Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
Note: This thread is 5455 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Recommended Posts

Posted

"User reviews are pointless......"

Yup, so are opinions (including this one). But expressing one's opinion, and reading others is what these forums are about.

Your point?

In the Bag

Ping i15 8* Diamana Whiteboard

Titleist 909f3 13.5* Aldila NV

Ping S57 3-PW KBS C-taper

Macgregor 52, 56, and 60 wedges

SC Newport 2.5

 

Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

 


  • Administrator
Posted

To anyone who thinks that this thread is silly, just consider that this is a "user review" of "user reviews."

Originally Posted by wmiller

"User reviews are pointless......"

Yup, so are opinions (including this one). But expressing one's opinion, and reading others is what these forums are about.

Your point?



Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted


I think the point is well taken.  In general people who take the time to write "user reviews" are either very happy or very unhappy with the product. But while a "grain of salt" is advised when reading these "reviews" there can be useful information in them.   Maybe we can get Consumer Reports to do more golf equipment testing.  I believe they are about as unbiased as any source of consumer information but they don't do golf as a rule.

Originally Posted by Gerald

I see so many user reviews that are pointless about how perfect the "thing" is ......

If you are enthousiast about your new driver and you decide to write a user report, review or test ...... the outcome is very predictable :

Butch


Posted

Oh I agree, and I believe it to be commonly held that opinions are just that. I was just asking Gerald where he was going with this. :)

While I enjoy reading people's opinions about things, I would never buy something sight unseen, based upon an opinion from someone I don't know personally. I might however, put something on my 'list of things to try' based upon an review thread or article. I do the same thing with the ubiquitous 'swing tips' found in every golf magazine ever printed...  ;)

In the Bag

Ping i15 8* Diamana Whiteboard

Titleist 909f3 13.5* Aldila NV

Ping S57 3-PW KBS C-taper

Macgregor 52, 56, and 60 wedges

SC Newport 2.5

 

Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

 


Posted

OK I didn't meant to step on toes ..... which I am very good at (shoe size 16 with pain).

But some reviews are nothing more than "This is a great ball" or "Brand XYZ balls suck" ........

Besides that what is the worth of people reviewing any product, copying and pasting the marketing b#llsh$t into their review.

If a real hacker, that in no way ever hit backspin at a ball is reviewing a ABC lobwedge and say they had trouble stopping the ball from the deep rough and conclude that it makes no sense investing $135 for an added spinning wedge, what is the value of such a review (yep ..... got the picture ?!??).

Of course I  am interested in what a mid capper thinks of a G15 or K15 driver, because I can play as good as a single digit, but the next day as bad as a high capper ...... so if he really takes the time to write a decent review on what the driver does for him, I am very eager to read it, but not if only can read what Ping says about it.........

Cal Razr Hawk 10.5 | TM Superfast 3W | Adams Idea Pro Black 20 | MP-68 3-PW | TW9 50/06 + 58/12 | Ram Zebra Putter


Posted
In general, people don't do a good job of reviewing anything; it's not just golf. Part of it stems, I think, from the fact that too many people form emotional opinions about their products. * Have you read electronics reviews at, say, NewEgg? People will leave 1/2 ratings in every category if their first one is DOA, never bothering to update it after they get a working one next week. News flash: [i]Somebody[/i] has to get the malfunctioning units... * If someone likes something and doesn't know how to evaluate it on a detailed level, they are unlikely to find any faults with it and thus figure it deserves 5 stars. Or worse yet, maybe they used it once and had good results, and assumed it was the (in this case) club that deserved credit. Maybe just their first drive with it was very good. I think a lot of reviews are written in the excitement of returning from the first round or driving range trip with it. * If someone has a bad experience with something, they may rate it terribly even if it's caused by outside circumstances. There's a review of a course on here with a1/2 star rating in every category because the player was [i]treated badly by members of the course[/i]. In his mind, that justified a terrible rating of the fairways, greens, etc... * People will compare completely unrelated products. Try reading car reviews. Someone will review a $30K car, rate it poorly, call it "cheap feeling", and then reveal that all the other cars they tested were $60K cars. That's completely unhelpful for anyone not looking at $60K cars... So, bad opinions abound. Couple that with the fact that, to be honest, most clubs perform fairly similarly and usually it's only the good players can really tell a difference, and you get a lot of bizarre ratings. [quote name="Clambake" url="/forum/thread/46917/user-reviews-are-pointless#post_608104"]

Just yesterday I was looking at a club review here on Sand Trap and a user rated a particularly driver 5 stars, and in the comments indicates that they will be getting fit for one a few weeks after they posted their review.    A club review by someone who hasn't even played it yet - how useless!

[/quote] +1. I've seen that happen too many times. I read reviews for every club before I buy it and I've seen too many reviews end with "and I hope to get it next week!" Um... OK? :-O All that said, reading the content in reviews is where the real benefit comes from. I'm more interested in reading reviews that talk about performance than the actual stars given. If I'm researching a ball, I want to read 10 reviews that say it had good bite around the greens. If I'm researching clubs, I want to see 10 different people agree that, as high HCPers they were able to get good launch trajectories with it. Etc. [quote name="Elvisliveson" url="/forum/thread/46917/user-reviews-are-pointless#post_608133"]







But that's most likely due to the fact that there are always a few users who give the product only 1 or 2 stars with a review that goes like this:"I bought this driver and it looked really nice, except for that big sock that was on it. I took the sock off played a round. It hit the ball okay, but for some reason became all scratched up. When I wanted to return it, they told me all I could get was trade-in value...what a rip-off. *1/2."

[/quote] I think he was referring to the actual reviews, not the cumulative reviews.
  • Upvote 1

"Golf is an entire game built around making something that is naturally easy - putting a ball into a hole - as difficult as possible." - Scott Adams

Mid-priced ball reviews: Top Flight Gamer v2 | Bridgestone e5 ('10) | Titleist NXT Tour ('10) | Taylormade Burner TP LDP | Taylormade TP Black | Taylormade Burner Tour | Srixon Q-Star ('12)


Posted

User reviews are not pointless at all. You just need a lot of them to really learn anything.

If you were to fill a jar with 5342 jelly beans and then ask 5 people to guess how many were in there the average of their answers would be wayyyy off.

However ask 5000 people and the average of the answers will be quite close.

The thing about user reviews is that specific contents of them are rather useless.

Some dude telling you this driver gave him 30 extra yards even if true... his driver old driver could have been made in his basement out of paper mache and toothpaste.

User reviews if in high quantity will give you an Idea of weather the product is well made, If it performs up to expectations, and If the promises made about it by the company hold true in practice. The actual content of each single review however is though... useless.

nickent.gif4DX Evolver Driver, ping.gif Rapture 3 Wood, taylormade.gif Burner 08 5 Wood, nickent.gif 3DX RC 3-4 & 5DX 5 Hybrid,
nickent.gif 6-PW 3DX Hybrid Irons, cleveland.gif High Bore 09 GW-SW, touredge.gif 60* Wedge, maxfli.gif Revolution Blade Insert Putter
 
Yes I'm Aware That's 16 Clubs!

Posted


Quote:

Originally Posted by Elvisliveson View Post





But that's most likely due to the fact that there are always a few users who give the product only 1 or 2 stars with a review that goes like this:"I bought this driver and it looked really nice, except for that big sock that was on it. I took the sock off played a round. It hit the ball okay, but for some reason became all scratched up. When I wanted to return it, they told me all I could get was trade-in value...what a rip-off. *1/2."


Quote:

Originally posted by B-Con

I think he was referring to the actual reviews, not the cumulative reviews.



It was a joke, a joke! Is this Frankie Carbone from Goodfellas? Or maybe it's just Dr. Kiljoy.

My Tools of Ignorance:

Driver: Ping I20 9.5*
Woods/Hybrids: Cobra AMP 3W and 3 HY

Irons: Cobra AMP 4-GW

Wedges: Callaway Forged Copper 56* and 60*

Putters: Scotty Cameron  35" (Several of the flow neck blade variety)

Ball: Bridgestone B330-RX and Srixon Z-Star

Bag: Nike Performance Carry


Posted




It was a joke, a joke! Is this Frankie Carbone from Goodfellas? Or maybe it's just Dr. Kiljoy.





My wife calls me Dr. Killjoy, so that will suffice. :-) I got that it was a joke, I just... iacas's point... Neeever mind. :-)

"Golf is an entire game built around making something that is naturally easy - putting a ball into a hole - as difficult as possible." - Scott Adams

Mid-priced ball reviews: Top Flight Gamer v2 | Bridgestone e5 ('10) | Titleist NXT Tour ('10) | Taylormade Burner TP LDP | Taylormade TP Black | Taylormade Burner Tour | Srixon Q-Star ('12)


Posted

No toes stepped on Gerald, at least not mine!  :)

I agree with your viewpoint, I just thought you were adding some new wrinkle that I hadn't thought of. I take amateur reviews for what they are: someone talking about their personal experience with product XYZ, not as an endorsement. Too much about this game is subjective anyway.

  • Upvote 1

In the Bag

Ping i15 8* Diamana Whiteboard

Titleist 909f3 13.5* Aldila NV

Ping S57 3-PW KBS C-taper

Macgregor 52, 56, and 60 wedges

SC Newport 2.5

 

Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.

 


Note: This thread is 5455 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    Carl's Place
    PlayBetter
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Day 254 5-4 Arms off chest in backswing and downswing. Short swing, pause and then hit.  Hit foam balls. Keeping arching of wrist a focus as well. 
    • I would think of it in terms of time. The time it takes to get the arm angle into a good position to deliver the club with proper shaft lean. Another component is rotation, but that is also a matter of timing. It relates to how the body stalls to give the golfer time to hit the ball. If you have to get 80+ degrees out of that right elbow in one third of a second versus 50 degrees in the same time then you have to steal time from somewhere. It is usually body rotation. That does not help with shaft lean.  I agree in that amateurs tend to make the swing more complicated than pro golfers. 
    • I haven't been able to practice like I wanted and won't for the next week.  1. The weather sucks in Ohio this year. I have been mostly inside hitting foam balls. Just kind of my basic stuff.  2. I woke up last Saturday with a left side rib muscle on fire. If I turned or leaned a certain way it would spasm that almost buckled my knees. I have been taking a break to let that settle. I don't want to get a long term injury. I think I pinched a nerve or just aggravated a muscles.   3. I am going on a mini-vacation to Florida (screw you Ohio weather) with a friend, and rolling that into a work conference I have next week. I will be with out my clubs for a week.  I will be back next in two Fridays to hit the ground running with some warmer temps and better weather in Ohio, hopefully. I would really like to get more out on the course and the range.     
    • Day 580 - 2026-05-04 Played eight holes. Sometimes golf kicks you in the nuts. 😉 
    • I work with a lot of golfers who want more shaft lean at impact, who currently have AoAs that range from +2° to -2°, and who love to see the handle lower and more "in front of their trail thigh" from face-on at P6. And a lot of these golfers try to solve the issue by working on the downswing. They do something to drag the handle forward. Or they just leave their right thigh farther back so the same handle location "looks" farther forward. Or they move the ball back in their stance. Or they push themselves down into the ground to get the handle lower and increase (decrease?) their AoA (to be more negative). The real fix is often to get wider in the backswing. To do LESS in the backswing. To hinge less, fold the trail arm less, abduct the trail arm less. I had a case of this over the weekend. Before, the player had 110° of trail elbow bend, "lifted" his trail humerus only a few degrees, etc. The club traveled quite a bit around him, and he tended to "pick" the ball from the fairways. In the "after" swings below (which are mild exaggerations — this golfer does not need to end up at < 70° of elbow bend. These were slower backswings with "hit it as hard as you normally would" intent downswings), you can see that he bent his elbow about 70° instead of 110° and lifted his right arm an extra ~15° or more. You can't see how much less this moved his hands across his chest (right arm abduction), but it was also decreased. His hands stayed more "in front of" his right shoulder rather than traveling "beside" them so much. The two swings look like this: The change at P6, without talking about the downswing one little bit (outside of him telling me that he tends to pick the ball), is remarkable: Without 110° of elbow bend to get out (which he gets to 80°, a loss of 30°), the golfer actually loses slightly less elbow bend (70 - 50 = 20), but delivers 30° less elbow bend, lowering the handle and letting the elbow get "in front of" the rib cage… because it never got "behind" or "beside" the rib cage. If you look at this video showing the before/afters of P6, you'll note the handle location (both vertically and horizontally) and the shoulders (the ball is in the same place in these frames). This golfer's path was largely unaffected (still pretty straight into the ball, < 3° path and often < 1.5°), but his AoA jumped to -5° ± 2°. I've always said, and in talking with other instructors they agree and feel similarly, that we spend a lot of time working on the backswing. This is another example of why.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.