Jump to content
  • Announcements

    • iacas

      Snell 20% Off   11/24/2017

      TST Partner Snell Golf is having a 20% off Black Friday/Cyber Monday sale! Check it out at snellgolf.com.
  • entries
    31
  • comments
    524
  • views
    11,459

Golfers are More Confused than Ever

iacas

2,690 views

Golfers are more confused than ever for two reasons.

  1. Never before has there been so much information available to the average golfer.
  2. The "bad instructors" have as much of a platform as the "good instructors."

The two kind of go hand in hand. A golfer will hear "stay behind the ball and roll your hands over to hit a draw" from one guy while he hears about how he's got to get his weight forward and follow through more like Zach Johnson from some other guy.



30 Comments




Recommended Comments

16 minutes ago, Patch said:

Confusion is why I read as much as I could about the golf swing, and then came up with my own swing decisions. 

You should get competent instruction instead of trying to figure things out yourself.

Share this comment


Link to comment

No. Not really. It took me some time. I read this, and that. I kept this, and threw out that. I saw what worked, and what didn't. I kept my own book of swing notes.

What I did is not that much different than what I think alot of swing gurus do. I read, studied, and learned. Biggest difference is I did it for myself, and not so much for others. I never had any plans to market what I had figured out.

I basically built my own swing over 2 year period back in the 1970s. I have played some pretty decent golf doing it my way the past 45+/- years. Sure there have been some ups and downs during my golf journey, but I was always able get mself back on track. Now old age is catching up with me, and my swing. Probably might read that senior golfer swing book that is lying around here some where. 

I tried the lesson route for a while with a combo teaching pro/club fitter. That helped the process. But, for the most part, I am self taught. Also, by doing my own thing, it was easer for me to retain what worked for me. 

Obviously for some, golf lessons are the way to go to speed up the process. This assuming those lessons are from a qualified teaching pro. 

Share this comment


Link to comment

Yes, it is confusing and gets in the way of being a stupid monkey.

Hopefully one can find someone good as it is best to just trust them and be a stupid monkey.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Those of us who learn on our own have only one person to blame for our crappy game. I kind of prefer that.

Back on topic... I agree, golf instruction can be very confusing - too confusing. It must be every bit as challenging for an instructor to find a way to make each student understand.

Share this comment


Link to comment

The only problem I have with some instructors is their way is the only way! Sorry, but I have eyes, I watch golf on TV, and know that isn't so. These guys always seem to want to do a complete tear down and rebuild. I'm 64, and have been playing for 50 years, so I'm not going to be into that. Take what I have, work with it, and help me improve.

I am also self taught for the most part, except for a few tips from an Uncle who was a country club pro before WWII. I got to be pretty good. This was longer ago than I care to remember, and I don't think I can approach that level again, but I think I can improve. I just want someone I can check in with from time to time to keep me on the straight and narrow.

But then I'm reminded of the old joke about the sign outside the pro shop...

"Series of 10 lessons - $500.00

 Single lesson - $1000.00

 If you want a miracle, you're going to have to pay for it!"

Share this comment


Link to comment

The one thing that always confuses me are the teaching pro's themselves. At my 3 local courses they offer lessons with 3 different pros all at different PGA levels.

Do you go for the guy at the bottom who charges £18 per hour or the top guy who charges £35. Will the young pro's be any good or will they just be preaching from the guy the learnt from?

Its quite a dilemma as no one really wants to say "hey, you may be a brilliant golfer.....but...."

Share this comment


Link to comment

I enjoy good instruction and coaching. That is what brought me to this site in the first place and eventually getting a lesson from Erik and Dave. I was unhappy with the local Pros for the reasons poster above have noted. Evolvr has been good for me, but if I was closer to Erie or where Stephan teaches, I would get more hands on lessons. 

Share this comment


Link to comment
18 hours ago, Patch said:

Confusion is why I read as much as I could about the golf swing, and then came up with my own swing decisions. 

I read as little as I can, outside of this site.  I'm amazed at how much instruction is available, and astounded by players who'll talk about using a Joe Smith swing but leaning toward a Jane Doe swing, as if each instructor's swing thoughts were independent from every other instructor's.  For most of us, who aren't completely knowledgeable about the true details of a golf swing, its really difficult to tell good advice from bad.  When I was learning, we had a few books (ink and paper books), and one or two monthly golf magazines.  We didn't have video, so we never really knew if we were doing what we wanted to be doing. Now we have dozens, if not hundreds, of "golf instructors" showing up on websites and Youtube, most of them hawking this or that method or device or home video with all of their "secrets."  Its no wonder that we're confused!

Share this comment


Link to comment
2 hours ago, DaveP043 said:

I read as little as I can, outside of this site.  I'm amazed at how much instruction is available, and astounded by players who'll talk about using a Joe Smith swing but leaning toward a Jane Doe swing, as if each instructor's swing thoughts were independent from every other instructor's.  For most of us, who aren't completely knowledgeable about the true details of a golf swing, its really difficult to tell good advice from bad.  When I was learning, we had a few books (ink and paper books), and one or two monthly golf magazines.  We didn't have video, so we never really knew if we were doing what we wanted to be doing. Now we have dozens, if not hundreds, of "golf instructors" showing up on websites and Youtube, most of them hawking this or that method or device or home video with all of their "secrets."  Its no wonder that we're confused!

I'm very guilty of trying to read whatever I have time to, but have been much more selective, the instruction I watch, they basically come from similar backgrounds, just a different way of going about it. 

It's not just pros. For example there is a guy on YouTube who is interviewing instructors, jumping from pro to pro and trying a different drill every video. It's just scattershot and while he means well, he's probably confusing a lot of people, his swing especially.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I used to watch Golf lessons on YouTube for hours. To be honest I wanted to find was a shortcut that would that would save me the discomfort of changing my swing flaws. As of my last lesson on Tuesday I'm swearing off YouTube and just going to humble myself and do what I'm told.      

I used to think (hope) the phrase "working with your swing" meant the instructor develops a workable swing based on what was comfortable for me, which would be a quick fix indeed... That's not at all what it means. It means he looks at your swing and applies a customized set of tweaks for you that will hopefully set you a path to the promised land. The fundamentals for all golfers are exactly the same - there's no avoiding the embarrassment and discomfort of learning the right way.

A lot of YouTube videos are just promises of a quick fix IMO.

   

Edited by Kalnoky

Share this comment


Link to comment
12 hours ago, Buckeyebowman said:

The only problem I have with some instructors is their way is the only way! Sorry, but I have eyes, I watch golf on TV, and know that isn't so. These guys always seem to want to do a complete tear down and rebuild. I'm 64, and have been playing for 50 years, so I'm not going to be into that. Take what I have, work with it, and help me improve.

Yes, we have a word for those kinds of instructors: bad.

Nobody has to "rebuild" their golf swing from the ground up. Well, there may be one guy I know of, but he literally can't even chip a ball six feet with his current state… next summer if he's still playing I'm going to convert him to lefty or something. :-)

Share this comment


Link to comment
1 hour ago, Kalnoky said:

I used to watch Golf lessons on YouTube for hours. To be honest I wanted to find was a shortcut that would that would save me the discomfort of changing my swing flaws. As of my last lesson on Tuesday I'm swearing off YouTube and just going to humble myself and do what I'm told.      

I used to think (hope) the phrase "working with your swing" meant the instructor develops a workable swing based on what was comfortable for me, which would be a quick fix indeed... That's not at all what it means. It means he looks at your swing and applies a customized set of tweaks for you that will hopefully set you a path to the promised land. The fundamentals for all golfers are exactly the same - there's no avoiding the embarrassment and discomfort of learning the right way.

A lot of YouTube videos are just promises of a quick fix IMO.

   

You Tube can be useful to some. In my case I use a specific chipping method. I am pretty sure I adopted this method before You Tube may have existed. You Tube now shows this method, and every once in a while, I will watch, just as a refresher. 

Right now I watch some of the "senior swing" videos looking for a useful tidbit. Nothing new so far.

Share this comment


Link to comment
7 hours ago, DaveP043 said:

I read as little as I can, outside of this site.

This is where I'm at - for the most part.

I don't know for a fact that Erik and Mike are right, but it is the path I've tried to stay on.

That's not to say it isn't confusing at times. Over the few years I've been here, there's been more than one occasion where I'll stumble onto something while practicing, immediately remember a topic or post and think...  so that's what they were talking about.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I think my best advice with this - you need to find a coach you trust and believe in.

This may take time, I have jumped from coach to coach and now I am completely settled with someone who I think knows and cares about my game.

There are lots of coaches out there that couldn't give two hoots if you improve, as long as you keep coming back, they will be happy.

So analyse it after a few lessons to see if your game is going in the right direction. I mean all these coaches know how to swing a golf club but not all of them know how to convey it to their pupils. I suppose this is the key to being a good coach.

Also once you get a coach, don't start you tubing as well. You need to stick to one person's philosophy otherwise you'll be more confused than ever.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Bad instructors- I've had one.   He gave me too much at once.  Different advice on every swing.   Change your stance, change your grip, change you posture, hit it harder.  It was a complete disaster and a waste of money. 

My current guy gives me one thing at a time.  The lessons are much more expensive, but they are so much better. 

In my opinion, self-instruction is a waste of time.  I tried that, and I just jumped from one thing to another.   Maybe it's this, maybe it's that, and on and on.   Sometimes smart people can be too smart for their own good.  You can confuse yourself with too much information.   And you start thinking you know something about how to swing a club, but you really don't.  

Johnny Miller says this was Ben Hogan's big secret!  I used to eat up that stuff.   But it's pointless. 

Anyway, I agree.   Golfers are probably more confused than ever.   I know I was.   Until I humbled myself and got someone who could tell me the truth, and give me that one thing at a time to work on.  

The only advice I have is that if and when you do select an instructor, by all means tell him that you want just one thing at a time.  Tell him that you don't want him overwhelming you with too much information.   There has to be two-way communication.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Couldn't agree more with this. you should only be working on one maybe two things at a time max.

Self-diagnosis is pretty dangerous and can leave you more confused and frustrated than ever. 

Have one coach who you trust and one blog/site you can gain inspiration from. 

That's all you need.

Dean 

Share this comment


Link to comment
On 11/11/2016 at 1:03 PM, iacas said:

Yes, we have a word for those kinds of instructors: bad.

Nobody has to "rebuild" their golf swing from the ground up. Well, there may be one guy I know of, but he literally can't even chip a ball six feet with his current state… next summer if he's still playing I'm going to convert him to lefty or something. :-)

Stop talking about me! :-P

It's not confusing. Just keep your head down and don't look up. 

Share this comment


Link to comment

You know what would be really helpful? If there were mirrors at the range. Sometimes the golf lesson is good - but there is this tendency to gradually slip back into what's comfortable. It happens in a real insidious way. I think I'm practicing what I learned in my lesson, but really I'm just back practicing the wrong thing again.

Share this comment


Link to comment
30 minutes ago, Kalnoky said:

You know what would be really helpful? If there were mirrors at the range. Sometimes the golf lesson is good - but there is this tendency to gradually slip back into what's comfortable. It happens in a real insidious way. I think I'm practicing what I learned in my lesson, but really I'm just back practicing the wrong thing again.

BYOM.

Share this comment


Link to comment
6 minutes ago, CarlSpackler said:

Now THAT is awesome! Where have you been all of my life portable mirror?

We have a couple downtown. They're handy.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Want to join this community?

    We'd love to have you!

    Sign Up
  • Blog Entries

  • Posts

    • Lol, I like both those movies you hated. Loved? No, but I liked them. I also liked Vanilla Sky too in spite of its flaws. To each his own I guess, and perhaps therein lies the rub that's makes % ratings unreliable more often than not. Or maybe I'm just a sucker for Tom Cruise vanity projects.  But I agree that Rotten Tomatoes doesn't help much at all in determining whether I'll enjoy a movie or not. It's still interesting to browse though, just to see where the pulse of the American critic is, if little else.  I also agree that the discrepancy between critic and audience score is a fascinating one to see when it happens. That's a fun list on that link. Let's see... what are some "bad" movies that I still enjoyed... The 13th Floor (1999) was 29% but with a 67% audience score. A totally flawed movie overshadowed by the Matrix, but still a fun sci-fi journey i think with interesting ideas in it.  I enjoyed Seeking a Friend for the End of the World (2012) that is 55% critic and 53% audience. I dunno, I thought it was a nice story... plus the Writer-Director lady is from the same town as me in NJ, so I always found that interesting that we grew up drinking the same water.  I've always loved the Cable Guy (1996) which is 54%, 51% respectively. Man, people really hated this movie when it came out, but I've always found it hilarious.  I thought Primer (2004) was an ambitious and cool sci-fi movie made on a shoestring budget. I'm not sure how it has only 72% from the critics given what they accomplished on a per dollar scale. Cool story that no doubt has its flaws.  One recent movie that I quite enjoyed that was totally panned (and for good reason) was Passengers (2016). It currently stands at 30%, 63%. Perhaps its just its basic log line that I like, as the film itself kind of loses its way at times. I certainly wouldn't fault people for thinking it was boring or lame as its execution and linear script was pretty banal at times, I admit.  But this random Youtuber made a really cool video about how to make the script for Passengers better, and I 100% agree with his suggestions. This is a pretty cool video if you've seen the movie already. His version is way better.  I think if they took this guy's suggestions, that 30% critic score would be above 65%.   
    • I'm not sure if this is what he meant, but I think you can you use the "feel ain't real" to your advantage. Meaning, if the feel seems right but the results are wrong (or video shows it's wrong), you can exaggerate a move to the point where it feels wrong and it might closer. Example... if I feel my head is remaining stable but video shows I'm moving it towards the target as I get to the top of my backswing, I might change to the point where I feel like I'm moving back away from the target. On video, that feel produces a steadier head. Does that make sense? That's not to say that feel will always work. In fact, there's a good chance it will not. Edit: I didn't realize this is exactly what @klinekahad posted. (it's good to know I'm not the only one who has used that feel). Anyway, maybe that's what @Buckeyebowmanmeant with his response.
    • He's played with every president. That's remaining neutral. You either play with none of 'em or all of 'em.
  • Today's Birthdays

    1. golf755
      golf755
      (28 years old)
    2. PaddyMac
      PaddyMac
      (48 years old)
×

Important Information

Welcome to TST! Signing up is free, and you'll see fewer ads and can talk with fellow golf enthusiasts! By using TST, you agree to our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy, and our Guidelines.

The popup will be closed in 10 seconds...