Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
MLPx

Hip rotation and X-factor

6 posts in this topic

Hi there,

would like some input on my loading position. At the bottom of this post you will find 2 images, fig B is my usual and A is what I would like some insights. I understand that X-factor refers to the angular difference in rotation of the shoulders and hips, the bigger the X-factor, the more torque and club head speed. A quieter lower body also means a more stable base with less moving parts, hence a more consistent swing. In fig A, you can see that I have restricted my hip turn too a very minimal amount while still maintaining the same shoulder rotation as in fig B which is my normal. By the theory of the X-factor stretch, would restricting the hip turn increase torque and allow me to drive it even farther than I already do? Your thoughts are most welcome.

PS: Is not an overswing, just an awkward camera angle.

Thanks,

MLP(:

fig A

fig A

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

As I understand it, X-factor stretch is a result of a dynamic action. That is, the sliding and turning of the hips as the downswing begins. Players actually increase their X-factor at some point during the downswing. It's not something you want to pose in your backswing.

I'm generally against any restricting of the hips or tension in the swing in general.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

The Jim Mclean X Factor is a bunch of bunk.
1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by colin007

The Jim Mclean X Factor is a bunch of bunk.

I don't know, Keegan Bradley hits the ball pretty far and McLean is his coach.  McLean like most swing coaches has very specific ideas about how a golfer should swing a club.

If you watch the pro's, it's pretty obvious there are many ways to swing a club and get good results.  Tiger has changed his swing 3-4 times and won with each different swing.  Bubba and Furyk have very non-textbook swings but they have won with them.  The SnT guys have some pro's on tour too that have had success.

The issue I have with these "swing guru's" is that they want you to swing the club according to their method rather than taking your natural swing and working with it.  Guys like Bubba and Furyk would probably lose their spot on the tour if they were forced to work with McLean.

What I like about 5SK is they take the common elements to what makes a good swing and put them together but understand there are a lot of different ways to get there.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Here's the thing, the 5 keys give you distance, they understand were the power in the swing come from, and get tweak you to gain more of it if you need to.

The X-factor, yes there is a correlation. If you plot it on a graph, those with a bigger x-factor hit it farther. But your talking about 0.75 mph per degree of x-factor. Just looking at some averages out there. Here's the thing though, the hole notion about restricting your hip turn to gain x-factor is crap. Its not a good way to increase it. Here's why. Lets say you keep your hips at 30 degrees, and your body has a max X-factor of 30 degrees. that means your shoulder turn will be 60 degrees. But lets say you still have another 15 degrees of hip rotation you can have. So, under the guidance of gaining maximum x-factor, you now took out 15 degrees of leverage (rotation) in your swing.

What is X-factor, flexibility. That's it. Its part genetics, and part exercise. I can say this, for a great number of people out there, your going to reach your maximum natural x-factor before you make a full turn.

If you throw in the fact that downswing starts with the hips, your going to gain a bit in the transition, you want to error on the side of not restricting your hips, because even if you say, open your hips up more, and take 5 degrees off your x-factor, you can gain that back in transition.

So i rather see someone get a full shoulder turn, and proper turn rates with there body, to ensure maximum leverage, and contact.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Originally Posted by newtogolf

I don't know, Keegan Bradley hits the ball pretty far and McLean is his coach.  McLean like most swing coaches has very specific ideas about how a golfer should swing a club.

If you watch the pro's, it's pretty obvious there are many ways to swing a club and get good results.  Tiger has changed his swing 3-4 times and won with each different swing.  Bubba and Furyk have very non-textbook swings but they have won with them.  The SnT guys have some pro's on tour too that have had success.

The issue I have with these "swing guru's" is that they want you to swing the club according to their method rather than taking your natural swing and working with it.  Guys like Bubba and Furyk would probably lose their spot on the tour if they were forced to work with McLean.

What I like about 5SK is they take the common elements to what makes a good swing and put them together but understand there are a lot of different ways to get there.

keegan is also tall (like 6'4" i think) and lanky, so he has a huge swing arc, plus he hits up on the ball, and it seems like he has a perfectly optimized driver-shaft combo.  he does murder the ball off the tee though.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • The most esoteric golf tournament name ever...
    • Hey all, we are off and running.  My #1 shot a 79 at a collegiate course where we played the "white tee positions" for the majority of the tournament.  She was working on an exceptional round when she triple bogeyed hole 18.  She is real long off of the tee.  She is rock solid on the green.  Word is finally out there about her and I've worked hard at getting her name in front of college coaches.  After this showing (2nd) she has received 5 emails from 5 colleges this week.  Tonight, she shot par on our home course.  That is a great feat since our course was under water a week ago.  The fairways are not good and there is now a lot of standing water and GUR.  The next golfer was 5 shots behind and she is the #1 for a traditionally state ranked team.  Unfortunately, the rest of my team didn't do so well.  We play tomorrow again. It will be a major chore.  These mosquitoes are gigantic.  I have welts all over me and I sprayed a couple of times.  My #2 shot a 51 and looks like she has hives.  Her mosquito repellent can was  empty and I didn't know it until she was on hole #5.  She said that she was playing in a cloud of mosquitoes.  Tonight, I had my wife go buy new Deep Woods Off for every player.  We will put a can in each player's bag.  I've never seen anything like this but the corn fields around the course are all still under water.  Some Notes: My golfers have a hard time learning how to line up their shots.  We work on various things but it doesn't sink in for some time. My players have swings that are too long.  Most look like John Daley and so, I have to help them control that back swing better.  We spend a lot of time working on putting and we putted really well tonight.  The problem is, we didn't get off the tee box in good fashion due to alignment.  We have trouble everywhere and our course is very tight.  My softball player turned golfer as a favor to me will play as #4 tomorrow.  She has played golf for exactly 2 weeks now.  We have trees everywhere.  I have to teach all of my players how to hit stingers low and long.  I have three players that can do so and draw the ball doing it.  We shot a 205 as a team tonight.  That isn't very good.  Tomorrow, we have to do a lot better.  (We still beat a couple of teams since the conditions were so bad.  It was also 100+ heat index)
    • Yeah, the ex-marshal did go a bit overboard. Not sure if he would have really pulled the trigger or not, though. One thing for sure, the thief will think twice before attempting to steal club again. In fact, anyone reading the article might give it a second thought.   That's kind of true.
    • I apologize guys....heres the video
    • I just can't narrow it down to one or two items... Stihl MS 180 chainsaw - 12 years of heavy use and it simply won't die. Even dropped an ash tree on it years ago. I have a larger Stihl but prefer to use the little fella. It may be starting to lose compression. If so, I'll buy the same model as a replacement. Carvin solid body electric. Love this guitar. I also have a Guild Starfire IV Semi-hollow body electric which is a beautiful instrument. I play the Carvin a lot more. iMac (purchased in 2007). I'd love to get a new Mac Mini, but this thing is still running strong going on 10 years - even if 60 fps, 1080 video doesn't run very well on it. Firearms and reloading equipment. All of it. Have to get back into reloading. 2004 Silverado 1500. The Northern Winters have taken a toll on her. Stays parked a lot now but is still my all-time favorite vehicle.   
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

  • Blog Entries