Jump to content
Check out the Spin Axis Podcast! ×
IGNORED

Is Golf More Mental or Physical?


Note: This thread is 3031 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!

Golf more mental or physical?  

59 members have voted

  1. 1. In your opinion, is golf more of a physical or mental game?

    • More physical.
      40
    • More mental.
      19


Recommended Posts

Posted
6 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Why do skilled performer get nervous going out on stage at the met?

They wouldn't even be at the MET without their physical skills to perform.

Performance anxiety is always an issue with performers in general. You're right that golfers are no different in that regard. They have cameras that allow the viewers to count arm hairs on the players. So, there is definitely a lot of pressure. However, I doubt that a professional golfer would miss a short putt like that because she was nervous. I'm guessing she was prematurely getting into her victory leap but ended up missing or something like that. :-D

:ping:  :tmade:  :callaway:   :gamegolf:  :titleist:

TM White Smoke Big Fontana; Pro-V1
TM Rac 60 TT WS, MD2 56
Ping i20 irons U-4, CFS300
Callaway XR16 9 degree Fujikura Speeder 565 S
Callaway XR16 3W 15 degree Fujikura Speeder 565 S, X2Hot Pro 20 degrees S

"I'm hitting the woods just great, but I'm having a terrible time getting out of them." ~Harry Toscano

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
51 minutes ago, iacas said:

They spend very little time working on their mental game....

 

I think they spend more time on it than we/you think. They just don't admit it. Also, it's something you would do where people can see you.

Maybe they meditate, or even do Yoga.........etc.....

In my bag Driver: Cleveland CG tour black Fairway Woods: Diablo Octane 3 wood; Diablo 5 wood Irons: Mizuno MP53 5-9 Hybrid: Cobra 3, 4 T-Rail Wedge: 46* Cleveland, 50* Cleveland, 54* Titleist, 60* Titleist Putter: Odyssey protype #6 Ball: Maxfli U4/U6... But I'm not really picky about the ball I use.

Posted
Just now, BallMarker said:

 

Maybe because it was for her first major WIN and a "large" sum of money.......

Why do skilled performer get nervous going out on stage at the met?

Most of us aren't saying the mental game never applies, it's just not that as important at the end of the day compared to your physical ability.  Again, what the OP asked was, "Is golf more mental or physical?"

And one bad putt by IK Kim or a missed 2-footer by Scott Hoch at the Masters or a three putt by DJ in the US Open or some random missed shot at any tournament, doesn't mean that the mental game wins.  Everyone hits bad shots, even pros.  

  • Like 1
  • Upvote 1

-Jerry

Driver: Titleist 913 D3 (9.5 degree) – Aldila RIP 60-2.9-Stiff; Callaway Mini-Driver Kura Kage 60g shaft - 12 degree Hybrids: Callway X2 Hot Pro - 16 degree & 23 degree – Pro-Shaft; Callway X2 Hot – 5H & 6H Irons: Titleist 714 AP2 7 thru AW with S300 Dynamic Gold Wedges: Titleist Vokey GW (54 degree), Callaway MackDaddy PM Grind SW (58 degree) Putter: Ping Cadence TR Ketsch Heavy Balls: Titleist Pro V1x & Snell MyTourBall

"Golf is the closest game to the game we call life. You get bad breaks from good shots; you get good breaks from bad shots but you have to play the ball where it lies."- Bobby Jones

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
19 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

 

But, what made her do what she did?....she probably talked herself out of what she normally would do.

A brain fart at worst. If you think a solid mental game is about NEVER having an occasional brain fart, then well.... good luck.

19 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

I bet she can make that same putt 100 time in a row when there is no pressure.

 I bet she can make that same putt 100 times in a row when there is greater pressure. 

Again, outliers don't speak to a larger picture. 

 

Vishal S.

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
1 hour ago, jsgolfer said:

...instead of a plan for attacking the course, based on the physical skills you have 

I always thought "planning" was processed in your head.

In my bag Driver: Cleveland CG tour black Fairway Woods: Diablo Octane 3 wood; Diablo 5 wood Irons: Mizuno MP53 5-9 Hybrid: Cobra 3, 4 T-Rail Wedge: 46* Cleveland, 50* Cleveland, 54* Titleist, 60* Titleist Putter: Odyssey protype #6 Ball: Maxfli U4/U6... But I'm not really picky about the ball I use.

Posted
Just now, BallMarker said:

I always thought "planning" was processed in your head.

A plan is a means for achieving an end.  You may have the plan in your head, but hopefully its based on what you can actually do, not what you think you can do.  

-Jerry

Driver: Titleist 913 D3 (9.5 degree) – Aldila RIP 60-2.9-Stiff; Callaway Mini-Driver Kura Kage 60g shaft - 12 degree Hybrids: Callway X2 Hot Pro - 16 degree & 23 degree – Pro-Shaft; Callway X2 Hot – 5H & 6H Irons: Titleist 714 AP2 7 thru AW with S300 Dynamic Gold Wedges: Titleist Vokey GW (54 degree), Callaway MackDaddy PM Grind SW (58 degree) Putter: Ping Cadence TR Ketsch Heavy Balls: Titleist Pro V1x & Snell MyTourBall

"Golf is the closest game to the game we call life. You get bad breaks from good shots; you get good breaks from bad shots but you have to play the ball where it lies."- Bobby Jones

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
11 minutes ago, Lihu said:

I'm guessing she was prematurely getting into her victory leap but ended up missing or something like that. :-D

 

Even if you're right about your statement above. What made her do that?

Obvious answer is. HER MIND. :-)

  • Upvote 1
In my bag Driver: Cleveland CG tour black Fairway Woods: Diablo Octane 3 wood; Diablo 5 wood Irons: Mizuno MP53 5-9 Hybrid: Cobra 3, 4 T-Rail Wedge: 46* Cleveland, 50* Cleveland, 54* Titleist, 60* Titleist Putter: Odyssey protype #6 Ball: Maxfli U4/U6... But I'm not really picky about the ball I use.

Posted (edited)
28 minutes ago, jsgolfer said:

She didn't say she felt nervous on that putt, as far as I can tell from her interviews.

"I played straight, and it actually just broke to the right, even that short putt,'' Kim said. ``So it was unfortunate on 18, but ... I feel good about my game. It's getting better.''

 

I get what she said in post interviews, I would the same. But this is a 1 foot putt! 100% make rate statistically for the PGA. From 2 feet the PGA is still 199 out of 200 made, and that includes putts that break. I will concede it's fair, but I feel terribly misleading, to call this miss due to lack of physical ability to make that putt, no matter what one would describe it afterwards.

 

12 minutes ago, GolfLug said:

A brain fart at worst. If you think a solid mental game is about NEVER having an occasional brain fart, then well.... good luck.

I just know some of my friends consistently people brain fart more than others... and it costs them dollar bills.

28 minutes ago, iacas said:

So, I also said, did "drive for show, putt for dough." Didn't make it accurate.

If enough golfers know what Jones is talking about, I'd say his quote is accurate too.  (noting the Jones' quote is not meant to be taken literally)

28 minutes ago, iacas said:

:doh:

She didn't spend time working on her mental game after that. She chalked it up to a freak occurrence, perhaps a brain fart, and moved on.

She didn't revert to a 20 handicapper.

I echo the :doh:!  I'm just tired of agreeing with you and telling you the mental game can have a material impact (a $300k "sliver" as it may be sometimes), and not just answering the specific question in the OP (which I believe the original poster has changed to something different from what either of us are answering anyways :-D).

 

Edited by bones75

Posted
1 minute ago, jsgolfer said:

A plan is a means for achieving an end.  You may have the plan in your head, but hopefully its based on what you can actually do, not what you think you can do.  

Top pros have similar physical abilities.

Who has the best chance to win on any given week?

In my bag Driver: Cleveland CG tour black Fairway Woods: Diablo Octane 3 wood; Diablo 5 wood Irons: Mizuno MP53 5-9 Hybrid: Cobra 3, 4 T-Rail Wedge: 46* Cleveland, 50* Cleveland, 54* Titleist, 60* Titleist Putter: Odyssey protype #6 Ball: Maxfli U4/U6... But I'm not really picky about the ball I use.

  • Administrator
Posted
30 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Why do skilled performer get nervous going out on stage at the met?

Because they care, and they're human.

They don't suddenly turn into beginners.

The mental game is a tiny, teeny aspect of it.

Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
Just now, iacas said:

Because they care, and they're human.

They don't suddenly turn into beginners.

The mental game is a tiny, teeny aspect of it.

It is a tiny aspect of it.

But, it is highly concentrated....   :-)

In my bag Driver: Cleveland CG tour black Fairway Woods: Diablo Octane 3 wood; Diablo 5 wood Irons: Mizuno MP53 5-9 Hybrid: Cobra 3, 4 T-Rail Wedge: 46* Cleveland, 50* Cleveland, 54* Titleist, 60* Titleist Putter: Odyssey protype #6 Ball: Maxfli U4/U6... But I'm not really picky about the ball I use.

  • Administrator
Posted
32 minutes ago, jsgolfer said:

She didn't say she felt nervous on that putt, as far as I can tell from her interviews.

"I played straight, and it actually just broke to the right, even that short putt,'' Kim said. ``So it was unfortunate on 18, but ... I feel good about my game. It's getting better.''

There you go, no nerves at all.

18 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

I think they spend more time on it than we/you think. They just don't admit it. Also, it's something you would do where people can see you.

I know how much time they spend on it. It ain't much. I've coached and worked with players on the PGA Tour, European Tour, LPGA Tour… high-level college players.

@mvmac can ask Xander how much time he spends on his full swing vs. his mental game. Guess what: in the 65/20/15 ratio… we included the mental game. It just rounded down to zero is all.

5 minutes ago, bones75 said:

I just know some of my friends consistently people brain fart more than others... and it costs them dollar bills.

You're missing the bigger picture. A poor mental game does not turn a PGA or LPGA Tour player into a 20 handicapper.

The mental game is a tiny portion of the overall performance. And you apparently play with schmucks.

9 minutes ago, bones75 said:

If enough golfers know what Jones is talking about, I'd say his quote is accurate too.  (noting the Jones' quote is not meant to be taken literally)

Oh, we just get to declare things now as truth? Let me try… "His quote is not at all accurate. Not literally, not figuratively, not in any way."

9 minutes ago, bones75 said:

I echo the :doh:!  I'm just tired of agreeing with you and telling you the mental game can have a material impact (a $300k "sliver" as it may be sometimes), and not just answering the specific question in the OP (which I believe the original poster has changed to something different from what either of us are answering anyways :-D).

I have never said that the mental game can't have any impact ever.

And @bones75, you're not agreeing with me at all, so please stop saying you are.

2 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Top pros have similar physical abilities.

Who has the best chance to win on any given week?

The one who performs physically better.

On the PGA Tour, the hottest putter out of the best ballstrikers that week.

This is a really bad point you're trying to make. Your premise is wrong. They have different physical abilities.

Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted (edited)
28 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Top pros have similar physical abilities.

Who has the best chance to win on any given week?

Dustin Johnson has different physical abilities than Jordan Spieth does, none more evident than the playoff at the Northern Trust. That week, Dustin Johnson, the person with the better physical ability, won, and the reason why he won was because he was physically superior to Spieth with his drive on the playoff hole.

No, top pros dont have similar physical abilities. 

There is over a 40 yard difference between the shortest driving average (271) and the longest driving average (317) on the PGA tour this year. Pros dont have similar physical abilities.

Edited by klineka

Driver: :titleist:  GT3
Woods:  :cobra: Darkspeed LS 3Wood
Irons: :titleist: U505 (3)  :tmade: P770 (4-PW)
Wedges: :callaway: MD3 50   :titleist: SM9 54/58  
Putter: :tmade: Spider X

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
3 minutes ago, iacas said:

There you go, no nerves at all.

Because when an athlete describes what went wrong in a post round interview, it's always 100% accurate.

4 minutes ago, iacas said:

The mental game is a tiny portion of the overall performance. And you apparently play with schmucks.

1. I do play w/ schmucks (myself included).
2. One of us chokes pretty consistently (one of the schmuckier schmucks we have), and for 10 years he does fine in our $2 nassaus and but only loses $$ in all our "big" games. Even when he's been playing well that year (index down), we play net, so he still loses, and even he admits he just gets the nerves. I'm glad he can be comforted knowing that mental games is a tiny portion of his overall performance. 

9 minutes ago, iacas said:

Oh, we just get to declare things now as truth? Let me try… "His quote is not at all accurate. Not literally, not figuratively, not in any way."

Gump says "life is like a box of chocolates". I'm allergic to chocolate so this is just wrong, literally, figuratively and in every way.

(That was a whole lot of sarcasm.  My mom would kill me if she saw me posting like this.  I do mean it in the most fun way possible)


  • Administrator
Posted
Just now, bones75 said:

Because when an athlete describes what went wrong in a post round interview, it's always 100% accurate.

Occam's Razor, man.

2 minutes ago, bones75 said:

2. One of us chokes pretty consistently (one of the schmuckier schmucks we have), and for 10 years he does fine in our $2 nassaus and but only loses $$ in all our "big" games. Even when he's been playing well that year (index down), we play net, so he still loses, and even he admits he just gets the nerves. I'm glad he can be comforted knowing that mental games is a tiny portion of his overall performance.

Cool.

I've made the same point to you now many times, but this is the last:

  • Your buddy doesn't turn into a beginner when he feels nerves.
  • Even if he loses a few more strokes to nerves, he's the exception, not the rule. He has a glaring weakness, and his inability or unwillingness to fix or improve it hints toward a larger mental deficit.

At the highest level, yes, the results of one or two shots can be affected by nerves, but even that is just a sliver of their overall ability to put up a score for 72 holes on a PGA Tour level course.

A sliver.

Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
3 minutes ago, klineka said:

Dustin Johnson has different physical abilities than Jordan Spieth does, none more evident than the playoff at the Northern Trust. That week, Dustin Johnson, the person with the better physical ability, won, and the reason why he won was because he was physically superior to Spieth.

Thats only one example, but yeah, the guys with the top physical abilities overall do better than the guys that have lower physical abilities. 

If that were true, Dustin Johnson would win all the time.

Physical ability between Dustin Johnson and Jordan Spieth isn't all the much different...meaning that Spieth hits it far enough to compete against anyone..

I would throw in that the person who is mentally sharp for that week, has a better chance of winning.

25 minutes ago, iacas said:

The one who performs physically better.

On the PGA Tour, the hottest putter out of the best ballstrikers that week.

This is a really bad point you're trying to make. Your premise is wrong. They have different physical abilities.

 

Right. And one putts better if one's mind isn't cluttered with JUNK!

You're mind is one dimensional..and you're making a bad point and your premise is wrong......  :-)

In my bag Driver: Cleveland CG tour black Fairway Woods: Diablo Octane 3 wood; Diablo 5 wood Irons: Mizuno MP53 5-9 Hybrid: Cobra 3, 4 T-Rail Wedge: 46* Cleveland, 50* Cleveland, 54* Titleist, 60* Titleist Putter: Odyssey protype #6 Ball: Maxfli U4/U6... But I'm not really picky about the ball I use.

  • Administrator
Posted
11 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

If that were true, Dustin Johnson would win all the time.

No. Sometimes Jordan Spieth is physically superior. Or John Rahm. Or whomever.

If you think one player has a better mental game, then someone could just as easily say to you "if that were true, that player would win all the time."

11 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Physical ability between Dustin Johnson and Jordan Spieth isn't all the much different...meaning that Spieth hits it far enough to compete against anyone..

That's true. But what separates them each week is small differences in that physical ability.

11 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

I would throw in that the person who is mentally sharp for that week, has a better chance of winning.

A very, very small amount, sure.

11 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Right. And one putts better if one's mind isn't cluttered with JUNK!

Oh brother.

I'm a good putter. I can out-putt a beginner whether I'm hyper focused on the putt or whether I'm thinking about what deductions I may have missed on my taxes or what I'm going to eat for dinner or whatever.

The mental game is a tiny portion of what determines your score. More so for some than others, but still, way, way, way the **** under 50%.

Erik J. Barzeski —  I knock a ball. It goes in a gopher hole. 🏌🏼‍♂️
Director of Instruction Golf Evolution • Owner, The Sand Trap .com • AuthorLowest Score Wins
Golf Digest "Best Young Teachers in America" 2016-17 & "Best in State" 2017-20 • WNY Section PGA Teacher of the Year 2019 :edel: :true_linkswear:

Check Out: New Topics | TST Blog | Golf Terms | Instructional Content | Analyzr | LSW | Instructional Droplets

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Posted
50 minutes ago, BallMarker said:

Even if you're right about your statement above. What made her do that?

Obvious answer is. HER MIND. :-)

LOL, yes. :-D

Yes, I agree that it was her mind that did it, but I doubt it was a "mental" issue as we defined it. She probably wasn't apprehensive.

:ping:  :tmade:  :callaway:   :gamegolf:  :titleist:

TM White Smoke Big Fontana; Pro-V1
TM Rac 60 TT WS, MD2 56
Ping i20 irons U-4, CFS300
Callaway XR16 9 degree Fujikura Speeder 565 S
Callaway XR16 3W 15 degree Fujikura Speeder 565 S, X2Hot Pro 20 degrees S

"I'm hitting the woods just great, but I'm having a terrible time getting out of them." ~Harry Toscano

Awards, Achievements, and Accolades

Note: This thread is 3031 days old. We appreciate that you found this thread instead of starting a new one, but if you plan to post here please make sure it's still relevant. If not, please start a new topic. Thank you!
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • TST Partners

    PlayBetter
    Golfer's Journal
    ShotScope
    The Stack System
    FitForGolf
    FlightScope Mevo
    Direct: Mevo, Mevo+, and Pro Package.

    Coupon Codes (save 10-20%): "IACAS" for Mevo/Stack/FitForGolf, "IACASPLUS" for Mevo+/Pro Package, and "THESANDTRAP" for ShotScope. 15% off TourStriker (no code).
  • Posts

    • Going to Florida for the usual February golf trip, and with our current weather, that date won't get here soon enough. Heading to Augusta GA for the Tuesday Master's practice round, will definitely get some golf in while I'm in the area for a few days. Hope to be able to catch up with @coachjimsc if he's around. Then it's back to Scotland first of July.  Playing 7 new courses, can't wait for that.  Then somewhere after that is the Rhode Island CC Member-Guest and then my normal October golf trip to Myrtle Beach.  
    • It sucks to carry around a lot of water, but ideally it should be way more than we think.  I buy those gallon jugs of water and hang them from my pushcart when I walk. I agree with the electrolytes as well. You don't just sweat out water, but you lose electrolytes as well. 
    • A 2010 study from the Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research compares the effects of different pre-round stretch routines for competitive golfers. Active Dynamic Warm-up: Swing Medicus driver, hit 3 shots each with selected clubs. Passive Static Stretches: Various athletic stretches such as hamstrings, chest stretch and reverse trunk twist. The subjects were collegiate golfers with a HDCP index of 5 or less who engaged regularly in strength and fitness routines. All golfers had two test days: one with active dynamic (AD) warmup, a second with AD followed by static stretches (SS). The results were then compared, within golfers and across golfers. For performance testing after the warmups, golfers hit three driver shots at time 0, 15, 30 and 45 minutes after the warmup. The study shows that static stretch formats produced poorer performance outcomes in the four measures shown in Table 5, which shows Time Zero results. The performance deficits under the PSS protocol decreased over time. Some suggestions on why the passive protocol was tied to lower performance than the active protocol: The passive stretches routine induced excessive range of motion,  basically producing wobbles in the golf swing. Other research indicates that the stretching produced slack in the tendons, lessening the amount of muscle force that could be transferred into the shot. One caveat: The study had good scientific controls and balancing of treatments (test routines). This was, however, an exploratory study and raises as many questions as it answers. Also, although the study was done back in 2010, it is still cited as a primary work in recent reviews. A quick online search did not reveal any follow-ups on the study. For those interested, the study PDF is below. PassiveStretchGOLF.pdf  
    • I have trouble with vertigo on occasion, but have gotten nutritional and biofeedback tips to keep it at bay. Dehydration can help trigger v-like symptoms so one recommendation, along with maintaining overall hydration, is to start with 8 oz. of water early in the morning. A meta-analysis on Golf As Physical Activity indicated that golf is rated as a moderately intensive physical activity. This scientific literature review came from the University of Edinburgh. The physical activity level ties into hydration. A former university colleague was a marathon runner who had published a couple of articles on endurance training. He likewise said that golf was a moderate physical activity especially when the round stretched past  the two-hour mark. For hydration he recommended switching from water to electrolyte drink on the back nine (past two hour point of exercise) to prevent cramping. At the two-hour point of moderate activity, water starts flushing electrolytes out of the body, which can lead to fatigue and cramping. (I have had trouble with leg cramps in the past during exertion.) During a round, I start out with water on the front nine and switch to sports drink on the back nine. If the day is unusually hot, I may drink 8 oz. of Pedialite concentrate before going to the course. Maintaining overall hydration plus on-course boosters keeps me going.
    • Personally I’d try booking direct first - either via the Vidanta golf reservations number/email or through the resort concierge - especially for Christmas/New Year. Vidanta’s main courses (Greg Norman and Nicklaus designs) are popular and can book out fast this time of year, so direct often gives you the best shot at your preferred tee times.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.