Jack vs. Tiger: Who's the Greatest Golfer?

[Acropo]

Compelling argument.

For simple minds.

[Chas]

I think the sarcasm was at saturation level.

[leftofmoe]

No contest. Jack by a mile. Look what happens when these guys revert to a softer ball to hold the greens with V grooves. They hit the driver all over the map. Jack used a ball that spun much more but could still hit it 300 down the middle. If jack was given the modern ball he would have won 30 majors.

[max power]

No contest. Jack by a mile. Look what happens when these guys revert to a softer ball to hold the greens with V grooves. They hit the driver all over the map. Jack used a ball that spun much more but could still hit it 300 down the middle. If jack was given the modern ball he would have won 30 majors.

They were gonna give Jack the modern ball but not let anyone else use it? Jack might have had a few more majors, but the reason has nothing to do with equipment-he just needed to cultivate a stronger short game.

[golf55]

jack! I hope tiger never catch up!

[TaylorMadeTaylor]

Pshhh... Jack.

He's an ol' rasin now and can still beat tiger.

[haddockd]

I am a Tiger fan for several reasons:
He is a legend in his own right
He is what you compare others to for a sign of how good they are
He seems to be a perfectionist when it comes to his game.

[heyscuba]

ya know,... this is a silly argument,.. there will never be any way to compare the two guys and definitely say who was better, or the best,... they are both awesome, have had great success at all levels, both were totally dominating their era's, both have brilliant highlight reels, and they both played with the best equipment available,... Jacks equipment was better than the guys 20 years before him, Tigers equipment is better than Jacks but you play with the times, so it's a moot point,...
nobody knows now, nobody will ever know,...
I love to watch them both play golf,...
I just hope Tiger can over come his BIG problems he put on himself and just tie Jack in majors and then retire !
It's a tie,...!
Let's be happy we had them to watch.
Good Golf Times,...

[GixxerTed]

golfer= tiger

+1 million.

[ml_golfer]

I'd have to say Tiger!

[bertrans]

I think by the time he's done it will be tiger woods

[MioDiMia]

He may be a moron but he's kinda a god ._.
And i am not talking just about golf, he makes , or used to make, every competion so exciting...

[DanGlen]

I think Tiger is the better golfer.
But I think Jack is the better person.

[mff18b]

I would love to say Jack, however, I am of the mind that in the end it will probably be Tiger.

[andy-golf]

tiger woods

[OH3Sticks]

Tiger has been an influence on everyone in this country, especially those with an ethnic background. 2000 US Open is the greatest display of golf ever, that says enough.

[billinga]

I have to go with Jack because of who he was competing against at the time. If you put Jack first or second and Tiger in the other spot, the majority of the rest of the top 10 would be players that Jack competed against. Just my two cents.

[dbuck]

I have to go with Jack because of who he was competing against at the time. If you put Jack first or second and Tiger in the other spot, the majority of the rest of the top 10 would be players that Jack competed against. Just my two cents.

I like this. Of all the 2770 other posts that may put it in the best perspective.