The Stack and Tilt Golf Swing

[uttexas]

Thought this was the best place to post this question.
Charlie Wi was striking the ball so well this weekend. It appears that his head moves forward and slightly down during the backswing--I'm guessing due to a lot of side tilting. This is clearly OK, considering his results. Is this something I should try and copy?--or should I try to keep my head "stacked" over the ball on the backswing?

[Joeyvee]

I spent a lot of time reading this thread. ONE guy gave simple instructions to a simple swing improvement and I tried to implement it last night. 55/45 weight distribution, Drop left shoulder to start swing, straighten leg, bump hips, accelerate hands. It was EASY to after a few.
I wont go on and on about my results because it was one bucket at one range on one day. Who knows. I could have swung the club with my feet and had a good night. Consistency is NON existent. I will tell you I had a TON of fun though.
But what I will do is this. These are my last 6 rounds with my score. Ill update if my game improves due to SnT. Im playing a TouGH course tomorrow so we'll see. Avg. putts a round are 34




06/24/10
Coral Creek
28.1
102

06/18/10
Hawaii Country Club
28.3
94

06/12/10
Hawaii Prince
30.5
108

06/09/10
Olomana
25.1
99

01/21/10
Koele
27.8
110

08/07/09
Hawaii Kai Executive
23.3
95

07/15/09
Olomana
36.5
112

[mdbuschsr]

Went to the range tonight. Let's just say I have some work to do on this pattern. Practice swings in the back yard are completely different than when I have the stupid little white ball in front of me. I love this sport!!!

[MMouse]

Ive lost what progress I've made with the swing recently. Sure I have my good shots, but they are becoming fewer and fewer.
It feels to me ( i need to take some video ) like I am losing things at the beginning of the downswing. Right now it feels awkward and from there by the time I get to impact I am all over the place.

What "feel" or action are you guys using to start the downswing?

[Weezy]

For me i like sean foleys swing theory, which is basically don't shift to your right side but don't tilt and straighten the right leg either. Just stay 55 45 and shift it all forward on the downswing rather than loading on the backswing.

[nuck81]

I don't know who this dude is, but I thought he had a real nice swing. I noticed a few things he was doing with the aspects I'm struggling with and I'm anxious to try it out...

[JRH11]

Believe it or not...S&T putting is good!!!...We have been told for years to keep the weight on the front foot and move the shoulders....pure S&T.;

Great points! When Tom watson was the best putter on the planet, he was noticeably putting the weight on his left side and keeping it there.

[Joeyvee]

I've never compressed a ball until I started doing this. My bad tendency is to lean back and thats when a slice creeps in. Otherwise I've been push-drawing. Starting straight draing left. I need to open the face a little more and I'll be ok. I also started taking a more athletic stance and less weight on my heels and more on my toes and I get A LOT more power. Again its a 55/45 thing. Not 90% on toes. Just a touch more than normal.. I stopped locking out my rear knee and feel a lot better as well too

[melchior]

So I finally made it out to the range to really get the ball flight to where it should be (push-draw). I can push it relatively consistantly (aiming about 10 yards right on most irons; obviously more the longer the club) but I can't draw it back at all. Should I try to in-to-out more, so that the clubface is more closed to the swing path? It feels like I'm really coming from behind my hip when I swing that far in to out (was a very constant out to in swing before I switched).

[mvmac]

So I finally made it out to the range to really get the ball flight to where it should be (push-draw). I can push it relatively consistantly (aiming about 10 yards right on most irons; obviously more the longer the club) but I can't draw it back at all. Should I try to in-to-out more, so that the clubface is more closed to the swing path? It feels like I'm really coming from behind my hip when I swing that far in to out (was a very constant out to in swing before I switched).

Try to feel like your right hip is at the ball at impact. Also make sure the right leg stays straight on the down swing. This will help get the path more towards first base with the weight going left.

[iacas]

Try to feel like your right hip is at the ball at impact. Also make sure the right leg stays straight on the down swing. This will help get the path more towards first base with the weight going left.

And what Michael means by that is that your right hip is FORWARD by sliding more at the ball at impact, not that it's spun to get there.

Your hand path is the second place I'd look - it may not be deep enough at P2-P4. Or still in at P5.

[melchior]

I love you guys! Going out for 18 today; I'll edit in and let you know how it goes!

[mvmac]

I love you guys! Going out for 18 today; I'll edit in and let you know how it goes!

Here is a good example of the hip slide, head staying centered, gets into a reverse "K" look from his right shoulder to right leg

And like iacas said, get the hands deep, keep the left arm connected to the left pec, like this

[melchior]

I love you guys! Going out for 18 today; I'll edit in and let you know how it goes!

So when I was going for a push; I actually drew it back a good 15-20 yards swinging pretty hard. Concentrating on my hips really helped my whole game too; my distances were spot on when I could look from a tee or close to a yardage marker; never more than 10-15 yards off line when I wanted to hit a straight shot.

I ended up thinking "my left hip bone is being yanked" and through the swing after my left leg straightens on the follow through the only way to keep it being "yanked" is to get that reverse k correct posture. I don't think I'm tucking in quite as much as I could; but this was such a big improvement. I had a streak of 3-4 GIR's which *never* happens for me (just look at my handicap for proof). Course, then I got all excited and screwed up putting, but that's not a SnT problem :P

[mdbuschsr]

Things are starting to come along for me slowly. I haven't been able to have the time at the range that I would like to really practice this.

Here's my question: All of my clubs are benefiting from the S&T except for my six iron. My 6 used to be my favorite iron, now it seems all I do is hit hosel rockets. Same setup as everything else, but now I can't seem to hit it. Mental only?

On the other hand, I have never hit my other irons better! And my 8i is leading the way.

[picrig]

I'm just beginning my S&T journey. I could go on about why I've decided to make the change, but that's for another day. I've been to the range a couple of times to work on things. Overall, I'm pleased. Saturday was a good session, I thought. What I liked the most was that I was hitting the ball flush 90%+ of the time and only hit a couple of fat shots (something I had struggled with lately).

In general, my ball flight was a slight push (maybe 10 yard push with a 6I) with a baby draw. I assume that this generally would indicate that I"m still not hitting far enough back on the circle to create the draw I need and/or my clubface is a little too open at impact?

My woods/driver are completely different. I've had no luck with them. Instead of the straight push or push/baby draw, I'm hitting a straight to slight push with a huge slice. This seems to tell me that I'm hitting the ball on the front half of the circle and not getting my hips far enough forward. With the driver, how do you work on really pushing your hips forward? How much wider is your stance w/a driver than with irons? What are some good sensations that y'all have for pushing the hips forward, but keeping the head centered on the downswing?

[alf174]

After reading and comprehending more of the book, I'm headed to the range tonight to work on some specific items. I don't normally like to go to the range (rather play) but now that I have a plan, I won't mind.

[damnitdave]

mdb... usually when i hit hosel rockets i don't stand up/extend on the follow threw give that a try