Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
  • entries
    57
  • comments
    772
  • views
    55,777

Small Things, Big Differences


Earlier today I fit a college player and a reasonably good putter with an Edel putter. His putter was a typical blade - the old PING/Cameron/Everyone-Has-a-Version classic blade putter with some heel/toe weighting.

He could aim his putter, from about ten feet (bear in mind that the laser reflects back over the same ten feet, doubling the error), to about four inches outside the right edge of the cup. Not great, but not as bad as we've seen from many. His putter had a single, solitary thin line on the top part of the putter.

What was his best fit putter? It was an almost identical Edel putter: the Umpqua head with no lines or dots at all. In fact, when I gave him just a dot - I like to give some players a bit more help to center the ball up beside just the heel/toe weighting - he aimed it about an inch right of the cup. Trying something, I drew a line on the putter. Bam! Back out to a cup right. Take the line away? Center of the cup every time.

Sometimes the tiniest of things makes a fairly big difference. Where it pulled his focus and attention, I don't know, but it resulted in some pretty big changes. Just a little dot.

P.S. His putter was also pretty badly weighted for him, too, or else I'd have recommended he find some way to make that putter work and save the cost of the Edel putter.

9 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • Moderator
mvmac

Posted

Yeah that's pretty amazing. Good for everyone to know, don't buy the hype that whatever new putter that comes out with different lines, colors, shapes will help you aim better than others. Depends on how it fits your eyes.

Makes me laugh at myself for how crazy I was to when I was younger. Going from mallets, to blades, different hosel configurations, etc.

Golfingdad

Posted

I had a very similar experience.  Ping Pal with one line on top aimed several inches right from 8' out and I ended up with a similar shaped head with no aiming lines.  I am sooooo confident in hitting my lines from 8' and in too. :)

colin007

Posted

for me, i think the hosel made the biggest difference.

 

and i would be one of the ones that @iacas would be referring to with my previous aiming....from about 12 feet i was easily 2 feet right and 2 feet in the air....omg....

Pete F

Posted

Interesting, I have a number of putters. From Pings to Odesseys all blades. The one I like best is a Spalding TP Mills 5 with a single dot.

  • Administrator
iacas

Posted

Interesting, I have a number of putters. From Pings to Odesseys all blades. The one I like best is a Spalding TP Mills 5 with a single dot.

You might aim that the best. You might also aim it like crap.

The point wasn't that there was a dot or wasn't a dot… just that the smallest little thing can have a pretty big affect on the ability to aim a putter.

Oh, and I'm not saying you were disagreeing or saying anything contrary, @Pete F. Please don't take it that way. You should check yourself with a laser to see how you do.

rkim291968

Posted

Along the same line, I taped an inch long white line on top/center of my driver's clubhead.    The driver's center mark wasn't visible at all - a small dark Taylormade sign on equally dark clubhead color.   With the clearly visible line, I "feel" I am hitting my drive more on center.

rusty35

Posted

dumb question...how does one go about checking putter alignment with a laser?

Zeph

Posted (edited)

Very good example. Would be interesting to see how his aim held up some weeks or months down the line. This is a tiny detail on the club we swing the slowest. I wonder how small changes can affect the full swings with the other clubs.

Edel has spread more in Europe the last years, hope they come to Norway one day. If I buy a new putter sometime, I'd really want to try an Edel fitting.

Edited by Zeph
  • Administrator
iacas

Posted

Very good example. Would be interesting to see how his aim held up some weeks or months down the line.

If our past experience with Edel is any indication, it'll still be true in years and even longer. We've almost told people that unless they suffer a major vision or brain injury or something like that, the way they see shapes and stuff is about the way they'll always see things.

I wonder how small changes can affect the full swings with the other clubs.

Yeah, it makes a good point. Unfortunately, there's not a LOT we can do with alignment aids on things like your 7-iron.

Edel has spread more in Europe the last years, hope they come to Norway one day. If I buy a new putter sometime, I'd really want to try an Edel fitting.

I recommend it. If nothing else, you'll see what kind of shape you aim best.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • Blog Entries

  • Posts

    • I had a free Titleist ball fitting yesterday at the facility where I practice. It was done outside off grass hitting Pro V1 RCT balls into a net with Trackman behind capturing data. Apparently for more advanced fittings I would hit the different balls but for this free type fitting everything is referenced off the Pro V1. Tech said characteristics of Pro V1 are well known and relationships to other balls are predictable and generally accurate.  It consisted of hitting a handful of shots with different clubs beginning with 60-yard SW and working up through driver, skipping a couple clubs between, for example PW to 7i. I had used the online tool, and it had suggested Pro V1 was the best ball, this algorithm was recommending the same until I got to driver. When we did get to driver, I commented to the tech person that it was one of the clubs I did not know how to hit yet, to which they said not a problem. However, based on how I hit the driver the recommendation flipped from Pro V1 to Pro V1x, which I sort of have an issue with. That being the whole concept of getting fitted for a swing I know is flawed and I am actively working on improving. Specifically, that my angle of attack with the driver can be -3 to -5 down according to my R10. The Trackman had me at -3.5 down, combined with 2500 RPM spin and the algorithm wanted to get me into a more spinney ball than the Pro V1 to help with apex height. I found it terribly disconcerting hitting into a net with not much feedback or transparency as to what the results were. Which could be fair as the information they did share wasn't in a form I am familiar with. The dispersion charts were about spin, apex, and landing angle and not distance and direction. Maybe I should have been more active in requesting feedback. The final outcome was that either the V1 or the V1x would be a fit and it would come down to if I had a preference based on shots around the green or some other specific area where one seemed clearly better. Overall, I am ambivalent to the experience. I was excited when the tech said they would email me all this information so I could review it and waved their hand at the tablet. However, all they emailed me was a page saying Pro V1x was the recommended ball with a link to buy some for $68/dozen. Excitement turned to disappointment. There was a good bit of interest in the fitting though, three people wanting to get involved came up to the tent while I was there. I would be hesitant to do any fittings again until I felt I had a more stable and viable swing. Which is another whole story I suppose.
    • Day 317 7-18 Keeping arm wide in down swing. I also spent quite a bit of time with arching, trail arm rotation. Today was a good practice. Foam balls. 
    • Day 654 - 2026-07-18 Played around with the Arm Shark a bit today. Mostly played 21 (a putting game) against some of the kids I coach.
    • Day 22: played 18. Average to below average - +8; 80. Tee shots good and approach play solid. Short game and putting not so good. Did make my first eagle of the year though - driver, 3 wood from 260, caused a 20 footer. 
    • Ernest Jones!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! As someone who doesn't play golf tournaments, links golf or any courses with tall grass, I want to thank Bryson for showing me what not to do in that situation. I was genuinely clueless about this kind of thing. I definitely would've known not to clear a path for my backswing, but it's still a nice way for me to very, very quickly learn what not to do if I ever find myself in tall grass.  Also I was kinda bored by the tournament, and this spiced it up a bit for me. Hoping Sam Burns can close this out tomorrow and get his major.  Edit: Some funny tweets  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.