Not even close....
Ping Redwood >>> Scotty Cameron
TheSandTrap.com Top Picks
I would agree whole heartly, I have a Circa 62 #3 and a Redwood Anser, they are so similar not sure I could close my eyes, putt with them and tell the difference. As a matter of fact last summer I was switching back and forth between them, during our league play one week I had an 11 putt 9 with one of the putters and the next week a 12 putt 9.
I even took them to a club fitter and had them checked for loft and lie, they were identical, 4* loft, 71* lie.
The Scotty I owned was a pro platinum. The thing that really put me over the edge was the weight. There is nothing wrong with the Scotty, I was in love with the thing until I picked up the Redwood for the first time. It just feels so smooth with my stroke.