or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Golf Talk › New putter
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

New putter

post #1 of 19
Thread Starter 
Hi all, I'm looking to get a new putter, price will not be an issue.
I currently have a spider ghost and am unhappy with it, I'm looking to switch to a blade putter. These are what I've tried-
Odyssey- great feel I like the soft but don't like the weighting
Nike method- great weighting, easy strokes, sound wasn't very appealing
Tm ghost- light I like that, off center hits felt like smacking a rock
Scotty Cameron- nice easy stroke, good feel and sound, not the best feel but it's up there ( I need to demo this one more)

Just want some opinions on the putters you have tried and which one you use and what you like about it pros/cons
post #2 of 19
I tried a dozen or so putters a few years ago and walked out with an Odyssey Rossie. Wasn't expecting to at all but it felt the best to me. Been putting well (for me at least) ever since.

Also, even though I'm 6'2 it's relatively short at 34 inches cause my stance is fairly hunched over. Definitely pay attention to lengths.
post #3 of 19
If price isn't an issue I would look to see if there is an edel fitter in your area. I got fit by them about 2 year ago and have no interest in any other putter. The fitting sytem they have is great and they measure all aspects of the stroke. Highly recommend an Edel.
post #4 of 19

I was in the same situation about a month ago....ended up with an Odyssey White Hot.  It just felt the best out of all I tried and so far I'm pretty happy with it.

post #5 of 19

If you sort of liked the feel of a Scotty, but it's just not right then try a Ping Anser putter.  Also I know you said you want a blade putter, but the new Golo 5 line is worth a try. 

post #6 of 19

I have a Scotty Cameron Newport II, 10 grams of weight added to the stock Newport's and it is by far the most balanced putter I've ever owned. I've played basically 5 putters since 1975, Bullseye, Wilson 8802, T.P.A. III, Ping Anser, and my Newport II. They were all great putters in their time but the Newport II is by far the best balanced putter I've ever stroked.

 

My first vote would be a Scotty Cameron, but Odyssey, Ping and Taylormade all make quality putters.

post #7 of 19
I just bought an SC Heavy Fastback from eBay. It Was custom made for seller with Winn xtra large grip. It 35.5long. Now I'm thinking of having it cut to 34. Should I go to my local pro shop and have it done fore $4 or send to Scotty for complete renovations, asking you opnions
post #8 of 19

I was a putter ho - and 4 years ago, bought an Edel after a 1-2 hr fitting. I played around with the models - I ended up with a Vari-Loft Putter in which I can fine-tune the internal weight of the head (4 weights of various heft) and change the loft of the putter by changing the face (you get 3 faces) depending on speed.

 

Haven't touched another putter since early 2009. 

post #9 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by kcho80s View Post

I just bought an SC Heavy Fastback from eBay. It Was custom made for seller with Winn xtra large grip. It 35.5long. Now I'm thinking of having it cut to 34. Should I go to my local pro shop and have it done fore $4 or send to Scotty for complete renovations, asking you opnions

If you're just shortening it, any pro shop can handle that.  The Winn xtra large grip likely already threw off the original swing weight and balance of the putter from the original specs.  1.5" of steel shaft won't have much of an impact on the swing weight, head may feel slightly lighter. 

post #10 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by kcho80s View Post

I just bought an SC Heavy Fastback from eBay. It Was custom made for seller with Winn xtra large grip. It 35.5long. Now I'm thinking of having it cut to 34. Should I go to my local pro shop and have it done fore $4 or send to Scotty for complete renovations, asking you opnions

Although its more expensive and less time efficient. Your best bet is to send it back to Scotty. The local pro shop most likely will not re-balance the putter which in my opinion will hurt you as a putter. I got fit through the Edel fitting process and saw first hand how the weight of the putter can effect your distance control. Mr. Desmond from above may also agree since he too did the fitting.

post #11 of 19

Did you try Yes golf putters? ( i have a tracy II for sale )

i went with TM Ghost 770 tour  

post #12 of 19
Thread Starter 
I'm stuck between the sc Newport and the Tm ghost da-62
Persuade mee
post #13 of 19

I've gamed nearly every OEM brand, and nearly every style of putter.  I've been gaming a Never Compromise Gambler for a little more than a year now, and it's the smoothest, best feeling putter I've played to date.  I think the only putter that would get me to switch at this point would be a custom Edel.  Highly recommend the NC milled putters.  They don't have the brand recognition of the Scotty Cameron, but the quality is as good or better, IMO. 

 

The hard part is finding a putter off the rack that fits your stroke.  You can try and try, but until the putter sets up right for you, you'll always be compensating.

post #14 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by keller19xc View Post

I'm stuck between the sc Newport and the Tm ghost da-62
Persuade mee

If they both sink the same number of putts, buy the one that best fits your eye and budget. 

 

I'm not sure how you're stuck between the two, given they are completely different putters.  SC has a milled face, TM uses an insert, SC is black, TM is white. 

post #15 of 19
Thread Starter 
Exactly haha I'm going to go try them one more time and make a decision
post #16 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Desmond View Post

I was a putter ho - and 4 years ago, bought an Edel after a 1-2 hr fitting. I played around with the models - I ended up with a Vari-Loft Putter in which I can fine-tune the internal weight of the head (4 weights of various heft) and change the loft of the putter by changing the face (you get 3 faces) depending on speed.

 

Haven't touched another putter since early 2009. 

I second the Edel suggestion. The fitting process is extensive and they make some very nice stuff. You will end up with a putter that is not only beautiful but one that fits YOUR game. Mine should be here soon, hopefully.

post #17 of 19

Always tough to provide advise regarding putters since putting is the most personal aspect of the game.

 

And it can be difficult to get the right combo of weight and feel in one flat stick. as you've already discovered.

 

Odysseys in general tend to have a nice feel as do many Taylor Made Rossa sticks.

 

I play the Rossa Daytona #1 with agsi insert and love it.....however it does feel a tad lighter than some may like.

 

It is a traditional "Answer style" blade but in black matte finish which I also find appealing at address -has a single white alignment mark on the back flange.

 

If this sounds interesting to you -perhaps check out the Tour model as it is a weighted version of the same club.....wouldn't mind testing that one myself.

 

BTW- my other putter is an Odyssey two ball mallet with DFX insert which is firmer than the White Hot insert...I mostly use this one on the carpet in my office as I find that the Two Ball alignment system helps me better refine my stroke -thus putting more effectively with my TM gamer.....like I said , it's a very personal, subjective thing.

 

Good Luck with your search. 

post #18 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by keller19xc View Post

Hi all, I'm looking to get a new putter, price will not be an issue.
I currently have a spider ghost and am unhappy with it, I'm looking to switch to a blade putter. These are what I've tried- Odyssey, Nike method, Tm ghost, Scotty Cameron
Just want some opinions on the putters you have tried and which one you use and what you like about it pros/cons

No club is used more often than the putter, so finding the right club can be a joy or a nightmare.

 

Over the last 50 years I have tried new putters and used putters; long putters, short putters, and standard size putters; regular, midsize and jumbo grips; mallet, blade, 2-ball, and perimeter weighted putters; right hand low, left hand low, claw, and croquet styles (now illegal) of gripping the putter; and, I have read Dave Pelz's "Putting Bible" plus 10 other books on putting by some of the all-time great golf pros, and am now reading "Zen Putting." 

 

I won't even pretend that what works for me will be best suited for you. This is a journey that only you can travel. Enjoy the experience, and best wishes on finding your ultimate putter.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Golf Talk
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Clubhouse › Golf Talk › New putter