Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
extremeld

20+ handicappers hitting 300 yards (mild rant)

1,290 posts in this topic

just wondering if the 20 handicappers that AVERAGE 300yards i read about on golf forums are hitting 5,6 and 7 irons into par 5s how are they playing off 20 plus - swinging driver at an average of around 120mph

I know of only 1 20 handicapper (via golf forum) that i actually believe and he is a longdriver, that leaves several hundred that i dont - tell me if you do hit driver 6/7 iron on a regular basis on to 500 yard holes how can you still be a 20 handicapper?

drive 9 iron or less to all flat par 4s - come on how many 20 handicappers can claim this is true?

I have played a lot of golf with a lot of good golfers (plus 2 to 4) and bar myself no one hits the distances claimed by these much poorer golfers.

99% of these claims are not true please just stop it!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

i was a 20 handicapper once that hit the ball 290-310. a lot of times i would be in the rough or if i had a great lie i'd simply just miss the green. from there i might blade a 60 across the green, chunk one from off the fringe and 3 putt. it really isn't that hard to believe. hitting 300+ yards isn't as coveted as it once was. but to be honest with you...i don't hit 300 yd drives as much as I used to because I simply don't go after it like I did before, but i do hit fairways and greens consistently. :)


p.s. putts are a different story. haha.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sorry but 300 yards drives are something most golfers will never achieve without significant help - unless you swing at around 120mph faster than the average tour pro you aint going to be averaging 300 yards.

anyway got it of my chest feel better!

rant over
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess I'm not as cynical of the 300 yard driving 20-handicapper, because I do realize how inconsistent they are. A great driver will be followed by a 50-yard duff. Scores at up quickly that way... Some people on this forum describe their game and shots by their potential/optimal performance rather than the average.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess I'm not as cynical of the 300 yard driving 20-handicapper, because I do realize how inconsistent they are. A great driver will be followed by a 50-yard duff. Scores at up quickly that way... Some people on this forum describe their game and shots by their potential/optimal performance rather than the average.

Honestly, I disagree.

If you have a swing that is so erratic that you hit a 50 yard duff then there is no freakin' way that you have the swing speed, swing mechanics, much less the lag pressure required to hit a 300 yard drive with no wind and flat ground. There is simply no way, I'm sorry but until I meet a 20 handicapper that can hit the ball that far I will assume they are all full of shit. I'm 6'5 295 and very muscular, 12 handicapper, and I can't hit the ball near 300 and I hit quite a bit further than most people that I know.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Size and weight don't have a whole lot to do with how far you can hit the ball. I'm 6 foot tall and weigh 165 and although I can't drive it 300 yards, I believe my average to be somewhere around 270-280. Also, I know big guys who have decent swings but only get there 9 iron around 130-140 yard whereas me, a lightweight, can get a 9 iron to 150-160. Technique, most importantly weight shift and lag, largely determines how far you can hit the ball.
When I was a 20 handicapper, I remember driving a slightly uphill 296 yard hole to the back of the green. The ball had plenty of roll but wind was not a factor. Now, I know plenty of guys who are sub 5 handicaps who only hit the ball an average of 250. Distance is nowhere near close to everything and I'm sure there are more 20 handicappers who have driving averages in the 275-300 range than you think.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I discount pretty much everything I read on internet message boards.

It's a given that the average person who posts on a MB is sexy as hell, has loads of money, has at least one really good "black" friend, dates only hot chicks (most posters are guys, which strangly enough I tend to believe to be true), and leads an all around amazing life.

I'm okay with this...
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

in med school, i believe it was the second year when we learned to take medical history from patients, one wise ass teacher told us something i still use today:

when asking about sexual and drinking habits, half the sexual potency part and double the drinking part
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not really suprised to see so many 20-hcp folks out there claiming 300 yard drives. If you look at most golfers they tend to go to the driving range and practice with the driver. It is almost like the short game does not exist.

Also, I think they are calling carry + roll at 300 yards which would bump down their swing speed slightly to about 108MPH. Which would be:

108 * 2.5 (ideal launch) = 270yards with 10% roll = 297 yards (add 3 -15 yards for poor measuring or big fish stories and there you have it)

even with 100MPH

100 * 2.5 = 250 with 10% roll is 275 (which for many probably is counted as 300 which is only a 10% margin of error, pretty good if they are drinking)

I do have to admit though that I find the number of folks that hit 300yard drives or 150yard 9-irons hard to believe. But a lot of that is my ego trying to protect me. I hit a 220yard drive and a 110yard 9-iron but that is good enough for now because my short game is getting all the practice attention at the moment so my handicap comes down.

-E
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2.5 as optimal is more like 2.4.

20 plus handicappers do not hit the ball on optimal launch all the time (no one does)

to be claiming 300yard averages you better be hitting it well and without excessive roll you better swing at 120mph

fyi 124.99 was JB Holmes swing speed for the first 6 months of this year.

i go to the driving range a fair bit and most of the golf balls are in the 20 yards before and after the 200 yard marker - the range i hit it despite saying it is 315 to the fence is only actually 280 yards and hardly ANYONE good golfers and high handicappers reaches the fence

Anyhow this will be my last post on this thread i just had a headache from all the crazy distances - ask yourself again AVERAGE 300YARDS - to do that you are likely given the lack of consistency of high handicappers to need to hit the odd drive 350yards to make up for the "Missed" drives that only go 250

kl
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly, I disagree.

Like I said, 1 out of 10 drives getting out there 300 yards does not qualify as saying you drive the ball 300 yards. It's the 9 out of 10 drives that hurts your score. I've golfed with many 20+ handicappers who can pound the ball long and straight every once in a while. A lot of these golfers try to swing their arms out every time, so if they're lucky to make solid contact, it can go a ways. Otherwise, 50 yard duffs.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's the 20 handicappers who hit it 300 yards and are always in the fairway that I doubt. I've played with plenty of people posting high scores after driving it long and wild, missing greens, ping-ponging and 3-putting.

I know I'm glad that my driver distance didn't jump rapidly. When I started, I hit my driver maybe 185. Kinda hard to miss, especially at courses without rough. Now that I'm 220 or so with my driver, but sending the ball all sorts of places, I'm glad I don't hit it much farther until I get back to my accuracy.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

How did we get into a discussion doubting that some 20 handicappers occasionally hit a 300 yard drive. He did say AVERAGE 300 yards. And I agree that claim is certified BS. However, I have played golf off and on since I was 19 and I definitely hit 300 yard drives when I was a 20 handicapper or worse. But I never averaged 300 yards and I didn't hit a 300 yard drive every round. It was really not that hard for me but I was athletic but not overly strong. I would say that I was usually longer than most of the people with whom I regularly played golf, most of whom weren't too much better than me, but not straight or accurate consistently.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've golfed with many 20+ handicappers who can pound the ball long and straight every once in a while. A lot of these golfers try to swing their arms out every time, so if they're lucky to make solid contact, it can go a ways. Otherwise, 50 yard duffs.

If they do not create and maintain lag pressure well they will not hit 300 yard drives on flat ground with no wind.

There are pro golfers who still struggle to do this.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also think the vast majority of players look at the tee box and look at their ball and think "thats around 300 yards" when if you actually laser it back to the tee or use your GPS to mark it, it turns out to only be about 265.

There's a lot of ego's that get fluffed by that eyeball test and a lot that get shot down by actual distance.

There is 2 guys at my club of roughly 300 members that hit the ball consistently 300 yards.

We have our fair share of high school and college golfers, and TWO of them hit the ball that far consistently.


You 20 handicappers claiming you can do it should go hit 25 drives and see how far that farthest one is and when its only about 275 come back to reality.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ive been to a few courses where the sign will say 160 par 3 and the tee box is lie 10 ft away from the 100 yrd marker haha which can make ppl think they hit farther than they really did if they dont know, the course just went thru some renovation and now has houses behind it, so could be they just havent gotten new signs yet, but still

another course my buddy and I went to it was a par 4 370 yards dog leg, and he hit the ball as hard as he could and kinda had a fade on it thought it was gonna be bad and go into the lake, but we got up there and it was a good 60 yard shot to the green, he def drove the ball 300 yards hes a fairly high handicapper,

i believe it is def possible here and there under perfect conditions the perfect contact and everything, but to have an average of 300 im not so sure about
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought I was the only person on this forum that didnt hit 300. Are you telling me I am wrong?
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just as an example... I live and play in Denver, at more than a mile above sea level. The 18th hole (420 yard sharp dogleg left) on my home course has a yardage plaque on the tee box that says "240 yards to clear left bunker". That is legitimate, as I've scoped it with my laser. 95% of the golfers I play with can't clear that bunker, even in the rarefied air here in the Mile High City. It takes a whale of a blow for me to carry that bunker... I usually aim a bit right because it's a slightly shorter carry (225-230) to clear the right bunker and reach the fairway.

That being the case, I have even stronger doubts of the truth of more than 95% of the 300 yard drive claims from players at lower elevations. They are either mistaken and have never actually measured their driving distance, or they are simply deluded. I've actually shown the truth to a guy with my Bushnell, and he just wouldn't believe it... said there was something wrong with the laser, even though it had been accurate for approach yardages all day.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • You are a tad close. I would say the ball is about a ball width too close. When you move the ball away don't adjust to that by bending over at the waist more.  Even still, the ball looks to be in the middle of your stance. That is not a good ball placement for a 6 iron. I would say it's two ball widths to far back. Hover your mouse icon over the text A4 . 
    • Sorry we'll miss you, @Big C.  If this one is remotely successful, I'll try to see to it that one happens in winter (organizing it myself if I need to), and hopefully you can join us then. 
    • I do not like hot temperatures... at all.  Being from the northeast, if it got above 90 degrees, you'd find me stationed in front of the nearest window air conditioner.  Then I moved south and I quickly realized that if I took that mentality, I wouldn't do anything for 2/3 of the year.  

      Last September, I played a round during a weekday at a local course in 98 degree temperatures.  As I usually do, I packed 2 frozen waters, 2 unfrozen waters and 2 sports drinks.  I had learned earlier in the year that I need 128 ounces of fluids, at a minimum, during rounds in warm weather.  I almost never walk (puts too much strain on my knees throughout a round and I can't move the next day), and that day was no different.  I took a cart and found shade as much as possible.  

      I had been drinking more water than normal that day.  All 4 waters and the sports drinks were gone by the 14th hole.  No cart girl on the course that day.  I started looking for a water cooler on the 16th hole because I was starting to feel a little weak.  The only place I had seen to get water was at the comfort station between the 11th and 12th holes, but it was from a water fountain that had brown tinted water, so I figured I'd be find to make it the last 3 holes with no problems.  15 minutes later, after I hit my approach shot on the 17th hole, I told my cart partner that I'd walk up the path in the shade.  Truth was, I was felling really sick at that point and I didn't want to vomit from the cart.

      I sat on a rock off the edge of the path and things got REALLY dark REALLY quick.  Sounds were muffled.  I was dizzy.  

      The guys in the other cart stopped to see if I was okay.  I told them I wasn't and that I felt off.  I knew I needed water.  Luckily, one of them had a bottle of water in his bag and offered it to me.  I slowly sipped it and the other guy went to my cart and grabbed an ice pack out of my cooler so I could put it on my neck.  It took about 5 minutes before I could stand up.  

      After putting out on the 17th, I considered just packing it up and sitting in the cart for the last hole, but I managed to play out the 18th hole.  Got to the clubhouse and drank a few cups of ice water and a Gatorade while trying to cool down.  

      I was out of it for 2-3 days before I started to feel normal again.  I learned my lesson that day and now I will fill up my water bottles even if I feel like I 'have plenty' for the rest of the round.  It was easily one of the scariest moments, health-wise, in my life.  I was extremely lucky to have been playing with others that day otherwise, things could have been real bad.

      Stay hydrated... stay in shade... and if you feel even a LITTLE off, make sure to get yourself somewhere safe and around people in a hurry.  As others have said... it will overtake you in a hurry.

      ETA - By the way... I'm not in 'good shape' by any means, but I'm only mid 30s and not easily 'gassed' or anything.  It just hit me quickly and I wasn't at all prepared for it.  Also, the course I played that day is now closed.  I suppose that's why they didn't have water in the coolers or anything that day.  

      CY
    • I won't walk above 95 deg. and only 9 holes max if above 85 deg. (I carry). Don't get too hung up on being in shape.   Dehydration recovery is also a mini race that your replenishment effort could lose. The 'water-ade' you are drinking may not make it fast enough to all of your body to make up for the sweat loss. So you can actually drink more than you sweat and still dehydrate (and have a bloated belly). Happens to people all the time - "but, but, I drank so much water..!!"  If the de-hy % exceeds certain amount then you could be in trouble. Sometimes you don't feel/recognize till a few hours later. Also, core temps take longer to cool down once heated up.   +1 to the umbrella recommendation. Priceless. Scores? IDK, don't think much difference but haven't paid attention to heat vs. scores before.
    • Darn, 0-for-2! I'll be out of town for a work trip that weekend. But (subtle brag alert), it's the good kind of work trip where I get to play some golf. I'll be teeing it up at Erin Hills, WI that day.  Regardless, that date sounds like it will work for others, so run with that and I'll try to make the next one.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. chriswuk
      chriswuk
      (25 years old)
    2. Gero
      Gero
      (73 years old)
    3. SUPGolfer
      SUPGolfer
      (46 years old)
  • Blog Entries