cart will never have a bad lie."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by onesome

Under "local rules" at my home course players are allowed to drop at point of entry with a one stroke penalty if the ball gets lost in them. This is of course to speed the pace of play and I thought maybe this may become something the USGA may want to change in the rules regarding "native/grass areas".

I've seen this at a few places too. As I've argued too much elsewhere, I'm sympathetic to the "illegal" local rule, but I think following the rules is more important. Unless the rule is changed, I think it would be better for the courses not to create situations like yours where real competitions have to ignore the local rule.

Someone should go bury a kiddie pool in the center of each native area. Poof. It's a hazard. Problem solved!

In the bag:
FT-iQ 10° driver, FT 21° neutral 3H
T-Zoid Forged 15° 3W, MX-23 4-PW
Harmonized 52° GW, Tom Watson 56° SW, X-Forged Vintage 60° LW
White Hot XG #1 Putter, 33"

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by zeg

I've seen this at a few places too. As I've argued too much elsewhere, I'm sympathetic to the "illegal" local rule, but I think following the rules is more important. Unless the rule is changed, I think it would be better for the courses not to create situations like yours where real competitions have to ignore the local rule.

Someone should go bury a kiddie pool in the center of each native area. Poof. It's a hazard. Problem solved!

I prefer the idea of changing the rule to allow non-water hazards as opposed to the kiddie pool work-around.

As far as not having a reasonable place to drop goes with stroke and distance, one thing you have to remember is that a ball can roll after it is dropped, so there is no guarantee you will get exactly the same shot as you had before.  While trying to hit a hero shot from the woods may or may not be a good idea, a foot to the left or right can make a huge difference at times on the playability of the shot.  I have had chip out situations from the woods where I thought I could get through 90% of the time and played the shot, but if I was a foot left or right (i.e. after a drop after a portion of 10% of the time I didn`t make it and the ball ended up in an impossible situation), then the odds could be only 10% or less.

:mizuno: MP-52 5-PW, :cobra: King Snake 4 i 
:tmade: R11 Driver, 3 W & 5 W, :vokey: 52, 56 & 60 wedges
:seemore: putter

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Administrator
Originally Posted by MEfree

I prefer the idea of changing the rule to allow non-water hazards as opposed to the kiddie pool work-around.

As far as not having a reasonable place to drop goes with stroke and distance, one thing you have to remember is that a ball can roll after it is dropped, so there is no guarantee you will get exactly the same shot as you had before.  While trying to hit a hero shot from the woods may or may not be a good idea, a foot to the left or right can make a huge difference at times on the playability of the shot.  I have had chip out situations from the woods where I thought I could get through 90% of the time and played the shot, but if I was a foot left or right (i.e. after a drop after a portion of 10% of the time I didn`t make it and the ball ended up in an impossible situation), then the odds could be only 10% or less.

Then you either take your unplayable one shot earlier (before the shot you thought you could pull off but obviously didn't since you're taking stroke and distance again) or you putt the ball a foot to the side so you have a shot again.

Besides the fact that I literally cannot conceive of a shot where you would have NO options at all under the rules and NO ability at all to move the ball from the lie in which it's dropped/hit/located/etc.

Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by iacas

Besides the fact that I literally cannot conceive of a shot where you would have NO options at all under the rules and NO ability at all to move the ball from the lie in which it's dropped/hit/located/etc.

Kevin Na when he ran up the 14(?) last year - classic example of should've taken an unplayable earlier and then was left with no shot.

I thought the USGA had non-wet hazards at Pebble - Dustin's ball that they couldn't find in the trees was thought to be in a hazard, they then found it outside the hazard after 5 min 10 secs or so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by iacas

Then you either take your unplayable one shot earlier (before the shot you thought you could pull off but obviously didn't since you're taking stroke and distance again) or you putt the ball a foot to the side so you have a shot again.

Besides the fact that I literally cannot conceive of a shot where you would have NO options at all under the rules and NO ability at all to move the ball from the lie in which it's dropped/hit/located/etc.

Originally Posted by Wansteadimp

Kevin Na when he ran up the 14(?) last year - classic example of should've taken an unplayable earlier and then was left with no shot.

I thought the USGA had non-wet hazards at Pebble - Dustin's ball that they couldn't find in the trees was thought to be in a hazard, they then found it outside the hazard after 5 min 10 secs or so.

One thing to remember about the unplayable, as with Kevin Na's case, if you don't take option 28a, which is to take a stroke and distance penalty and play the shot over, you can wind up dropping a ball under 28b or 28c and be as just as unplayable as you were before you took the drop.  Plus, if you take a swipe at it first, before you deem it unplayable, you've eliminated your option of replaying the stroke from outside the junk and will have to drop under options 28c or b.  (two club lenghts or keep the point of the drop on a line from the ball and the pin.)

Depending on how deep you are in the junk, if you take a chance with a drop and still cant' hit it, you may have to invoke another unplayable and again decide on which option to play under Rule 28..... replay the shot, two club lengths, or keep the point between the ball and the pin and drop on that line.  If you make a stroke at the ball while in the junk, and the resulting stroke still leaves you in an unplayable position, you are left with taking another drop 2 club lengths, or keeping the line between the ball and the pin.  Because you took a swipe at it in the junk, option 28a replaying the stroke really doesn't help you, because under option "a" you would now have to play the stroke from the lousy lie you just tried to hit it from.

The point to all this is unless you are positive you can advance the ball to some place where you can hit it again, deem the ball unplayable.  Once you deem the ball unplayable, make sure you have a place to drop it or take your medicine and replay the stroke.

28/5

Regression Under Unplayable Ball Rule

Q. A player plays a stroke from Point A to Point B. Point B is in an area from which it is very difficult to extricate the ball. The player considers deeming the ball unplayable but this would result in a stroke-and-distance penalty (Rule 28a ). Dropping behind under Rule 28b is impossible due to a boundary fence and dropping within two club-lengths under Rule 28c is not feasible because it would require a considerable number of such drops to escape the area. The player plays from Point B and moves the ball a few feet to Point C, where the ball is clearly unplayable. Under Rule 28a , may the player:

(a) deem the ball unplayable at Point C and drop a ball under penalty of one stroke at Point B, and then

(b) deem the ball unplayable at Point B and drop a ball, under an additional penalty of one stroke, at Point A?

A. No. Under Rule 28a , the player would be entitled to drop a ball only at the place from which he played his last stroke (Point B).

In the circumstances, the player's only alternative is to invoke Rule 28c a sufficient number of times (starting at Point C and dropping the ball sideways within two club-lengths each time) to get the ball into a playable position

Regards,

John

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by Dormie1360

One thing to remember about the unplayable, as with Kevin Na's case, if you don't take option 28a, which is to take a stroke and distance penalty and play the shot over, you can wind up dropping a ball under 28b or 28c and be as just as unplayable as you were before you took the drop.  Plus, if you take a swipe at it first, before you deem it unplayable, you've eliminated your option of replaying the stroke from outside the junk and will have to drop under options 28c or b.  (two club lenghts or keep the point of the drop on a line from the ball and the pin.)

Depending on how deep you are in the junk, if you take a chance with a drop and still cant' hit it, you may have to invoke another unplayable and again decide on which option to play under Rule 28..... replay the shot, two club lengths, or keep the point between the ball and the pin and drop on that line.  If you make a stroke at the ball while in the junk, and the resulting stroke still leaves you in an unplayable position, you are left with taking another drop 2 club lengths, or keeping the line between the ball and the pin.  Because you took a swipe at it in the junk, option 28a replaying the stroke really doesn't help you, because under option "a" you would now have to play the stroke from the lousy lie you just tried to hit it from.

The point to all this is unless you are positive you can advance the ball to some place where you can hit it again, deem the ball unplayable.  Once you deem the ball unplayable, make sure you have a place to drop it or take your medicine and replay the stroke.

28/5

Regression Under Unplayable Ball Rule

Q.A player plays a stroke from Point A to Point B. Point B is in an area from which it is very difficult to extricate the ball. The player considers deeming the ball unplayable but this would result in a stroke-and-distance penalty (Rule 28a). Dropping behind under Rule 28b is impossible due to a boundary fence and dropping within two club-lengths under Rule 28c is not feasible because it would require a considerable number of such drops to escape the area. The player plays from Point B and moves the ball a few feet to Point C, where the ball is clearly unplayable. Under Rule 28a, may the player:

(a) deem the ball unplayable at Point C and drop a ball under penalty of one stroke at Point B, and then

(b) deem the ball unplayable at Point B and drop a ball, under an additional penalty of one stroke, at Point A?

A.No. Under Rule 28a, the player would be entitled to drop a ball only at the place from which he played his last stroke (Point B).

In the circumstances, the player's only alternative is to invoke Rule 28c a sufficient number of times (starting at Point C and dropping the ball sideways within two club-lengths each time) to get the ball into a playable position

I had one today on 10 at Keystone River that made me think about these ramifications.  I hit my tee ball into the left trees, where you usually, but not always find it.  1st provisional goes into the right trees which is harder to find as you have to sort through a ton of balls from the range.  2nd provisional finds the fairway.  I find the first ball not very deep in, but there is a stick on top of the ball that I can`t risk moving and I have to wedge myself between 2 trees to even be able to make at most a quarter swing at the ball.  So may options are:

1.  Play it as it lies and hope I can actually make contact with the ball and not hit a tree on a chip out.

2.  Go back the tee and hit my 4th tee shot

3.  Take 2 club lengths, but it is uncertain where the drop will roll to and is almost certain to leave me a worse angle on my chip out.

4.  Go straight back deeper into the trees.

I went with option 1 and chipped out onto the fairway only tee see the ball roll back down and to the left off the fairway into another lie which involved a stick that I couldn`t move.  I was able to make a swing at that one and wedged it onto the green and two putted for a bogey.

:mizuno: MP-52 5-PW, :cobra: King Snake 4 i 
:tmade: R11 Driver, 3 W & 5 W, :vokey: 52, 56 & 60 wedges
:seemore: putter

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by MEfree

I had one today on 10 at Keystone River that made me think about these ramifications.  I hit my tee ball into the left trees, where you usually, but not always find it.  1st provisional goes into the right trees which is harder to find as you have to sort through a ton of balls from the range.  2nd provisional finds the fairway.  I find the first ball not very deep in, but there is a stick on top of the ball that I can`t risk moving and I have to wedge myself between 2 trees to even be able to make at most a quarter swing at the ball.  So may options are:

1.  Play it as it lies and hope I can actually make contact with the ball and not hit a tree on a chip out.

2.  Go back the tee and hit my 4th tee shot

3.  Take 2 club lengths, but it is uncertain where the drop will roll to and is almost certain to leave me a worse angle on my chip out.

4.  Go straight back deeper into the trees.

I went with option 1 and chipped out onto the fairway only tee see the ball roll back down and to the left off the fairway into another lie which involved a stick that I couldn`t move.  I was able to make a swing at that one and wedged it onto the green and two putted for a bogey.

Since you found your original ball, obviously your 2 provisionals are negated. Wouldn't option 2 be to re-tee and play your 3rd shot or did I miss something?

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by reedf

Since you found your original ball, obviously your 2 provisionals are negated. Wouldn't option 2 be to re-tee and play your 3rd shot or did I miss something?

It'd only be his 3rd stroke on his scorecard, but it'd be the 4th time he physically teed off on the hole. At some point it gets demoralizing to be treating a tee box like the driving range. :-)

In the bag:
FT-iQ 10° driver, FT 21° neutral 3H
T-Zoid Forged 15° 3W, MX-23 4-PW
Harmonized 52° GW, Tom Watson 56° SW, X-Forged Vintage 60° LW
White Hot XG #1 Putter, 33"

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by zeg

It'd only be his 3rd stroke on his scorecard, but it'd be the 4th time he physically teed off on the hole. At some point it gets demoralizing to be treating a tee box like the driving range. :-)

exactly, not to mention how the guys playing with you and behind you might feel about it.

:mizuno: MP-52 5-PW, :cobra: King Snake 4 i 
:tmade: R11 Driver, 3 W & 5 W, :vokey: 52, 56 & 60 wedges
:seemore: putter

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Originally Posted by MEfree

exactly, not to mention how the guys playing with you and behind you might feel about it.

And then you move on, and everybody is fine. These things happen on golf course.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Note: This thread is 4294 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-15%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope.
  • Posts

    • Loving the deal I made.
    • Day 590, June 15, 2024 Worked the same as yesterday (link here to my Member Swing topic) on the QuadMAX and the same pieces. Clubhead speed stayed around 93-95 most of the time (after five warmups in the 89-91 range).
    • Some updates after using the Titan Elite for three rounds. This will be a semi-random assortment of thoughts. Battery The Titan Elite still says it has a full charge, so I'm not worried about the battery at all. Though a CR-2 battery will seemingly last more than a full season, the documentation for most of these rechargeable batteries says they'll last about ten rounds with Bluetooth on, and 40+ with it off. Not quite the years I get from a CR-2, but… not so few that "range anxiety," errrr, "battery anxiety" is a real thing. Plus, more carts have USB chargers for phones these days, and the supplied USB-A to USB-C charger should charge in a cart. (I keep a pair of USB cords in my golf bag these days anyway.) Heft and Magnets Previously in reviewing the NX9 I remarked on little things like the feel or heft of the unit as well as the strength of the magnet. Neither are concerns with the Titan Elite: the aluminum body gives the TE a satisfying heft, and the magnet — beneath the Precision Pro logo on the left side of the rangefinder — gives a satisfying pull with good strength. The Precision Pro App I won't be reviewing the app's functionality beyond that which directly interacts with/affects the Titan Elite. You can use the app to keep score and do other things, but I'm going to talk about MySlope and the Bluetooth connection almost exclusively. Basic App Features Unlike some other apps that require your phone to stay pretty much loaded up at all times, the Precision Pro app can work in the background. To get into the app quickly, you'll find a notification present on your lock screen at almost all times. Tap it and you're back into the app. The app will do basic performance tracking, but it's limited. Here you can see I selected a Driver, and basically, you do this when you're standing on the tee and, when you arrive at your ball, you tap a button to end tracking and the distance of your tee shot will be noted in the app. It's basic, and may fulfill a need, but I won't ever really use it. Slope Both the Titan Elite and the app feature slope capabilities. In the rangefinder itself, it's as you expect: you switch a button on the top of the rangefinder, and the slope turns on or off. It works just as you'd expect, and is nice and accurate. I'll say more in the MySlope section later. A small quibble: I have found myself accidentally hitting the button and toggling slope on/off a few times when grabbing the Titan Elite from the cart (it has a great magnet to stick to the cart). Accidentally turning the slope on could cost an honest player strokes in an event, so I wish the slope switch was either tougher to toggle, in a different location, or ideally, both. Also, the state isn't super obvious, to you or any people you're playing with, while other rangefinders make the state more obvious. In the app, you can turn slope on to use GPS/map elevation data to tell you what the effective playing distances of shots are, as seen here: MySlope I've never really cared for slope in rangefinders because I've never been totally certain that the slope calculations were right for me. Though you probably could assume about a 45° landing angle (which makes the math pretty easy - one yard up or down would equate to one yard longer or shorter in distance, until you get to larger elevation changes), the Titan Elite pairs with the app to let you put in literal launch monitor stats (not just carry yardages) — ball speed, launch angle, and spin — to calculate a ball flight/trajectory to adapt to any type of situation. In testing, I don't have the largest of slopes at Whispering Woods, but the numbers have felt pretty spot on. I'll continue to test this, particularly at some courses around Pittsburgh, and will post should I notice anything more. If you don't have the launch monitor stats for all of your clubs, you can either estimate the ones in the gaps, or just leave them blank and the app will make estimates. They'll still likely be better than the standard guesses from other rangefinders. MySlope requires your TE to be connected to your phone to work, though I haven't sought clarity on whether it will continue to work once you've connected the device to your phone the first time or whether the Titan Elite reverts to a stock slope model. I've emailed and will let you know the answer. GPS The Titan Elite has two modes — laser rangefinder mode and… GPS mode. The GPS uses your phone (and the Precision Pro app) to give you front/center/back yardages. Toggling is as simple as tapping a button on the top of the Titan Elite. For example, you can see "147 playing 144" in the laser mode, then tap a button and see that the front/center/ back are 143 / 155 / 167. You have almost all of the information you need to hit a good shot to the fat side of the green. 😄  Of course, GPS mode requires that your phone be with you (and somewhat recently woken up, as I had a yardage for a hole three holes ago once when I hadn't used or awoken my phone in awhile). I prefer to play golf without my phone on me, so on days when you can park a cart nearby (a push cart or a driving cart), no sweat. But on cart path only days? You might get some odd numbers, and should rely only on the laser rangefinder mode. In other words, if you have your phone on your or very close nearby, this is a nice feature. Otherwise, you won't find yourself using it much. Perhaps a future version will have a GPS chip in the rangefinder itself, and can do a little calculating (even if the map is just sent to the rangefinder from the phone on each new hole or something). Find My Titan If your Titan Elite disconnects from the phone for more than two minutes, you'll get an alert. If your TE is still with you, you can dismiss this, otherwise, you're shown a map with a red dot where your Titan Elite was last connected to your phone. It's not true "Find My" because the Titan Elite doesn't have a GPS chip in it, doesn't connect to the phones of strangers, etc., but it's helpful to know when you last used your Titan Elite, and given the range of Bluetooth isn't too far, and two minutes isn't too long, you should have a pretty good idea where your TE was last "seen" by your phone. If you get close but can't find it, you can ping your TE and it will beep. Some Extra Photos The eyepiece, like every other rangefinder I've used for the past decade or so, is adjustable focus. The USB-C port for charging and the Bluetooth on/off switch: The case is not quite the same as the usual "latch the elastic over a post" type case, and I kinda like this variation a lot. The slope on/off switch is the one with the green showing (green = slope is on). The button with the two arcs on it is the mode switch button: pressing it will switch between laser range finding and GPS range finding.
    • Great to hear. I am looking forward to making a trip. Tough to find a day right now but hopefully soon
    • Get the feeling Bryson is going to pull this off and win his second US Open
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...