Right Sided Swing (Gary Edwin) Discussion

[garyt]

56 minutes ago, boogielicious said:

This is what you said.

We have no problem with reading comprehension as you have so sarcastically indicated a few times now. You said basically to stay out of the thread if we disagree with the swing. That is not going to happen in a discussion thread on The Sand Trap. We can politely discuss the merits or lack there of for any golf swing method.

That's not what I said at all. Go back and read it again and don't cherry pick parts. I said I totally get why people would post negative comments on the swing in the original post because it's an open thread about the swing. Dave posted the same thing  to Kingfrenzo and  I agreed but said IF it was a thread started for devotees of the swing with the idea of trading tips etc on executing said swing I wouldn't  jump in to tell them the swing sucks.  I'd respectfully not comment and let them enjoy their conversation. I never said everybody should do the same, just that that's what I'd do. 

[iacas]

None of the recent posts are on topic.

@garyt enough straw men. This isn’t a topic “for RSS users only” so nobody has even violated your definition of what’s rude or not.

OT commentary ends now.

[Jaygolf]

Who is still using this swing method? Stumbled upon it a few weeks ago and have questions. 

[iacas]

You can ask the questions, but I don't know how many RSS users are here. You can learn a lot about golf and the golf swing in many other topics here, too.