Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
dsc123

DIY Putter fitting?

Note: This thread is 1632 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

8 posts in this topic Last Reply

Recommended Posts

As a Christmas gift, my wife gave arranged for me to send my Newport 2 to the Scotty Cameron Custom Shop.  In addition to cosmetic additions, I figure its a good opportunity to change some of the specs.  Earlier last this year I tweaked my setup based on a video that's been posted here before by Mike Shannon ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MLEdpWxt63U ) and some tips from an older evolvr lesson and feel pretty comfortable with it.  I'd like to make sure my equipment fits what I now feel is a relatively consistent stroke that I don't plan to tinker with. I'm wondering what you all think about this DIY approach:

Current specs: 35 inches, 71* lie, 4* of loft and 2 10g weights.

Length - I currently choke down about 2 inches. This lets my arms hang, the shaft to line up with my forearms, and gets my eyes over the ball. I'll probably take 1.5 inches off or so.

Lie - With my newish setup, the toe of my putter is closer to the ground, but its still not level.  I'm thinking of taking a video of my stroke from behind, measuring the angle between the floor and the sole, and flattening the lie by that same amount.  Is there any reason why that wouldn't work?

Loft -- Maltby says 4* effective loft is the right amount.  If I take a video and measure my forward press, I can just subtract that from the 4* to find my effective loft.

Weight -- I've read that balancing requires that I add 10g to the head for every inch that I cut off, so I'll have to buy the appropriate weights based on what I end up cutting.

Of course, a proper fitting would be the ideal way to do this, but since I'm sending it away and the loft and lie changes are free, I might as well give this a shot.  I can always get a proper fitting afterwards if I don't like this.

Is there any reason why this wouldn't work?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Want to hide this ad? Register for free today!

Loft -- Maltby says 4* effective loft is the right amount.  If I take a video and measure my forward press, I can just subtract that from the 4* to find my effective loft.

On faster greens (9 and up), 4° is too much. 2-3° is about right. You can measure things that way, sure. It's somewhat accurate. Make sure that you account for the fact that the shaft is tapered and measure the middle (or both edges and take the average).

Weight -- I've read that balancing requires that I add 10g to the head for every inch that I cut off, so I'll have to buy the appropriate weights based on what I end up cutting.

Don't do that.

Find a 33.5" putter. Ideally one that's similar in head shape and shaft flex to your current putter. Experiment by taping quarters or nickels or something to the putter head, to the middle of the shaft just below the grip, and to the top of the grip to find the combination of weighting that makes sense to you.

What's that mean?

It means put a string out 15 feet away on a level (i.e. straight across a slope, ideally a gentle slope) green that's typical of the speed you play. Hit putts trying to stop the ball on the string. Change up the weight, and hit them again. Keep going and you'll find a combination of weighting that will let you stop the ball more consistently on the string (or very close to it) than the other combinations.

The old rule about 33" putters being 350g, 34" being 340g, and 35" being 330g is bogus. It might have been a rough estimate when greens were stimping at 7, but they don't apply now. Almost everyone needs a heavier putter head than they think, and a lot of people do well with a little counter-weighting and/or mid-shaft weighting.

My honest advice? Since the Cameron stuff is pretty expensive? Sell your Cameron, and between that money and the money you got from your wife, find an Edel fitter and get fitted for exactly the putter that fits you best. You'll get a better putter in the end that's customized with your paint fill, initials, etc. and is going to fit you far better than guessing at your Cameron specs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Thanks for the thoughtful response, Erik. I think the greens at my course are about a 9, so maybe I'll shoot for 3* of loft or less. And I'll definitely mess around with the weights like you said, I hadn't thought of that. I'm tempted to go the edel route. My scotty Cameron was a wedding gift from my best man (and golfing buddy) , so I'm a little reluctant to get rid of it. But if the custom shop is going to cost $150 or more and I might be able to get another $150 if I sell the scotty....maybe ill go that route.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Thanks for the thoughtful response, Erik. I think the greens at my course are about a 9, so maybe I'll shoot for 3* of loft or less. And I'll definitely mess around with the weights like you said, I hadn't thought of that.

I'm tempted to go the edel route. My scotty Cameron was a wedding gift from my best man (and golfing buddy) , so I'm a little reluctant to get rid of it. But if the custom shop is going to cost $150 or more and I might be able to get another $150 if I sell the scotty....maybe ill go that route.

Another option, too, btw is that if you aim your Scotty well, you can have the same one built for you (same head and hosel and such) from the Edel fitting cart (in a 33" version), then spend some time playing around with the weights they have in the fitting kit to help you nail the weight setup for your putter.

A fitter should probably do that for you for about $25 to $75 (to be honest, if you were coming to us, we'd charge you about $25 and let you play around with the weights and stuff by yourself.). Shouldn't take more than half an hour or so, and you'll get far more precise results than taping coins to your putter. :) (But the coin thing can work in a pinch, especially if you have a postal scale or something to weigh how much you add).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Thanks for the thoughtful response, Erik. I think the greens at my course are about a 9, so maybe I'll shoot for 3* of loft or less. And I'll definitely mess around with the weights like you said, I hadn't thought of that.

I'm tempted to go the edel route. My scotty Cameron was a wedding gift from my best man (and golfing buddy) , so I'm a little reluctant to get rid of it. But if the custom shop is going to cost $150 or more and I might be able to get another $150 if I sell the scotty....maybe ill go that route.

I'm sure Edel putters are excellent, but if you want to keep your Scotty, find a good fitter in your area.  I had my putter fit by a Golf Digest Top 100 fitter in NH (http://www.kustomclubs.com).  He uses a lot of the same techniques that the Edel fitting uses.  The whole fitting was about an hour.  I had the $35 fitting because after the initial evaluation, Ken felt that I was very close.

There is a top 100 fitter in Bethesda.

Golf Care Center
Bethesda, Md.
301-652-6094
golfcarecenter.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Another option, too, btw is that if you aim your Scotty well, you can have the same one built for you (same head and hosel and such) from the Edel fitting cart (in a 33" version), then spend some time playing around with the weights they have in the fitting kit to help you nail the weight setup for your putter. A fitter should probably do that for you for about $25 to $75 (to be honest, if you were coming to us, we'd charge you about $25 and let you play around with the weights and stuff by yourself.). Shouldn't take more than half an hour or so, and you'll get far more precise results than taping coins to your putter. :) (But the coin thing can work in a pinch, especially if you have a postal scale or something to weigh how much you add).

I do have a postal scale at work, that's a great idea. Fiddling around with the Edel fittings sounds line a good alternative but the only Edel guy around here is the head pro at congressional. Having no prior relationship with him,and his club being the most exclusive in the area, I don't think I'd feel comfortable asking him. [quote name="boogielicious" url="/t/71738/diy-putter-fitting#post_934781"]I'm sure Edel putters are excellent, but if you want to keep your Scotty, find a good fitter in your area.  I had my putter fit by a Golf Digest Top 100 fitter in NH ([URL=http://www.kustomclubs.com]http://www.kustomclubs.com[/URL]).  He uses a lot of the same techniques that the Edel fitting uses.  The whole fitting was about an hour.  I had the $35 fitting because after the initial evaluation, Ken felt that I was very close. There is a top 100 fitter in Bethesda. Golf Care Center Bethesda, Md. 301-652-6094 [URL=http://www.golfcarecenter.com/]golfcarecenter.com[/URL] [/quote] I have read really great things about that place. I actually called them about a year ago to have my putter fitted but they charged something like $200 and were booked for months. I'll probably pay $20 for the putter fitting at golf galaxy and mix that with a diy approach like I mentioned. The adjustments are free from the custom shop, so I'm not really risking much if I later decide to go that route. Thank you both for your advice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Fiddling around with the Edel fittings sounds line a good alternative but the only Edel guy around here is the head pro at congressional. Having no prior relationship with him,and his club being the most exclusive in the area, I don't think I'd feel comfortable asking him.

I know Mike Dickson. We trained together in AimPoint, actually. If you'd like I can introduce you to him. Last I heard he's happy to have outsiders come and get fit at Congressional.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I know Mike Dickson. We trained together in AimPoint, actually. If you'd like I can introduce you to him. Last I heard he's happy to have outsiders come and get fit at Congressional.

Thanks! I'll probably send the putter in for cosmetics and take you up on that when it comes back for a proper fitting. I tried to convince my wife that I should just get an Edel. Fist I told her that I needed some help going through the customizations on the custom shop website and after she designed a beautiful putter I showed her the price which exceeded $300. But rather than seeing the logic in spending that money on an Edel she suggested fewer stamps, engravings and such. ;p but ultimately that's fine. I like the putter and as I said it was a wedding gift from my best man and golfing buddy,so it's got sentimental value too. He just got engaged last week so maybe I'll get him an edel.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Note: This thread is 1632 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2018 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    FlightScope Mevo
    More to come…
  • Posts

    • Agreed. It depends what you value, how you derive worth. If you take the economic concept of utils (a unit of happiness/joy/satisfaction) - and having PXG provides you with 3x more utils than a $1000 set of clubs (plus spending the remaining 2k on other things) then it is worth it . Utils don't only come from 'better golf' or 'lower scores'. For me - I derive very few utils from cars, I just don't get it. My wife and I drive a basic, very high value car. I get my utils from reliability, value for money, that is says something about me (frugal, sensible). My best friend loves cars, and gets his utils from european styling, luxury etc. My pushbike costs about 6x what he does. We are both better off me having a cheap car and an expensive bike and him vice versa. This is why you can't argue with what other people value - it is deeply subjective, not rational.
    • I have been super busy renovating a house I recently bought, so I haven't been following golf closely, and I'm very late to the party on this one.  My opinions have probably already been stated many times because they seem fairly standard and obvious to me, but I'll chime in anyway. First, I'm very surprised at the level of animosity against Phil.  Talk about "What have you done for me lately?," here's a guy who has spent the last 25+ years doing his best to be as gracious to fans as he could, probably the best since Arnie, and yet he has one brain fart and the knives are out.  I know all about FIGJAM and Phony Phil, but you HAVE to be phony to be nice to the galleries, because they are full of idiots.  Don't get me wrong, I'm one of them, and most of us are respectful of the players and the game, but even if it's only 10% that are loud and obnoxious, that's thousands at any one event, and the fact they are the loudest and pushiest triples their impact.  Seriously, if he smiles and chats and signs autographs for an hour when he'd rather be relaxing somewhere, I guess technically that's phony, but in a good way, so what's wrong with it?  I mean, how many people would actually prefer to hang around a bunch of half-drunk morons than go home to their wives? I'm also aware that there are many people who have nothing against Phil, but still think he should have been DQd.  And I'm one of them.  I like him, I like the way he tries to be fan friendly, and I don't care about his personal life -- and even if I did, I haven't heard much bad about him, other than his ego, as if being arguably the second best golfer of his generation, especially when that generation (IMO) includes the GOAT, shouldn't inflate his ego. But when I say he should have been DQd, I mean in a perfect world, which this obviously isn't, because golf rules are often stupid.  In this situation, the rule was properly applied, so he didn't get DQd, but the rule is wrong.  Lots of the rules are wrong.   Up to a couple of years ago, you could get DQd for signing an incorrect score card, even when you had no idea it was incorrect.  The USGA and R&A thought that deserved a DQ, but deliberately hitting a moving ball didn't.  It's crazy. People say he gained an advantage from his action.  Well, duh.  I've seen guys who hit a poor approach, got an absolutely dead lie, but then got a free drop because a TV cable was nearby.  Then they got another free drop because the bleachers were in the way.  Then they got another free drop because of a sprinkler head.  And by the time they were done, they went from being in the rough in a horrible lie to being on the fringe, or even on the green.  Talk about gaining an advantage. And the rules official was directing them every step of the way.  I repeat, it's crazy. This is a golden opportunity for them to change the rule.  Deliberately hit a moving ball, DQ.  Very simple.
    • The player can choose to call his ball unplayable in any circumstance.  He is the only judge of this.  In the case you mention here he was taking one of the water hazard options, rather than an unplayable lie.  One could decide his ball sitting right next to the hole is unplayable, and go back to where he hit previously, at the cost a stroke.  Of course, he could be rightfully called a sandbagger, at that point!
    • Yes.  I welcome the challenge.  I'll pick appropriate tees and do my best.  I am going to play a Pete Dye course on my birthday this year, although it isn't necessarily among the toughest of his courses (and it'll be my fourth time playing that particular course). 
    • Day 20 - 50 practice chip shots (stance, swing, target), then a half hour of putting, then a small bucket at the range (30-35 balls, an hour) working on half swings, punch shots, and my old priority piece (I have a new evolvr lesson in, but I don't want to work on it until Saturday because I'm playing tomorrow & Friday)... and of course some drives and full wedges.  I finished up with another 15 minutes of putting. 
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. magnolia
      magnolia
      (26 years old)
    2. masoshe21
      masoshe21
      (22 years old)
    3. mp33man
      mp33man
      (32 years old)

×

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...