Which American player will win more majors in his career?

[sean_miller]

Before all is said and done, which of the American players listed here will win the most Major Championships?

Followup question: Will all of their resumes added together surpass that of Tiger Woods - simple yes or no answer.

[deasy55]

No

[Kieran123]

Yes.

[sean_miller]

I'm leaning toward No, but this poll will expire long before all the results are in!

[Zwick]

Not even close

Peter Uihlein will win the most (2)

[jamo]

No, not even close. There are no more than a handful of guys on that list I see even winning one major.

[cdnglf]

Isn't the obvious answer "Other" (Phil Mickelson)?

I doubt any of these guys will win 4+.

[iacas]

Originally Posted by cdnglf

Isn't the obvious answer "Other" (Phil Mickelson)?

I doubt any of these guys will win 4+.

If that was the case, you'd just say "Tiger" (if you wanted to limit it to semi-active players) or "Jack"...

[shades9323]

No, they won't even come close to Tiger.

[Long Ball Larry]

Given his two close calls last year, I have to go with Dustin Johnson. I'd love to see him or Watney close one out. I don't see the group even coming close to Tiger either.

[newtogolf]

Of the guys on the list, Dustin Johnson and Nick Watney will likely be the most popular choices, but I think Keegan Bradley has a chance to be great.  He has a good swing, seems to handle pressure, and has the family support structure to do very well.

[bplewis24]

Looks like nobody is considering AK anymore.  My vote was down to AK, DJ and Watney.  Went with DJ.  He has the ability but may not have the intelligence and mental toughness to put it together every major.  But those things apply to Phil, IMO, and he has won 4.

Brandon

[sean_miller]

Originally Posted by newtogolf

Of the guys on the list, Dustin Johnson and Nick Watney will likely be the most popular choices, but I think Keegan Bradley has a chance to be great.  He has a good swing, seems to handle pressure, and has the family support structure to do very well.

So far you're in the lead.

[makaveli]

No love for Kuchar? He is better than most of the American players up there imho

[Bo the Golfer]

No, they will not come close to Tiger!

[jclifton]

I personally think Keegan Bradley is going to win more majors than anyone on the poll list. He hits it long, plays smart golf, and performs well under pressure. Two wins in his PGA rookie season, including a major!

His play at the PGA Championship proved himself to me. When Keegan and Jason Dufner were in the playoff, specifically. Third hole of playoff, #18, 200 yards over the water for an approach shot for Keegan. I figured he would lay up, make par, and still win. Instead he does not back down and made a hell of a shot to about 17 feet. Dufner had no choice but to go for the green, over the water at around 200 yards then.

It will be an interesting next few years to see what develops in the majors.

[xxsoultonesxx]

Originally Posted by jclifton

I personally think Keegan Bradley is going to win more majors than anyone on the poll list. He hits it long, plays smart golf, and performs well under pressure. Two wins in his PGA rookie season, including a major!

His play at the PGA Championship proved himself to me. When Keegan and Jason Dufner were in the playoff, specifically. Third hole of playoff, #18, 200 yards over the water for an approach shot for Keegan. I figured he would lay up, make par, and still win. Instead he does not back down and made a hell of a shot to about 17 feet. Dufner had no choice but to go for the green, over the water at around 200 yards then.

It will be an interesting next few years to see what develops in the majors.

That was so awesome! I think he had brass balls for playing it like that.

Still voted for Nick Watney.

No.

[Deryck Griffith]

Dustin Johnson was my pick out of the guys on that list and no way Dustin, or anyone else on that list, will come CLOSE to Tiger.

14 Majors, 71 wins?  Hmm....good luck.