• Announcements

    • iacas

      Visit FlagstickRule.com   03/13/2017

      Visit the site flagstickrule.com to read about and sign a petition for the USGA/R&A regarding the one terrible rule in the proposed "modernized" rules for 2019.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
amac

Hit Ping's new i25 irons - WOW!

9 posts in this topic

I hit a friends new set of Ping i25 irons this past weekend.  If you haven't hit these clubs, I suggest you check them out.  If you are looking to buy new clubs this year, I suggest you check them out.  Yes, I am endorsing these clubs.  If I hadn't purchased new irons last year, I would certainly consider these to go in my bag.

I only hit one iron, that's all it took.  I was hitting my Mizuno MP64 9 iron pretty flush down range.  I grabbed my buddies i25 9 iron and flew it easily 10 yards past where my pile of range balls were.  WOW.  I proceeded to hit shot after shot to the same spot - 10 yards past my club.  I then grabbed my club and hit it to the same, shorter spot where my previous shots were going.  Yes, the Ping irons are longer.

The look and feel of the club is what you would expect from Ping.  I owned a set of Eye2's back in the day and gamed those clubs for nearly 10 years. The i25's bring back fond memories.  The set up is nice - not too offset.  The topline is definitely thicker than my Mizuno's, but not like a super GI club.  The ball flight was higher.  The ball picked up quick and then sailed forever.  My Mizuno hits a lower trajectory shot.  The feel at impact is sweet.  Not grain flow forged sweet, but you know you hit the center by the sweet sensation shooting up the shaft into your hands.  The sound at impact was, for me, more clank and clack versus my forged iron, but YMMV.  I checked out the rest of the set.  The longer irons were progressively larger and thus more forgiving.  Personally, that was the main drawback for me.  I prefer a more aggressive look.  I'm not ready to trade in my Mizuno's just yet, but the performance of the i25's is noteworthy.  In all, these clubs looked and felt great.

Trying to get at the root of the distance gain, I checked out his personal setup and the loft comparison's of our 9irons.  First, the Ping is 1* stronger.  Next, he had his irons fitted 1/2 inch longer than standard.  He used the Regular flex shaft, but tipped them.  Would that plus the 1* equal 10 yards?  Finally, there is Ping's technology.  They claim to have made the face of these clubs "more lively".  I guess they did!  If distance is your thing, you should certainly check out these new irons.  Enjoy.

amac

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Trying to get at the root of the distance gain, I checked out his personal setup and the loft comparison's of our 9irons.  First, the Ping is 1* stronger.  Next, he had his irons fitted 1/2 inch longer than standard.  He used the Regular flex shaft, but tipped them.  Would that plus the 1* equal 10 yards?  Finally, there is Ping's technology.  They claim to have made the face of these clubs "more lively".  I guess they did!  If distance is your thing, you should certainly check out these new irons.  Enjoy.

I would guess they go farther because they launch higher with the right amount of spin (for you). Could be a combo of the CoG location of the head with the firm regular shaft. So even though you can hit the MP 64's solid, you might not be getting the most out of them due to the lower launch angle with possibly not enough spin.

Also the shafts could be lighter, if you have S300's in your MP 64 irons and he had PING CFS shafts, those are about 20 grams lighter.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I would guess they go farther because they launch higher with the right amount of spin (for you). Could be a combo of the CoG location of the head with the firm regular shaft. So even though you can hit the MP 64's solid, you might not be getting the most out of them due to the lower launch angle with possibly not enough spin.

Also the shafts could be lighter, if you have S300's in your MP 64 irons and he had PING CFS shafts, those are about 20 grams lighter.

I have the ProjX 5.5 in my irons and I think his shafts were lighter.  I knew I wasn't buying a distance iron when I purchased my MP64's.  The grass will always appear greener when it comes to golf clubs.  Just when you think you have your bag just right, an easier to hit, higher launching, lower spin longer version of the same club is released.  Same guy had the newer version of Ping hybrid.  I have the i15's and he has the i20's.  After swinging his, the shafts felt better, the impact felt more solid and the ball flight was straighter!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the ProjX 5.5 in my irons and I think his shafts were lighter.  I knew I wasn't buying a distance iron when I purchased my MP64's. ...

Building on what @mvmac said, you're dealing with shafts with different characteristics.

Shaft

FCM

Weight

Tip

BendPt

PX 5.5

6.0

115 gr

Med-Firm

Mid-Hi

CFS Reg

??

99 gr

Medium

Medium

CFS Stiff

??

109 gr

Medium

Medium

?? = Conflicting information

FCM = Frequency Coefficient Matching - used to compare shaft flexes across different shaft models and mfgrs.

The PX 5.5 is firmer, heavier, and has lower launch characteristics and stiffer tip than CFS. (Using the generic Regular and Stiff terms, PX plays the stiffest to flex of any major steel shaft. The PX 5.5 actually has a higher FCM than the S300 (FCM = 5.8).)

The CFS has variously been described as average flex to light to flex.

I tried the R.flex CFS in both the i25 and G25 at a recent Ping demo day. I have about 85 MPH clubhead speed with driver, and the CFS was impressive. Although the i25 felt good, the G25 went about 8 yards longer, and higher. I switched back and forth between the i25 and G25 to lessen warm-up and fatigue effects.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Building on what @mvmac said, you're dealing with shafts with different characteristics.

Shaft

FCM

Weight

Tip

BendPt

PX 5.5

6.0

115 gr

Med-Firm

Mid-Hi

CFS Reg

??

99 gr

Medium

Medium

CFS Stiff

??

109 gr

Medium

Medium

?? = Conflicting information

FCM = Frequency Coefficient Matching - used to compare shaft flexes across different shaft models and mfgrs.

The PX 5.5 is firmer, heavier, and has lower launch characteristics and stiffer tip than CFS. (Using the generic Regular and Stiff terms, PX plays the stiffest to flex of any major steel shaft. The PX 5.5 actually has a higher FCM than the S300 (FCM = 5.8).)

The CFS has variously been described as average flex to light to flex.

I tried the R.flex CFS in both the i25 and G25 at a recent Ping demo day. I have about 85 MPH clubhead speed with driver, and the CFS was impressive. Although the i25 felt good, the G25 went about 8 yards longer, and higher. I switched back and forth between the i25 and G25 to lessen warm-up and fatigue effects.

So did you end up getting the i or g 25's?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Building on what @mvmac said, you're dealing with shafts with different characteristics.

Shaft

FCM

Weight

Tip

BendPt

PX 5.5

6.0

115 gr

Med-Firm

Mid-Hi

CFS Reg

??

99 gr

Medium

Medium

CFS Stiff

??

109 gr

Medium

Medium

?? = Conflicting information

FCM = Frequency Coefficient Matching - used to compare shaft flexes across different shaft models and mfgrs.

The PX 5.5 is firmer, heavier, and has lower launch characteristics and stiffer tip than CFS. (Using the generic Regular and Stiff terms, PX plays the stiffest to flex of any major steel shaft. The PX 5.5 actually has a higher FCM than the S300 (FCM = 5.8).)

The CFS has variously been described as average flex to light to flex.

I tried the R.flex CFS in both the i25 and G25 at a recent Ping demo day. I have about 85 MPH clubhead speed with driver, and the CFS was impressive. Although the i25 felt good, the G25 went about 8 yards longer, and higher. I switched back and forth between the i25 and G25 to lessen warm-up and fatigue effects.

I'm sure this is important, relevant information, but I have no idea what all this means!  LOL.  The Mizuno swing "optimizer" suggested PX5.5 and KBS Tour.  I hit them both and felt better with the PX.  It's near impossible to keep up with technology in golf clubs.  That and finding a fitter that would take the time to ask a few questions like, "What do you want to get out of your irons - more distance, shot control, higher ball flight, etc…"  I guess I'll focus on my swing technique and get lessons to gain the extra 10 yards instead of buying new clubs. ;-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So did you end up getting the i or g 25's?

The G25s would be on the short list - gets the ball up higher and longer. Same thing I saw last year with Callaway. I was actually able to hit the X Forged with decent shots, but the X.Hot Pro went a club farther.

The Cleveland TT seems to work nice, with the TRaction R-flex shaft, although it's a bit light.

I may get my X20 Tours reshafted - I have a demo 6i, which I had reshafted in NS Pro 8950 Rflex. Had a side-by-side yesterday with my current 6i, shafted in PX 5.0 - went to the 160 yd. area on the front nine holes, dropped some balls, and hit 2 each with NS and PX. Lighter NS (95 grams, and has about same profile as CFS Rflex) hit the ball higher and a full club longer - even into a 20 MPH headwind.

I'm going to "test drive" the Bridgestone J40 dual pocket cavity irons: for a month, I get 2x2 test set: 5i and 9i in NS Pro 1090 R, and 5i and 9i in DG R300 SL (superlight). I'll do a similar 170 yard and 130 yard tests to see how other lightweight steel shafts work out.

I want to decide in a month or so - I need to have the new irons solution zeroed in by mid-May.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

The CFS has variously been described as average flex to light to flex.

I tried the R.flex CFS in both the i25 and G25 at a recent Ping demo day. I have about 85 MPH clubhead speed with driver, and the CFS was impressive. Although the i25 felt good, the G25 went about 8 yards longer, and higher. I switched back and forth between the i25 and G25 to lessen warm-up and fatigue effects.

CFS is a good shaft. I like it, feels similar to a KBS Tour.

"What do you want to get out of your irons - more distance, shot control, higher ball flight, etc…"  I guess I'll focus on my swing technique and get lessons to gain the extra 10 yards instead of buying new clubs.

Well you shouldn't have to choose just one ;-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Well you shouldn't have to choose just one

To become a club hopper would make me one of "those" people!  LOL.  No, I am going to learn to hit what I have to the best of my ability.  I have my 3rd lesson lined up with Manzella (our relationship is much better since my first, so is my swing) and will continue to work with him on building my swing.  What's more, the wife and two children are expensive!  If only I had a Pro's budget for golf equipment. :w00t:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    Leupold Golf
    Snell Golf
    Talamore Golf Resort
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • I too, have difficulty understanding what is being asked.  Down - obviously Towards the ball - obviously A thought I often use is "point your lead shoulder at the ball" on the backswing. The caveat being, don't get overly steep with your shoulder plane.  
    • Just curious.   I've been watching some of the videos by Mark Crossfield and other youtube pro's and there is an argument to how much shaft stiffness truly matters.  Obviously too whippy is gonna lead to inconsistent strikes and dispersion.  I'm a S stiff guy, like I'm sure a lot of us amateurs are, but what makes these pro's need and prefer X?  Is it all the dispersion?  Because it can't be swing speed.  Bernhard Langer, Tom Gillis and all these guys on the champions tours still swing X even with decreasing swing speeds compared to the younger pro's.  So why is it?   And also are there any pro's that choose to swing a S or R flex and why? 
    • I get what you're saying @Vinsk ... but there might be a little more to it that we don't know.  Like @iacas said, Ernie thought he incurred a penalty so he assessed one. If I had to guess, there's probably slightly more to it than "it came out too good" because I agree with you on that one ... lies in the rough frequently come out differently than even the pros expect.  But perhaps he was having extra trouble getting it back where it needed to go, and the good result was just the confirmation.
    • Hey everyone,   So I've been really investing some time into this game the past couple years and think (hope, its golf ) that I'm making a breakthrough.  I started playing in high school with buddies where my main purpose was to hit the ball as hard as I could.  I'm a long lanky guy and was routinely out hitting my buddies even though they had much more experience.  Where they were really envious of me is with my driver where I could pound it 265+ even back then.  My irons were hit or miss, literally, where I would get a high flying 165 yd 8 iron and stick the green or duff one 10 feet.  So I've been working on the control game ever since I started taking this game more seriously to no avail.  I was still duffing and on the course I would find my self trying to crush it instead of just make solid contact.     My long sought effort of developing a controlled swing finally started to click at the range the other day.  One thing I had to continually fight myself on was coming out of my front foot.  I guess to hit it far I would do the jump out of my shoes like Justin Thomas, except without near the control.  I noticed I also tried to help the ball up a lot doing this, so when contact was good I would hit that high flying, but low spinning iron shot.  I was finally able to just roll onto the outside of my left foot without having these anxious spasms right before I hit the ball.  Honestly I think anxiety has a lot to do with golf.  Many of us amateurs don't know how the shot is going to end up.  Hitting a small ball with a big stick leads to a myriad of results and can literally be quite shocking when striking the ball.  I think I'm finally getting over that and losing my little nervous hop right before impact.  I was able to swing and roll through with a solid grip.  That was another thing I would do is release or tense weird areas of my hand when striking.     Its crazy how these little subtleties made such a difference.  While everyone around me was hitting tops and thin shots, I was able to stay cool and composed and struck the ball great!  Decreasing my nervous hop is decreasing my mishits by a large margin.  I'm also way more relaxed in my stance and grip.  I know its golf and this was just a one time thing, but I truly felt it and hoping I can make this change stick.  Hopefully on my way to lower scores 
    • On which tour did you plan on watching him play? I'm pretty sure he's not even a regular player on the Web.com Tour. This is probably a one and done kind of thing. In all honesty he hasn't been that fun to watch. He's not really cranking the drives because he needs to keep them in play and he's clearly not good enough to compete with PGA Tour players. If he wasn't who he was, he wouldn't even be getting air time.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Cwmgr
      Cwmgr
      (40 years old)
    2. Gfleck067
      Gfleck067
      (28 years old)
    3. golf82
      golf82
      (58 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon