Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
evinkc05

whats a good handicap?

231 posts in this topic

I am curious as to what handicap is considered a good handicap, as I have heard 10 handicappers call themselves duffers or hackers, so Im just interested in people's opinions as to where that line is that a golfer becomes "good" in your eyes. Thanks.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Want to get rid of this advertisement? Sign up (or log in) today! It's free!

If you compare a player with hcp 10 and one with 20. The 10 is not twice as good as the 20 hcp'r, he's better.
And the lower handicap you get, you realize how hard it is to get a lower score.

So, the 20 hcp'r thinks that someone with 10 is a good golfer, and the golfer with 10 thinks that someone with 5 is a good golfer and so on. This automatically always puts yourself in the hacker/duffer slot.

My opinion on a good golfer is a scratch player.
1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think anyone below 18 is good in general standard. I think from research there are more than 70% of golf population who can't break 100 in their life time if I remember correctly. Only a minor % of the population are single handicaps. (I think it was less than 10% of the world golf population)

Handicap 18 vs handicap 0 is usually one putt difference or one club shot difference in 18 hole round so basically you won't be delayed or annoyed with someone at handicap 18 even if you play single handicap.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd say a good golfer is anyone who can hit to an 18 hdcp. Bogey golf is good. A scratch golfer wouldn't be considered "good" in my opinion, they are at another level altogether.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree - if you can average out bogey golf you are a decent player.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll agree with the others and say if you're a bogey or better golfer, then that's at least a 'decent' handicap (usually around 18 or so). That usually means you're hitting a lot of good shots and can play at a decent pace on almost all courses. As for a 'good' handicap, I would think somewhere around 12/13 or lower because that means you're making several pars, occasional birdies and a few bogeys or blowup holes (we all have them).

But it's all relative. On most courses if someone can consistently shoot under 100 I don't think they are a bad player. If they consistently shoot in 90's I think they are 'decent'. In 80's I consider them good. 70's and under I consider to be 'very good/great'.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dunno..I tend to think im a good player. But i watch tour guys, or the + handicaps i see at some of the ametuer tournments i play in and just think im a wannabe hack.. I guess its all reletive as others have said.

Forgetting about the handicap - if youre confident enough in your own game to play for money or challenge someone to a match then it means youre probaly a decent player. Thats the general barometer i use.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At the moment 27 would good for me personally,but my goal is to play bogey golf I certainly think that that's attainable,and I would consider that good golf,as you would need to be skilled in all areas of the game to shoot 90 as an average.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Good" is relative.

A tour pro doesn't consider me to be a very good golfer. A 18 handicap does......and a 30 handicap likely considers a bogey golfer pretty darn good.

The neat thing about this game is that we can either play against ourselves, the course, or others of similar abilities........and that's all good !
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

I dunno..I tend to think im a good player. But i watch tour guys, or the + handicaps i see at some of the ametuer tournments i play in and

Boy howdy, isn't that the truth?! Until you've played with some guys that carry + handicaps, you just don't realize what that means! Very humbling.....and will make you re-evaluate what it really means to be "good"!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

My opinion would be that your index would need to be in the upper half of the average to be "good".

The one misleading part about all those stats is that it only includes golfers that have an established handicap; it doesn't include people that play but don't submit scores or simply don't play enough ot establish a handicap.

As for the main subject, I think that a "good" golfer is between a 10-15 handicap. That being said, I think being "good" has just as much to do with consistancy; I'd consider a consistant 15 to be better than an erratic 10. A "great" golfer is someone in the low-to-mid single digits (ie. 3-6). Anyone below that needs to get back to work.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my opinion:
me= hacker
if you shoot in the low 90's=pretty good
mid-low 80's= good
70's= very good
scratch= great.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am curious as to what handicap is considered a good handicap, as I have heard 10 handicappers call themselves duffers or hackers, so Im just interested in people's opinions as to where that line is that a golfer becomes "good" in your eyes. Thanks.

Most people will say that "single digits" is very good, and between scratch and 4 is excellent. In many State tournaments, you must have a handicap of 2 or less just to enter.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good to me is just better than I am, so it's relative. However, I think the golfing community as a whole feels like single digits is a really big milestone. If you do that, I would say you're considered good by the vast majority of players.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Reportedly 90% of golfers can't break 100 on a regular basis (playing by the rules), so if anyone reaches an honest single digit handicap they must be pretty darn good in the big picture. That probably takes into account millions of people play a few times a year and seldom, if ever, practice.

I have played with many golfers who lose balls, hit OB and drop another ball incorrectly, swing and miss, give themselves 4 ft. putts and so on, and then think they shot an 85 because their egos won't let them be honest about it. I played with a guy once who thought he "played pretty good". I kept track and he lost more than 15 balls. The first time I played with him he said he had shot a 50 on the front 9. I had counted every penalty he was due and every missed putt and he actually had something over a 70 on the front nine.

As for a "good handicap", the best measure is how good do you need to be to enjoy the game. To me that number is around 10-11. When I got down to a 10 or so, I had some control over my swing and occasionally shot in the low 80s, or maybe now and then a 78 or 79.


SubPar
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think anyone under a 6 or 7 handicap is good. Anyone can play golf on and off for a couple years and manage to become a 10. It takes alot of effort to get down to a 7, and anyone who has achieved that goal should be considered good.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A "great" golfer is someone in the low-to-mid single digits (ie. 3-6).

Haha...

One of my favorite things to ask playing partners and competitors after a good shot is "don't you work anymore?" As to the OP, I have to only slightly disagree with others that 18 is a "good" handicap. I see 18 as a reasonable golf for the serious, athletically inclined golfer. I would judge "good" to be better than that, a 15 and lower, say. That said, I'll be happy if I can reach and maintain an 18 in my lifetime.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • 2016 TST Partners

    GAME Golf
    PING Golf
    Lowest Score Wins
  • Posts

    • A buddy of mine got a chance to play Oakmont quite a few years ago. I had been there for a couple of Opens, and told him to spend a substantial amount of time on and around the practice green chipping and putting, since neither he nor I had ever played on greens like those. He called me when he got home and thanked me for the advice. He claimed to have had only two 3 putt greens when he left his approach too far from the hole. As far as "better" courses having nicer greens, I guess it's where you are and what kind of players you have. There's a local course called Kennsington that I absolutely love! The greens are huge, undulating, and quite fast. However, it's a public, daily fee course. I could spend all day fixing ball marks! I do what I can without holding up play. I appreciate Pretzel's comment about the course that hires someone to go around and do nothing but fix ball marks. Sounds like a great job for a motivated kid. Teach him how, give him or her a repair tool, cart, and turn them loose. However, I am reminded of the quote from the 18th and 19th Century German writer and poet Johann Wolfgang von Goethe who wrote, "Let every man sweep in front of his own door, and the whole world will be clean!"
    • I still like this method.  It feels like I using my bottom hand as a "forehand" to the chip toward the apex and let the ball break downhill to the hole . Great for downhill chips  I look at the top back corner edge of the ball to chip the ball that kicks right and look at the leading edge of the wedge rather than the ball if I want to kick left  I find I can also shut and lay open the wedge face with the same hand and make it easy to hit out of the sand with similar rhythm 
    • Placed a coaster on the carpet, and hit putts from five feet away until I hit the coaster 50 times. The few times I missed were to the right.
    • That's awesome - good stuff!  You must have been doing a little "scoreboard-checking" after that 30...no matter how hard you tried not to!
    • Tough practice session today.  It's hot out there (even at 8pm), and I'm tired from 36 holes of golf this weekend in 90-degree heat...and probably about 36 beers (not while golfing, but still). I'm sticking with the same practice template.  First half of the session focuses on backswing and downswing path; second half focuses on clubface control.  Every swing is on video and reviewed. I was a bad "stupid monkey" for about 5 swings at the beginning...I was thinking about the "short-arm" stuff above, and trying to work on it.  Based on the slow-mo video, I was actually able to get one REALLY good inline impact with the 6-iron by DRIVING my hands forward...but I made terribly fat contact.  After that swing I made myself stop and put it completely out of my head.  I didn't even take any more face-on video.  F-O-C-U-S is key right now. After that brief distraction, my swing path and backswing work went OK...I was getting a bit lazy on the backswing and not completing my turn on some swings, but I'm doing better at hitting my downswing positions.  Contact and ball flight with the irons is really good right now (relative to my skill level).  I was hitting mostly my "on-course" pushes, moving towards push-fades with the longer clubs, but with overall very solid contact and height.     I think my A4 is pretty good on this swing...full shoulder turn and good hip turn (not sure about hand/arm position, but that's not part of what I'm working on right now):   Club is in-line with the hands at A6 (that's good):   Impact (not checking anything here yet, but including for completeness).  I can tell I'm still "short-arming" it at impact, but I'm not worried about that yet:   Game Golf tag basically visible at A8 (that's good):   I'm also finally hitting my target positions with my driver, which represents progress.  Contact was pretty bad tonight (quite a few heel and toe strikes), so I just slowed it down to 75% with the driver and focused on path.  Hit some decent 200-yard baby-fades with that swing (also a bunch of my "on-course" pushes).   A4 here felt a bit abbreviated, but it looks OK on the video (feel was probably because it was not a full-speed swing):   Club is in-line with the hands at A6 (took me a damn month to be able to do this with the driver, but...it's getting more and more consistent):   Impact for completeness:   Good A8 here for the driver (again, I say "really good" only in terms of the swing path I've been working towards):   Overall, I think it was a good night of work on swing path, considering how I was feeling.   As for the clubface control drill: I really need to find a way to put something downrange (or start going to a different range to work on that piece).  Without a visual reference, the open/closed clubface positions are way too exaggerated.  I'm probably still working on the skill (the "twist"), but not as productively as I could be.  This might be the piece that prompts me to buy a small net for the backyard.   Summary / Next Steps I'm hoping to get one more practice session in this week before my trip to work with @iacas on Saturday.  Based on my slow progress to date, unless that session is some sort of cosmic breakthrough, I don't think I'm going to be ready to add any more drills or pieces to work on yet.  If I tried to add another swing thought on either the backswing or downswing, I'm pretty sure it'd mess up one of my current priorities.  Especially since I've only cracked the surface of the clubface control drill. We'll see.  I suppose if I were to focus on getting into a better position at A4, I could work that into the backswing drills I've been doing...or something similar.  
  • TST Blog Entries

  • Images

  • Today's Birthdays

    1. chriswuk
      chriswuk
      (25 years old)
    2. Gero
      Gero
      (73 years old)
    3. SUPGolfer
      SUPGolfer
      (46 years old)
  • Blog Entries