Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?

[cdc3660]

Tough to say we have to compare apples to apples and oranges to oranges. the biggest difference that i see is the golf equipment, then compared to now. just my .02 cents

[quicksilvr]

Tiger might take it beyond Jack's footprint but it will take time.

[hippyboy]

I have to say Tiger, I'm only 31 years old so never had the pleasure of watching Jack (other than the occasional grainy video on golf channel)

[deaconblues]

Tiger, but why isnt arnie in the argument?

[JDSooner]

Where's the option for "both"?

[wrathletik]

Tiger is the one who got me interested in golf. The Nike gear is not too shabby either.

[dvd436]

I'm young and have seen Tiger come from nothing to one of the best players ever so easy choice for me!

[Green]

I am going to have to go with Tiger. While Jack was certainly great, you can't compare the level of competition yesterday with today.

[shades9323]

I would say so far in his career, Tiger is more accomplished than Jack at the same point.

[OhioBuckeye]

Tiger for sure

[OU812]

I used to love Tiger when he first came on tour, then I started cheering for anyone else to beat him (as they were all the underdog), and now I'm a huge Tiger fan again, mostly because I realized how hard he works, and how much he's struggled at times too. Undoubtedly, Tiger over Jack, although Jack was awesome too.

[HSip]

I am going to have to go with Tiger. While Jack was certainly great, you can't compare the level of competition yesterday with today.

I'm not so sure that Jack's competition doesn't compare to Tiger's. He had several multiple major winners, both younger and older than he, had he went head to head with on a regular basis. They are both certainly the greatest of their respective generations.

[fsuryan88]

arnold palmer

[Coastal]

I'm going to have to say Tiger but what do I know, I just started this game.

[Toph]

i think tiger just still has alot of career ahead of him and i still see plenty of championships for the guy

[david17589]

Still early days in his career compared to Nicklaus, but I would say Tiger Woods.

[Primate]

Tiger has the advantage of all of the tech we have today. If Jack was in his prime today I think you might be saying Tiger who?

[sinclac]

Jack all the way Tigers good but also over hyped IMO