Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
carpediem4300

suddenly snap hooking/pulling?

32 posts in this topic

Right guys, bit of an odd one,

Swing background - always been a push slice/block swinger,.....mostly due to a flat swing way on the inside with flat shoulders and open face at impact,.......

after numerous lessons and watching videos of my swing (afraid i dont have one on my works computer i can shar) I have significantly changed my club path to being more upright and on plane, my shoulder angles are much much improved, clubface im not sure one if im honest

the result for the last 4-5 rounds has been much better contact, much straighter shots with the occasional snap hook off the tee with my driver,

ive been down the range the last few weeks as not been on course but now the hook as introduced itself to everyclub in my bag,...(im hitting off mats i dunno if that has any effect at all?)

So ive checked my grip and both hand "v's" point between my chin/shoulder, so ive sorta ruled that out,

i've noticed im hitting behind the ball quite alot also, so ive focused on turning within myself more to stop swaying off the ball as much and its helped but instead of a snap hook/hook its now a 40 yard straight draw,

the only thing ive found that lessens this shot shape is from the top of the backswing, i shift the weight forwards and feel like i whip my hands through and forget about the shoulders, although this makes it feel like im swinging really fast at the ball,.......and not knowing to much about the mechanics of the swing perhaps this is the correct feeling? all the instruction i read say to forget the hands and arms, let the torso/shoulder drag them through, i tried this to no avail really

any help dissecting this would be much appreciated (apologies for any spelling mistakes, im typing whilst in work so having to be quick as not to get busted!!!)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

Get a video up when you can. Someone could explain what a causes a snap hook, but giving you a tip wouldn't be good because its something you are going to have to work out yourself by changing the image on the video. Basically we have no clue what YOU are doing with out seeing it happen. So we can't give you good advice.

In general terms a snap hook is an extreme hook spin caused by a wide angle difference between the clubpath and clubface. Sounds to me that your new swing path hasn't changed your inside to out swing path much, and you are turning that very open clubface into a square clubface, probably to a slightly closed one. This would cause a snap hook.

Again post a video and you'll get some very smart people looking at your swing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Possibly, I know the inside out swing can cause it, but also the inside inside swing with a closed face also, ive booked a lesson for tonight but just wondered if anyone had experienced the same,

the hooks have only occured since changing swing path and shoulder plan as i said before i was way inside out and flat causing a block slice

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Possibly, I know the inside out swing can cause it, but also the inside inside swing with a closed face also, ive booked a lesson for tonight but just wondered if anyone had experienced the same,

the hooks have only occured since changing swing path and shoulder plan as i said before i was way inside out and flat causing a block slice

Well inside to out is just the direction of the club at impact. EVERY swing is on an arc, so at some point the clubhead has to go back in and up in the finish. It gets tricky with over the top moves. The clubhead usually goes in and up then loops and goes out and down to the ball, but still comes back to in and up in the finish. For a lets say a guy like Fowler who does the opposite. His clubhead still goes in and up, but on a much less severe path, then it goes more in and down, but still after the strike it goes in and up into the finish.

Hooks occur do to a wide degree of difference between face to path. Basically if your path is lets say +6 degrees to the right at impact, and your face is -1 degree closed, then you have a 7 degree change. That would not be good. You want to get that face to be about +4 degrees. That would be a good push draw.

Depends on yours swing path though. If you are very excessive from the inside, you probably want to get it less inside. Its REALLY tough to maintain a very open clubface. This is why I was kinda skeptical you were saying push slices. That is a very uncommon flight path. Most slicers are pull slicers. You might get what looks like a push slice, which might actually be a pure push block to the right.

Yea, try to get a video up.

Most likely if you are hitting snap hooks, its because your clubface is very closed to your inside swing path. Fixing it might not be as simple as opening the club face. Some swing faults can cause a closed face, like not getting your weight forward at impact. Yep, post a video. :-D

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

when I start hooking it ... I just slow it down & go back to the beginning.      Take slightly less than full power swings & really focus on the backswing tempo & I can always reel it back in & stop the hooks.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea, like @saevel25 said, get some video up for us to check out.

Here are a couple quick fix tips though:

1) You say you hit it better when you just focus on bringing your arms down and not turning your shoulders. Who knows if that's what you're actually doing (as feel isn't real) but if you are actually doing that, then I would keep using this feel. If the left shoulder gets too high, you can swing too much from the inside. You can also hit it fat with the divot starting slightly from the inside too.

2) Hooking the ball simply means the face is too closed relative to the path and sometimes the target. Since there's no video to work with, I can really only offer this basic suggestion, which is an easy quick fix: Cup (dorsiflex) your lead wrist more on your backswing to open the face up. You'll probably end up fighting pushes instead of hooks by doing this... but in my experience, it's easier to score fighting a push than it is fighting a hook.

But yea, get swing vids. I'm grasping at straws here. :-D

when I start hooking it ... I just slow it down & go back to the beginning.

True.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

i tried slowing down, a big problem of miine is trying to leather it, but the slower i go the more i hook,...weird lol

will try to get a video up, not sure how to do it from iphone as cant get video on works computer

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you don't have a stable shoulder, you could be putting much tension on your wrists, so they might not work as you need.

At address flip the club around, toe down, because its easy to track, and trace a nice circle to your right shoulder, your right arm folds nicely to your body,

giving a great support, and easy tension on your wrists.

This video at 7.00 shows this.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well had my lesson and the pro thinks im getting quick in the transition and not clearing my body properly and im flipping at impact to compensate The problem is when i try to slow the transition down i just slow everything down so i have the same problem and still hook But the harder i turn the better the contact and leas hookey more draw or slight fade, problem with the though is my long clubs are slicing when i do that which isnt ideal
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well had my lesson and the pro thinks im getting quick in the transition and not clearing my body properly and im flipping at impact to compensate

The problem is when i try to slow the transition down i just slow everything down so i have the same problem and still hook

But the harder i turn the better the contact and leas hookey more draw or slight fade, problem with the though is my long clubs are slicing when i do that which isnt ideal

Thinks, or does he know? Just asking. Did he just stand there and look at your swing and go, "I think its this?" I can say its very hard to discern much from a swing just form the naked eye.

Try to get a video posted and get some feedback from some of us on the site here.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

He looked at my swing for a number of shots, could see my grip was fine, plane was fine, but noticed my transition was quick and i was getting stuck and flipping at the ball My problem is the swing and release has never felt natural to me its always felt manipulated in some way probably because of previous swing faults Just need to find a tempo that works so he reckons Ill try and post a video
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This link should take you to a video http://s855.photobucket.com/user/jamesr4300/media/32171982-EC01-4628-B3C7-DF32D02DE3F7_zpstrcm3dqg.mp4.html
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I find that since I change from overlap/ten fingered to interlock I dont snap hook as much.

It seems to limit my hands from turning too quickly. I can still hook the ball with interlock but its more controlled, if anything I can get more of a pull hook sometimes duck hook  rather than a snap hook .

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This link should take you to a video

http://s855.photobucket.com/user/jamesr4300/media/32171982-EC01-4628-B3C7-DF32D02DE3F7_zpstrcm3dqg.mp4.html

Please create your own thread there with the title being "My Swing (carpediem4300)"

http://thesandtrap.com/f/4180/member-swings

You'll get more responses about your swing if you create your own swing thread.

Also get off photobucket. I can't get a video to embed from there. So It makes it a pain to view the video on another website. Youtube works better, then you can just copy and paste the youtube video link into the embed video feature the forum has. Its the little icon next to the emoticon icon.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Youtube Embedding Another thread To be honest its to much hassle
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Youtube

Embedding

Another thread

To be honest its to much hassle

Sorry if I seem like I am being picky, yet there is a section on this forum dedicated for swings. One it keeps the forum clean, and it also allows you as a member here to keep tabs of your swing. It is a great resource for you as well. Look at it as a golf swing diary, were you can see your progress and look up old things that might start to creep back into your swing. Now lets say you didn't have your own swing thread, you would have to search for every thread you created to try to find the post you want. Just saying, it benefits both you and the forum to create your own swing thread.

Also, embedding the video is a courtesy towards those of us who want to view and review your swing. I tried to embedded the video from photobucket but it wont do it. You can use Youtube or any other service that allows you to embedded the video. Or you could just post the link and hopefully people wont be bothered by having to switch between two screens while they write up a critique on the swing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Lol wasnt suggesting you were, merely pointing out its a lot of hassle Especiallybeing an iphone only user its alot harder but i guess thats my issue not your guys
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Lol wasnt suggesting you were, merely pointing out its a lot of hassle

Especiallybeing an iphone only user its alot harder but i guess thats my issue not your guys

Ah, yea, cell phones would make it annoying. Though you might want to PM @iacas . He is the MAC guru when it comes to this forum :-D

I do not use the so called iphone. :whistle:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • Driver does seem inadequate since it's got a big head on it but a 3 iron for those who carry would do just fine I imagine. Better yet, just get a cattle prod. It can fit in the bag and doesn't count against you as a club. A lil ol zap to the zipper fly area ought to adjust a persons attitude right quick. 
    • Where is the hole in your game?  Do you struggle close to the green?  Then look at lob wedge.  If you find yourself always needing a 200 yard club then go for a wood or driving iron. I would suggest since you already mentioned you don't hit your hybrid so well replacing it as well.  I don't hit hybrids myself, but there are many different types of hybrids from fat sole driving irons to short shaft woods.  A true hybrid will go a lot farther than an iron of the same loft making a 5 hybrid get into you 3 iron range.  If you go this route I would suggest a 2 and 4 hybrid to cover the gap between driver and irons. My personal preference is toward big fairway woods.  Most people will carry at least a 3 wood.  Lots of pros are using a strong 3 wood, whether it is called a 2 wood, 3+, or mini driver, these guys are using 11 to 14 degree woods with lots of club head speed to get 300 yards out of their fairway wood.  But with slower swings that most amateurs have they should be using a 12 to 14 degree driver meaning they should be using more loft on their fairway wood as well.  To go this route you might want to look at a 4 wood and 7 wood setup.  A 7 wood should be around the same yardage as a 3 hybrid. One last suggestion.  Find a 2nd hand store and look at some older model clubs.  You might just run across a 1 iron for less than $10.  For that price you could grab a hand full of long irons, hybrids, and woods that you can then hit the driving range and find what works for you.  
    • So IMO, if there are easier options to hit that can produce similar results, why play blades?  I had a set of Titleist 710 Cavity Backs and sold them for blades. Simply because they looked cool, and "all good golfers play blades". Well, I wasnt as good a ball striker that I thought I was. I now play AP2's and my handicap is as low as its ever been. For guys like Jordan Spieth and Luke Donald in your example, if they hit it pure most of the time, why risk that 1% where you dont pure it and the blade iron leaves you 15 yards short of your target and in a creek/hazard.  The technology in irons today is incredible for hitting high shots while still being able to work the ball plenty. Im not knocking anyone who plays blades, because that is impressive. It all comes down to preference.
    • KFC fried chicken scented sunscreen.   
    • Exactly, it comes up a lot in some of those "senior" golf tip sections on TV and in Magazines. We don't have those twist-o-flex spines anymore like we did in our 20's, so a little head start helps. But I think ANYONE can use it to help rotation. We may THINK we get around a lot, but sadly if you saw yourself on video... not so much. Then I wouldn't do it with the long irons. :^)  But seriously, folks... I run into this as well and it's my hands... I will tend to flip and steer the club trying to get the perfect ball flight. Hands get ahead and it's pulled or hooked. REALLY trying to keep my head behind the ball and WATCH the club hit the ball helps a bit, though. Good Luck.
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. Jason141
      Jason141
      (27 years old)
    2. ngreed86
      ngreed86
      (30 years old)
  • Blog Entries