This is the ridiculously difficult pitch/chip that Natalie and the other girls had to hit at Baltusrol. As you can see from the third shot, you had to fly the ball about eight feet just barely over the rough, and then it would roll 30-35 feet to the hole, downhill the whole way. @NatalieB would have beaten a good percentage of PGA Tour players if they had to hit this shot cold.
I'm torn because overall I agree with Erik's reasoning in his first post but I've played a lot of different courses these last two years where the greens weren't in great condition.
The combination of the poorly maintained greens and current hole size made making a putt longer than 6' more about luck than skill. On those types of courses I think a 5" hole might make it more fair.