or Connect
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Pro Shop › Clubs, Grips, Shafts, Fitting › Should I get new irons ?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Should I get new irons ?

post #1 of 15
Thread Starter 
First post so bear with me.

This will be my first full year of golf. I bought callaway diablo edge irons off the rack last year because they were cheap and I wasn't sure if I'd stick with it. Almost a year later I had a handful of lessons at golf galaxy and the PGA pro told me I have "out grown" my irons. I was thinking of getting the new x hots but I hit these diablo edges really well. I would like to get a set fitted to me, but I hit these irons I have pretty well and consistent. Do you guys think that I would hit something like the x hots even better if I get them fitted to me or is it not worth the money because I am hitting the ones I have now pretty well. Regardless my SS has jumped up to between 95-100 and the pro said I needed stiff shafts, I play uniflex now. Any suggestions?
post #2 of 15
I would entertain the idea of an upgrade fitted to your new swing. Bring your current irons with you and try a few on a monitor amd compare. Nothing to lose except time hitting a few clubs. I doubt anyone here would consider that wasted time.
post #3 of 15

You can just get the irons you have reshafted, would be significantly cheaper than buying a new set.

post #4 of 15

i think you should look into a wider range than Callaway. There's much more out there, and i think better also. Not to speak off the price.

post #5 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeremie Boop View Post

You can just get the irons you have reshafted, would be significantly cheaper than buying a new set.

 

not necessarily.  theres tons of great used sets out there that may fit you, and be better clubs than what youre playing now, and be barely used.  reshafting a whole set can be costly, you might be talking 9 clubs.

post #6 of 15

Best way to check this out would be to hit your Diablo Edge irons on a launch monitor, and compare to another model iron fitted with stiff shafts. A shop with a Callaway, TM or Mizuno fitting cart can put different shafts into the same head for comparison testing.

 

Uniflex is a medium-weight shaft with flex between regular and stiff, so for some of the "lighter" stiff shafts you might not notice too much difference.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeremie Boop View Post

You can just get the irons you have reshafted, would be significantly cheaper than buying a new set.

 

Sometimes reshafting is cheaper, other times it really isn't.

 

Let's say you have D.Edge 3-PW, a total of 8 irons. Cost estimate:

  • Shaft prep per club:{ Reshaft labor = $10 / Regrip labor = $4 + New grip = $6} = $20 a club
  • Cost of new shaft: TT S300 = $20 or Project X Pxi = $40

 

So....For eight irons...

  • TT S300: $160 prep + $160 worth of shafts = $320
  • PX Pxi: $160 prep + $320 worth of shafts = $480

 

Note also that salvage resale value for Uniflex pull-out shafts is pretty small.

post #7 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by colin007 View Post

 

not necessarily.  theres tons of great used sets out there that may fit you, and be better clubs than what youre playing now, and be barely used.  reshafting a whole set can be costly, you might be talking 9 clubs.

 

I'm comparing to a new set, as in not used. Reshafting, in my area, is 24-30 *stiff steel shaft* a club so even at 9 clubs that's 270. Which is cheaper than even most used sets of good irons, depending on how new the model is and the club maker.

post #8 of 15
Thread Starter 
I don't really want to get the irons I have now reshafted I don't really like their thickness at address and I'd rather buy a new set or just keep the ones I've got.

I am open to any and all brands but don't have massive amounts of cash. I usually get my clubs from global golf.com because they give 25% off to lefties for used clubs. 3/5 clubs I've ordered in "mint" have been brand new still in plastic. But I've read online that its tough to get a set custom fit for you after it's made? So I'd probably have to buy new?
post #9 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by smoothest485 View Post

I don't really want to get the irons I have now reshafted I don't really like their thickness at address and I'd rather buy a new set or just keep the ones I've got.

I am open to any and all brands but don't have massive amounts of cash. I usually get my clubs from global golf.com because they give 25% off to lefties for used clubs. 3/5 clubs I've ordered in "mint" have been brand new still in plastic. But I've read online that its tough to get a set custom fit for you after it's made? So I'd probably have to buy new?

So you are looking for something with a more classic profile then?

post #10 of 15
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeremie Boop View Post

So you are looking for something with a more classic profile then?

Yeah I would say. I really like how thin the AP1s and rocketbladez seem to be. Those diablos are ridiculously thick. The reason I lean towards he x hot is because I play these callaways I have now pretty well. They are a year old but again I want something custom fit to me and stiffer shafts. I just played a round with a guy fitted with x stiff irons and I was hitting the ball just as far as he is. Not saying I need x stiff but I think stiff would help my accuracy. I tend to fade the ball (left handed)
post #11 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by smoothest485 View Post


Yeah I would say. I really like how thin the AP1s and rocketbladez seem to be. Those diablos are ridiculously thick. The reason I lean towards he x hot is because I play these callaways I have now pretty well. They are a year old but again I want something custom fit to me and stiffer shafts. I just played a round with a guy fitted with x stiff irons and I was hitting the ball just as far as he is. Not saying I need x stiff but I think stiff would help my accuracy. I tend to fade the ball (left handed)

Thinner club heads are less game improvement, or at least a majority of the time they are. If you feel confident enough that you can move towards a less GI set then you'll get that look you want. My local driving range is also a golf shop and allows me to try out different clubs if I'm looking to buy. You should see if anyplace is near you that you can do that. Hitting off a mat into a net at the store, or even a simulator, won't give you enough real world feedback. You could look at muscle back irons, or even some old school ping eye2s if you can find them.

post #12 of 15
Thread Starter 
My teacher thinks I could hit the pro versions of both rocketbladez and x hots. I don't know if I'm ready for all that tho. Why make it harder than it already is I suppose. Again back to my buddy he uses forged razr x's and mine go just as far as his. What would the advantage be of a muscle back that I can't have cavity back?
post #13 of 15

Musclebacks should provide more distance on center hits than regular cavity backs while being more forgiving than a blade on off center strikes. They are basically a cross between a blade and cavity back. I had a set of musclebacks that I loved but they were stolen from my car years ago. Also that was back when I played a lot more and better than now. I had been playing some old titlest blades that were given to me and moving to those musclebacks improved my game a lot at that time.

post #14 of 15
Thread Starter 
I'm hitting the ball pretty dang far already I need a bit more accuracy. I will look into some and see what I can find out. Never considered something that advanced.

So y'all think I should get fitted with new clubs or keep playing with the ones I got off the rack? I don't want them reshafted
post #15 of 15

"If it ain't broke, don't try and fix it"

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Clubs, Grips, Shafts, Fitting
TheSandTrap.com › Golf Forum › The Pro Shop › Clubs, Grips, Shafts, Fitting › Should I get new irons ?