Jump to content
Note: This thread is 4945 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

Oddly enough this never happens on the course and I am playing the best golf I have ever played.I am playing at par or slightly under par and usually from the tips.The problems with shanking and hitting it thin only occur on the range and it never seems to go away unless I use a driver,hybrid,3 wood.The shots usually come off the hosel but sometimes off the toe and I blade it.I tryed for about  30 minutes today with my 58 wedge and pitching wedge to get consistant shots going but no luck,even going for just short chips was awful,I just dont get it because it never happens on the course and I guess thats a good thing but I would like to practice some.

Adams 9065LD 8.5* with a Nunchuk shaft
Adams CB1 gw-4i with Project X 6.0 shafts , Mizuno MT-11 58* wedge
Callaway Steelhead 3
Tour Exotics Hybrid 16* and 18*
Ping long putter


I can shank or thin a shot in a heart beat while on the practice tees.  I have absolutely no idea why.  As you stated and its the same for me, I never do this out on the course.  I find that I do this alot with my mid irons on the range : (

I'm really interested in the comments : )

Driver Callaway Diablo Edge --- Custom Sonartec 3, 5 and 7 woods made +1" stiff shafts --- Irons 5-L Ping G10 +1" 4.5* upright reg shafts --- ---Putter Tiger Shark


I have no idea why either, but I'm glad to hear it happens not just to me, but to lower cappers than myself! There has to be some kind of different mentality on the range vs the course that's causing it. Maybe when we hit a bunch of shots in a row, we get in a groove and lose sight of fundamentals? That's my only possible theory.


I have come across this problem as well.  Very, very rarely will I hit a shank while playing a round.  Yet when practicing I can hit two or three in a row and be completely confused about why I have done it.  Usually the shots before and after the shanks are hit flush.  I guess it is a lack of focus while practicing.  Although I tend to focus on the basics while hitting balls on the range.  I'd love to know what causes this cause it can shatter your confidence with certain clubs.

In the Bag:

Driver: FT 9 Tour 10*
3-Wood: Big Bertha Diablo 15*
Irons: MP-68 3-PW Project X 6.5Wedges: JAWS 52*, 56*, 60*Putter: White Ice #9Ball: ProV1x

Some of my best rounds lately I didnt even warm up at all,I just swung a couple irons around for about 5 minutes, then just teed up and went for it.I am thinking of never going to practice again except for putting.

Adams 9065LD 8.5* with a Nunchuk shaft
Adams CB1 gw-4i with Project X 6.0 shafts , Mizuno MT-11 58* wedge
Callaway Steelhead 3
Tour Exotics Hybrid 16* and 18*
Ping long putter


The shanks will hit me at about 1 1/2 buckets of balls.  Up til then I can be hitting the ball perfectly, having fun, hitting shots left/right and right/left, high, low, with many different clubs......and POW......I start hitting shank after shank.  The only way I can stop it is go back down to a PW and start hitting a few pitchs of 40-60 yards.  By then though I'm scared to death!

Driver Callaway Diablo Edge --- Custom Sonartec 3, 5 and 7 woods made +1" stiff shafts --- Irons 5-L Ping G10 +1" 4.5* upright reg shafts --- ---Putter Tiger Shark


Mine are the opposite. I never shank a full shot, but I have to be very careful when pitching.

My current explanation, is that I put tension in my forearms, which makes me extend them slightly, shoving the club away from me just enough to introduce the hosel to the ball instead of the clubface.

At least that's what I noticed today at the range.

Who knows? The cause of these shots does not have a simple explanation, believe me, and I have cycled through a s_tload of them and am still looking.


I shank full shots a lot on the range, almost always after a lay off or when trying to flatten the swing.  It's not a huge deal, once I either get used to it again, or get the move somewhat ingrained, it goes away, usually after about a day, often less.


"My current explanation, is that I put tension in my forearms, which makes me extend them slightly, shoving the club away from me just enough to introduce the hosel to the ball instead of the clubface. "

It took me a few months, beleive it or not, to learn how to hit a 40-60 yard pitch with a pitching wedge.  I shanked literally 100's and 100's of golf balls on the range.  I had zero idea what the heck I was doing.  I then found that I was "trying" to keep the face square instead of rotating on the back swing.  Once I rotated on the back swing and held the club loose enough that it felt as though it would fly out of my hands everything was fine.  I no longer have the shanking booboo with the pitches.  YAAA!

Come to think of it.....when I get hit by the shnaks on the range, I do 2 things.

1- back off and hit a few PW 40-60 yards

2- be sure I grip the club super light

This does seem to work, though I'm still scared to death until I hit about 10 shots with the d*mn shanks coming back : )

Driver Callaway Diablo Edge --- Custom Sonartec 3, 5 and 7 woods made +1" stiff shafts --- Irons 5-L Ping G10 +1" 4.5* upright reg shafts --- ---Putter Tiger Shark


We'll I went to the range today determined to fined my fault.After shanking my usaul 60 balls or so I thouroughly analyzed everything club position ,hips arms weight forward or back etc. and this is when I finally realized that my old nemesis was haunting me again and I just didnt feel it or realize it . My problem was my hips getting ahead of my downswing and when this happens it puts the club literally on a different plane.So what I did was hit many,many shots basically feeling like my whole body and arms were swinging together or just an arm swing sensation with the hips following.If my hips rotated to far out in front of my downswing my only chance was come in on a different plane example for me was hitting it thin,topping it,hitting it on the hosel and looking like a fool on the range of course I cant leave that one out.I hope this helps someone with similar problems.You can check this for yourself in slow motion in the living room or anywhere.Stsrt your downswing then watch your clubs plane,then move your hips way out in front and watch what the club does.

Adams 9065LD 8.5* with a Nunchuk shaft
Adams CB1 gw-4i with Project X 6.0 shafts , Mizuno MT-11 58* wedge
Callaway Steelhead 3
Tour Exotics Hybrid 16* and 18*
Ping long putter


: )

The fool thing..... I thought I was the only one!  When I start shanking I start looking around to see who saw that sh*t swing : )  I do look like a total newbie swinging like that.  It hurts!!  God, that swing and result is ugly : )  I think I'll take up "putting" instead of golf!!

Driver Callaway Diablo Edge --- Custom Sonartec 3, 5 and 7 woods made +1" stiff shafts --- Irons 5-L Ping G10 +1" 4.5* upright reg shafts --- ---Putter Tiger Shark




Originally Posted by 596

: )

The fool thing..... I thought I was the only one!  When I start shanking I start looking around to see who saw that sh*t swing : )  I do look like a total newbie swinging like that.  It hurts!!  God, that swing and result is ugly : )  I think I'll take up "putting" instead of golf!!



I was wondering the same thing at the range a few weeks ago.  "What the hell is wrong with me?  How can I hit this many shanks and topped wormburners?  I haven't hit a shank on the course in over a year!  I shot 79 last week!  Alright, here we go-smooth swing...shank.  Are you serious?!  I hope no one I know is watching."


LOL......................

I went to Phoenix a few months ago to play in a 4 man scramble tourney.  I spent the day before driving down and practicing on the range.  After a few buckets of balls I went into the cafe and had a meal and ONE beer.  So I go back out on the, range and start hitting a few more balls to waste some time.  Holy sh*t, Batman....I couln't hit a d*mn ball without a shank.  I must have hit 100 shanks in a row.   I tried everything, PW, 8 , 6 , 4, hybrid, every club in the bag.   So I go to bed that night figuring I'm gonna suck really bad and I warn my team (we ended up with only 3 players) the next morning about the SHANKS.  We ended up shooting a decent 66.  I think we played about 55 of my own shots.  We played 16 of my tee shots.  I played really really well.  Hit every fairway and only hit 1 bad approach and 1 bad shot on a par 3.   ZERO SHANKS.....go figure.

Driver Callaway Diablo Edge --- Custom Sonartec 3, 5 and 7 woods made +1" stiff shafts --- Irons 5-L Ping G10 +1" 4.5* upright reg shafts --- ---Putter Tiger Shark




Originally Posted by walk18

There has to be some kind of different mentality on the range vs the course that's causing it. Maybe when we hit a bunch of shots in a row, we get in a groove and lose sight of fundamentals? That's my only possible theory.



I experience the same.  I can start a practice session with some decent shots, then gradually the weight gets stuck on my right foot and I groove myself into a series of fat shots.

Not saying that I always avoid fat shots out on course, but more often than not I can get myself into a poor routine on the practice area.


Same thing happens to me on the range every once in awhile...scary every time.  I find it happens mostly when I get tired and my swing gets lazy. I can't stay connected.  I usually have to pull a few shots to start gaining confidence again.  Last winter I actually went about 3 weeks without being able to hit a chip shot and not hit it off the hosel.



Originally Posted by basscat348

We'll I went to the range today determined to fined my fault.After shanking my usaul 60 balls or so I thouroughly analyzed everything club position ,hips arms weight forward or back etc. and this is when I finally realized that my old nemesis was haunting me again and I just didnt feel it or realize it . My problem was my hips getting ahead of my downswing and when this happens it puts the club literally on a different plane.So what I did was hit many,many shots basically feeling like my whole body and arms were swinging together or just an arm swing sensation with the hips following.If my hips rotated to far out in front of my downswing my only chance was come in on a different plane example for me was hitting it thin,topping it,hitting it on the hosel and looking like a fool on the range of course I cant leave that one out.I hope this helps someone with similar problems.You can check this for yourself in slow motion in the living room or anywhere.Stsrt your downswing then watch your clubs plane,then move your hips way out in front and watch what the club does.

I think you're on to something here. When I think back to times when I had shanks, it felt EXACTLY how you described, with the hips racing far out front as if they were possessed and had a mind of their own. And then what happens, of course I'd get angry and tense, and it ended up making things even worse.


  • 3 months later...

I just suffered thru an episode of the shanks at the range yesterday and wanted to post here more for therapeutic reasons more than anything.  This past weekend, I had on of my best back nines (4 over par which is great for my handicap!) ever to salvage a round. I start at the range and have a BEAUTIFUL first 2 minutes. I stop and go to the car to get my phone to check something. After I return to begin hitting about 5 minutes later, I shank a ball that goes low and slicing to the right with my 3-hybrid. It happens for 3-4 consecutive shots.  Then I pull out an iron, now I hit thin, real think so that it rolls for about 50 yards. I get worried after 20 horrible shots and start trying to fix things which causes me to start digging up a lot of earth hitting the ball flat!!  Needless to say I spent the next 45 minutes trying to fix this to no avail.

Just to end the session, I placed the last few balls in some long rough since we were at the front of this grass range, and hit a few good (straight which good distance) 9-irons, 4-irons, and even a good 3 hybrid. Luckily I have a session with my pro tomorrow, but honestly, I'm embarrassed for him to see how I've digressed -- "digressed" isn't even accurate if I'm skulling and hitting low extreme slices b/c that's worse than when I started the game 3 yrs ago!


I hit thin on the course all the time, but I rarely shank it.  On the driving range, on the other hand, shanks, thin shots, fat shots, and SUPER-MEGA SLICES galore.  It's like my faults are all exaggerated on the range.

Like Topspin4hand, I just came back from a miserable day on the range. I spent about an hour trying to get back to hitting the ball well, but I never did.  It was the bizarre 'inverse' club day --- I hit my 3 and 5 irons and my 5 wood really well, and everything else was lousy.  ...normally it's the reverse.  (Driver stayed true to form --- lousy.)

I think for me, part of it is that when I'm on the course, I consistently go through a pre-shot routine, line-up the ball, take a practice swing (at most, two), and then hit (it only takes about 15-20 seconds).  On the range, I am inconsistent with the routine.  I'm also often thinking about a particular part of the swing on the range, and on the course I try to limit myself to "Hit the ball".


Note: This thread is 4945 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    TourStriker PlaneMate
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Wordle 1,248 4/6* 🟨🟨🟨⬜⬜ ⬜🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⬜🟩🟩🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 Almost 🦅, lipped out birdie, tap in par…
    • One of the best TV series I've seen.  Fast-paced, bits of humor, excitement in every episode.   Renewed for a third season.   Highly recommended.  
    • Wordle 1,248 5/6* ⬛⬛🟧🟦⬛ ⬛⬛🟧🟧🟧 ⬛⬛🟧🟧🟧 ⬛🟧🟧🟧🟧 🟧🟧🟧🟧🟧
    • Day 307 - Mirror swings, focusing on rotation. That seems to take pressure off my lead hip. 
    • With a lot of help from @iacas, I was able to take a great trip down to Pinehurst this past week. Took advantage of having a day off because of Veteran's Day and spent 4 days in the Pinehurst area. @iacas, @Hardspoon, @GolfLug, and @NCGolfer joined me for at least 1 round on the trip. I got in 2 courses in Pinehurst proper - Southern Pines and Pine Needles - and then the Duke golf course in Durham and Tobacco Road. All of the courses were new to me, and I really liked all of them. I am going to add more to this later when I have some time, but I wanted to post a quick recap/thoughts for each course. Duke Golf Club I really enjoyed this course. It's a big ballpark that goes up and down a couple of hills. The front 9 starts off going straight downhill, with 1 and 2 being similar dogleg left, downhill par 4s. You make your way to the bottom of the hill with a par 3 that plays over a lake, and then you creep up slowly. The best hole on the front is the 7, the first par 5. It's a dogleg right goes downhill to a small green protected by a creek and bunkers. If you can get your ball to the fairway, you should have a chance at going for the green in 2. That shot was probably the most memorable one I had on this course. You then crest the hill again with the tee shot on 9, which is a par 5 that goes down the hill and then the green is back on top of the hill by the clubhouse.  The back only goes up and down the hill once, so it's slightly more tame than the front. I really liked 11, which is another par 5. The tee shot plays down the hill, and if you hit a good one, you could have a mid iron into your hand with your second shot. The green is huge, but protected by a creek that runs in front of it. The closing stretch of holes are pretty good. 16 is a short par 4 playing straight up hill. Distance control with a wedge is really important. 17 is slightly uphill, but the trick is navigating the uneven lies in the fairway. 18 is fairly straightforward but a stout par 4 to end the round. The only negative is that there were a lot of holes with forced carries to the green. 4, 7, 11, 12, and 13 all had ponds or creeks fronting the green. Most of those required hefty carries.  Bottom line, I liked the course and the setting. I would be happy to play here regularly. Pine Needles I loved this course. The setting reminded me a lot of #2, and it feels like a mini #2 with a lot of small, turtleback-type greens. The opening 5 holes were outstanding. 1 was a really cool par 5 that was no gimme. The green was pretty wild. 2 was a long, downhill par 4. 3 was one of my favorite par 3s that we played - over a lake with bunkers framing the green. 4 was a short uphill par 4 that I really liked. 5 was an excellent but tough par 3, sitting on a shelf well above the tee. It's a great opening stretch. And again, the feel and look of the place is unique to the Pinehurst area. It feels like something you wouldn't find anywhere else. Other highlights - the green site on 9 was really cool. There is a big run off area to the right of the green that you want to avoid. It reminded me a bit of the second hole at Sand Valley - you don't want to be right of that green either. 12 was a great hole. You can't see the green from the tee, as the tee shot plays over a hill. When you see the green, it looks tiny, with a huge runoff and bunkers to the left of the green. The fairway is pretty wide, so the trick is accuracy with your approach shot. 18 was an extremely cool finishing hole. You can't really see the fairway off the tee, but it turns out to be fairly generous when you get there. And then the green site is fantastic - sitting at the bottom of the hill, but still requiring precision to be on it. I really want to get back and play this course again. There are a few shots that I want to try again (the drive on 10, the approach on 12, the drive on 18). And I just really loved the look and feel of the place. A great course and a fun day of golf. Southern Pines I thought this was the best course of the 4 I played. It's wider than Pine Needles, and the greens are bigger. But the greens are much more undulating. The land here is truly excellent. There is a ton of land movement, and seemingly every hole has elevation changes you have to navigate. I really like both par 5s on the front. If you hit good drives on both, you will get a big kick down the fairway. If you don't, you're going to be faced with a long 2nd shot just to have a wedge in. 2 plays down the hill with the tee shot and then back up the hill with the approach. You have to be careful about club selection and distance control there. 7 was a good, fairly long par 3 with a green perched on a ledge. 11 was a driveable par 4 with a wild green. 15 was really cool as well - the tee shot is downhill, but then the green is back uphill. This is a course I would love to play everyday. It's a thinking man's course, because you have to be really careful with all the elevations changes there. You constantly have to play and commit to a club longer or shorter than the distance. And I don't really think there are any bad holes. Only negative is that a few holes are a bit repetitive - 4, 16, and 18 are all shorter par 4s where you're hitting an uphill approach wedge or short iron. This is a very minor nit, though. One of the best courses I've played. I'd have to think about where exactly to rank it, but easily within the top 10. Possibly cracking the top 5. I will play this again next time I'm in Pinehurst. Tobacco Road I had a blast at this course. It is unique and pretty wild. You start out with these massive dune-like hills pinching in on your tee shot on 1. And then the entire round feels like you're going around these massive dunes. There are a lot of interesting shots here. You have long carries over bunkers, blind tee shots, shots into tiny greens, shots into huge greens, carries over deep bunkers, downhill shots, uphill shots, you name it. The setting is incredible. It is a huge course, and the fairways and greens tend to be very generous. I want to write more about individual holes later. But I really liked 7, 9, 10, and 16. I want to play a couple of the par 3s again with different hole locations and/or different tee boxes. 6 and 17, in particular, could play like wildly different holes with a different hole location (for 17) or coming from a different tee box (for 6).  While I had a lot of fun seeing this course, I do feel like a smart golfer could get bored here. To me, it was fairly obvious that Strantz was trying to bait you into trying a bunch of hard shots. On 11, for example, if you hit a good drive to the right side of the fairway, you could have a shot at the green in 2. But the green is over a massive bunker that has to be 40 feet below the green. And the green is narrow, essentially facing perpendicular to you. The only chance you really have is to hit a perfect shot. The alternative is an easy lay up to a wide fairway, leaving you with a wedge at the perfect angle. Maybe I try going for it with a 7 iron or something shorter, but that's about it. I felt similar on 5 - the direct line to the green is not that far and the green is driveable, But if you miss, you're going to have a 40ish yard bunker shot or a lost ball. Meanwhile, if you play to the right, you have a massive fairway and you'll likely be left with a wedge in your hand. I think it would be fun to play with 2 balls on some of these holes and try the shots. If you are a LSW disciple, though, you are not going to try the crazy risky shots Strantz is trying to bait you into. In the end, I really enjoyed this course. But I think it's below PN or SP. It's still awesome, and it was fun to see and play. I would come back here, but it's a lower priority than other Pinehurst courses. Well, that ended up being longer than I was anticipating. I may add some more thoughts about specific holes later, but this is a good starting point. I do want to think more about course ratings out of 10 for these, too. More to come...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...