Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?

[VolunteerGolfer]

Currently Jack. If Tiger can regain his previous form, than Tiger. Only time will tell.

[breakout89]

Tiger is the superior athlete, but Jack's got more majors. In a head to head matchup, both golfer's being in their prime, I'd have to go with Tiger.

[wahtever]

Do not know enough about Jack, but Tiger strikes me as a real athlete

[Asad]

Tiger! as I don't know much about Jack.

[MSU Fishing]

Tiger for sure.

[JackShephard]

Although hes had some rough times as of late...ive looked up to Tiger for quite some time now. Hes brought so much to the sport that I would not know where to begin.

[ggolferboy123]

Tiger woods marks the golf name. we all know and for one the competition is tougher. so what if good old jacko didn't have the technology. The courses are much longer and tougher and more international play! guys from all over the world

[BeautifulLie]

Even after tiger woods as had his off the course complications, I still think after his career is finished he will be seen as one of the best if not the best golfer of all time.

[andy101]

I like to look at the results on this one. I am not to worried about swing technique as one of Tigers greatest tips was that "if it works for you then keep it". So comparing swing, short game....etc I feel doesn't fall in this category for me. I don't feel that both have had it harder then the other as it is all relevant. Both have contributed to the game in massives ways. So I am in favour of Jack at the mo as he has won the most majors ever, has won more PGA tour events then Tiger. I def think Tiger will beat these records, but until then Jack is my number 1 pick :)

[lsuwjk]

I would have to wait until tigers career is over...Probably woods when it is all said and done

[nashcarr]

I hope Jack can keep the record, but time and talent is on Tiger's side..

[D.C.Woods]

We will talk about them for years to come just like now!!!!!

[Radford Wooly]

Nobody has done more for the growth in popularity for Golf than Tiger. Jack's a legend and the second best of all time, behind Tiger.

[max power]

Nobody has done more for the growth in popularity for Golf than Tiger.

Okay-but what does this have to do with who is better?

[The Recreational Golfer]

And what does "growth in popularity of golf" mean? Lots of people watch him on TV, but there isn't any evidence I've seen that more people are taking up the game because of him.

[max power]

And what does "growth in popularity of golf" mean? Lots of people watch him on TV, but there isn't any evidence I've seen that more people are taking up the game because of him.

Good point-there's more money in golf, but equipment sales have been stagnant for about 12 years, and participation is actually down recently. If we're judging on the basis of "growth in popularity" it's probably Arnold Palmer vs. Tiger Woods...

[GolfingGav]

I reckon Jack is probably the greatest, he has been and will continue to be, not just because of his on course supremity and integrity, but also for his off course demeanor and what he has done for the game. At the end of his career, I think that Tiger will have broken most of Jack's records and major wins, but will he be seen as the greatest ever? I am not so sure.

[max power]

I reckon Jack is probably the greatest, he has been and will continue to be, not just because of his on course supremity and integrity, but also for his off course demeanor and what he has done for the game. At the end of his career, I think that Tiger will have broken most of Jack's records and major wins, but will he be seen as the greatest ever? I am not so sure.

If he wins more tournaments and majors than Jack? Then yes, yes he will.