Peyton Manning the Greatest QB?

[mmoan2]

You're right ... I did forgot to consider the 70's.  Let me revise:

If I had to vote now, I think I'd take a coin and put Joe Montana's face on one side and Tom Brady's on the other, and Jim Plunkett's face on the other other ... and flip it.  I couldn't go wrong.

BTW, in the sub-argument that we were previously having of Peyton vs. Brady, I feel like I could tie it to golf fairly well.  Like majors, the pinnacle of the sport is the Super Bowl, but everything else also matters.  In fact, somewhat unlike golf, you could argue that everything else (stats) matters quite a bit more due to the nature of it being a team sport.  So you can't say 4>1 and wipe your hands clean, but you certainly can say that 4 + slightly less in the regular season stats department > 1 + slightly more in the regular season stats department.

No offense, but I think even Jim Plunkett's high school yearbook picture was afraid to display Jim Plunkett's face on it

[Golfingdad]

No offense, but I think even Jim Plunkett's high school yearbook picture was afraid to display Jim Plunkett's face on it

LOL.  No offense taken because I was just making a silly joke at Erik's expense. :)

[mmoan2]

LOL.  No offense taken because I was just making a silly joke at Erik's expense. :)

Me too... Sometimes I just can't help myself (though this one was at Plunkett's expense. I'm sure he's heard worse!)

[boogielicious]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Golfingdad

LOL.  No offense taken because I was just making a silly joke at Erik's expense. :)

Me too... Sometimes I just can't help myself (though this one was at Plunkett's expense. I'm sure he's heard worse!)

I liked Plunkett, but he was the only player I remember whose face seemed to stick way out of the helmet!

[Fourputt]

Quote:

Originally Posted by mmoan2

Quote:

Originally Posted by Golfingdad

LOL.  No offense taken because I was just making a silly joke at Erik's expense. :)

Me too... Sometimes I just can't help myself (though this one was at Plunkett's expense. I'm sure he's heard worse!)

I liked Plunkett, but he was the only player I remember whose face seemed to stick way out of the helmet!

As opposed to Hauschka (Seahawk's kicker), who wears his helmet so far down on his forehead that he looks like Robocop.

[Golfingdad]

I liked Plunkett, but he was the only player I remember whose face seemed to stick way out of the helmet!

As opposed to Hauschka (Seahawk's kicker), who wears his helmet so far down on his forehead that he looks like Robocop.

I miss the days (not really) when the kickers andn some of the QBs used to just wear that tiny single bar facemask.