Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
RadioCop

The Sound of my Putter.

9 posts in this topic

I recently purchased a Ping Sydney Putter. I after reading the reviews online (Something I should have done before I made the purchase), one of the chief complaints was the sound the putter made. I can understand feel and performance, but I don't understand how "Sound" can make a difference with a putter.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sign up (or log in) today! It's free (and you won't see this ad anymore)!

Sound translates into feel.  If a putter has a clicky sound at impact, if creates the feeling of harshness.  Some of the softer putters out there make more of a dull thud at impact and that sound translates into the putter feeling soft.

Sound is feel.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by RadioCop

...I can understand feel and performance, but I don't understand how "Sound" can make a difference with a putter.

IMO, it's a largely personal thing (as is the case with putters in general).  My Ping Scottsdale makes a pronounced "Ping!" sound (appropriately enough) when striking the ball.  I like the sound; others who have tried my putter had mixed feelings about it.  I also have a TM Corza Ghost which emits a much more muted 'clunk' - it never bothered me, but I like the sound of the Ping better.  Probably not coincidentally, I putt better with the Ping.

I liken it to the psychological effect of how your irons look to you at address; if you don't like the look and don't feel confident standing over it, you're probably not going to play well with the clubs.  If you don't like the sound of your putter, you're going to think about it every time you putt and it can get into your head and screw with your game.  As GaijinGolfer said, sound is part of the feel.

Bottom line - if you like the putter and how it sounds/feels/performs, who cares what other peoples' reviews say?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

IMHO, sound is a proxy for feel. I do not think we can feel as much difference as we can hear. Therefore we think we feel differences that are bases on our ears.

That "click" sound that some people like high pitched and others like lower and still others like none at all. Some like it loud and other others muted. All that can be changed a bunch by changing balls. I do not like loud click sounding balls off my white ice insert. Some balls have that click sound and it makes me think they are harder. They may be harder but does that actually translate much to distance control? I am guessing what I "feel" is largely informed by my ears. I think that link between our ears and our heads is why people care so much about sound -- it is a proxy for feel. Putters and putter inserts change the sound interaction with balls. But, at the extremes, I don't imaging any putter making hardly any sound when striking a Srixon Soft Feel ball. And, I do not recall any ball making a "click" off the white hot insert putters.

Not sure what other grip about with the Ping, but if you want to hear and feel a harder or softer feel when putting your ball, change balls.

My guess is that you will love your new putter. Go out and find the ball that feels (I mean sounds) the best to you on the greens.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted by rustyredcab

IMHO, sound is a proxy for feel. I do not think we can feel as much difference as we can hear. Therefore we think we feel differences that are bases on our ears.

That "click" sound that some people like high pitched and others like lower and still others like none at all. Some like it loud and other others muted. All that can be changed a bunch by changing balls. I do not like loud click sounding balls off my white ice insert. Some balls have that click sound and it makes me think they are harder. They may be harder but does that actually translate much to distance control? I am guessing what I "feel" is largely informed by my ears. I think that link between our ears and our heads is why people care so much about sound -- it is a proxy for feel. Putters and putter inserts change the sound interaction with balls. But, at the extremes, I don't imaging any putter making hardly any sound when striking a Srixon Soft Feel ball. And, I do not recall any ball making a "click" off the white hot insert putters.

Not sure what other grip about with the Ping, but if you want to hear and feel a harder or softer feel when putting your ball, change balls.

My guess is that you will love your new putter. Go out and find the ball that feels (I mean sounds) the best to you on the greens.


I find that the harder covered, "distance" balls make more of a click at impact, whereas the softer, urethane covered balls sound much softer and make more of a dull thud.

Thats one of the reasons why Im such a big fan of the Bridgestone E5.  Its got a soft cover but costs about half of what a tour ball does.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If it sounds good, then it more than likely feels good. I currently am using a Carbite Polar Balanced and it produces a solid thwack each time. It's a little louder than my Odssey White #2. I think that the sound can inspire confidence. I had a friend that used to use a Ping 1 A (I believe that is the model ~ the one that produces the "ping" sound) and I didn't like the "ping" sound it made at all. He did however, but it drove me nuts!! We know skill is involved in putting, but I would not discount emotion entirely. Again, if you have a good feeling about a club or the way it looks or sounds, then you may subconsciously be inspired when you strike the ball with it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a Cameron Futura that has a distinct ting sound. It took me a while to get used to it. The sound the ball makes rattling around in the hole after making a putt helped me get over it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ping is known for the louder sound, not only on the putters, i think the woods do the same thing.

I never was a Ping fan, and i think never will be.

I've got a TM Ghost tour series putter and with my latest grip change ( Super Stroke slim 3.0 ) i'm holing

more putts than ever. But the TM makes a softer noise i kinda like that.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agreed with the posters about sound and feel working together.  My SC Newport Beach has a sound slot cut into the face that give a nice "pop" sound on good contact.  I don't like the sound/feel of composite faces.  Some of the milled faces of putters sound nice.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2017 TST Partners

    PING Golf
    Leupold Golf
    Snell Golf
    Talamore Golf Resort
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • That looks nifty, but… it's only really going to be an option for awhile in some high-end places, I'm wagering. If it's a full range, you can of course see your ball flight. So the tracer itself is probably not that important, right? The points and games are another thing, kinda TopGolf-like.
    • That looks awesome! I hope that sooner or later all driving ranges will have that technology built into them.  Was it more expensive than a regular bucket of balls?
    • I didn't take it that way. I know the HGG quote, and that it's a way of saying "goodbye." That's not exactly "cool" though either: Mike tells you he's mad at you, I demonstrate that your impact conditions and backswing are worse, and you say "okay, goodbye." But yeah, I took it this way: That fits quite well since you keep talking about how you have to know and understand the whole system just to implement a piece, and about how your brain works that way, and so on. How I took the fish quote is pretty clear from the response, is it not? All that said, I apologize. I took it the wrong way. I reacted more strongly than I would have had I taken it the HGG way, and I'm sorry for that. Disagreement isn't intolerable at all. But you're not really disagreeing with anything, either… you're choosing to ignore things, and you seem to think that you're not being helped. You're wasting our time. Disagreement? At least there's discourse there. Ignoring? That's just a (small) slap in the face… Mike and I - and others - have given you a boatload of free advice. I can't speak for others, but I don't expect you to pay for anything, ever. When all else fails, play the victim card again? Anyone who has met @mvmac will tell you he's not quick to anger. So if you pissed him off, well, then more than likely you did something, and are not just some passive victim. P.S. You're likely getting better because you're hitting balls. You're learning how to make the flaws in your swing at least time themselves up right. You're learning to time your flip just right so that you can pick the ball off the ground without fatting or thinning it. You're learning how to sway your hips and drop your head back/early extend on the downswing so you can hit out a little bit despite being super steep (and you need a really closed stance to help you with that). You're getting better at making a flawed swing because you're repeating it often. You're lowering the ceiling on how good you can get each time you visit the range and don't practice properly, or practice the proper things. Your swing may actually be worse now than a week or two ago. We tried to help you - free, and by giving you much of our most valuable asset (our time) - and you instead pissed off one of the calmest people around and ignored the advice of many others, including me, who knows what I'm talking about. Then you chose to play the victim after a vague reference to fish, and took the easy out of saying "oh, you just don't like people who disagree." No, I don't like people who waste my time, but the solution on my end is very easy: I simply choose to stop wasting my time on them. I don't care if you disagree. I prefer it, really, so long as you're a worthy adversary. You? You don't stack up. We can't talk about some intricate part of the golf swing. Nor should you at this point, or possibly ever, because you're a golfer, not a golf instructor. That's all fine. But I can choose to stop giving you free advice, and spending my time doing it.  So if your goal is to have me ignore you from here on out, you've succeeded! :-) I'll spend my time helping those who appreciate it.
    • Did anyone make it to this?  I had some things come up and couldn't make it. Also, we should get a spring round get together going...
    • You misunderstand. Yes, of course he is one of the ATGs on the current list. What I am saying is that can change, not that it will, but it can. Like I said it is an ever expanding/changing list.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Blog Entries

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. henry granic
      henry granic
      (61 years old)
    2. Jscrillah
      Jscrillah
      (45 years old)
  • Get Great Gear with Amazon