Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
RFKFREAK

Ping I20 vs. Titleist 714 AP1 vs. TItleist 714 AP2

15 posts in this topic

I'm not sure if I'm posting this in the correct forum or not but I'm going to be getting new clubs relatively soon and over the weekend I hit a Ping i20 and a Titleist 714 AP1.

Both felt great but after reading up a bit, it seems like the AP2 is more comparable to the Ping i20 than the AP1.

Is this a safe presumption to make?  If so, I'll likely go back and hit the AP2 to get a better idea of how it feels compared to the i20.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

Ap2 is very expensive, and the i20 will probably go on sale soon. Plus, I thought NY is getting too cold to golf. Would it be better to purchase a new series of clubs this spring?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

i20 is basically in between the AP2 and AP1 in terms of size.  They "slimmed" down the 714 AP1, less offset and thinner topline than previous models.  I like the i20's, here's my review http://thesandtrap.com/b/clubs/ping_i20_irons_review

Like Lihu said, I think you'll see a price drop soon on the i20's, i25's will be coming out in Feb

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I had the 712 Ap2 and recently upgraded to the new 714 AP2.  Totally different club.  The I20 I also was on the fence on.  I went with the AP2 because for me it was a much more forgiving club.  All I can say is see if you can demo both on Trackman or on an outdoor range even better.  You want to see the ball flight and what its doing.  Now is the perfect time to be fitted.  You never want to be fitted in early spring.  If you play alot do it now while your swing is still in "mid season form."  Trust me.  You dont want to be fitted for new clubs early spring when you havent really been playing.  The new AP2's are solid.  I'm still trying to put down a review of the differences between the old and new models. Need more time. The weight is different on the 714's.  Seems much lighter and balanced well.  Solid ball strike.  I love the new clubs.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i20 is basically in between the AP2 and AP1 in terms of size.  They "slimmed" down the 714 AP1, less offset and thinner topline than previous models.  I like the i20's, here's my review http://thesandtrap.com/b/clubs/ping_i20_irons_review

Like Lihu said, I think you'll see a price drop soon on the i20's, i25's will be coming out in Feb

Really?  Do you know what changes they made from the i20 to the i25?

I had the 712 Ap2 and recently upgraded to the new 714 AP2.  Totally different club.  The I20 I also was on the fence on.  I went with the AP2 because for me it was a much more forgiving club.  All I can say is see if you can demo both on Trackman or on an outdoor range even better.  You want to see the ball flight and what its doing.  Now is the perfect time to be fitted.  You never want to be fitted in early spring.  If you play alot do it now while your swing is still in "mid season form."  Trust me.  You dont want to be fitted for new clubs early spring when you havent really been playing.  The new AP2's are solid.  I'm still trying to put down a review of the differences between the old and new models. Need more time. The weight is different on the 714's.  Seems much lighter and balanced well.  Solid ball strike.  I love the new clubs.

Well I'm planning on hone my swing more during the winter so I don't worry so much about my swing not being in mid-season form.  I guess there is some difference from course play to practicing my swing in my backyard or at the range.

Please let me know when you do the review.  Would love to read it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Quote:

Originally Posted by mvmac

i20 is basically in between the AP2 and AP1 in terms of size.  They "slimmed" down the 714 AP1, less offset and thinner topline than previous models.  I like the i20's, here's my review http://thesandtrap.com/b/clubs/ping_i20_irons_review

Like Lihu said, I think you'll see a price drop soon on the i20's, i25's will be coming out in Feb

Really?  Do you know what changes they made from the i20 to the i25?

Well I'm planning on hone my swing more during the winter so I don't worry so much about my swing not being in mid-season form.  I guess there is some difference from course play to practicing my swing in my backyard or at the range.

Please let me know when you do the review.  Would love to read it.

This is a tough one. If you want the newest club, I would add it to your choice list.

If you want a club that is pretty darn good, the i20 is it. The only thing I don't like is the high ball flight, but I am pretty sure they will make updates that will only make the flight higher.

http://blog.2ndswing.com/preview-ping-i25-irons/

Keep an eye out for this thread:

http://thesandtrap.com/t/68897/ping-i25-irons-release-date

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Lihu have you hit the AP2's? Also have you hit the S55's? I was curious how the i20's, S55's, and AP2's all compare and contrast.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Lihu have you hit the AP2's? Also have you hit the S55's? I was curious how the i20's, S55's, and AP2's all compare and contrast.

Never hit the S55, but the AP2 we're nice. I tested them at Roger Dunn in Santa Ana. I guess I could have tested the S55, but I figured I wanted something easier to hit than the MP32 or the Cleveland CG tour I use for training. It's really hard to get the feel of something with tape on the club, though. They only have the 6i or 7i on the demo rack. I also liked the rocketbladz, which Shorty recommended. Very soft on the hands on a mis-hit.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Really?  Do you know what changes they made from the i20 to the i25?

I don't but I think the tuning port is going to be larger/deeper.  I think the head will look pretty similar at address.

Lihu have you hit the AP2's? Also have you hit the S55's? I was curious how the i20's, S55's, and AP2's all compare and contrast.

S55's are really nice.  AP2 and i20's go about the same height and S55's will go lower.  Pretty easy to hit though for a "blade" type club.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

So as far as ease to hit they are all similar?

i20's and AP2's have wider soles and lower CG.  I wouldn't say the S55's are "hard to hit" but the i20's are best on off center hits.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jakester23

Lihu have you hit the AP2's? Also have you hit the S55's? I was curious how the i20's, S55's, and AP2's all compare and contrast.

Never hit the S55, but the AP2 we're nice. I tested them at Roger Dunn in Santa Ana. I guess I could have tested the S55, but I figured I wanted something easier to hit than the MP32 or the Cleveland CG tour I use for training.

It's really hard to get the feel of something with tape on the club, though. They only have the 6i or 7i on the demo rack.

I also liked the rocketbladz, which Shorty recommended. Very soft on the hands on a mis-hit.

I see you have the Ping I20's in your bag.  Did you decide to go with them over the AP2's for a particular reason with respect to hit or did you already have the I20's?

I might be brainwashed and a complete market monkey, but I really want Titleist irons, haha.  I know Ping makes good irons so I wouldn't be upset if I go that route but, for some reason, mentally, when I think Titleist is the top of the line.

Stupid, right?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

[QUOTE name="Lihu" url="/t/71307/ping-i20-vs-titleist-714-ap1-vs-titleist-714-ap2#post_925576"]   [QUOTE name="Jakester23" url="/t/71307/ping-i20-vs-titleist-714-ap1-vs-titleist-714-ap2#post_925562"] Lihu have you hit the AP2's? Also have you hit the S55's? I was curious how the i20's, S55's, and AP2's all compare and contrast.[/QUOTE] Never hit the S55, but the AP2 we're nice. I tested them at Roger Dunn in Santa Ana. I guess I could have tested the S55, but I figured I wanted something easier to hit than the MP32 or the Cleveland CG tour I use for training. It's really hard to get the feel of something with tape on the club, though. They only have the 6i or 7i on the demo rack. I also liked the rocketbladz, which Shorty recommended. Very soft on the hands on a mis-hit.[/QUOTE] I see you have the Ping I20's in your bag.  Did you decide to go with them over the AP2's for a particular reason with respect to hit or did you already have the I20's? I might be brainwashed and a complete market monkey, but I really want Titleist irons, haha.  I know Ping makes good irons so I wouldn't be upset if I go that route but, for some reason, mentally, when I think Titleist is the top of the line. Stupid, right?

No, you should go with what you really want. You're the one who's going to be hitting them. I like Ping and they have been really good to me in the past.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

[quote name="RFKFREAK" url="/t/71307/ping-i20-vs-titleist-714-ap1-vs-titleist-714-ap2#post_925593"][QUOTE name="Lihu" url="/t/71307/ping-i20-vs-titleist-714-ap1-vs-titleist-714-ap2#post_925576"]   [QUOTE name="Jakester23" url="/t/71307/ping-i20-vs-titleist-714-ap1-vs-titleist-714-ap2#post_925562"] Lihu have you hit the AP2's? Also have you hit the S55's? I was curious how the i20's, S55's, and AP2's all compare and contrast.[/QUOTE] Never hit the S55, but the AP2 we're nice. I tested them at Roger Dunn in Santa Ana. I guess I could have tested the S55, but I figured I wanted something easier to hit than the MP32 or the Cleveland CG tour I use for training. It's really hard to get the feel of something with tape on the club, though. They only have the 6i or 7i on the demo rack. I also liked the rocketbladz, which Shorty recommended. Very soft on the hands on a mis-hit.[/QUOTE] I see you have the Ping I20's in your bag.  Did you decide to go with them over the AP2's for a particular reason with respect to hit or did you already have the I20's? I might be brainwashed and a complete market monkey, but I really want Titleist irons, haha.  I know Ping makes good irons so I wouldn't be upset if I go that route but, for some reason, mentally, when I think Titleist is the top of the line. Stupid, right?

No, you should go with what you really want. You're the one who's going to be hitting them. I like Ping and they have been really good to me in the past.[/quote] Yeah, but the primary reason should be which I hit best, not which of a particular brand I hit best. Haha

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • The official definition involves ability for male to hit 250 .. reach 470 in 2, or female to hit 210 and hit 400 yd. hole in 2. Informally, people probably view it more like GD: Similarly, various club pros have told me that a scratch golfer has a 2 HDCP or less. The USGA 2016 events site doesn't talk about scratch golfers, but it did specify max HI for amateurs entering its high-level tournaments: * US Open = 1.4
      * US Women's Open = 2.4
      * US Amateur = 2.4
      * US Women's Amateur = 5.4
      * US Senior Amateur = 7.4
      * US Women's Amateur = 18.4
    • You're forgetting that the handicaps throw out the worst ten.  So your true average is always going to be a few strokes higher than your handicap - unless you shoot the same score all the time.  Using me as an example - my handicap is 4.9 at the moment but if it was calculated using all 20 differentials, it would be 6.7. 79.5 guy would almost certainly be very close to a zero and 72 guy would likely be closer to a 5. :)
    • I see your point there. It's also interesting that he does not typically see it with driver where his contact is consistently to the heel side. I'm guessing that he tends to catch it toward the heel most of the time and the big draws result from hitting the sweet spot (as well as possibly better impact conditions). Might want to see what he does differently with these clubs in setup / swing and experiment with adopting the adjustment with the others, and then just tweak the path a bit so the draw isn't so big. Honestly you can't 'feel the spin' at impact, because the ball doesn't really spin until it leaves the clubface. You may feel more solid contact or better impact conditions that causes you to 'know' the spin that's likely to result.
    • I can definitely feel the extra spin at impact.  But, my movements during the swing feel the same to me and it looks the same to the people I am playing with. But, as soon as I hit it, I know it is long and left. Honestly, I wish I could repeat it.  But, I usually only do it 3-4 times per round.  I just can't figure out what I am doing to cause it. It has to be that I am swinging in to out and my right elbow gets away from my body causing the club face to close at impact rather than after. I just wish I knew what to work on to either do it all the time or to stop doing it. Golf is a great game!
    • Yes, lower initial ball flight but you cannot discount how much more and longer duration of lift the ball flight will get with added spin, which is result of differential between club path and verticality of face X speed at impact.  More the speed at impact, more the spin, more the lift, longer the ball will continue to rise and will have a higher apex but further out. When I said look for longer deeper divot, it is to see if in these particular cases he has more impact speed, which sustains directional inertia in downward direction for longer. In short, he is hitting it better on these shots, probably because of better weight transfer, and more refined turning rates and better impact position... I mean duh. :-))    Si.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. JLeeWildcat9
      JLeeWildcat9
      (30 years old)
    2. Ping Man
      Ping Man
      (52 years old)
  • Blog Entries